Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Squirrel

    Community Leader
    Points
    31,121
    Posts
  2. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts
  3. Doctor Gast

    Verified Member
    Points
    3,665
    Posts
  4. Aggies7

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    17,347
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 12/04/2022 in all areas

  1. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    gman and 3 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I love what Correa brings to the table here for the Twins, which everybody knows. But as I hear casually what to expect as a result of a signing, I started to get uneasy. #1) His health- He had been fine here with Twins so why should I worry? His health history hasn't been that great, plus his size tend to limit his span of playing SS. This alone doesn't necessarily warrants worry but coupled w/ others, especially the next, it does. #2) The money- Of course it's not my money so why should I worry? being a small/ mid-size market, we are limited to what we can do. When I hear estimates of well over $300MM of 8-9 yrs. it makes me nervous. If we sign Correa, that will hamstring us to fill other areas of need for the entirety of the contract. And of course incase of an injury, that'll limit his quality & quantity on the field performance & would eventually switch him to an inferior position. Can we afford that? #3) He'd block Lewis's ceiling- You may say no big deal, he can be an utility player, And I'd agree with you except playing Correa at SS will retard & delay Lewis's full impact on the team and diminish his full trade value if we decide to trade him. When I hear him playing CF, that makes me very very nervous. Arraez was prohibited to play OF because of his knees & their is no danger of him running into anything or anyone. Yet it's alright for Lewis to play CF after 2 major knee surgeries and him at high risk of running into something, someone or diving at full bore. The chances of losing our MVP caliber player to another major knee surgery is high under these circumstances. For me this the tipping point. #4) Lost secondary options - Chances of Correa signing this year by many estimation is less than 50%. So this scenario of coming mid January or later we don't sign Correa we turn to our secondary options, Abreu is gone, Contreras will be gone, Rodon will be gone, Haniger will be gone, the other big SS won't come here (I wouldn't care because I'm not interested in any FA SS). If there is a hole burning in their pockets they'll spend it on the terrible left overs that don't fit this team. It pains me say this but I think we should reevaluate our postion with Correa, cut bait and focus on getting our secondary options that'll help more adequately fill our needs.
  2. Now that DeGrom is confirmed to be off the board, according to Heyman, the Mets are now in on his market. Given the Mets owner and the fact they desperately need rotation help I feel like it's entirely realistic the Twins are going to get entirely priced out of the market. If that's the case does it make sense for them to go after another pitcher that's left? I feel like it's pretty unlikely the Twins will get Rodon at this point.
  3. Personally, I'd look for a trade, if I could ... but I'd be looking for high end BP arms about now. I never thought signing a front end FA starting pitcher was ever realistic for the Twins because it never seems to be realistic. This may free up money for other needs then.
  4. 4 points
    I'm a big no on trading Polanco. The argument here seems to be "he's not very good defensively, has a lot of trade value because his bat and contract, and we have Julien waiting in the wings". But Julien is a worse defender and untested as a major league hitter, so what are we really doing here? A healthy Polanco isn't bad defensively at 2B and is certainly good enough to get by. (and let's be clear, with his terrible knees I wouldn't expect Arraez to hold up well at 2B for a full season either) But the real issue is, we have a superior hitter with a team-friendly contract who is already tested at the MLB level and has performed at an all-star level. If he was going into his final season, maybe it's worth considering, but we've got Polanco for 3 more years if we want him at well below market rate. He makes this lineup significantly better and gives us financial flexibility to add more pieces without having to hope an untested player will come through. This team is too talented to trade away a player like Polanco. We're not in rebuild mode and dealing Polanco would be waving the white flag. Might as well deal every veteran at that point.
  5. 3 points
    Here we are in the first days of December, and there are some fans who are already wondering if this has been a lost offseason for the Twins. Aside from the standard roster cleanup at the end of the season and the 40-man roster additions, the only moves made have been bringing back minor-league free agents Jair Camargo and Elliot Soto. It is also important to note that the annual Winter Meetings are set up for league meetings, rules meetings, minor-league meetings and more. It is also a place where people will bring their resumes and meet with teams, hoping to get jobs or internships. Those looking for jobs in baseball will be dressed in suits and ties. GMs and media are often seen in business casual, if not shorts and a beach button down shirt. If the season started today… I think that it is always important to know the current status. That way, we are able to look at where the roster stands, and see where there are weaknesses and strengths. This is all stuff that the front office does, though much more in-depth and thoroughly than any of us. But for us, it’s where we’re starting. If the season started today, what would the roster look like? C: Ryan Jeffers 1B: Alex Kirilloff 2B: Jorge Polanco 3B: Jose Miranda SS: Kyle Farmer LF: Trevor Larnach CF: Byron Buxton RF: Max Kepler DH: Luis Arraez More 40-Man Options: Edouard Julien, Gilberto Celestino, Mark Contreras, Matt Wallner, Kyle Garlick, Injured: Royce Lewis. Upper-Level, Non-40-Man Roster: David Banuelos, Jair Camargo, Alex Isola, Chris Williams, Michael Helman. Austin Martin, Brooks Lee, SP: Sonny Gray, Joe Ryan, Kenta Maeda, Tyler Mahle, Bailey Ober RP: Jhoan Duran, Jorge Lopez, Caleb Thielbar, Griffin Jax, Jorge Alcala, Emilio Pagan, Jovani Moran, Trevor Megill. More 40-Man Options: Jordan Balazovic, Blayne Enlow, Brent Headrick, Ronny Henriquez, Cole Sands, Louie Varland, Josh Winder, Simeon Woods Richardson Injured: Chris Paddack, Matt Canterino Upper-Level, Non-40-Man Roster: Evan Sisk, Randy Dobnak,Austin Schulfer, Kody Funderburk, Steven Cruz, Cody Laweryson Roster Needs 1.) Shortstop - Obviously the big talker this week, as it has been the last month or more, is what will happen with Carlos Correa? While the Twins have made offers, Correa is going to have many offers. In my opinion, he’ll get 10 years from someone, and I would guess that he would get a number very close to the $325 million that Corey Seager got just a year ago. The Twins love