Everything posted by twinstalker
-
I've forgotten the goal for teams playing MLB games
Is it to participate? Are trophies given to every player who gets in a game? To full teams? I watch the Twins, and I have a real hard time figuring it out. Now, I was really tired this afternoon and kept dozing off, but I could swear the Twins were fully participating in a game today, and I'm pretty sure they once again had no ulterior motives. At least I didn't see any. Now I could be wrong, it might have been my sleep daze, but I may have actually seen the Twins try to lose, but I'm sure that wasn't a conscious decision. I've seen this before. Ron Gardenhire actually gives away outs so that he can limit his team's scoring, and he's done that many times. I've often wondered why he would lessen the Twins' chances of scoring runs, but he does it. Recklessly, from what I can tell. No factual information behind him, it's like he subscribes to a religion where only faith is required. Friday was another example, a different example. Mr. Gardenhire had many options for whom to pitch in a certain special situation. The bases were loaded, there was one out in the 8th inning, up by 1. One of the options he had was his best pitcher: Glen Perkins. Another was one of his worst pitchers: Tyler Robertson. The former was well-rested, the latter had pitched the day before and had just gotten off a spring where he'd given up nearly two hits and walks per inning. Gardenhire chose the worse pitcher in the most critical of situations. Why did he do this? I have wracked my tiny brain, and all I can come up with is that he wanted his best pitcher to get a "Save." What is a Save? A Save is an artifact of games that are won. They themselves do not cause a game to be won, but when a win is awarded, frequently a Save is award as well. There is nothing special about a Save. One doesn't push you ahead in the standings, such as an overtime loss does in the NHL. I have done extensive research, and all I can find is that a Save confers special acknowledgement on the pitcher it is awarded to. In contrast, an Out gotten by a pitcher actually is something that will yield a higher probability of a win (and a Save, coincidentally). One might say that the decision on which pitcher to choose can really come down to this: Is your goal to try to get a critical out that would more likely result in winning the game at hand, or is your goal to increase the probability that an arbitrary acknowledgement is conferred upon one of your options? I dug through the archive for seconds upon seconds to take another look at the situation Mr. Gardenhire had in front of him. He had five outs to guarantee a win, and among other constraints, two of those out most likely had to come before two of the runners currently on base scored. His best pitcher might not have the easiest time getting all five outs, and possibly it might be decided to have another pitcher face the first righthanded bat of the 9th inning, thereby negating the awarding of the arbitrary acknowledgement on his best pitcher. So it wasn't as if he only had to think about getting one out. Clearly, though, the highest leverage situation for this game was at this critical decision point: bases juiced with one out in the 8th inning, up by one run. The game most likely was going to be won or lost there, depending on whether the Twins gave up 0, 1, or 2 runs. If the goal of the Twins in playing this MLB game is to win it, the decision of which pitcher to use would seem obvious. If the goal of playing the game is to decrease the chance your best reliever pitches in a game where he doesn't get award the arbitrary acknowledgement, the choice is also obvious. While not mathematically correct in every situation, in most cases, including this one, the choice of pitchers identifies the goal of the one making the decision. (i.e. Simpson's Paradox is unlikely to apply, stat geeks) There's a leap there, and I'm hand-waving to get to my conclusion, but I'm pretty confident it's correct. I don't think Gardenhire is purposely trying to lose games, but I'm pretty sure he's ignorant when it comes to understanding what to do to win games. Many, many, many times over the course of a season, including Friday in the 8th inning.
-
Chris Parmelee
Heh, normally I'd say wtf, it's three games (now). But his PAs aren't Parmelee PAs, he's completely overwhelmed at the plate, as evidenced by consistently letting third strikes be thrown down the middle of the plate. Absolutely sure it's mental and a confidence thing this moment, so much so that something similar to the original post crossed my mind. The thing is, you hardly notice when something like this happens for three games in the middle of the season, but it's been pretty bad. My first year in little league I had no clue. I either struck out or walked in every PA. That's what Parmelee seems like right now. Here's hoping his smash off Fielder turns him around and restores his confidence. For me to even comment on such a small sample means I see something that's not right and not likely attributable to noise. He looked that bad.
-
Reusse: Could Parmelee Be Platooned?
Heh, yeah, "Gardenhire's always looked to..." is not a good way to start a point. He's never platooned. Between Ryan and Gardenhire, do not expect anything that makes sense or optimizes wins or spares outs.
