Leaderboard
-
Brock Beauchamp
AdministratorPoints29,624Posts -
TopGunn#22
Verified MemberPoints1,164Posts -
Lucas Seehafer PT
Twins Daily ContributorPoints440Posts -
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/25/2021 in all areas
-
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
glunn and 8 others reacted to TopGunn#22 for a post in a topic
9 pointsWhy the Twins FO has dithered on this for so long is a question the average fan cannot answer. Remember when we Twins fans basically had the conversation "If you had to choose between Buxton and Berrios, who would YOU choose??" Well, it was a spirited debate but I believe the winner was Buxton. It wasn't "massively" in favor of Buxton, but he WAS the player most here on TD would have chosen. And this was with our starting rotation in a total shambles. The reason Buxton won out was because his talent (when healthy) is top 10 in baseball. Berrios was no where near a top 10 pitcher. So the Twins "appeared" to make their choice and traded Berrios to Toronto for two very nice looking prospects. I believed the trade was a good one at the time and I still do. Time may prove me wrong, but Martin and Woods-Richardson could be outstanding players for the Twins in the future. Now however, the Twins FO seems to be stumbling and bumbling with what that strategy was supposed to be. As fans, we still have no idea how they and the Pohlad's view this team for 2022. There is nothing close to a "clear vision" coming out of the ivory towers of Twins leadership and I'm not sure ownership or the FO sees that for the problem it is. We play in the A.L. Central. There is no reason, given the talent still on the team and the resources that could be leveraged, that the Twins SHOULD be a contender in 2022 despite the fact that the White Sox are "ALL IN" on burying us next year and for years to come. Buxton is the key to everything. he's the type of player that should be the foundation of what the Twins want to be for the next 8-10 years. He appears to be coming into his own. You can just tell when you see him at the plate...this is a different cat than what we've seen previous. He is confident and has a plan. Remember when Paul Molitor kept getting hurt early in his career. And then, he just kind of cleared that hurdle all the way to a Hall of Fame career, helping the Blue Jays to back to back World Series championships and being named World Series MVP in one of them. I believe Buxton is going to clear that same hurdle and be relatively healthy going forward. This ownership and FO need to step up and get this deal done. As I mentioned earlier, the lack of clarity from both as to 2022 and their vision is dumping water on any fire there might be for 2022. When a two time defending A.L. Central team crashes and burns to a last place divisional finish, the FO and ownership need to be correcting the flaws and making moves to get the team in a position to fire up the fanbase. Failure to do this will ensure a disaster revenue-wise for the team next season. Fans will continue to be soured on the commitment of ownership and the FO to not only provide a good team/good product but to keep good, homegrown talent on the roster. And wasn't that the entire premise of building Target Field anyway ??9 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
Hunter48 and 6 others reacted to GNess for a post in a topic
7 pointsByron Buxton, injuries and all, is an exceedingly rare talent who can impact the outcome of a MLB game in myriad ways. Just how many current and future Buxtons do the Twins think they have? Here is a hint for the Front Office: Less than 2 and more than zero. Sign Buxton!7 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
snyde043 and 6 others reacted to Lucas Seehafer PT for a post in a topic
7 pointsFair, but the two moves aren't a 1:1 comparison. As time went on, it became pretty obvious that Berrios wasn't going to re-sign with the Twins. In that case, it makes some sense to trade him and at least get something in return. (And they got more of a prospect haul than anyone expected.) In the case of Buxton, it seems as though he's more than willing to re-sign, but the Twins are the ones balking. Giving him an offer well-below his production value only to trade him gives a false sense of trying.7 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
LA VIkes Fan and 6 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
7 pointsThe enigma is why the Twins waited so long to extend and lock up this talent. Everyone sees it, we know it is special, we have no CF to replace him at this point. Since losing Kirby we have had a long list of good CF all of whom we traded, maybe we should keep one. I am not a money guy and prices make no sense to me, but MLB has created its own economy and the team needs to work within it. We still have a need for a strong C/SS/CF to defend and compete. Without Buxton we have only one of the positions filled at this time. Give us a Thanksgiving present - sign Buxton so we can go on and anguish over SS and SP!7 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
Twins33 and 5 others reacted to heresthething for a post in a topic
6 pointsIf true, a 20 million gap over 7 years is absurd for the Twins to balk at. If you're already at 80 the extra 20 for a shot at this level of talent is a no brainer. How many millions have we watched them throw at dumpster talent in the hope that they will have a turn around year? Yet they seemingly won't budge for Buxton.6 points -
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
spanman2 and 4 others reacted to sorney for a post in a topic