Correa. Correa clearly enjoyed his time with the Twins and developed some very strong relationships in the Twins organization. It may simply come down to money, and the fact that teams like the Dodgers, Yankees, Padres, Phillies, Braves, and Cubs are other teams looking to sign a shortstop, it will be very hard for the Twins to compete with those teams. Could he be willing to get creative to stay with the Twins? So what is the fallback plan? The Twins were aggressive in bringing in Kyle Farmer. If he’s the Twins opening day shortstop, the Twins will be fine, but that is the proverbial floor that they have set. They clearly want Correa. If they don’t get him, I think they’ll continue their conversations with Scott Boras in hopes of signing Xander Bogaerts. You could argue that dollar-for-dollar, that would be a better investment. Bogaerts is only a year younger than Correa, has had a remarkable career in Boston already, and will likely make $100 million less than Correa. The Twins front office clearly has a strong relationship with the Boras agency, so while odds may be low, it’s OK for Twins fans to have some hope in bringing one of them in. 2.) A top starting pitcher - Forced to fill innings and starts in 2022, the Twins gave opportunities to several young starting pitchers. Joe Ryan was the Opening Day starter, and when Bailey Ober was healthy, he pitched well. With the emergence of Varland, Henriquez, Winder, and Woods Richardson, the need to sign veteran fifth starter options to eat innings should not be there. That is especially true when looking at the eight-figure contracts signed last week by Mike Clevinger and Matthew Boyd. Can the Twins count on their starters being healthy in 2023? While it would surely be nice to assume that Kenta Maeda will return from Tommy John and pitch like he did in 2020, that’s probably not fair. Tyler Mahle made just four starts before his shoulder issues continued, but if he’s healthy, he would likely be their top pitcher. Sonny Gray ended the season in the Injured List with a hamstring issue. Bailey Ober had two long stints on the IL with leg issues. If healthy, this rotation can be pretty solid. Maybe no number one starters, but potentially a couple of solid #2s and a couple more solid #3s. The youngsters can be the as-needed starters, working to improve their readiness in St. Paul. If the Twins can add a true #1 starter, that would be huge. The problem is Jacob de Grom inexplicably got five guaranteed seasons from the Rangers. Justin Verlander will either pitch for Houston again or in New York. The only other ace available in free agency is lefty Carlos Rodon, an injury-risk in his own right. Is that the move? Risks are very high with free-agent pitchers. Between one-third and one-half of the 30 teams in the league will be after the southpaw. How strong a starter could the Twins hope for in free agency? Is the trade route a possibility for the Twins? 3.) Backup catcher - I know, the front office and others have said that they would like to add a catcher to split time with Ryan Jeffers or even be a starter. I’m admittedly a big believer in Jeffers. I don’t see a big problem at all. For me, I much prefer they find a solid left-handed hitting catcher to start maybe 60 games while Jeffers gets the other 100 starts. Willson Contreras would be fun and provide strong offense, but I don’t think they need to spend four years and $80 million on a catcher. Christian Vasquez may get $10-12 million annually over a year or two.Both are right handed. Omar Narvaez makes a lot of sense. To a lesser degree, Tucker Barnhart might make sense. I would be fine with them. Honestly, I’d also be intrigued by the likes of Austin Hedges and Mike Zunino, or Roberto Perez or Kevin Plawecki. Really, once you get past Contreras, there aren’t really many catchers that can hit, so they should grab another strong defensive catcher that is well respected. As I mentioned, I’m a big believer in Jeffers, and that includes his bat. Yes, it would be good to see him hovering around .240 instead of .200, but he has the power to hit 20 or more homers if he gets 100 starts. How many catchers can do that? Other Things to Consider Where should the Twins payroll be? While there aren’t great or exact public records for MLB team’s books, if they are to be in the player preferred 48-52% of revenue, the Twins should probably be somewhere between $150 and $165 million in 2023. Will the Twins be able to trade veteran Max Kepler? Should they? Are there other veterans that could be traded? Maybe even Jorge Polanco? Will the team add some solid veteran relievers? Adding even just one more reliable arm for the late innings would help and provide depth for the unforeseen. Or, could they move some of their intriguing starting pitcher prospects to the bullpen to work in roles where they can pitch 2-4 innings at a time? The Twins tendered a 2023 contract to Emelio Pagan, but they will certainly try to trade him during the offseason. Can they get anything for him? Do the Twins need to add speed to their roster in the offseason to take advantage of some of the new rules coming in 2023? Will the Twins make a Rule 5 draft pick? Could they potentially lose players in the Rule 5 draft? They protected four players - and traded one of them - but there are players that the Twins could lose. To this point, the Twins have added a solid MLB shortstop (and a potentially very nice utility piece) in Kyle Farmer. They have a lot of work to do and a lot of difficult questions to answer. Shortstop will certainly be the focus, but will any of the Big 4 free agent shortstops look to sign this early in the offseason? The Twins should also be looking at high-level starting pitching, and they would be wise to add at least one more reliable reliever. Finally, they need to add a reliable catcher to team with Ryan Jeffers. Of course, the Winter Meetings are often more of a time for rumors and conversations to set things up for the next few weeks. The Twins did already make one move this offseason that we all hope will have a huge impact on the organization. In hiring head athletic trainer Nick Paparest, the hope is that the Twins will be able to avoid the massive amount of lost time due to injuries. If that can happen, it could play a huge role in the Twins success in 2023. Some of this may be answered over the coming days in San Diego, and talks will continue right through spring training. It should be a lot of fun.
  6. 3 points
    They need to burn the screen play portion of their playbook
  7. 3 points
    I can see another team taking him but I don't think he will stick. As noted by others the control just isn't there and while he can hit triple digits he can't seem to control his stuff and he has tendency to groove fastballs to stay in the strike zone which tend to fall for hits. So between giving up hits at about one per innings plus all the walks he seems like a long shot to go in Rule V to me. A team could take flyer to see if they can "fix" anything but unless he makes some significant improvements I don't see him in the majors now and maybe never.
  8. The Argument for Trading Jorge Polanco

