NewClearHarley

this was a great deal for them, plus they can flip him at the deadline to another team in need of a catcher

I'm not sure that the Twins would want a ton, even within the division. His loss would save the team nearly 8 million and open up regular atbats for Garver and Astudillo, and their is seriously zero chance the team will keep him beyond this year anyways. That said, KC could sign someone like Martin Maldonado for around 5-6 million and solve same situation, but either way the Twins will trade Castro at some point this year so if there is a match now might as well make it.

no not really, but I bet they would like a veteran catcher to help Gallagher and the young pitching staff, the only other catcher currently with a shot to make the team is a hit tool kid who has only High-A experience.

anyone have any thoughts on what KC might give us for the one year Castro rental? Not expecting much but it would save us some cash and open a roster spot.I know they said they are comfy with Cam Gallagher, but as a Royals fan I cannot fathom that.

I'm holding out hope for the team to figure out how to keep Austin as a bench bat. The threat that the Twins could use him as a PH late in games would be nice. He is a legit power threat in that spot. Right now Garver and Gonzalez are guaranteed bench slots. I'd be fine with the other two slots going to Austin and either Astudillo or Cave. Hopefully once we get into the season, we can deal Castro to another team (could they send him within the division to KC???) and use Garver as the primary catcher and Astudillo as the backup allowing the team to bring Cave back up. Worse case Cave gets regular atbats at AAA and is called up when the ineveitable OF injury occurs. Looking at our defensive depth charts: C: Castro, Garver, Astudillo 1B: Cron, Gonzalez, Sano, Austin, Garver 2B: Schoop, Gonzalez, Polanco 3B: Sano, Gonzalez, Astudillo SS: Polanco, Gonzalez RF: Kepler, Gonzalez, Cruz (emergency) CF: Buxton, Kepler, Gonzalez LF: Rosario, Gonzalez DH: Cruz, Sano, Austin SP: Berrios, Gibson, (Praying for Keuchel), Pineda, Odorizzi, Perez BP: Parker, Hildenberger, May, Rogers, Reed, Mejia, Romero (i'm cool with him starting the year in minors too)

I assume that taking on some of Greinke's contract would be part of the deal

From Rotoworld: Raley, 23, has seen his stock rise after a strong 2018 season with Double-A Tulsa where he's hit 17 homers and posted an .822 OPS over 83 games. A seventh-round pick out of Lake Erie College, Raley has above-average power from the left side, and he makes enough hard contact to project a solid hit tool despite having some swing-and-miss in his game. He could be an everyday outfielder, and could help the Twins by the end of 2019. Me: Lots of extra base hits and he has fared well at each level so far. I like this.

I like Brad Miller but as a second baseman, he makes a good first baseman

I actually like the Raley kid raking at Tulsa this year - LH spray hitter with extra base power who also destroyed both rookie ball and high A the last two years.

i have no problem playing forsythe for that reason - but the real reason he was included was to keep Dodgers under lux tax reset figure.

right now Dozier projects out to 90-24-80-12 if he finishes the season getting regular AB for the Twins. That should be an ok output for our 2B next year even at QO pricetag. I've heard the number 16 million for him next year on QO. If that is correct please list for me every other second baseman that we can sign this offseason that will post that same line above.

At this point I almost think if we don't get someone stupidly overpaying for Dozier, we might as well keep him, give him the QO, and if he signs elsewhere we get the bonus pick, otherwise we pay him a little more than necessary and then dump him at next trade deadline. He may never hit above .250 again, but I'd be happy with him if he can deliver 75-20-75-15 ( we could do a lot worse than that for the 16 or so the QO would require) next year while allowing Gordon at least a half if not a full season at AAA.

Here is why this trade is phenomenal: 1) We open up a slot in our starting rotation for one of Romero, Gonsalves, or Mejia 2) We add a much needed RH power bat that was not playing regularly with the Yankees because he was blocked and that can play more positions than Kennys Vargas 3) We dump half of Lynn's salary 4) We get a teenage flier pitcher 5) We get to watch Lynn get LIT up at Yankees' stadium.

and yet many on the twittersverse were begging the yanks to keep playing him and dump Bird

that is good because someone who can crush southpaws is something our offense has been sorely lacking

exactly RH power hitting 1B/CI, - this is what we needed this offseason. If Sano can stick at 3B next year, Austin is our starting 1B next year. Otherwise he can potentially platoon with Kepler & Mauer (if he returns), and split some time with those two and Sano at DH. Worse case he gives us that RH power bat off the bench we are sorely lacking.

we just heisted the Yankees

While I would only offer one of them, Lewis is the only one on that list I would not be willing to deal for Realmuto.

if we trade gibby who by all accounts has been a top 20 AL SP this year, who will be use next year that projects as a top 20 AL starting pitcher to replace him? If MIL wants to give us Peralta ++ I'm down, but that aint gonna happen.

100% agree - if we get him back and get some prospects for him - then this is a win win - I just really wished we would have gotten someone closer to playing at a higher level

I hope you are right - I'll check into the FG reports right now I am going on other internet reports and write ups I have scoured on each of them. ie: fourth OF at best who will never hit MLB pitching, possible mid-rotation starter but likely back of bullpen power arm, and decent bat - but years away. I seriously thought that the Twins saw themselves targeting 2019 to compete for the division, this deal screams we don't think we have a chance next year either. The bigger question is wil the team punt on Gibby. If they do we know that we are heading down the complete rebuild rabbit hole.

Maybe a Mejia type that was at least going to be MLB bound before 2022

which would rank them 20th or so on any other MiLB league system

Great in 2022 when he makes his MLB debut him and Romero and Gonsalves and Graterol can be traded so the Twins can get some more A-level prospects

He is #7 on their team as of 7-25-2018 http://prospects1500.com/top-50-lists/philadelphia-phillies-midseason-top-50-prospects/ Baseball Prospectus had him at #68 overall coming in to the season