Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts
  2. nicksaviking

    Community Moderator
    Points
    18,707
    Posts
  3. Squirrel

    Community Leader
    Points
    31,121
    Posts
  4. Deduno Abides

    Provisional Member
    Points
    1,816
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 12/16/2017 in Posts

  1. 6 points
    Which teams are selling pre-arbitration aces? Both contenders and rebuilding clubs tend to want to keep those kind of pitchers.
  2. What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?

    DocBauer and 4 others reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic

    5 points
    Kepler for Cole straight up would be a loss for us. If the Yankees are going to move Frazier and Adams for two years of Cole, I think we move on. If the Yankees are giving up on Frazier, it means they have another future corner OFer coming into the fold (Bryce Harper). Money can fix a lot of issues and the Yankees have more money than anyone. They can overpay. Adams is similar enough to Gonsalves or Romero to match up but I don't think we can - or should - match Frazier.
  3. What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?

    beckmt and 4 others reacted to Linus for a post in a topic

    5 points
    Use said prospects to get Archer. 2 years of Cole isn't enough.
  4. 4 points
    Is his first name Clayton?
  5. 4 points
    From NYY's point of view, and it's all guesswork here, but I think Torres would be too much to give up for a Cole trade. However, a request for Torres might hopefully be Pittsburgh signaling their interest in a middle infielder over corner outfielder, which leads us back to Gordon.
  6. 4 points
    Easy to like that, but if the Yankees set the market for Cole at Adams/Frazier it will take much more to get Archer.
  7. OOTP Baseball -- Who Plays?

    snepp and 3 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    4 points
    That's what they told me about moderatin' this site.
  8. Agreed. I just meant that time will tell, but we can’t know now whether he’ll be a failure. My post was worded incorrectly. KDome may be proven right.
  9. 3 points
    The problem is that based on recent data/experience, seems about equally likely they would have to fix it again next year even if they signed a guy for 2-3 years.
  10. 3 points
    Moderator's note: Independent of any discussion with TD ownership, the moderators had been discussing the "crushing it" meme. It was fine to debate the term in the comments for the article that introduced it, indeed that is what occurred. However, throwing it around left and right, in thread after thread, starts to look more like trolling than good-natured banter. Regardless of the intentions behind it, I'd like to ask that posters refrain from this particular attempt at humor, going forward.
  11. 3 points
    CC, his wife and their 4 children have been living in New Jersey for almost a decade. Hopefully he and his wife have a great marriage. CC has already earned almost a quarter billion dollars. I cannot imagine him taking a job where he would play for a team out of the area.
  12. 3 points
    First, you had to watch Colon deliver (probably) the final surge of effectiveness in a Hall of Fame career, adding watchability to a rotation that severely lacked it in the middle of the season. At literally zero cost. Now you have to watch Rodney, who's been a successful closer for many contenders, including the D-backs last year, for whom he pitched quite well. On a small commitment that won't prevent them from doing anything else. And bye bye Burdi, who you've never watched in a Twins uniform and wouldn't have this season. The horrors. If you're going to continue making these smarmy "CRUSHING IT" remarks, and mocking my positive reviews of the front office, how about bringing some reasoned critique instead of just griping about your personal distaste for these players? For me, I find it quite enjoyable when an aging star comes here and gives one more strong effort at the end of a long and storied career. We saw it with Thome. We saw it with Hunter. We saw it with Colon, somewhat. It adds an additional dimension of historical significance to the season. I hope Rodney puts an exclamation point on a very impressive career next season.
  13. What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?

    TKGuy and 2 others reacted to Winston Smith for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I think a lot of Twins fans over value Kepler at this point. Not hitting LH pitching hurts his value a lot, imo. Frazier has the two extra years of control and he still has the high prospect shine on as he hasn't played enough for any big flaws to show up.
  14. What will it take to get Gerrit Cole?