-
Article: Rotation becomes clear as Minnesota Twins cut two more
Did someone expect or hope for 1.5 years from a guy on a one-year contract?
-
Article: Roster Becomes Clearer With More Transactions
Ramirez, Deduno, Walters all present the same problem. Which other bad guy who's actually on the 40 that we're overrating because so many are so bad that we're scared to lose him can we take off the 40? I'd say Burnett is the most likely candidate. At least with Thielbar, you have no real proof he's bad at the MLB level. Roenicke probably doesn't get much rope. Knowing the Twins, though, they'll decide Ryan Pressly has to go back to Boston so as not to hurt anyone's feelings.
-
Article: Rosario could rise to the top in '13
Being worried about the Twins having too much middle infield talent the next couple years is an indicator that we should take nothing else you say seriously. As Kwak says, Dozier won't be blocking anybody (I'm sure he means anybody good). Right now the only player in the system who is in danger of being both good and in the MI is Rosario. The rest are mediocre or utility, with fingers crossed for Jorge Polanco.
-
Article: Twins To Sign RHP Kevin Correia
Who would you rather have pitching for the Twins, Kevin Correia or Sam Deduno? My money's on the dizzy-eyed one.
-
Article: Twins To Sign RHP Kevin Correia
Awesome. This rivals the Marquis signing. I can't think of any move that would be quite as stupid as this one. Congrats, Terry Ryan. For a moment there, I thought you had finally clued in. I now know you traded Ben Revere because you actually do think Aaron Hicks is ready, not because it was the right thing to do.
-
If Revere goes to Philly, who comes back?
Baseball seems to be centerfielder-crazy right now. Ryan is right to take advantage of that. Taking advantage of a system's inefficiencies is so...so MoneyBall.
-
If Revere goes to Philly, who comes back?
It appears the #1 suitor for Revere is Philadelphia. The Revere thread was about Revere, so I wanted to take the discussion in another direction. They need a CF, and the FA alternatives are incredibly expensive. Who is reasonable to get back from Philly if we give them Revere? The candidates: Vance Worley, 25. He's not a bad young pitcher. His peripherals don't predict amazing success, but they're good by Twins standards, he's outpitched them over his two years with the big club, at least until his elbow started hurting. And the Phillies are trying to move him. So what's the problem? He's injured and is a surgery waiting to happen. Worley hurt his elbow this past season, rested, and tried to play through it. No such luck, as he was shut down in late August. They say bone chips, but that's often a precursor to TJS. Okay, being a pitcher is often a precursor to TJS. Jesse Biddle, 21. One of three Philly prospect pitchers that might get the Twins attention. Biddle had a good year in the FSL and should be ready for AA and perhaps beyond 2013. Trevor May, 23. Philadelphia's most intriguing pitcher is a K machine. Okay, make that a BB machine. He's struggled with his control, and his first few months of 2013 were near-disaster, but he put together a nice August. From 2011 A+ ball to AA in 2012 May's K rate declined, and his BB rate increased. The Phillies top pitching prospect last year might never get it together in a starting role. I'm hoping for May so stupid Twins fans can refer to our young SPs as Mays and Meyers. Julio Rodriguez, 22. Pitching at age 21 in AA, Rodriguez threw up numbers that weren't that different from the age 22 May (both have had birthdays since). His high A numbers in 2011 were tremendous and also mirrored May, and it give you pause with Biddle's nice 2012 season there in Clearwater. Ethan Martin, 23. What is it with Philly pitchers? Martin pitched 158 innings between AA and AAA inn 2012, giving up only 118 hits and striking out 147, but yielding 79 walks. Adam Morgan, 22. Morgan had a very good season between A+ and AA in 2012. A 3rd rd pick from Alabama in 2011, Morgan threw 159 innings with 169 K, and a K/BB of 4.33. The majority of those numbers were at Clearwater, and he didn't dominate as much at AA Reading in seven starts, but his year is remarkably similar to Alex Meyer's. Others: Jonathan Pettibone 22. My preference? I do like Worley, but I think having a bone spur removed from your elbow is a bigger deal than some might. Still, he's expected to be fine by spring training. He's a #3 starter at best, but he's a good pitcher who did well when healthy in a horrible park for pitchers. The Twins should jump on Worley if one of the others is included, but that's probably asking way too much. Maybe that gives the Twins a chance to be creative. Perhaps Revere and Nate Roberts can persuade the Philles to give up Worley and one of these prospects. That could be a tremendous deal for the Twins. But getting Worley alone might be too risky if his elbow doesn't both hold up and allow him to get back to early numbers.