    ashbury and 2 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic

    3 points
    The only trade that would make sense is if we got an equal or better MLB bat in return. Even then you are just treading water. Need to add not subtract or go lateral on the offensive side.
  9. Despite talent, age, results, and potential, I felt Rodon would be similar to Gausman and Ray last year. I thought 4 or 5yrs and about $25 would get it done. Logic would state that's very fair and within reason. Maybe even an opt out after the 3rd year on a 5yr. But with the Dogers interested and now the Mets, we just might see $30M per and not only am I unsure about return vs $ over time being slanted poorly, history would say the Twins FO just wouldn't take that risk, even with the $ available if they strike out on Correa. I WANT Rodon, and I wanted him last year. So did the Twins. And they wanted him at the trade deadline but the Giants held on. I just don't see it happening at $30+ M. I would like an addition as good as what we have, at least, for depth and opportunity. And there are arms I like out there. I'm not sure about trades as the Twins, while still having a solid system in place, have already traded away a lot. With or without Correa back, I think I would concentrate on the rest of the lineup, and add at least one quality BP arm, maybe two if it works, and worry more about the lineup and the pen and trust in the rotation arms and young depth on hand. Again, someone added the equivalent to what we have might be prudent and smart. But with no Correa, and Rodon probably costing that much, I shift to bats, bullpen, and another SP that is SOLID.
  10. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    Heiny and 2 others reacted to Beast for a post in a topic

    3 points
    If you have a chance to secure one of the elite shortstops in the game, you don’t turn him down in the hopes that Lewis sticks at short. It’s not guaranteed. Also, it’s unlikely that he’s anywhere near as good as Correa. I don’t know how you can plan your future around a guy that has barely played in the last three years. I see the potential, and I’m hopeful. Seems like a great kid. But, handing him the keys the shortstop position and just finding someone to keep the seat warm is a disaster waiting to happen. That’s a losing move way more often than not
  11. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    TwinsRealist and 2 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I'm not optimistic about that. The Twins need to boost their anemic attendance to match similar markets like Milwaukee and St Louis. Paid attendance is important not just for the dollars it directly brings in, but as a proxy for overall interest in the team. If I'm in the broadcast business and trying to sell ads, I'm not hopeful I can suddenly charge, say, 50% more during the next contract. So I'm not offering 50% more. I have many concerns about our FO, and this is one of the underrated ones. Twins attendance in 2022 was a tad below the worst of the dreary final years under Terry Ryan. That is a low bar already, and not something to be proud of. If I were owner I'd be demanding a 5-year Get Well Plan that increases the paid attendance up closer to 3,000,000 (among other metrics I'm less aware of) without relying on a World Series title or another sparkling new stadium. St Louis does it; the franchise needs to turn the Twin Cities into a "good baseball town" too. Joe Pohlad has a real opportunity to make his mark in the franchise's history, if he can help figure this out. And he can reach out to teams like those I named, Boston also, to help guide his thinking - the teams compete on the field and that's a zero-sum game, but financially a rising tide lifts all boats, as they say, while struggling franchises are like an anchor to the others. Successful teams should be willing to share ideas and their accumulated wisdom. (And yes, I'm sure they and MLB in general do some things along such lines already.) As you note, better income would make a world of difference. I'm not seeing the progress. Hopefully the next broadcast contract proves me wrong.
  12. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    TiberTwins and 2 others reacted to dxpavelka for a post in a topic