    DocBauer and 2 others reacted to drjim for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Kepler and one of those arms is a lot. I may be higher on Kepler than the industry, but I wouldn't even think of trading him for Frazier.
  15. I don't understand the logic here. We go from losing two promising relievers that we could have put on the 40 man roster, to picking up a guy that we HAVE to put on the 25 man roster. Where is the logic in that?
  16. On MLB Tonight, the Twins were 1) linked to Napoli; and 2) had Ron Darling call them favorite to sign Darvish.
  17. "19-year-old... got engaged to his long-time girlfriend." Sheesh.
  18. You’re assuming Kinley will make the team without proving he deserves it. You should hold your comment until then.
  19. The Twins headed into the Winter Meetings with almost zero closing experience on their roster. They will exit with a wealth of it. On Thursday the team agreed to terms with veteran reliever Fernando Rodney, who ranks third among active major-league players with 300 career saves. Craig Mish reports that it’s a one-year, $6 million deal.Recently, Twins GM Thad Levine explained that he’s open-minded about his future closer already being on the roster, but made clear he wasn’t keen on throwing any of the internal options directly into that role. Based on this mindset, Rodney is a very logical fit. He doesn’t require an extensive commitment, allowing Minnesota to retain plenty of flexibility going forward. He adds a healthy infusion of veteran experience to a bullpen that clearly lacked it. And there are plenty of signs to suggest he’s capable of being a force in the late innings. One might look at Rodney’s 4.23 ERA from 2017 and presume he’s in decline. After all, he does turn 41 in March. But a closer look suggests that the right-hander significantly outperformed his inflated ERA. He posted a 3.03 FIP, registered his best strikeout rate since 2013 (10.6 K/9), and was dominant in the second half (17 out of 18 saves converted, 2.55 ERA, .189 BAA, 31-to-8 K/BB in 25 innings). Over the past six seasons, Rodney has been tremendously durable, making 61 or more appearances in each. He has also mostly been very effective, landing on three All Star teams while posting a 3.11 ERA, 3.22 FIP, and 1.23 WHIP. Known as much for his amusing style on the field as his performance (he wears his hat cocked to the side and shoots an imaginary arrow into the sky after every successful save), Rodney is sure to become a source of entertaining for fans, as well as anxiety. His clearest blemish is a lack of control (4.4 BB/9 career, 4.2 in 2017), so the Twins will need to hope he can continue keeping the contact in check. We’ll have further analysis of the move soon, but feel free to share your initial thoughts in the comments section below. Click here to view the article
  20. 2 points
    Well they've never signed one, if we're talking about contending in 2018 there's no reason not to break the seal now that one appears to be interested.
  21. 2 points
    ......or, after the first couple of months this year, perhaps........
  22. Although there were some bright spots like Hildenberger, Rogers and Busenitz, I think we can count on this bullpen imploding if we don't make any more moves this off season. Kind of like Rodney, last year, we were lucky to have the bullpen implosions take place in big ways in relatively few games, rather than in smaller ways in more games. I don't know if Rodney was lucky in this same way or good. I hope I'm wrong, and he's good and the Twins bullpen also is good, and they don't lose us a lot of games. But I think that will happen if we don't sign at least one more proven reliever.
  23. Certainly a risk. I think our current group can hold the fort down until the cavalry is needed and will fall more in the 'average' than 'bad' category....but "thinking" is not "knowing", so feel free to bank this quote in the event of any future implosions
  24. 2 points
    Because he's not all that good, and they'll just have to fix the problem again next year.....
  25. 2 points
    I can think of one.
  26. OOTP Baseball -- Who Plays?

