Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    891
  • comments
    3,675
  • views
    1,591,149

Twins Reduce Clarity With Roster Cuts


Ted Schwerzler

2,659 views

 Share

Twins Video

This morning, first year manager Paul Molitor announced the next handful of roster cuts for the Minnesota Twins. As the team whittles down its roster to 25 players prior to Opening Day a week from Monday, the group of Fort Myers is going to get smaller. With 31 players now left in camp, Molitor has six more players he must send packing. The latest round however may have caused more confusion than clarity.

 

Amongst the roster moves this morning, the Minnesota Twins elected to send out position players Eddie Rosario and Aaron Hicks. Both outfielders will head to Triple-A Rochester to begin the 2015 season. Relief pitcher Mark Hamburger was also optioned as well as starter Trevor May. Both pitchers will head to the Red Wings as well. With the moves, it was also announced that Tommy Milone would open as the Twins fifth and final starter, with Mike Pelfrey transitioning to the bullpen.

 

No matter how you break it down, Saturday was by far the most integral day of roster shuffling the Twins have seen thus far. With the plethora of decisions made, the roster is taking shape. That being said, there's no doubt that a few of the moves made cause reason for confusion.

 

Starting with the outfield, namely centerfield, both Hicks and Rosario were sent packing. Thus far during the spring, we have heard that neither Hicks nor Rosario would stick with the club in a rotational capacity. They would either be named the starter, or would be sent packing. The curious part of the equation is that those sentiments seemed to be in unison with one another. Either Rosario or Hicks would start, as it never appeared likely that Jordan Schafer or Shane Robinson were viable candidates.

 

That brings us to where we are now. The Twins are heading into 2015 with some opportunity to outperform expectations. No one is banking on them being a playoff team, but if all things break right, they could squeak in. That being said, the upcoming season is about figuring out who you have to pair with the arrival of the talented youth on the way. Rosario still very much remains of that grouping, but the problem is Aaron Hicks.

 

Hicks, a former first round pick for the Twins, has struggled mightily at the major league level. After an impressive 2013 spring training, he was promoted to the starting role from Double-A, despite being more of a tools prospect than the refined category of a Byron Buxton. Last year, for the first time in his career, a demotion allowed him to successively progress through both the Double-A and Triple-A levels. He did so while hitting for average, getting on base, and playing solid centerfield defense. Today's move suggest the Twins aren't looking to substantiate that at the major league level and the big question is why? Figuring out what Hicks has to give you prior to turning Buxton and Rosario loose seems to be an integral thing to unlock. Doing so out of the gate with a strong end to the 2014 season made the most sense. Now it would appear the Twins have created more questions than answers.

 

In moving on from Hicks to start the season, Molitor is giving the centerfield job to Jordan Schafer and Shane Robinson. He has said he will "play matchups" but that it won't be a straight platoon situation. While that's great in theory, by and large, that is what's going to take place. The problem there is that a platoon is designed to allow a batter to exploit his talents against a certain type of pitcher.

 

Neither Robinson nor Schafer possess any real ability at the plate. Schafer owns a .229 career average, and was under the Mendoza line last season before coming over from the Braves. Sure he hit .285 for the Twins, but there's no way the production is sustainable. As an outfielder owning a UZR (Ultimate Zone Rating) of -8.4, he's not someone you ideally want starting in center either.

 

On the other side of the equation, Robinson fooled no one with a breakout season at the plate. He spent much of 2014 in Triple-A for the Cardinals. His career UZR of 7.8 is indicative of his billing as a defensive outfielder, but his career average suggests he's virtually a guaranteed out as well. At the end of the day, Molitor and the Twins appear to have looked past Aaron Hicks at the juncture that may result in them getting another opportunity to do so.

 

Looking at the mound, normalcy has likely been achieved. As Mike Palfrey heads to the pen with Milone rounding out the rotation, the Twins know how things will start. Palfrey voiced displeasure suggesting he was told he'd be given a chance to start, and that he didn't believe he'd be destined for the pen. This morning, he went as far as saying if there are clubs who believe in him as a starter, he would be open to moving on.

 

To be fair, the competition likely never included Palfrey from the get go. While he posted a sub 2.00 ERA this spring, 13.2 innings were never going to be enough to extrapolate any information that multiple years of bad starting pitching wouldn't overshadow. Trevor May pitched well, and despite his rough outing on Friday, he was always going to be in an uphill battle. Malone is a proven commodity and pitched well on a solid Oakland team. Minnesota should expect him to return to that form this season.

 

Despite being upset about his new role, Pelfrey actually could extend his career this way. With the ability to push the radar gun to around 97 in a less stamina related role, he could overpower hitters to a much larger extent. While Wade Davis is the golden example, if Palfrey can follow that path and become even close to that level, the Twins stand to gain a lot with this decision. Should Palfrey be focused on starting, the Twins could look to the Mets, Blue Jays, and maybe even the Red Sox as options. The problem is that a bad starting pitcher is probably going to net them less in a trade, even if that team needs an arm, than what they would find out by having him relieve first.

