Everything posted by Thebigalguy
-
Former Twins Cooperstown Case: AJ Pierzynski
I think he's one-and-done, but thanks for laying out his bona fides. I'd forgotten how good he was, and for how long. Without Mauer in the pipeline, he would likely have been a Twin for a long time. I remember him developing a rep as a player with a chip on his shoulder; that never helps considerations for the Hall. Though he repaired the image, he rubbed too many voters the wrong way and doesn't have the stats to overcome that rep.
-
Is this front office borderline hostile to "not their" guys?
Everybody who agrees with Brock is absolutely right. Berrios was our ace and he was affordable. Buxton, despite the injuries, is a budding superstar and he's affordable. It's hard to judge prospects, but it seems clear to me that we got more in the trade for Cruz, on the end of a single year contract, than for Berrios, entering his prime. Falvey and Levine are fading fast in terms of credibility.
-
Trade Target: Frankie Montas
I agree with the commenters who oppose such a trade. Berrios was home grown. Why didn't the Twins sign him long term, or at least make a viable offer to him? All of this crud about wanting home grown talent? Berrios was home grown. So is Buxton. The idea is to build a team that can make it to the World Series, not a team with a winning record that's incapable of getting past the Yankees. It's disheartening.
-
Get Ready for the Opposite of Joe Mauer
Well-played. My position is that it's Buxton or bust. If they let him go, my loyalty to the team suffers irrevocably. I like watching Twins games in the summer; it's a comfort food. I'll find some other way to spend that time unless the Twins make a realistic offer to Buxton. These days, there's plenty of entertainment on offer apart from the Twinkies. Lots of good books to read. Movies to watch. Podcasts to listen to. And that's not even taking into account quality time with family and friends. A day at the ballpark is great fun if the team is competitive, which means signing Buxton. Otherwise, adios.
-
Pick Your Veteran Trade Asset
I say keep all three. The right coach will get Kepler back where he should be. Arraez as super-utility guy is priceless and won't bring all that much. Garver is the goods behind and at the plate. That said, there's always the chance somebody will make an offer the front office can't refuse, but my deal is that Falvine should play hard to get with offensive (and, with Kepler, defensive) talent. It goes without saying they should pay the piper to keep Buxton. If we want to be the next Houston, we need the smarts they have (without the corruption, of course). It's the only way to be competitive year in and out. It's the classic business axiom, as far as pitching goes; you have to spend money to make money. Let's make some money (win some games)!
- Should the Twins Gamble on Carlos Rodón or Noah Syndergaard?
-
What Would a Dramatic Roster Upheaval Look Like for the Twins?
Fun to read. Thanks for it. I want them to keep Buxton, Donaldson, and Kepler. Trade Sano for pitching. I'm not all that worried about the offense with the right coaching. It's the pitching that needs an overhaul along with young talent. Mike Florio wrote about the Vikings that every year they're 'just good enough' to keep up hope but never anything but bridesmaids. The same goes, obviously, for the Twins. We need to revisit 1991 and get to the big games.
-
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
Make him an offer he can’t refuse. If he refuses, trade him.
-
Who Is Or Isn't a Part of Next Year's Team (Hitter's Edition)
Thanks for the update. I think it’s depressing to hear that Buxton might not be back. He’s the linchpin for the offense. If he ain’t back, 2022 = a rebuilding year.
- Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
- How Does the 2021 Eddie Rosario Experience End?
- Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
-
6 Questions that Will Determine the Twins' Offseason Course
Extend Buck for whatever it takes. Build the offense with him in mind. And hope he stays healthy. Compete next year. Anything else is unacceptable. I like the idea of a revolving DH until/unless somebody steps up and makes the position his own. As for Cruz, he might finally have hit a wall and no doubt he's too proud to play part-time and coach Sano and others. Keep Polanco at second. Give Arraez a shot. Build the offense with what the team has and find a hitting coach who can actually make a difference when needed. Use FA and trades for some pitching but give the young arms who are ready their shot. No more dilly-dallying: 2022 is the year.
-
2021 Postseason Discussion and Game Thread
As a Twins fan, I watched the 106 win Dodgers last night play a do-or-die game to get to the next round in the playoffs. They won, a nail biter for their fans I'm sure, but both the Dodgers and Cardinals trotted out pitchers who, when compared to the Twins' staff and prospects, make me weep. If the Twins can't develop home grown pitching or trade for it, the Pohlads need to pony up. No more Happs and Shoemakers, please.
-
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
If the Twins don’t resign Buxton to an extension, I’m gone.
- Looking Back at Michael Pineda’s Twins Tenure
- Game Score: Twins 3, Cleveland 0
-
Which Prospect Anchors 2022's Rotation?
One man’s ceiling is another man’s floor.
-
The Twins Shouldn't Spend (Much) On Starting Pitching This Offseason
We’ll reasoned but I don’t buy it. Life is too short to write off 2022 before it starts. Sign Buxton. Re-educate Kepler and Sano. With pitching, promote, innovate, and let the competition begin. Falvine need to earn their keep after this year. Put them on notice. Win or pink slip.
-
Can the Pitching Staff Compete in 2022?
My fear is that Falvine trades Buxton for pitching. I think the team's first priority should be to sign BB to a long term contract. He's come of age. His last injury was a hit-by-pitch: could happen to anybody. His dazzle will draw fans like me on a regular basis to the stadium. He's worth 15/mil a year, which is what his agents say they want. We haven't won a World Series, or played in one, since 1991; there's a reason for that. Yes, Mauer wasn't worth what he got, and an injury that reduced his effectiveness was one reason, but Buxton can be transformational in the lineup and in center field. Just do it, guys, and figure out the pitching on the fly.
-
Game Score: Twins 8, Cleveland 7
Day game. I watched, gave up, ran errand, came back, we’re up, blown save, figures I thought, but this time Polanco came through again. Nice. Even nicer if the take Yankees down.
- Game Score: Twins 5, Cleveland 4
-
Trade Deadline Tracker: Twins' News and Rumor Roundup
Keep The B Boys and Kepler. Build around them with young talent and FAs. Consign 2021 to the ash heap. With FAs, avoid has beens. Let the young pitchers finish out the year. Give Happ and Shoemaker their check and send them home. Ditto Columbe. Figure out if Rogers is the closer or too unpredictable.
-
Twins Rookie Duo Impresses While Other Teams' Top Prospects Struggle
4 game win streak. Rookies part of it. Don’t count these guys out yet.
- Taylor Rogers Named to All Star Team