    snepp and one other reacted to Mill1634 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Clearly this is going nowhere but downhill.
  27. 2 points
    Judge and/or Stanton will move to 1b/DH for Harper. Their most common first baseman last year were Carter, Headley and Bird, around 40 games each. Their most common DH was Matt Holliday, with 89 starts there. None of that should prevent them from signing Harper. Did you know that Harper is actually younger than Judge? They could have a future with LF/RF/1B/DH held by (in some order) Harper/Stanton/Frazier/Judge if they wanted.
  28. pitchers and catchers report Feb 13. Considering the grousing is 90% pitching related and the short supply in the FA class, I see it warranted. Rodney has already been anointed closer. If that doesn’t scream “done with relievers”, I don’t know what does. I guess they could acquire a setup man, but I was hoping for a bigger step up.
  29. Don’t worry Twins Fans. Almost every upper echelon Free Agent is yet to sign. Here is my list of the Top Remaining Free Agents at each position and then my top 50 overall. It is worth noting that the highest rated player I had that has signed thus far has been Mike Minor, who was at 18 behind Logan Morrison. All top of my 17 Free Agents are still available, including 7 pitchers. Starters: 1. Yu Darvish 2. Jake Arrieta 3. Alex Cobb 4. Lance Lynn 5. C.C. Sabathia 6. Jaime Garcia 7. Jason Vargas 8. John Lackey 9. Andrew Cashner 10. Jeremy Hellickson 11. Jhoulys Chacin 12. Charles Tillman 13. Francisco Liriano 14. Matt Garza 15. Miguel Gonzalez Only guys of note to sign are Tyler Chatwood, Drew Smyly, Michael Pineda, and Doug Fister (I guess). I would argue that if healthy, Pineda is the best of those 4 and would have gotten 3 to 4 years for $45 to $60 million. Not a bad get for the Twins, but I expect them to be targeting one of the top 4 starters or looking to acquire one via trade. Relievers: 1. Wade Davis 2. Greg Holland 3. Addison Reed 4. Tony Watson 5. Tyler Clippard 6. Hector Rondon 7. David Hernandez 8. Seung-Hwan Oh 9. Trevor Cahill 10. Matt Belisle 11. Matt Albers 12. Boone Logan 13. Brian Duensing 14. Bud Norris 15. J.J. Hoover 16. Koji Uehara 17. Sergio Romo 18. Francisco Rodriguez 19. Neftali Feliz 20. Craig Stammen Interestingly enough, I had Davis, Holland, and Reed as the top 3 Free Agent Relievers available. With all the relievers flying off the shelves, it is worth reminding that the top of the relief market is still there. Specifically pertaining to the Twins, nobody outside of the top 6 would be an initial priority. It will be interesting to see if someone like Addison Reed struggled to find that 3 year $27 million deal, or if he is holding out for more. After Reed, there is a massive drop off, but Watson, Clippard, and Rondon are all intriguing and affordable. After that, there are plenty to circle back on in late January and February, including some old friends. Catchers: 1. Jonathan Lucroy 2. Alex Avila 3. Rene Rivera 4. Nick Hundley 5. Chris Gimenez Welington Castillo quietly did pretty well for himself early on in Free Agency. But since then, not much has happened pertaining to catchers. The Twins should feel comfortable with Garver as the backup catcher / DH / 1B / LF type player. I wouldn’t be opposed to bringing back Gimenez though. Especially if it means he brings his friend Yu with him. First Basemen: 1. Eric Hosmer 2. Carlos Santana 3. Logan Morrison 4. Yonder Alonso 5. Mitch Moreland 6. Lucas Duda 7. Mark Reynolds 8. Mike Napoli 9. Adam Lind 10. Matt Adams This market is at a stop sign. Literally nothing has happened, as is true with just about all position players (What an odd market / boring winter meetings – No?). I’m an advocate of circling back here for a right handed platoon DH type later in Free Agency. However, the only two guys on this list that are right handed are Reynolds and Napoli. Probably doesn’t make a ton of sense to go after Lucas Duda, Yonder Alonso, and Hosmer and Santana will be too expensive while not really being a need. Second Basemen: 1. Neil Walker 2. Howie Kendrick 3. Brandon Phillips 4. Chase Utley 5. Danny Espinosa I fell asleep typing this list of names. I guess Howie Kendrick would