5 pointsWith the DH now open, they can even rest him in the field on cold days (that's why they got Caveman, right? ARG!!!). I have never been more on a side of a player than Buxton...especially if the $70M extension plus incentives, was true. If a team isn't going to pay for elite home grown talent, board em up.5 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Doctor Gast and 4 others reacted to bean5302 for a post in a topic
5 pointsJeffers had a grand total of 6 passed balls last year. You can see how they stack up vs. all catchers in MLB with 300+ innings last year. In terms of innings caught between passed balls, Jeffers (111.7) and Garver (112.8) were slightly below median average (121.2). Both Jeffers (27.9) and Garver (28.2) were slightly above median average (26.0) in terms of innings caught between wild pitches. Overall, the combination puts them both slightly above average, ranked 24th and 22nd out of 60, respectively. So if there were metrics for the balls that got away from Twins catchers, they would likely be positive overall. Catcher Team Innings Passed Balls Inn/PB Rank Wild Pitches Inn/WP Rank Inn/Combo Rank Buster Posey SFG 892 2 446.0 6 18 49.6 2 44.6 1 Manny Pina MIL 452.1 3 150.7 23 8 56.5 1 41.1 2 Yan Gomes - - - 771.1 3 257.0 12 18 42.8 3 36.7 3 Cam Gallagher KCR 308.2 1 308.2 10 8 38.5 5 34.2 4 Danny Jansen TOR 481.1 0 Inf 3 15 32.1 12 32.1 5 J.T. Realmuto PHI 973 6 162.2 21 25 38.9 4 31.4 6 Austin Hedges CLE 743.2 2 371.6 8 24 31.0 13 28.6 7 Roberto Perez CLE 364 3 121.3 30 10 36.4 7 28.0 8 Travis d'Arnaud ATL 470.2 3 156.7 22 14 33.6 11 27.7 9 Sandy Leon MIA 437.1 4 109.3 38 12 36.4 8 27.3 10 Sean Murphy OAK 923.1 1 923.1 5 34 27.2 24 26.4 11 Jacob Stallings PIT 892 0 Inf 1 35 25.5 29 25.5 12 Carson Kelly ARI 706.2 8 88.3 49 20 35.3 9 25.2 13 Max Stassi LAA 703 8 87.9 50 20 35.2 10 25.1 14 Tucker Barnhart CIN 846 3 282.0 11 31 27.3 23 24.9 15 Reese McGuire TOR 523 4 130.8 28 17 30.8 14 24.9 16 Victor Caratini SDP 787.1 6 131.2 27 26 30.3 15 24.6 17 Cal Raleigh SEA 333 5 66.6 58 9 37.0 6 23.8 18 Michael Perez PIT 488.1 2 244.1 13 19 25.7 28 23.2 19 Austin Wynns BAL 342.1 0 Inf 2 15 22.8 34 22.8 20 Will Smith LAD 1004.2 9 111.6 36 35 28.7 18 22.8 21 Mitch Garver MIN 451.2 4 112.8 33 16 28.2 19 22.6 22 Willson Contreras CHC 935.2 3 311.7 9 39 24.0 32 22.3 23 Ryan Jeffers MIN 670.2 6 111.7 35 24 27.9 20 22.3 24 Austin Barnes LAD 442.1 3 147.4 24 17 26.0 25 22.1 25 Christian Vazquez BOS 1051.1 10 105.1 40 38 27.7 21 21.9 26 Stephen Vogt - - - 496 5 99.2 45 18 27.6 22 21.6 27 Kyle Higashioka NYY 519.1 6 86.5 51 18 28.8 17 21.6 28 Tomas Nido NYM 365.2 2 182.6 15 15 24.3 30 21.5 29 Tom Murphy SEA 727.2 6 121.2 31 28 26.0 26 21.4 30 Daulton Varsho ARI 319 4 79.8 55 11 29.0 16 21.3 31 Francisco Mejia TBR 582.2 4 145.6 25 24 24.3 31 20.8 32 James McCann NYM 826.1 8 103.3 43 32 25.8 27 20.7 33 Yadier Molina STL 1001.1 6 166.9 20 44 22.8 35 20.0 34 Jose Trevino TEX 713 4 178.3 16 33 21.6 39 19.3 35 Alex Jackson - - - 324.2 3 108.1 39 14 23.2 33 19.1 36 Curt Casali SFG 509.1 4 127.3 29 23 22.1 36 18.9 37 Andrew Knizner STL 406.2 1 406.2 7 21 19.3 47 18.5 38 Martin Maldonado HOU 1010.2 7 144.3 26 48 21.0 40 18.4 39 Jonah Heim TEX 641 3 213.7 14 33 19.4 45 17.8 40 Mike Zunino TBR 860.1 10 86.0 52 39 22.1 37 17.6 41 Dom Nunez COL 622 6 103.7 41 30 20.7 43 17.3 42 Austin Nola SDP 399 4 99.8 44 19 21.0 41 17.3 43 Elias Diaz COL 775 8 96.9 46 37 20.9 42 17.2 44 Eric Haase DET 543.1 7 77.6 57 25 21.7 38 17.0 45 Alejandro Kirk TOR 338 2 169.0 18 18 18.8 50 16.9 46 Omar Narvaez MIL 886.1 5 177.2 17 49 18.1 51 16.4 47 Yasmani Grandal CHW 627.1 7 89.6 47 32 19.6 44 16.1 48 Andrew Knapp PHI 330.2 4 82.6 54 17 19.4 46 15.7 49 Tyler Stephenson CIN 588.1 7 84.0 53 31 19.0 48 15.5 50 Jason Castro HOU 355.1 3 118.4 32 20 17.8 53 15.4 51 Jake Rogers DET 310.2 3 103.4 42 18 17.2 55 14.8 52 Kurt Suzuki LAA 557 7 79.6 56 31 18.0 52 14.7 53 Salvador Perez KCR 1002.2 1 1002.2 4 69 14.5 57 14.3 54 William Contreras ATL 415.2 7 59.3 59 24 17.3 54 13.4 55 Gary Sanchez NYY 879.1 8 109.9 37 60 14.7 56 12.9 56 Zack Collins CHW 506.1 3 168.7 19 37 13.7 59 12.7 57 Kevin Plawecki BOS 336.2 3 112.1 34 24 14.0 58 12.5 58 Jorge Alfaro MIA 476 13 36.6 60 25 19.0 49 12.5 59 Pedro Severino BAL 883 10 88.3 48 66 13.4 60 11.6 60 Framing is not some whimsical made up concept. MLB teams have paid millions of dollars to coach their catchers on how to frame better, and the concept has been around for many decades, but the PitchF/X system allowed real data on how framing was working in 2008. More solid data = more attention by front offices in the post-Moneyball era. "References to pitch-framing date back to at least the 1950s, and probably before. An organizational instruction manual prepared by the Brewers in 1982 advised catchers to catch possible strikes with “a minimum of body movement” and “very smooth hand action,” noting that “good framing technique will usually get you more marginal pitches.” And in his 1989 book The Diamond Appraised, trailblazing sabermetrician Craig R. Wright wrote that “the mark of the master is the illusion whereby balls become called strikes,” arguing that “learning to catch the ball so it looks like a strike may do more toward preventing runs than throwing out the extra base runner once a week that is the difference between the best- and worst-throwing catchers.” https://www.theringer.com/mlb/2018/9/21/17885820/pitch-framing-strike-zone-jorge-alfaro-tyler-flowers5 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
glunn and 3 others reacted to Lucas Seehafer PT for an article
