My two favorite Twins, ever, are Tony Oliva and Rod Carew. The greatest Twin, however, was Harmon Killebrew. He played 1B, 3B, LF, and DH in his career. Hrbek, Koskie, Allison, and Morneau would all agree to step aside for Harmon.

Your first four should be unanimous picks and if the Veterans Committee chooses Tony, all Hall of Famers.

I would choose a couple different players: Lyman Bostock, LF; Greg Gagne, SS; Gary Gaetti, 3B; and Johan Santana as my ace. Leave Herbie at 1B with Harmon as the DH or switch them as Harmon was from (mostly) a pre-DH era.

The Twins have had some great players and teams.

I'm with you tony&rodney.  Oliva and Carew are my Fav's.  Killebrew is the greatest.   Here's my try:

Carew   2B

Puckett   CF

Mauer  C

Killebrew  DH

Oliva   RF

Gaetti  3B

Bostock/Allison  LF (platoon)

Morneau/Hrbek  1B  (tough call)

Gagne   SS  

Tovar  (Utility)

SP:  Santana, Blyleven, Kaat

RP:  Nathan,  Aguilara

Mine is close to everybody's.

C : Mauer

1B: Hrbek

2B: Dozier

3B: Gaeti

SS: Gagne

RF: Oliva

CF: Puckett

LF: Killebrew

DH: Carew

Utility: Tovar

Batting Order: 1. Carew 2. Puckett 3. Mauer 4. Killebrew 5. Oliva 6. Hrbek 7. Gaeti 8. Dozier       9. Gagne

SP: Santana, Pasqual, Blyleven, Viola, Grant and Kaat

BP: Nathan and Aguilara

1B was tough between Carew, Killebrew, Hrbek and Morneau

Smalley was a close 2nd at SS

Killebrew started his career at LF so there is where I put him

8 minutes ago, Doctor Gast said:

Utility: Tovar

Cool that you added Cesar. He was such an exciting player and can easily be left off of an all time team and utility players have always been critical components of great teams. Tovar belongs, for sure.