be an interesting utility guy. However, I’d rather have Adrianza in that role based on age, cost, and massively superior defense. Pass on all of them. Third Basemen: 1. Mike Moustakas 2. Todd Frazier 3. Eduardo Nunez 4. Yunel Escobar 5. Danny Valencia 6. Jose Reyes 7. Trevor Plouffe 8. Pablo Sandoval It’s not the worst thing I’ve ever seen. I just don’t see the Twins really paying any attention to it unless someone blows them away with a Miguel Sano offer or something. Shortstop 1. Zack Cozart 2. Alcides Escobar 3. Erick Aybar 4. J.J. Hardy 5. Adam Rosales Yeah I don’t have much to say here. Outfielders 1. J.D. Martinez 2. Lorenzo Cain 3. Jay Bruce 4. Carlos Gomez 5. Carlos Gonzalez 6. Jarrod Dyson 7. Jon Jay 8. Austin Jackson 9. Curtis Granderson 10. Melky Cabrera 11. Jose Bautista 12. Matt Holliday 13. Colby Rasmus 14. Rajai Davis 15. Cameron Maybin I’d be curious to see if the Twins have any activity here. I think we’ll know based on how they treat Robbie Grossman and Kennys Vargas. If they move on from Robbie via trade, I think it is highly likely they add at least one outfielder via free agency. Granted, it would be a lower end 4th outfielder type. There are also some cheaper 4th outfielder / DH type options here that might be worth pursuing if you lose Vargas. I’m biased and want to see us take a $5 million flier on Joey Bats, but I understand the hesitation on that. Overall Rankings 1. OF J.D. Martinez 2. SP Yu Darvish 3. 1B Eric Hosmer 4. SP Jake Arrieta 5. OF Lorenzo Cain 6. 3B Mike Moustakas 7. RP Wade Davis 8. SP Alex Cobb 9. 1B Carlos Santana 10. RP Greg Holland 11. SP Lance Lynn 12. SS Zack Cozart 13. 3B Todd Frazier 14. OF Jay Bruce 15. RP Addison Reed 16. C Jonathan Lucroy 17. 1B Logan Morrison 18. OF Carlos Gomez 19. 1B Yonder Alonso 20. SP C.C. Sabathia 21. 3B Eduardo Nunez 22. SP Jaime Garcia 23. RP Tony Watson 24. 2B Neil Walker 25. RP Tyler Clippard 26. C Alex Avila 27. SP Jason Vargas 28. OF Carlos Gonzalez 29. 1B Mitch Moreland 30. SP John Lackey 31. SP Andrew Cashner 32. OF Jarrod Dyson 33. OF Jon Jay 34. 1B Lucas Duda 35. RP Hector Rondon 36. OF Austin Jackson 37. RP David Hernandez 38. OF Curtis Granderson 39. SP Jeremy Hellickson 40. OF Melky Cabrera 41. 1B Mark Reynolds 42. RP Seung-Hwan Oh 43. SP Jhoulys Chacin 44. OF Jose Bautista 45. RP Trevor Cahill 46. 3B Yunel Escobar 47. SP Charles Tillman 48. 2B Howie Kendrick 49. SS Alcides Escobar 50. RP Matt Belisle Happy Shopping, Derek Falvey and Thad Levine.
  30. Prussia and Russia didn't sign off on our plan for Poland. The front office's hands were tied.
  31. This is a really good post - something nobody else in this market will do. So thank you.
  32. Hector Rondon signed with Houston for $8.5 million for 2 years. Big miss by the Twins IMHO. If/when Rodney blows up he could've stepped right in to be the closer.
  33. This is a really good post. I appreciate the hard work that went into making these lists.
  34. 2 points
    I'm a fan of the move. But, it's hardly a given that he'll be a #3 starter in 2019. If it were, he'd have gotten a lot more money.
  35. 2 points
    I’d like to see the window opened before worrying about when it will close. And Waiting around for the window to open itself doesn’t sound like a good plan to me.
  36. 2 points
    I don't think Mauer's contract has hamstrung this club in anyway. This team isn't getting to the World Series without significantly better starters, is there another option? If Darvish is good for the next 3-4 years and the Twins have a shot at winning, I don't care if he isn't living up to his contract at the end of the deal. Got to take a shot sometime and this club might not be another chance to get a front line free agent. They don't tend to WANT to come to Minnesota even if the front office is willing.
  37. 2 points
    The offseason hardly ends after the winter meetings conclude. None of Darvish, Arrieta, Lynn, or Cobb have signed anywhere. When articles are written or noise is made doesn't dictate when guys do deals. It's one thing to be frustrated with moves that were and weren't made after the dust settles, but hand wringing because they didn't follow a perceived timeline is silly.
  38. 2 points