4 pointsHowever, Buxton’s body, which has blessed him with his many talents, is also his greatest curse. Since becoming the Minnesota Twins’ full-time center fielder in 2016, Buxton has appeared in a mere 447 of a possible 870 games (51.3%) due to myriad injuries. And yet, over that span, he has produced 12.8 fWAR, has averaged 133.3 wRC+ since 2019, and won one Platinum Glove. In short, when healthy, Byron Buxton has performed like an MVP candidate. But the Jekyll and Hyde nature of their star player — who is due to become a free agent after the 2022 season — has placed the Twins in a profound predicament: Do they try to extend Buxton and build around him, or trade him as part of a greater re-tooling project (one that was arguably initiated with the shipping of Jose Berrios to the Toronto Blue Jays)? For all intents and purposes, it appears as though both Buxton and the Twins have interest in inking a long-term deal. However, recent reporting by The Athletic suggests that the two sides remain at an impasse. The Twins reportedly offered Buxton a 7-year, $80 million deal laden with incentives in July, but the star center fielder and his agents rebuffed as they are more interested in a contract nearing $100 million in value. While it may seem a touch insane for the Twins to cave and submit a nine-figure offer at first blush, consider that Buxton has produced $102.8 million worth of value over this 5.160 years of service time, according to FanGraphs. Assuming he is able to keep pace for the foreseeable future, a 7-year, $100 million deal would be right in line with his production value, even if he remains unable to keep his body from betraying him. If he does find a magic elixir that keeps him healthy, well, then the deal would be a steal (pun intended). But perhaps the most pertinent question facing the Twins isn’t so much, “Is re-signing Buxton the correct move?”, but more, “Would trading him be the wrong one?” Minnesota is coming off a disappointing 73-89, last place finish in the hapless American League Central, 2021 campaign and find themselves with only two pitchers — righties Bailey Ober and Joe Ryan, both of whom were rookies last season — slated to be in the starting rotation next summer. They already shipped away Berrios at last summer’s trade deadline and figure to be interested in offloading Josh Donaldson and a healthy chunk of the $77.7 million remaining on his contract. Trading Buxton either during the offseason or prior to the 2022 trade deadline would likely net the Twins a significant return of high-level prospects to further bolster their already deep farm system. These nebulous prospects could then be swapped for more veteran MLB talent or developed to form the foundation for the next iteration of the Minnesota Twins. But the world is an uncertain place, often rendering the most logical hypotheticals moot. Trading Buxton may make the most sense at this specific point in time from a long-term team building perspective, but doing so also introduces far more uncontrolled variables into the equation that is the Minnesota Twins than simply re-signing him would. Byron Buxton is an oft-injured MVP-caliber talent; the amorphous prospects could be anything, even a boat. (Or, more than likely, a boat that requires a healthy amount of time in the shop to reach its full potential.) Both moving on from as well as re-upping with Buxton present benefits and pratfalls that could either push the Minnesota Twins back into the contender’s race or further into baseball purgatory. But the talent that Buxton possesses is the kind that many teams blatantly lose for and spend years trying to acquire. If you’ve got a boat, you may as well use it, even if it requires spending quite a bit of dough on spare parts. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook, or email — Read more from Lucas here4 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
Hunter48 and 3 others reacted to Heiny for a post in a topic
4 pointsThis whole topic has me wondering what the point is to MLB. Is it for the owners to make money? Is it for the players to make money? If the Twins have a payroll of $130M, how much money are they making? I doubt like hell that they are losing any money. What if they were to raise their payroll to $180M? Would they then be losing money? I doubt that too. How much have MLB team values increased over the last half dozen years? Money recouped. So, what is the point of MLB? I think it should be to win the world series. "Every year". That should be the goal. You try to sign the best players, which makes your product more desirable, which makes the fans want to spend more of their entertainment money on it. This is what the Yankees do. Yes, they have more money to spend due to market size, but they try to win the WS every year. Again, I doubt like heck that any MLB team is losing money. So, 'my point', sign Buxton, cuz he is a great player. The Yankees would sign him. Also spend some of those billions of dollars to sign some more of the top players. Try to win the World Series. Hey, if you try and it don't work out, well that should be the norm. At least you tried. But hey, I don't really believe that is the Twins goal.4 points -
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
4 pointsSigning Buxton to an extension is crucial if the Twins really are serious about retooling for next year and beyond. Not only is his bat important, but his defense is irreplacable. If you were Marcus Stroman, for example, would you sign here if you knew Buxton is gone or on his way out, there is no starting shortstop and the Twins look to be in the market for a "stopgap" player, third base is iffy because nobody on the roster, not even Donaldson because of injuries, is an above average defender, left field has no incumbent and Rooker is a poor defender, and first base is questionable if Sano spends any time there? Stroman needs good infield defense, and would love to have Buxton in center catching everything within eyesight. Established pitchers want to be on a team that can compete out of the gate, not in two or three years. If the Twins don't plan to sign him, then stop this ticket selling charade and trade him, Taylor, and anyone else with value for top prospects. Frankly, this front office is constipated in its approach to free agency. They are like a dog at the Thanksgiving table waiting for scraps to fall that they can gobble up. Happy Thanksgiving everyone.4 points