    3 points
    When you sign Correa you bring in the owner at 600 1st Avenue to discuss the potential of spending a big part of his big contract as a 3rd baseman. He's been down that road. Don't make moves based on what MIGHT happen in the future. If Lewis comes back and earns the opportunity to take the SS job away from Correa then great. If he's the better man, great. If Lewis doesn't ever do that, than how are we better served by NOT signing Correa. Two years ago we moved on from Eddie Rosario because we thought we had better future alternatives. We can argue all day about what Rosario has done elsewhere or might have done here but what cannot be debated is that that the guys we've run out to those corner OF spots for the last 2 years have NOT met expectations. Don't repeat that history. If Lewis comes back and performs there will be a spot for him. If he performs and Correa does as well, there will be a spot for both. This team (and fan base) spends too much time worrying about having too much talent. Such an issue will never exist.
  13. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    Heiny and 2 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I don't not want to sign Correa because of what Lewis might become. For a long time, there was a lot of doubt that Lewis would even stick at SS. I still have those doubts. We should never pass on a huge upgrade at a position because of what a prospect might become. That is a way to build a losing team. Not to mention Lewis won't be available at the start of the season and then will need time to ramp up. And Arraez isn't in the outfield just because of his knees, although that is a consideration. He's not in the outfield because he wasn't needed out there and he wasn't all that good out there. Lewis does not have the same knee issues Arraez has. And Arraez has knee issues playing infield, too ... if that truly is a concern for Lewis, he won't be a SS and his value is already gone. But I don't think he faces the same knee issues. If they converted him to play CF, he has value. Playing 3rd would be a good place for him, too, especially with Correa at SS. Or they trade him while his stock is good. But to not sign a legitimately great player at a position because of what a prospect might do is foolish. And because he might not sign until January or later is no reason they can't make other deals. They know what they have to spend. Considering what DeGrom got, I'm concerned with the money Rodon will make and he his far more risk for the cost, imo, than Correa is. Signing any player to a long term deal is a risk. Heck, every player is a risk, for that matter. They will never be worth the money at the end of it, but you sign them for what they bring at the beginning/middle of it. And signing Correa will not hamstring us. We have the payroll budget room to do it. These ideas are the way to never win, imo.
  14. Hello everyone, allow me to introduce myself. Steve Trefz, 42 yrs old, Twins fan by virtue of birthplace (farm in rural NorthCentral South Dakota), of influence (Herb and John every summer evening for 3.5 hrs), and of circumstance (first World Series that I remember watching was 1987, which was also the year of the first Metrodome trip and Twins game of my life). I have more to share when it comes to "Why the Twins?," but for now I just want to introduce where this blog is headed...literally. 26 Series 22 Stadiums 81 Games 1 Idea that I just can't shake What started out as a dream...a vision...is now actually happening. The original vision for this journey emerged in the winter of 2019-20. I had planned out the travel, the cost, the ramifications of attending all 162 Twins games in person Needless to say, 2020 would not be the year that I attended all 162 games for my favorite squad. The reasons are legion, and obvious to all of us who have lived through the past few years. But in the meantime, and in the present, the dream continued. An altered quest emerged. As a resident of Mitchell, SD, I've discovered that while I've loved having a flex-plan season ticket package off and on for the past several years, getting to Minneapolis for home games has become less and less feasible. In many ways, every pilgrimage to Target Field serves as a reminder that while I feel at "home" at Target Field, going to all 162 essentially "away" games was not going to happen with my current life circumstance (Husband of an awesome lady, and Father of two awesome teenage boys). The dream, however, refuses to leave me. Enter a negotiation, a truce, a window of grace... "All 81." An epic, albeit difficult, journey to be with my team out on the road. A pledge to be present and accounted for in a Twins jersey at each of the enemy stadiums. A quest to rekindle a love for community, and my country, after a couple of years of being isolated. A hope for the kind of experience that might shape me for years (if not generations) to come. Plus it should be a blast! Stay tuned please, I would love to share this journey with you. I plan to post every few days during the "planning" phase of the season. Let me know as we go how far into the weeds you want me to get. I have spreadsheets, data points, mileage and cost estimates, qualitative community assessments for the various cities and neighborhoods, etc. I'm prepared to nerd out. I also look forward to sharing the stories, sights, emotions, and insights that emerge from the quest. I'm prepared to get personal. I also look forward to a freaking division championship and a World Series run that adds another dozen or so "away" games to my list :) I'm prepared to get medication to help with that part. I'm going to need your help in this. I'm starting this quest with this community in mind. The TwinsDaily family (aka you the reader) has helped me navigate through much of the nastiness of the past few years. It's my prayer and hope that by me going to all 81, you will be right there with me. Grace and peace, and thanks for reading! Until next time, Steve
  15. Next week, the MLB Winter Meetings will take place in San Diego, and the Rule 5 Draft is part of the annual event. The opportunity is given to teams to select unprotected players from other organizations that meet specific criteria. Rule 5 Draft eligibility is tied to when a player first signed with their club. Players signed at 18 or younger must be added to the 40-man roster within five seasons. Players signed at 19 or older have four seasons before they must be protected. For this year's draft, high school or international picks signed in 2018 had to be added to the 40-man roster, and college players signed in 2019. There are also rules tied to the drafting of a player. During the MLB phase of the Rule 5 Draft, drafting clubs pay $100,000 to select a player. From there, the player has to stick on the team's 26-man roster for the entire season or be offered back to his former team for half the selection fee ($50,0000). Over the last decade, here are some of the players tied to the Twins through the Rule 5 Draft. Minnesota's Best Pick: Ryan Pressly The Twins had the fourth overall pick in the 2012 Rule 5 Draft after finishing with 99 losses the previous season. There were plenty of holes to fill on the roster, so the Twins selected Ryan Pressly from the Red Sox organization. Pressly spent six seasons in the Twins organization and posted a 3.75 ERA with a 1.30 WHIP. He had an 8.0 K/9 and a 112 ERA+ before the Twins traded him to the Astros at the 2018 trade deadline. Pressly has gone on to have a tremendous career in Houston with multiple All-Star appearances and a World Series title. He provided plenty of value to the Twins before the trade, and both players acquired from Houston project to impact the 2023 roster (Gilberto Celestino and