3 Takeaways From the Twins 2022 Draft Class

Super post and super draft analysis. Thank you. 

Excellent work! Appreciate the time put into it. After the first 2 picks this was an easy A+ draft regardless of what came next. The VT shortstop is interesting to me given he outproduced Gavin Cross when they played together.  Hopefully some other guys also end up becoming contributors too.

First, the consensus board was a home run.  I had that and the TD live draft coverage open throughout the draft. Great work. I hope you do it next year. I agree with your three points. I think looking for power breakouts in the later rounds makes great sense. If these players had put together 2 or 3 years of those kind of results, they would have been drafted much earlier. Late developers and small college guys always go later, but you never know when you will find a Festa. 

While the OP mentioned Fans saying how many Shortstops do the Twins need? I think that is somewhat misleading.  Most of those shortstops are predicted to move off the position and really become utility players.  If all those picks were "true" shortstops then lay it on me I love it.  We need them.

The Twins took 5 infielders in the top ten picks and seven over all.  6 of those were shortstops so what gives?  The Twins in general seem to like fairly balanced drafts and for the last 4 years rarely picked any shortstops.  Usually 1 or 2 per draft and none in 2020. Shortstop has pretty much always been a position that the Twins system has been in short supply and it is not for a lack of trying spending 1-1 pick on Lewis, signing Javier to one of the biggest FA contracts ever and reaching for Cavaco in the first round just to shore up the position.  The only one close so far is Lewis taken all the way back in 2017.  

While the Twins haven't been lucky generating shortstop talent they appear to be rich in utility talents Arraez, Gordon, Miranda, Palacios, Steer, Martin, Jullien, Prato, Cavaco and Miller and Possibly including Lewis unless you see him as sure fire shortstop.  While Utility players can play 2nd, 3rd and short in a pinch that list above doesn't even include guys in the system tied to one spot like CES, Gray and Severino.  If you are counting that is 11 straight up utility players at the MLB level and with potential to make it to the MLB level.  Some like Prato and Cavaco appear to be long shots at this time and if you wanted to take them out that still leaves 9 guys to play primarily two spots 2nd and 3rd and maybe short in a pinch.  That is more than enough utility talent for quite some time.

So why did the Twins take all those shortstops this year?  It was totally out of character for them.  They have never drafted this many shortstops since Falvine took over.  I couldn't make much sense of it.

I looked hard through the system though and “true” shortstop is a bit more barren than I realized.  At A ball we have Miller who has held his own so far this year but since he is high schooler it is going to take some time yet.  At high A the Twins have Holland and Javier. Holland is 24 and will be 25 next year and is still in High A with a .691 OPS and 32% K rate. It seems pretty obvious he doesn't have the contact skills to make it.  He looks like he could be on his way out.  Javier is still only 23 but is only in high A with only a .690 OPS.  He has been better as of late but he doesn't look like an answer either. That is it there is no one else there at High A.

You can see why the Twins tried so hard to make Martin work at short because without him there is nothing at short at AA.  The Twins were so desperate for someone to play they plugged in defensive whiz Ozoria and his .580 OPS just to fill the hole.   So that is two levels with essentially no one exceling at short and low A needing depth beyond Miller.  Essentially they could use another 5 guys at short.  The question is are the guys they picked actually shortstops or utility players.

A lot of scouts are already saying it is just a matter of time before Lee moves off of short.  There are mixed opinions on Schobel but several outlets again feel his ultimate home is utility player.  No one knows much about Ross and he has good speed so he could be an answer but he also is from a D2 school so will have to wait and see.  Schuffield looks like a sure thing to stick at short but he is a 5 year senior and already 23 the bat doesn't look quite as good and he looks more likely to be a backup option than a star shortstop.  The two high school shortstops they drafted would likely be  five to six years away if they can sign them but both project well to stick at short but will they sign them?  Have to wait and see.

So my question for the OP is did the Twins really draft a bunch of shortstops or are these really more utility players in disguise?  I mean Sano, Steer, Cavaco, and tons of others were drafted as "shortstops" but were all projected to move off and to no ones surprise they have all moved off the position.  Granted many felt Lewis might not stick there either and I still think he can play there.  Still after drafting 6 more shortstops I still don't know that the Twins have solved their shortstop issue.
 