-
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Minny505 and 3 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
4 pointsInfield defense is less important than ever but it still matters, particularly depending on your pitching staff. If you have a rotation with Dobnak in it, a good SS helps. If you have a rotation with Dobnak and Stroman in it, it'd be downright foolish not to field a good defensive SS. And remember that defense tends to bite one in the ass particularly hard in the postseason. Polanco alone basically guaranteed a loss in the postseason with his defense at least once.4 points -
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
operation mindcrime and 2 others reacted to Ted Schwerzler for an article
3 pointsAs we enter the final week of November, it was recently announced that the deadline to tender arbitration-eligible players would be pushed to November 30. This gives free agents a day to sign before the expected December 2 lockout. While many will wait through the labor strife, players have the option to strike a deal in the 24 hours between the two deadlines. With relation to Buxton, it’s a certainty that Minnesota will tender the star centerfielder a contract. Entering his final year of arbitration, MLB Trade Rumors projects Buxton’s 2022 salary to come in just north of $7 million. At the very least, the Twins will come to terms with the Baxley, Georgia native on those grounds. What’s more interesting is the dates that loom large in the future and the belief that Buxton’s situation will be resolved before the commencement of the 2022 regular season. Here are some key dates to circle and what they mean: November 30th - Arbitration Tender Deadline This one jumps out as the most important. As highlighted above, Buxton will be tendered a contract, and there’s zero doubt about that. Avoiding arbitration doesn’t mean that the sides can’t still reach an agreement on an extension, but simply that Byron knows what he will be paid in the year ahead. It’d be ideal for both sides to hammer out the extension before this point and extend the player to a multi-year deal that buys out free agency years. December 2nd - Current CBA Expired Should nothing more be accomplished than a contract for 2022 being agreed to, the two sides will have 24 more hours to negotiate. December 1st is the final day covered by the current Major League Baseball Collective Bargaining Agreement. At 11:59 pm Eastern Time, the current CBA becomes void, and the lockout begins. Both parties can continue working towards a conclusion of this saga or leave each other hanging for whatever duration the labor limbo hangs on for. Both teams and players may have different parameters to deal with following the ratification of a new CBA. Still, little of it should impact Buxton, who is already in the final year of arbitration eligibility. February 26th, 2022 - Spring Training Begins As things stand now, this is where Minnesota opens the 2022 exhibition slate against the Toronto Blue Jays down in Florida. More often, the regular season is a hard deadline for contract negotiations to be completed by. Still, both sides could look at Spring Training being a key date given Buxton’s injury history. Wanting to have something done before actual action gets underway makes a good deal of sense. Obviously, this date is tentative given the uncertainty of where a lockout takes us. I’d imagine the league and player’s association are more open to losing Spring Training games than they are actual regular-season games that count. April 2nd, 2022 - Opening Day If there’s a hard deadline established, this would seem to be it. Minnesota can’t afford to go into the regular season without clarity on Buxton’s future. If he’s not extended by this date, the alternative of trading him has to become a reality. Given the volatility of his playstyle and injury history, risking the asset depreciation before the trade deadline would be a fruitless endeavor. Again, this date could be moved with respect to the CBA situation, but it’s almost a given that whenever the regular season starts, Twins fans will know the fate of Byron Buxton. July 31st, 2022 - Trade Deadline Should we reach this point with no clarity, the front office will have massively overplayed their hand. Not only having failed to extend the talented centerfielder, we could be talking about a player with a few months of lackluster performance or an injury that drags down his trade value. Without a long-term deal in place here, the opposition understands Minnesota is set to move on in the winter. Draft pick compensation may not be what it is now, and regardless, it would be a sad return for someone that should’ve commanded so much more. That should be the complete timeline for dates to follow regarding this Buxton-saga. The longer it drags on, the more hopeless the outcome looks. I’d wager we see finality before the commencement of Spring Training, and having something done far sooner than that would be a much-welcomed reality. The Twins have an opportunity to pay a generational talent because he’s been injured. It’d be silly to balk at that, but if they’re going to, they best get it right, and soon. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email3 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Twins33 and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