Jorge Alcala). Twins fans can play the "What if?" game with Pressly, but he likely wouldn't have reached the same level of success without moving to Houston. Minnesota's Worst Loss: Akil Baddoo Baddoo was Minnesota's second-round pick one year before the current front office took over. He had shown some promise as a prospect, but he had played fewer than 30 games above the Low-A level, making it easier to leave him unprotected. The Tigers took him with the third overall pick in the 2020 Rule 5 Draft, and he went on to have a tremendous rookie campaign. In 124 games, he hit .259/.330/.436 (.766) with 20 doubles, seven triples, and 13 home runs. He provided 2.1 WAR for a Tigers team that started moving in the right direction. From the Twins' perspective, losing Baddoo was challenging because the club desperately needed outfield depth during the 2021 campaign. Last season, Baddoo struggled at the big-league level as his OPS dropped to .558, and the Tigers sent him to Triple-A to find his swing. He posted a .905 OPS with 14 extra-base hits in 30 games, so there is some hope for him to return to his performance level from his rookie season. The Jury's Still Out: Tyler Wells Minnesota left Wells unprotected in the same Rule 5 Draft as Baddoo, and Baltimore took him in the second round with the 17th overall pick. The Orioles used him as a reliever throughout the 2021 season, and he compiled a 4.11 ERA with a 0.91 WHIP and 10.3 K/9. Last season, the Orioles transitioned him to a starting role, and the results were mixed. In 23 starts (103 2/3 innings), he had a 4.25 ERA with a 1.14 WHIP and a 76-to-28 strikeout-to-walk ratio. He ranked in the 59th percentile or higher in xBA, BB%, and chase rate. His fastball spin also is among the league's best, in the 93rd percentile. Baltimore was a surprise team in 2022, and Wells tied for the second-most starts on the team. He will continue to get opportunities to start in 2023, and he plans to focus on consistency and endurance to become part of Baltimore's long-term plan. The Rule 5 Draft can be challenging for teams to find big-league talent, but it's been nearly a decade since the Twins found a consistent big- league player. Do you think the Twins will regret losing Baddoo and Wells? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion.
  16. 2 points
    As the longest-tenured Twins player—he rubbed elbows with Kendrys Morales while sipping his cup of coffee in 2014—Polanco’s presence provided continuity during the great team overhaul following 2016. Rather than start from scratch, the new decision-makers earmarked Polanco (and Max Kepler) as answers to the problem, not sources of the malady, and both players signed extensions before the 2019 season. Polanco represents the best and worst of Twins position players under the Falvey regime: a skilled OBP and power threat with a worrisome lack of defensive ability whose nagging injuries have capped his upside. His .272/.339/.455 slash line since 2018 makes him the envy of the middle infield ball—those players have hit for a collective .257/.318/.409 over the same period. Yet, despite a move to an easier position, defensive stats remain unamused with Polanco’s glove, constantly ranking him as a poor defender. Looking around the league, that style of position-less player has fallen out of fashion; the Houston Astros employ a litany of two-way stars who can hit as well as they can field, and the Dodgers only sign a player if they can catch, man shortstop, glide in the outfield, and announce in a pinch if Joe Davis catches a cold. Yordan Álvarez is an exception, but teams tend to ignore fielding gaffes when you’re hitting at a near Bondsian level. Despite the defensive issues, Polanco’s contract helps buoy his value. That deal from 2019 remains in effect, and assuming that a team will jump at the opportunity to pick up his $12 million club option for 2025, he is effectively good for three years of control at $30 million. That’s an attractive price tag. A team like like the Cubs might happily deal quality prospects or equivalent major-league talent to net Polanco’s offensive consistency for just $10 million a season. In what we could call “The Edouard Julien Influence,” the Twins may already have a major-league-caliber starter waiting in the wings. Julien spent his 2022 regular season smoking pitches at AA before finding an extra gear in the Arizona Fall League, ramping up his batting to lead the whole darn league in OPS (1.249). Yes, that number is correct. He also stole six bases without a misstep, just for giggles. Minnesota understood his value and added him to the 40-man roster, protecting him from other conniving teams in the Rule-5 draft. Julien’s glove is as detrimental as Polanco’s, which negates the previous defensive argument, but his bat has a good chance at reaching the same plateau. Or, just as well, the Twins could move Luis Arraez back to his original position, ending the hilarious adventures in having a 5' 10" first baseman with 14 career home runs. The savings matter. Re-signing Carlos Correa—beyond being the right move—eats up a significant portion of the theoretical payroll cap, enough to make squeezing in a Carlos Rodón type impossible. If the Twins want both a star shortstop and a starting pitcher better than Matt Shoemaker, they need to diligently purge their books, and the Gio Urshela trade does not create enough leeway. It would be a tough move; few enjoy seeing an old friend go, especially when they are still productive, but Minnesota needs to engage in ruthless efficiency if they want to move forward into the highest tier of teams.
  17. This is the first I’ve heard concerns about losing him. The Twins have never had luck fixing guys with this level of control issues, I think it would be a long shot the Twins would ever call him up. So if he does get picked, added to a MLB roster and paid a MLB wage, good for him.
  18. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    Squirrel and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    We just played the top 4 ranked defenses in football the last 4 weeks. How did that turn out? Mike Zimmer, is that you?
  19. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    wabene and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I highly, highly doubt it. Jimmy G is out for the rest of the season.
  20. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    NotAboutWinning and one other reacted to gman for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I don't know that I would want to fill 1 spot with $40mil and leave the other 8 spots in the lineup as unknowns. True 1 spot filled is better than none, but usually you sign that $40mil player when most of your other spots are known and have been performing for a number of years. If we were in the playoffs without Correa and chased him down to get a push over the top that's one thing. Signing a player for $40 mil when you have 8 unknowns due to health, inexperience or both doesn't get us very far. I would like to see the $40 mil spread among 3-4 players instead.
  21. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    Jerr and one other reacted to MABB1959 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Hard to make any money from satellite or cable when it is unavailable to many. I dropped DishTV this year and went to YouTube TV. Don’t miss DISH at all. It is pathetic that we cannot watch many games. MLB is all about money. But it is also the ridiculous player salaries. Going to a game is very expensive. Sadly families cannot afford to go to many games. Ticket costs and food costs ($6 for a soda) are insane.
  22. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    wabene and one other reacted to LVTwinsfan for a post in a topic