 

At the end of Saturday, we know a lot more about how the Twins will look when they head north. Some of it is easy to agree with (sorry Pelf, the pen is home now), and some doesn't make sense (Hicks now becomes a bigger question mark than he was before). As the Twins embark on their last week in Florida, look for the backup catcher role to be determined, and Eduardo Nunez to continue to be evaluated.

 

Let's hope we aren't having another frustrating discussion involving Kennys Vargas later this week. The Twins are at the mercy of injury when it comes to Josmil Pinto, and if they have to bring Chris Herrmann north because of it, so be it. That being said, lets shoot for a bit higher ceiling with the rest of the decisions alright brain trust?

 

For more, check out Off The Baggy's official site. Or follow on Twitter @tlschwerz

 Share

9 Comments


Recommended Comments

Thank you for your sentiment - mediocre might be an improvement, but it is not the standard I care about.  Blow up this whole damn roster and fill it with young players who might fail, but have the potential to be something.  Safe and boring!  I am already anxious for next spring training.  Oh wait, there is a season to play.

Link to comment

Hicks was the key to the decision making in CF, with Rosario second in line to control his own destiny. Aaron demonstrated an appalling lack of polish on defense for a player of his age and experience, and failed to distinguish himself at bat this spring, or in winter ball for that matter. He's the most talented of the group under consideration, and the decision was apparently made that the best chance for him to develop into a major leaguer is to spend time in AAA. Rosario was an outside shot at best and didn't do enough to convince. So the starting CF role gets defined by default, with the two guys who have low upside but a track record. Ugh to that, and I wanted more off-season options, but given the options now, I grudgingly concur.

 

On pitching, Milone always seemed the default option due to his handedness, if he put up only decent spring numbers. He's very hittable, but probably the best of a limited set of options. I still would have rolled with May, on the principle of getting our youngsters the experience they need at the major league level, but I can understand this choice. If Big Pelf is disappointed at the decision, I can understand and would think less of him as a competitor if he weren't, but if he's angry, then I'm in turn disappointed in him. Pitch well in the bullpen (though I expect only modest increase in radar gun numbers) and the opportunities to start again will still happen. A trade would also make sense, if some GM is willing to offer a significant prospect who doesn't need 40-man protection, but I don't expect this to materialize. (Maybe a multi-player trade, and I don't mean Duensing as a sweetener. :) )

Link to comment

I would dispute that Hicks did well in AAA last year and his performance in September was pedestrian as well. Nothing he did from the time he was demoted last year screamed readiness. Hicks continues to have tools and potential, but the performance has been pretty abysmal.

Link to comment

I guess I would dispute him not showing readiness last season following the demotion. He slashed .291/.387/.441 across AA and AAA after he was sent down. 2014 was the first time Hicks was successively pushed through both levels. As much as he shouldn't have been expected to blossom in 2013 off of a strong string, his numbers progressing on the farm should have weighed more than a less than spectacular spring.

 

At the end of the day, this team has the opportunity to exceed expectations. That being said, finding out what fits going forward and pushing the ceiling should be the goal. By not taking Hicks (or Rosario for that matter), the Twins did accomplish nothing.

 

Schafer is not a defensively sound centerfielder, while Robinson is. Neither of them can hit however, and the ceiling along with the long term viability on the roster is not there for either guy. A week ago, Molitor suggested Hicks or Rosario as the starter noting that neither would play in a 4th man role. Now, they will head north with a platoon of one defender, no hitters, and no ceiling. It figures out nothing with Hicks going forward, and when Buxton arrives, the time to figure out anything is over.

 

Thanks for reading though!

Link to comment

To me, your last sentence sums up my frustration and aggravation with the Twins decision makers. Potential upside does not appear to be a factor in their thinking at all.

Link to comment

Hicks had 84 PAs at AAA (SSS), he hit .278 w/ a .738 OPS, not dominance, not mastering that level.  No, that isn't enough to convince me that he has mastered AAA.  His September numbers were fine for OBP (walks fueled), but he hit for virtually no power. 

 

It is unlikely that Schafer duplicates his performance, but I wouldn't rule it out any more than I would rule out Hicks hitting in his next try with the Twins.  Schafer's defense in center probably isn't much better or worse than Hicks'.

Link to comment

Not mastery, but I'd argue if you aren't going to use that as a springboard to find out what's there now, you likely never will. The decision is basically the Twins believing Hicks' ceiling is lower than a guy added as a NRI for the sake of defense. It may be true, but would have liked to see that substantiated out of the gate in 2015. It's tough to exceed expectations to an extent that matters when you set them at the floor.

Link to comment

Hicks springboarded back to the majors and hit  .348/.300/.648, which told me that he still had work to do offensively to be a major league regular.  His time in winter ball and this spring have yielded similar numbers.  If any move would sound like "scholarship", it would be to anoint Hicks as the regular center fielder with the results he has put up. 

 

If we are talking about bringing Hicks north instead of Robinson, with the assumption that he platoons in center, then the questions are whether Hicks is a good fit for the role and what it will do for his development as a player.  IMHO, Robinson definitely fits the role better, despite not having nearly the tools of Aaron Hicks.

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...