3 pointsThe catcher position will completely change when - not if - robot umpires are implemented in MLB. It will go from soft-handed framers to catch and throw guys because framing will be irrelevant. Personally, I think that's a good thing. Framing's primary goal is to prevent umpire mistakes so let's just remove mistake-prone umpires and remove the necessity of framing pitches. (not that umpires are bad at their jobs, it's incredibly difficult, but a machine will be more consistent and accurate than a human)3 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Longdistancetwins and 2 others reacted to Paul for a post in a topic
3 pointsI begrudgingly agree with your point that the crowding of fielders lessons the value of the better fielders. But I’m longing for the sure to come day when hard bunts into the opposite field correct this abominable aberration we call “the shift”. And maybe we should be prepared for it.3 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
Hunter48 and 2 others reacted to Whitey333 for a post in a topic
3 pointsIt's almost amusing that people bemoan the fact of trading Buxton for prospects. The same people who are saying the Twins made a haul of prospects on the Berrios trade are worried they will only get prospects for Buxton. Remember prospects are just suspects until they prove themselves at the Major league level. In any case I believe the Twins will mess it up3 points -
Survival Flexibility
Survival Flexibility
Richie the Rally Goat and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
3 pointsJust to reinforce how much baseball has changed, if you go back 35 years to 1986, the best team batting average in the AL was Cleveland at .284. The Astros' 2021 number of .267 would have finished fifth in the American League in 1986. The median AL team in 1986 had a batting average of .259-.260 (between the Twins and Orioles that season). The median AL team in 2021, Detroit, had a batting average of .242. I'm not one to wax nostalgic about times past but baseball was simply a better spectator sport 30+ years ago, even if the overall performance level was considerably lower.3 points -
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
Six words are enough to write.3 points
-
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Minny505 and 2 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
3 pointsI don't think messing with Polanco at SS makes a lot of sense at this point. He just got comfortable at 2B and his offensive numbers took off in the process. I don't think that's a coincidence. I think you leave him there and focus on Martin and/or Lewis to take the reigns at SS, or acquire another option somewhere.3 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
joefish and 2 others reacted to farmerguychris for a post in a topic
3 pointsI just don't see any reason to mess with Polanco. He's a well above average 2nd baseman, so why weaken 2 positions by switching him to SS and putting a limited Arraez at the 4 spot? I do however like your plan of trying to develop Martin and/or Lewis for the SS role in the future - as early as mid 2022 perhaps?3 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Squirrel and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsFraming's goal isn't to cheat, it's to get as many strikes called as possible. I haven't seen data in a few years but last I saw, the byproduct of framing was getting more actual strikes than stealing balls with slick glove work. But at the end of the day, it doesn't really matter whether framing is built to keep strikes or steal balls. The reason it exists is because human umpiring is flawed so catchers have had to completely alter their defensive game to compensate for human deficiency in umpiring. And that's stupid. No position on the field should re-dedicate its approach to counter human error if we can EASILY remove human error and improve the overall process.2 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Twodogs and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsI've read quite a few pieces on how robot umps will change the game and the consensus seems to be "a lot", though how it will change differs quite a bit on opinion and how MLB implements the automated zone (for example, we've discovered that umps don't really call the rulebook strikezone but robot umps would, which creates a lot more vertical strikes).2 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
h2oface and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsUmps are people, they make mistakes and are prone to prejudices and pressures to not call a fair game. For me they can't bring in robo umps fast enough. Standardize the ball & strikes so both pitchers and hitters know exactly what they are dealing with.2 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
I agree. I also believe it is far more likely that Buxton will figure out how to stay healthy than trading Buxton will bring in someone of comparable talent.2 points
-
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
D-Day is Coming for Twins and Buxton
roger and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsBuck has expressed on several occasions publicly & privately that he wants to remain a Twin, fans have overwhelmingly have expressed their love for Buxton and Jim Pohlad has express his desire to keep Buxton. So what's holding up the show? FO. FO has a plan, what is that plan? No one knows. But with every move this FO is leading us to an abyss. FO actions toward Buck through out his career is unforgiveable especially their handling of negotiations with him. This FO has no sense of evaluation, if they did they'd have signed Buck by last season. Buxton impacts the game with his fielding, base running and hitting. An owner favored incentive based contract that Buck in theory has agreed to has been on the table for a while now. The fact that Buck hasn't signed yet is the epidemy of this FO's lunacy and incompetence. With each passing day of him not signing, insults Bucks worth and patience and jeopardizes him signing. I don't care if Buck signs tomorrow or not, this FO has proven to me for awhile that they don't deserve to be our FO.2 points -