    2 points
    10-2, that’s not luck, the reason the Jets lost is because they couldn’t finish drives. Defense deserves credit for holding them to 5 field goals
  23. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    wabene and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    We just finished 3-1 against the most difficult stretch on our schedule. 14-3 is not out of the realm of possibilities.
  24. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    cHawk and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    2 points
    The DC is terrible. Awful. Horrible.
  25. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    Danchat and one other reacted to LVTwinsfan for a post in a topic

    2 points
    We should be used to this by now
  26. 2022 Vikings Regular Season Thread

    Parfigliano and one other reacted to Aggies7 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Timeouts are irrelevant at this point. I would have thrown it there
  27. If anybody has read any of the other Rule 5 articles over the last few days, let me attempt to summarize a response that the title of this article is asking: No.
  28. To stop thinking of money and concentrating on pitching, fielding, hitting and managing is a weird statement to make. Those positions cost money. If you go with the cheap players all the time you get what you pay for:. Cheap performance and terrible results. The past two years have been very poor and very boring. I believe we need to invest the payroll and distribute it out better. Another weird statement? That Buxton is a superstar. A superstar puts up superstar stats and plays. Part time players are not superstars!! Buxton got a great deal for himself. Getting 15 mill per year to play to play about 50% of your teams games for 7 of the 8 years, is a very friendly deal. A Buxton friendly deal. Good for him.
  29. But I keep this article current so stop by and check it out. Thank you.
  30. 2 points
    As near as I can piece together what must have happened, Florida with the second pick really wanted Jared Camp and was afraid Minnesota would snare him first. So they must have offered Minnesota $50,000 to swap picks - except MLB doesn't allow trading of draft picks so they had to resort to this bit of chicanery, and they opted not to operate simply on a handshake and then pony up the $50K later in some fashion. Kudos to Terry Ryan for keeping a good poker face and still getting the man they probably wanted in the first place. I think it's completely fair to view Santana as Minnesota's actual rule-5 pick.
  31. I don't believe the Twins have any realistic chance, and maybe not even any interest, in signing Rodon. They would get out bid in a heartbeat. I think Bassitt is a possibility, but even he's probably more than they would spend on a FA starter. I think they're gonna roll with the starting pitchers they already have, and focus on a SS and a catcher. There's always the chance they make some kind of trade.
  32. The Argument for Trading Jorge Polanco

    bighat and one other reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Why this keeps coming up? The offseason is long and people get bored? Of the 4 deals you mention, the Twins came out well for Kepler and Polanco's contracts; even with Kepler not having a great year in 2022 he was still worth 2.1 bWAR and definitely more than his less than $7M salary (and has done for the length of his contract). It's also why people still talk about him having trade value. Polanco's deal has been an absolute steal for the team. The Dobnak deal hasn't worked out, but also has cost them very little. If he can get healthy and be a quality reliever, then they could still end up about even on that one. The Sano one didn't work out for the team, but the decision-making around it was sound, so I don't have any real objections to how they're moving on extensions. If the Twins add high-end talent through free agency this off-season they can absolutely contend, whether it's bringing back Correa, or adding Rodon plus a big bat, or whatever. Health is what snuffed out this team's chances last season, not talent. Polanco is a key part to that lineup, a consistent veteran presence and they would have to get a ridiculous, staggering return (which they won't) to make dealing Polanco worth it.
  33. This is not happening for the Twins. Don’t look now but the Twins are one major trade like this (if it is all prospects) from having a pretty barren farm system.
  34. No worries. We have Pagan and Megill so we are all set.
  35. Right now, I am working on the other side of Florida on the St John's and Tolomato Rivers and we too have to adjust to damage from Ian. It is hard to explain how big and damaging that storm was. Thank you for remembering those who stepped up - there are so many who deserve to be thanked. Good luck to the team getting this done and moving on.
  36. The way MLB works now - BP is the key. I love the Verlander style of SP, but not at 40, but his role is going out and 4 - 5 inning starts means lots of BP arms - quality arms to fill half the innings pitched. Rodon's health is an issue (as an aside - good luck keeping deGrom healthy) and there just needs to be a new strategy to pitching composition.
  37. The Argument for Trading Jorge Polanco

    RpR and one other reacted to bighat for a post in a topic

    2 points
    The "trade Polanco" chant has come up every off-season for the past 3 years. The Twins have gambled on a few guys, giving them affordable long term contracts: Sano, Kepler, Dobnak and Polanco. It could be argued that the Polanco contract was the only one that worked out in the Twins' favor. The guy is capable in the infield, he can carry the team with his bat when he gets hot....and he's got a team-friendly contract. News flash: those are the guys you KEEP. No way the Twins trade him, and I have no idea why this sick fantasy keeps popping into some fans' heads.
  38. 2 points
    The argument shouldn't be should the Twins trade Polanco. It should be what value can they get for him? I am a big fan of Polanco, enjoy watching him play, but if the Twins can clearly improve their MLB team and chances of stronger contention by trading Polanco of course they should trade him.
  39. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    Doctor Gast and one other reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic

    2 points
    From a "Doc" to the "Doctor", I understand the misgivings of so much $ tied in to one player, Correa in this instance. I would be lying if such a deal didn't concern me, as well as the "potential" of spending that money elsewhere. I think one question to be asked is "would they spend that $ wisely? Now, that's not an indictment of the FO. I think they've made a ton of good moves. I also think they've missed the boat more than once and ended up slashing in the bay. So there is the factor of "can" they spend the $ better vs "will" they? Again, not starting up a debate or indictment. CAN they sign Correa? Yes. I think the odds are above the 10-15% thoughts I've heard. I really like the variety of offers they have started with. Makes tremendous sense for both sides. It actually gives Correa and Boras a lot of power down the line in a couple of years. I think the proposal Nick laid out in a recent article is probably closer to a "get it done" scenario that i think Correa and Boras, frankly, would be FOOLISH not to grab a pen and sign immediatley, if not sooner! It has all the guaranteed $ they could possibly want and STILL gives them options. Personally, i think the reality of such a deal might be a bit of a compromise between the Twins initial offer and the proposed Nick offer. And later years, hus overall $ to the payroll decreases. But I'm getting a little off point here. Even with the Correa signing, the team still has needs, but still has $ to spend for a couple more smart adds to the team. He doesn't completely handcuff the team. I really want Correa for a lot of reasons, and not just for what he brings to the field and the plate for the next, at least, 4-7yrs. I want his leadership. He already began running some drills and practices, reportedly, almost as a coach last year. He, reportedly, wants to take that a step forward in 2023. I love his experience, leadership, and drive. My goodness, he's opened his door to take Miranda under his wing to work with him and develop him this offseason. I want Correa to sell jerseys and put fans in the seat for a team that's "going for it". I want Correa to show the rest of the baseball world that Minnesota, and it's tremendous park and fans, is actually a destination place to be taken seriously. I believe he can help do those things. From what I've seen of Lewis at the ML level, ST games, and hilights from the minors, I have little doubt he'd be a good, solid, ML SS with some great offense, and the potential to be better. Even still, why pass on adding a great player when you can? I commented a year or so ago about Lewis taking all of his talent and potential and playing 3B, or the OF, and got pushback from others as that would be a "waste of his talent". And I never understood that thought process. Was it a waste for the Yankees to put Rodriguez at 3B? Was it a waste for the Angels to play Erstad at CF AND 1B while in his prime? Do the Dogers "waste" good players because they can plug them in at different positions? Lewis could end up being one of the best 3B or 2B in all of MLB. That's not a "waste". How about, a year or so from now, maybe Lee takes over 3B, Correa at SS, Lewis at 2B, and Miranda back to 1B again, possibly sharing time with AK and Arraez, while ALL of these young talents could cover other positions as needed. And then, what about Julien? (Notice I haven't even mentioned Polanco)? Well, there are trade possibilities. Maybe Julien ends up at 2B and Lewis becomes a tremendous OF? And while I still believe Martin ends up in the OF, maybe he becomes a super-utility type who covers the OF as well as 3B/2B and emergency SS? I think Lee and Lewis and Miranda are quality. I think Julien might be. I'm finally starting to believe Martin might be, though not as a SS. And I'm not even speaking about AK, Larnach, and Wallner right now as I'm just focused on the infield. There is a real chance, not an "inconceivable" one......CUE TO ASH FOR THE OBLIGATORY PRINCESS BRIDE GIF......that some point in 2023 and/or early 2024 that the Twins, position player wise, have a "how do we fit all of this talent on to one roster" situation. Man, that would be an outstanding "problem" to have. I won't cry if Correa goes elsewhere. The sky won't fall. There's a lot of young talent already here and on the way. But you never pass up difference makers to your team, and your organization, if you can do so. But I believe if the Twins CAN/DO bring back Correa, he does a lot more than raising the floor of the infield. I think he changes the look, feel, product, and perception of the Twins. All is not lost without him, by any means. I understand misgivings. I just think time and opportunity, as well as manipulaton of the roster and payroll, has presented the Twins with a special opportunity to make a statement. I'd hate to lose out on that opportunity.
  40. I think the Twins could and should sign Rodon, regardless if the market comes in stronger than estimated. With as low of payroll as they have right now, if they don’t sign a big name, big contract, front of the rotation starter, they never will. my guess is “never will”, but my hope is this is the year
  41. Agree. Get good BP arms 1st. Id be shocked if deGrom makes 20 starts.
  42. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    TwinsRealist and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Boston's been sub-.500 4 out of the past 10 seasons (and if I were cherry picking even more transparently I'd say 5 of the past 11). Last place in each instance, to boot. You're right about the investment in players though, as they and St Louis both blow kisses to their fan base with big signings and so forth. I'll mention also for Boston, though it has a nominally larger metro population than the Twin Cities, their being hemmed in on one side by the ocean means that the population isn't ideally distributed for supporting a sports team close to downtown. If you measure by number of people within, say, 10 miles of the ballpark, Target Field might give Fenway a run for its money., and might be a closer comp than is generally assumed. (TV market of course would be a differentiator. Concentrated wealth of the nearby population might be another. But I digress.) IMO much of Boston's edge in revenue is gotten the old fashioned way, as the old TV commercial phrased it: they earn it. Anyway, that investment doesn't do much if the fan base doesn't feel like the kisses are being blown to them. Dave St Peter and I think Jim Pohlad both in this offseason have remarked about poor attendance maybe putting constraints on next year's budget - talk about shooting yourself in the foot! Even if they re-sign Correa now there's still a bad taste in the mouth from the scolding, as though any signing is grudging. Blown kisses should never be grudging. ? Okay I'm pushing the metaphor too far. But St Louis loves the Cardinals and the Cardinals return the favor, ditto Boston, and there are lessons to be learned from them.
  43. 2 points
    I don't care what the figure is - what I want is a complete team - we will not have DeGrom and Judge and probably not Verlander and Correa, but that does not mean that we will not have a good team. California can't win with Trout, Rendon and Ohtani. Yankees have not won the Series with Cole, Judge and Stanton. The Dodger have the best season record but did not get to the Series. The Braves were NL champions for over a decade, but only one a single WS title. It is about getting an all around team and working as a team. That is not money - Scherzer did not bring the Mets a championship. Correa did not win a championship for us. Stop thinking about writing a big check and think about fielding, hitting, pitching, managing. Think about the bench and the bullpen, the minor league support system. It is about an organization! The Braves might have only won a single series in the decade but they were always there. St Louis has consistently been a winning team, but other than Nolan they did not spend wildly. They traded and they stayed with their system. Its not moneyball anymore, its finding the right parts.
  44. If you go looking for Twins 2022 payroll numbers, you are going to get frustrated because virtually every site you look at has a different number. Did they calculate before, during, or after the season? Did they include dead money to the right year? Did they include any dead money? Etc, etc. Believe me, I've looked. So let's just talk an average based on all numbers. That's almost dead on at $140M. (Ultimately, it sure looks like they spent more TOTAL than that when all was said and done. If you allow for even a small, expected, inflationary rise across all of MLB and allow for ONLY 5% you now have a target of $147M. Now, even for a mid-market team with poor TV and radio deals, that states they actually have usually been "exceeding" comfortable percentages of payroll vs income...(one assumes the normal 50-52%)...another couple $M to get to $150 is a drop in the bucket. (And I'm not going to argue books not being open or the Pohlad's are cheap or any of that). I'd love $160M! I'm just not sure attendance, shared revenue, and other factors are going to allow for a $20M bump in a 1yr time frame. But if the Twins truly want to be in legitimate contention, the bump to $150M should be more than affordable, even if a little "uncomfortable" to put the best team on the field, a nice collection of young talent and some quality adds. $150M!
  45. 2 points
    Locking down a premium defensive SS, that also hits at the top 3 at his position has tons of value. You say he only added 4 wins. 4 wins from one player is fantastic. Yes, I agree giving up that money hurts, but if there was a time to do it, it is now. Most the rest of our talent, especially in the pitching staff is CHEAP right now. Also, the only reason I am even close to OK with paying Correa whatever it takes is the fact that he is 28 years old. If he were 30-32 I would not want to give him all of that money. Lewis is interesting. He looked really good in limited time at SS when we saw him. But he will likely take a couple years to become the kind of stud we all think he can be. He is still very YOUNG. He can get plenty of time between SS and 3rd until it is apparent he is the better option at SS than Carlos.
  46. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    Jerr and one other reacted to MABB1959 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    If the Twins don’t spend on players like Correa by focusing on the negatives, then they might as well hang it up for good. We don’t need to be a small or mid market team. If they spend/invest they can get there. Hard to make money if you don’t invest. Geez I bet jersey sales are down since we don’t have a marquee player. Ticket sales won’t go up, Not sure how TV revenue works. I don’t think the Pohlad’s have ever taken a loss but they haven’t come close to delivering what they promised when they got the new stadium. In fact it seems like they did better in the Metrodome. We at least have memories of really good players and a stable team. The only players that stick around more than a few years are substandard. The worst part is we have had the same discussions at the end of every season since have been at Target field. It is too sad.
  47. Reconsidering Carlos Correa