    Good stuff on Doogie's podcast. Big takeaway was for better or worse, they aren't going 3 years or $9mil (AAV) on a reliever. Almost all work now on a starter. Might circle back on some third tier free agents.
  39. 2 points
    I couldnt agree more. Last year was the year of the young hitters coming of age and this year our young pitchers will step forward. There will be plenty of opportunity for many to shine.
  40. You completely missed the point. It isn't pointless to participate in Rule V. It is pointless for Internet GMs to act like losing Burdi/Bard or a 25 man roster spot are awful moves. I think we (the Internet GMs) can form somewhat valid opinions on MLB players that we have actually seen play and have comparable stats for but we really don't have any idea on the real potential of Burdi/Bard/Kinley/Haley/Reed/Melotakis/Chargois/etc... It is okay to have an opinion but to act like some BIG MISTAKE has been made is laughable. Also participating in Rule V and poor roster management (keeping Rule V guys too long) are two completely different issues.
  41. 2 points
    This off-seasons approach to relief pitching almost exactly mirrors last off-season. Wait out the market while the middle relief pool is exhausted then pick up a guy out of the bargain bin. The most surprising thing to me is that it became clear over the course of last season that adding a better reliever in free agency could have had a pretty substantial impact. To repeat the exact same mistake twice leaves me frustrated.
  42. 2 points
    Where they were a year ago/recent transactions: Joe Smith, just signed for 2 years and $15 million: Signed by Toronto for 1 year/$3 million. Traded to CLE for two prospects, one of whom is now 22nd on the Blue Jays list. Brandon Kintzler, 2 years and $10 or $15 million: minor league contract with the Twins (sorry, we all knew that) Steve Cishek, 2/$12-$14 million finishing a 2 year/$10 million contract he signed with Seattle, who traded him to TB. An example of a "good" reliever contract? Juan Nicasio, 2/$17 million 1 year/$3 million with the Pirate, waived midseason, claimed and traded. Luke Gregerson, 2 years/$11 million signed a 3/$18.5 deal with Houson. Good value? Pat Neshek, 2/$16.5 signed a 2/12.5 with Houston in 2015, was traded to PHI for a PTBNL last November Tommy Hunter 2/$18 million Minor League signing by TB. Mike Minor 3/$28 Finishing a 2/$7.25 contract with KC, previously had been non-tendered by ATL following injury, spent 2016 rehabbing. Shades of Pineda? Yusmeiro Petit, 2/$10 minor league deal with LAA Anthony Swarzak, 2/$14 minor league deal with CWS Bryan Shaw, 3/$27 acquired via trade, just finishing up rookie contract years Brandon Morrow, 2/$21 minor league deal with Dodgers I bolded the minor league deals--that is $90 million dollars allocated this offseason to guys who signed as minor league free agents (plus Nicasio, who was also available to just about everyone for nothing.) I'm not really trying to say teams shouldn't sign expensive relievers, but there are plenty of good pitchers to be found out there, before they sign expensive contracts. Cishek, Gregerson, and Neshek (and others) are examples of good investments in relievers.
  43. 1 point
    There is somethibg to be said for high quality, proven, consistent relievers and large contracts. Despite the volatility of the "world of a relief pitcher", some guys are proven year in and year out. But it can be very dangerous, and we see it every year, when big contracts are handed out to RP via FA that aren't those guys. Remember a couple years ago when everyone was on board for signing Sipp? Got the last laugh on that one. And every year it seems there are a few guys that either slip through the cracks and get picked up on the cheap, or coming back from off/injured seasons and then out to be huge bargains. With Rodney on board, what we have, what's coming, what us still availbe, I'm not in serious worry mode. Though I believe it would be highly prudent to find one more good guy. There are always trade possibilities down the road if you suddenly end up with bullpen wealth.