Thanks
Thanks
nclahammer and one other reacted to AceWrigley for a comment on a blog entry
2 pointsWas reading the words of Solomon this morning, the end of Ecclesiastes Chapter 5: "Even so, I have noticed one thing, at least, is good. It is good for people to eat, drink, and enjoy their work under the sun during the short life God has given them, and to accept their lot in life." So on Thanksgiving, eat, drink and be merry, enjoy those who are around you and give thanks. Thanks to everybody here for a great forum for all things Twins. You know, God foretold us about baseball in the Bible. It all starts with, " In the big inning . . . " ( you have to say it, not read it). Have a great Thanksgiving everybody. ?2 points -
Former Twins Cooperstown Case: Joe Nathan
Former Twins Cooperstown Case: Joe Nathan
Dantes929 and one other reacted to awmonahan for a post in a topic
2 pointsJoe was great, but I think he is just short, sadly. It's tough for a RP to make it into the HOF. There seem to be three types enshrined: 1) those that redefined what a reliever does, 2) those that have held the saves record or 3) those that had signature moments in the playoffs. Joe does not comfortably fit in any of those spots. Maybe after some the coming decade plus, voters will place more value on relievers. For now though, he think he's on the outside looking in. Too bad. He was underappreciated outside MN.2 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
DJL44 and one other reacted to bean5302 for a post in a topic
2 pointsSince we're so bullish on moving shortstops to center field, maybe we should move Buxton to shortstop? Keep him from running into walls and all that?2 points -
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
Rigby and one other reacted to old nurse for a post in a topic
2 pointsClass of 1936 was much better.2 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
roger and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsYou just listed two guys who will be paid $36m and $25m, respectively. Yeah, that's always going to be a problem until the Twins develop literally the best pitcher in baseball to counter them, at which point Minnesota will have *maybe* 2-3 years to compete before that pitcher leaves to one of the teams able to offer him $36m a season for eight seasons. Whether the Twins are "playing" the scrappy little team that can or not, baseball's economics virtually ensure they "are" the scrappy little team, at least compared to the top eight-ish baseball markets that can simply throw money at the best players and afford to miss pretty regularly.2 points -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Minny505 and one other reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
2 pointsI think there are plenty of options for finding a competent bat for SS without having to move Polanco back. But I do agree, elite defense is overrated.2 points -
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
TNutts48 and one other reacted to 4twinsJA for a post in a topic
2 pointsFO has been busy negotiating with Jack Cave.2 points -
Twins Avoid Another Mistake, Protect Big Arm
Twins Avoid Another Mistake, Protect Big Arm
Nickasaski and one other reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI think this is right: Enlow would have gotten grabbed up in the Rule 5 by a team who would have stashed him on the 60-day IL and paid him to rehab. It's a worthy flyer to take on someone with so much upside and an even easier pitching stash than most Rule 5 picks, because they wouldn't have needed to even use a slot on the 26-man because of his injury. They made the right call in protecting him, I think. He's going to hold a slot on the 40-man until the season gets going and we can shift him to the IL, but the talent is there and I'm not ready to give up on Enlow.2 points -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
glunn reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
1 pointSign Buck to watch him play and take a chance that he stays healthy. The proposed contract is already at a discounted value based upon his health. If it were not, he'd be worth 20 million per year.1 point -
Current TV, regardless the year
Current TV, regardless the year
Brock Beauchamp reacted to Richie the Rally Goat for a post in a topic
1 pointIndeed Apple is killing it. In the other thread I was debating if Apple+ was going to get the axe. I’m glad I haven’t yet. really liking Invasion. Looking forward to Finch and Shrink Next Door1 point -
Defense at shortstop
Defense at shortstop
Doctor Gast reacted to Mark G for a post in a topic
1 pointWith all due respect, I am somewhat at a loss to understand this thought process. Donaldson, Simmons, and Polanco make a pretty decent, no, more than pretty decent infield defense. Sano was the weak link, and if we were to put Kirilloff there it would be even better. All I hear is people wanting to send Simmons packing, trade Donaldson to get rid of his contract, and replace that contract with a top tier SS that is just as expensive as Donaldson. How that helps an infield defense that was already pretty damn good (without Sano) is somewhat hard for me to wrap my brain around. If everyone is correct about the payroll being flexible, which I am not convinced of but that is another post, then we can afford Donaldson's contract, we can afford Simmons light bat, and we can move Kirilloff to first and Sano to DH/relief corner infield and come out with a pretty good infield. The outfield? Again, another story, but in the infield we already had the bird in the hand; why do we want to try for the two in the bush? (And, again, this is defense)1 point -