    TwinsRealist and one other reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    My favorite kind of post, pass on a star because the next prospect will be great. star may get hurt, star may cost too much.Talk about trading the Twins scraps for an Stud pitcher. Sell hope for a future that is never there because because next year a different star will be too much money and the next prospect will save the day. Complain the Twins don't spend enough money, rinse/repeat. Correa turned 28 in September if he will sign here for 8 years you sign him end of story. Lewis will be 24 by the time he might be ready to come back. Correa had over 20 WAR by that age and close to that since.
  48. 2 points
    Really it’s just a question of when, not if. And that’s no knock on Polanco - he’s a really good professional baseball player and absolutely one of my favourite Twins. But the facts are: a) He plays on a mid-market, budget-constrained team that will need cash to fill in the holes via FAs; b) The Twins top three prospects (Lewis, Lee and Julien) plus two top youngsters already on the club (Arraez and Miranda) are all infielders needing a place to play - and this traffic jam is compounded by signing Farmer and if we resign CC; and c) His performance - perhaps all or mostly all due to health - is clearly starting to diminish and it’s unclear if that slide can be turned around. Having said all that, Polanco clearly has chemistry with CC (which may help on the margin in resigning CC), he has been really good in the field and at the plate when healthy, the young guys still need seasoning/proving/healing, and he’s a true pro with veteran presence who’s not that expensive. Prediction: Polanco is not traded in the off-season. The Twins resign CC and give Polanco every chance to get back into form. However, if the Twins are not definitively in the hunt by the trade deadline (almost regardless of how Polanco is performing), the prospects are knocking hard at the door, or he’s not very good anymore, he gets moved in the summer. The chances of Polanco being with the Twins in ‘24 are slim. The sad truth is that the old young core we were hoping would lead us to a WS a couple of years ago - Sano, Kepler, Polanco, Berrios, and, even, Garver - are now, rightfully, having to give way to a new, deeper, and possibly/hopefully better young core. Kepler and Polanco are the last two and both, unless something extraordinary happens, will be gone before next season,
  49. Ronny Henriquez Has Earned a Shot

    Minny505 and one other reacted to HerbieFan for a post in a topic

    2 points
    This kid is so clearly one of the top internal options to help the bullpen. Would love to see what he and a healthy Alcala can add to the 'pen.
  50. Santana wasn't technically a Rule 5 pick by the Twins. He was a Rule 5 pick for the Marlins, then the teams swapped R5 picks giving the Twins Santana.. The Twins have had some success pulling guys out of the draft: Shane Mack Scott Diamond Ryan Pressly They have also lost a little as well: RA Dickey This article is a few years old, but gives a nice overview of the Twins R5 history: https://twinstrivia.com/twins-rule-5-draft-history/
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.