  44. The other issue is that the Twins may think they have seen something in Kinley or now have a better pitcher development program than Florida. Falvey and Levine could also be trying to figure out their type and may think Kinley is a good experiment. I don’t miss Burdi, because he probably wouldn’t help this year, but Bard was probably, on 2017 stats, much closer to the majors, but even if he proves to be much better than Kinley, it’s unlikely he’ll be more than a 0.5 WAR pitcher, so it won’t be a huge difference. Even if Kinley fails, Falvey and the pitcher development program may learn something that helps in the future.
  45. 1 point
    I'm fine with Rodney as part of a successful offseason. Since it's only Dec 15, there's still a good chance that will happen.
  46. 1 point
    Interestingly, maybe only one key reliever on those teams was a free agent signee last winter - Chapman. Two, if you count Jansen reupping with the Dodgers. A lot of key relievers were not expected to be, such as Morrow, and several of the guys who were expected to be important at the start of the season, such as Betances, Giles and Devenski, were almost meaningless in the playoffs. The Rockies may be an exception, but their season ended the same way the Twins’ did, and their signings were tailing off a lot at the end of the season. Everybody agrees that relievers are important. It may be that predictability is so bad that the Twins don’t want to sign multi-year deals right now.
  47. Burdi annoited to All Star status. Oh wait he has to pitch above AA and be healthy first. Four years and AA. On track if healthy but he isnt. When rolling the dice on 95mph to 100mph fastballs and staying healthy good luck. In todays game there seems to be more and more arms that can create that velocity. I guess Falvey just decided to take a different direction to 100mph. IN MANAGEMENT I TRUST!
  48. 1 point
    Verducci just went into my Dinosaur column on this special spreadsheet I keep by me. I agree that shopping for bullpen arms is pretty volatile. The baseball highways are littered with poor numbers and big contract combo's... although... it should be pointed out that in the small sample size world of relief pitching, one horrible performance can be hard to overcome and some metrics can end up looking worse than they actually are. Regardless... you just gotta do it and do your best to do it right. Monster bullpens are being built and they are producing victories. You handicap yourself getting a closer, a couple of setup guys and finishing off the staff with a bunch "I'm just trying to stay in the profession guys" who get to throw when the starter chokes. The closer goes down and everybody moves up a chair and pretty soon you are counting on one of those "I'm just trying to stay in the profession guys in a high leverage situation. The Yankees had a great bullpen and still went out and got Robertson and Kahnle. We knocked Severino out in the 1st inning and that bullpen beat us. The Indians bullpen was 7 quality deep. The Dodgers had arms lined up. The Red Sox. The Astros D-Backs Rockies The Nats didn't start with a great pen but they finished with a pretty nice one. Of all the playoff teams... Only the Twins and maybe the Cubs had what "I myself" considered to be sub-par bullpens. All 30 teams should be looking for or trying to create their own Andrew Miller. I'm trying to think of a team that had a lights out bullpen and didn't make the playoffs. I can't off the top of my head. All of this is driving the price up in my opinion. The evidence seems to be pretty clear... The Year is soon 2018... baseball is different than it was two decades ago and bullpens are producing playoff teams.
  49. . Like it. I know Rodney has his ups and downs, but this deal is reasonable considering his stats over the last few years and it seems like his teammates like him. It’s a short commitment at not much more than was paid to Kevin Jepsen in 2016. He probably won’t be The Guy, but he should be a guy who is better than a lot of what’s come out of the bullpen the last few years. If he’s terrible, they’ll eat it. Multi-year deals for relievers, as stated by Han Joelo above, can be expensive crapshoots.
  50. 1 point
    Try a bite of raw onion after minty Crest. It's... different.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.