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
My Take On The Twins' Byron Buxton Conundrum
rv78 reacted to Dennesey55347 for a post in a topic
1 pointBuxton is going into his age 28 (8th) season and has exactly 1+ exceptionally productive combined campaigns under his belt (2017 and 2020). He has only 6 AB's in post season play .125 with 4 K's). His career slash: .248/.299/.761. He has never seriously contended for MVP in any season because his offensive stats haven't been at all star level for most of his career, he doesn't draw walks, steal bases, or get on base enough to make a difference. The guy drafted 1 spot ahead of him also joined the league in 2015 and is grossly underpaid at $11.7 mil. Carlos Correa has also missed games pretty much every year like Buxton (albeit far fewer) but is a big-game legend already. Top 10 all-time (of 22,000+ players) in RBI's, HR's and WPA in the post-season. Yes, different positions and waaaay different teams but only one of the two has truly made a name for himself. I find it fascinating that Buxton is the only player in baseball garnering as much praise as he gets with such paltry career offensive production. If I were him, I'd pledge to give the team at least 2 FULL seasons of all-star caliber play before making contract demands. Is there any other example of a guy playing in only half of his teams games over his career hitting under .250 with an OBP 20+ points below league average, zero 20+ HR seasons, zero 70+ runs/RBI campaigns, more K's than RBI's, runs, and stolen bases combined, one 100+ games played/season, and half the WAR of a guy entering the league at the same time and drafted in practically the same spot who rejected a contract worth $80 mil +incentives? Defense is definitely worth consideration but you have to make roll call every day to use this as your bargaining tool. Buxton's speed trumps his smoothness and ball tracking- particularly deep balls where he has a habit of misreading and turning up the jets to recover only to crash test dummy with the wall. He's still got the wheels to make zero probability snags but playing at least 85% of your teams games for ONE season is just as impressive as the catches. What the Twins offered makes sense. You already overpaid Donaldson, who absolutely killed it as the FOURTH best player on Atlanta in 2019. As for Buxton, well, as famously quoted "the most important ability is availability". Show up. Get paid. Take the deal.1 point -
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
Heiny reacted to TopGunn#22 for a post in a topic
1 pointPlus, the players that cheated got PAID. That should be all the "reward" they are allowed. Look, I'm a very "traditional" kind of guy. The whole PEDs thing just has always rubbed me the wrong way. My son, whose opinion I respect a lot is of a different mind set, played High School and Legion baseball against some guys whose bodies certainly changed a little too rapidly for at least "some" suspicion to linger. We debate this in a good natured way all the time. I've even given him an autographed Barry Bonds bat (after I acquired a Hank Aaron autographed bat) and told him "you can keep the Bonds bat or sell it, but you can't sell it until he's elected to the HOF because the bat will be worth a lot more once he is." I think eventually ALL the cheaters will get in. I think if they do, an *asterisk* would be appropriate. I will say, that no matter what, it's hard to ignore what Barry Bonds accomplished. Of all the cheaters, he did the most with it. In looking the list over, I wondered why Schilling's name was on it. I don't recall ever hearing his name mentioned as a PED cheater. And as an American, he's granted the right of free speech. It's a right that is fundamental to our Republic. Anyone is free to agree or disagree with what he says because we're "Americans." If he had pitched in China, he'd already be disappeared and there would be no talk of him for any Hall of Fame or any other purpose for that matter. He'd be gone and all memory of him would be erased. But he's an American. He's also one of the greatest post-season pitchers in the history of baseball. He should already be in.1 point -
The Greatest Hall of Fame Class is Up for Final Consideration
Understandably people will look at people who cheated in a different light. But I mean how many football players are in the hall of fame who have used performance enhancers at some point in time. Those types of arguments can go on forever. But I guess my only thing that I look at, is no matter how distasteful some of these players may be, were they the best players in their era??? If yes, then I guess they should probably be in. I mean people just don't like Barry Bonds, people like David Ortiz and because of that I think Ortiz has a better chance to get in and he has that same performance enhancement cloud that follows him around also. I mean is it fair that one guy is overall liked better than another? I mean were these guys the best of their era? I mean you could put the vaunted asterisk by their names as saying they were the best of their era, but that it was the steroid era, so maybe the records don't quite mean as much, just like Roger Maris's home run record didn't mean as much because of the 8 extra games. But was it not still great? So these guys are the record holders of their era, not the best guys, but they were the best players and that is really all it should be voted on.1 point