10 minutes ago, gunnarthor said:

I didn't look into draft stuff so much this year as in other years but I think the first two picks make this my favorite draft since 2016. We'll see how it plays out but I'm happy with this draft.

Yeah I really liked that draft and the way they went with the young guys.  It took 6 years but those 4 straight high school picks have all made their way to Major League Baseball and with Jax the first 5 picks of that draft have all made it.  Even the 15 round pick Wells has made it.  That was one heck of a draft.  It will be hard for this one to beat that but I think the first three guys picked have a good chance to make it.  After that though who knows.  2016's success looks like it could be hard to beat.

With the obvious caveat of A] not being any sort of talent scout/evaluator, and B] who the heck knows how ANY draftee will turn out in the long run, I really like what the Twins did.

As to the SS issue, I was very OK with the numbers selected. Wander hasn't turned out. Cavaco is a huge question mark and has moved off SS. Holland is playing 2B and CF and is also off SS, unless I'm mistaken. Many a 3B and 2B, including some great ones, were once SS. And some have turned out to be fine OF as well. You need a bunch to find a couple, can move others, some become fine utility players, and some just become organizational players. But you need them too.

But going deeper in to the players themselves, after Lee and Prielipp fell in to their laps, the Twins had to readjust their approach, at least to some degree, to make sure they could play with their signing pool $. I have little doubt some of the players they picked, while liked I'm sure, were drafted earlier than projected in order to save $ to ensure Lee and Prielipp are both signed. Doesn't mean they didn't draft guys they actually like, or project, just means they had to consider the financial impact. And what better way to do that than draft guys from smaller schools, or late bloomers getting their breakthrough opportunity, etc.

I'm going to let the SS issue die at this point, enough already said. But did I read correctly that 6th pick Ortega, 2B, was actually a SS originally? Regardless, a huge explosion in his game after getting his first real opportunity for one of 2022's top programs. Exactly what the scouting department was looking for and targeting. 

Despite being second day arms, I'm really intrigued by Matthews and Lewis a lot. (And not just Lewis' knuckleball). They have a foundation to work with and the length to see a velocity jump the same way we've seen with Winder, Varland and others. And I'm very intrigued by LHP, 18th pick,Veen. He's not that big/long, and his velocity is reported as around 90mph. But the K's and control are outstanding. Can they add a couple MPH and have a surprise BP arm there?

I was very pleased to see the pair of catchers selected. Lossetti's bat seems to play, though he's from a smaller school. I think it's easier to develop a catcher defensively than teach him how to hit, or have power. Baez had a good year, but doesn't seem to have as good a hit tool or as much power, but he did play at a higher level. If I understand his bio on the draft page, he was more a utility player who finally got his chance to be the every day backstop. A potential steal as a late bloomer? Again, I see a trend here.

I'm not holding out much hope for any of the 3 HS kids being signed. I think they have a shot at Omari Daniel since he is rehabbing from injury. He's a shot in the dark but talented. Does he take a nice, solid $ number and run with it or decide to try college in 2024? If you were 18yo and uncertain what your future was, would you grab a chance at a pro future, and somewhere between $300-500K for an overshot signing? (I'm just spitballing $ numbers with potential $ saved even after Prielipp).

I just don't see $ available to SS Daniel or OF Dickerson, but you never know. The Twins took a flier on both. Maybe, just maybe, they save enough pool $ with all the senior/4th year juniors that they can tempt them. In most of OUR worlds, I dare say, numbers like $300-500K are a small fortune. But for an 18yo with dreams and aspirations of college ball, a degree, the possibility of being a top 5 round pick or better in 3yrs, it might sound small in the grand scheme of things. 

But if you're the Twins, why wouldn't you take the shot, just in case?

This draft will be defined by the first two picks. Anything after is gravy and good scouting work. But I think they worked this draft pretty damn well. 

Outstanding work Jamie. Thank you.

My biggest concern is whether they can sign Prielipp. I assume they will use the Xtra 5 percent over their bonus pool, but that only takes his number to around 2.1 million. Will that be enough?  Any savings they get from picks 4-10 will have to go to the overslot bonus for Lee.

There was rumors they signed Priellip today overslot. 
 

Also regarding Daniel since he was injured and going to a Juco and if he doesn’t sign, the Twins have up to a year to sign him for $225,000. This sounds like what will likely occur.