-
Thanks
Thanks
nclahammer reacted to ashbury for a comment on a blog entry
1 pointI'm thankful for people who have the good grace to be thankful. And of course for Twins Daily.1 point -
Defense at shortstop
1 pointConcur, except to me how much they pay the guy isn't the point. I want guys who help you win...and that generally means they contribute on both ends, offensively AND defensively. Simmons, last year, wouldn't have been a bargain at $10, much less $10mil.1 point
-
Twins show patience
Twins show patience
Twins33 reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
1 pointSteven Matz has never been a good pitcher more than 1 year in a row.1 point -
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
FO's tentativeness is killing the team
sjunisu reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
1 pointI'm not sure I'm as worried as others but it's mostly b/c I didn't expect this FO to do much. To be competitive next year, they needed to completely overhaul the pitching staff and they don't have enough internal options to make that happen. Pohlads won't let them increase payroll so they're sorta stuck in no-man's land. To compete, they needed three strong starting pitchers, which they can't afford. Instead, Levine suggested a few weeks ago that the Twins will be looking at multi-inning relievers and we will probably be a pitching staff where only two or three pitchers even throw 100 innings and each game is a five pitcher game. Basically, a reenactment of last season with a few new faces.1 point -
Defense at shortstop
1 pointYeah as much as I dislike it, you really don't need Ozzie Smith at SS anymore, I mean they typically play 3 guys on one side of the field now anyways? These stats will become way more interesting if MLB bans the shift. If you can Get Arraez 500 at bats because he is an everyday 2B then your lineup probably gets better and with the shifts the fielding getting worse is probably negligible. Where does the biggest bang for your buck come in, probably with the better lineup. Then instead of focusing on spending money at SS you dump all of it in to pitching?? They need to have one of Martin/Lewis focus on SS and the other one focus on CF probably because the Twins will have to replace that spot pretty soon also.1 point
-
Should the Twins Trade for Athletics Starter Sean Manaea?
Should the Twins Trade for Athletics Starter Sean Manaea?
Dennesey55347 reacted to rv78 for a post in a topic
1 pointIf it would take the 4 prospects you list to get him then it's an absolute NO. 4 prospects for a 1 year stop-gap pitcher? NEVER.1 point -
A case against signing the top free agents
A case against signing the top free agents
Squirrel reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
1 pointThe right guys signed to 5 year deals should provide help to several potential windows of contention. That's the beauty of it....sign Corey Seager or Robbie Ray and they should be a factor for several potential runs. Signing stop gaps only ensures they never help your future. That's what a stop gap is.1 point -
A Different Idea For Twins Catching
A Different Idea For Twins Catching
RpR reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a comment on a blog entry
1 pointI would not be in favor of trading either Garver or Jeffers. The Twins catching position seems to be in good shape for next year. Leave it alone. If we trade either of them, then the Twins will need to "strengthen" the catching weakness which the Twins just created by trading both major league catchers. I is a good situation to have 2 capable major league catchers on the team.1 point -
A case against signing the top free agents
A case against signing the top free agents
Twins33 reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
1 pointWhy does spending in FA equate to team building in FA? Free Agency is for supplementing. And you can supplement at high price tags. And....you can supplement your future teams that may be only 1 or 2 players away a year or two in advance. I believe this team has a bonafide group of young pitchers. I think in two years that Miranda, Martin, and Lewis are players for this team. If so.....I want to add now to have those supports in place for them. Signing Seager or Ray or any other top FA doesn't mean you wipe your hands clean and pat yourself on the back for a job well done or mission accomplished. But it means you are one more good player closer to where you want to be in the future. And you have one less offseason where all your "I need to add one or two players now!" eggs are not in the same basket. It's not like St. Louis waited for Arrenado and Goldschmidt to be simultaneously available. They added periodically. Ditto the White Sox. Waiting for the perfect moment is folly.1 point -
A case against signing the top free agents
A case against signing the top free agents
Twins33 reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
1 pointAnd when revenues have gone up the purse strings still stay tight. So using that excuse doesn't fly for me.1 point -
Twins sign Jake Cave to 2022 contract for $800k
Twins sign Jake Cave to 2022 contract for $800k
Twins33 reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
1 pointAlso, while I’m no Cave fan, he literally fractured his back. I’ll give him something of a pass on 2021.1 point -
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Am I wrong? I'd rather the Twins have Martin, Woods Richardson, and $20M per year to spend than Jose Berrios?
Twins33 reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
1 pointThis is literally what decides 90% of free agent signings everywhere.1 point