-
Is Marcum the Twins' Best Hope?
If the Twins planned on signing two FA pitchers, and they signed two plus Marcum, I'd be okay with getting him at a safe price. Otherwise, I view him as damaged good.
-
Article: Could the Twins still trade Ben Revere?
Revere does some good things, but there are reason to deal him, too. While he's a great CF range, speed on the bases, and high BA, 1. He doesn't walk 2. (redacted) Hicks, Arcia, Buxton, with Willingham, Benson, maybe Roberts as bridge to Buxton. 3. His arm sucks for center. He'll be sucking up most of the balls in the outfield, but he has no arm and teams will run wild. 4. He has no power. Zero power, almost. Many of his hits are infield and don't move runners along more than one base. 5. Someone mentioned getting a crappy Juan Pierre-type to replace him. Well, his GOAL is to be Juan Pierre, because that's his upside. 6. Revere will (or should, anyway) be dealt when the kids arrive. At that time, he'll be overpriced in terms of salary. Right now he's a min salary player, which could mislead teams to give up something for him. 7. He's easily replaceable in a losing season with a platoon. While the lefty hitting guy might not be quite as good, the rh guy should be close, and if it's remotely close, that's all you need to bridge to Hicks. Mastroianni could provide the right side of a platoon this year with a late, cheap FA getting ABs from the left side. There are plenty out there who could put up a .320 obp. Of course, what's the point if the Twins can't get anything in return? I really don't know what the Twins could get for him. It's somewhat possible that they could get a pitching prospect that''s in the 100-150 range, but those guys are incredible variable, or they'd be in the top 50. It would be giving up Revere to throw a dart at a board. Could the Twins trade him to the Braves? Well, I think he could play left for them (because of his arm) or center (because of range) with Upton moving to a corner. Will the Braves give up a Randall Delgado for him? Probably not. They'd probably offer Sean Gilmartin, and I suspect the Sean Gilmartins out there are Revere's value. Revere is valuable enough to not give away for something you could just as well get in FA, but if they can get any pitcher with upside who could pitch in 2013 or 2014, they should probably pull the trigger. Revere helps the rebuild only slightly and as a bridge.
-
Article: Twins trade Denard Span for Nationals' 2011 first round pick
Haven't read through the last eighty or so comments, but I just saw this tidbit out there on the interwebz: Meyer is a Boras client. That should tell us all we need to know about how horribly the Twins will handle Meyer and his contract status each year. Meyer will never sign a team-friendly contract, and the Twins will likely shop him too late. Oh, well. The initial excitement about this just wore off. Let's hope he provides a positive contribution his first few years. On the other hand, it will maybe keep the Twins from handing out a Blackburn/Mays/Baker contract when they don't have to.
-
Article: Twins trade Denard Span for Nationals' 2011 first round pick
Keith Law is more respected than Dave Cameron? I think that is probably true among people who don't understand sabermetrics as well. In the same way Souhan is probably more respected than Gleeman.
-
Article: Twins trade Denard Span for Nationals' 2011 first round pick
Here's why Meyer is a much better return than Mike Leake. Mike Leake has no more upside than what he's shown, and if Meyer doesn't pan out, you can find FAs who are basically as good as Leake. Top prospects for average guys when you're a losing team is absolutely the most cost-efficient and talent-optimal way to do business. And I really dislike Terry Ryan.
-
Article: Twins trade Denard Span for Nationals' 2011 first round pick
I had hoped he wouldn't draw any attention prior to my draft that starts this weekend. Meyer was in my sights, and now I suppose he's in everyone else's, too.
-
Article: Twins trade Denard Span for Nationals' 2011 first round pick
Geez, John, Meyer is anything but a C prospect. He's the guy I was hoping we'd go for if we couldn't figure out how to pull Minor for Span. He's a B prospect, maybe a B+, according to Sickels, I'm sure. I'm disappointed the Twins didn't get more, but if they couldn't get more out of the Nats, this is a guy they couldn't walk away from. He starts at A+ and moves to AA this year.
-
Article: Braves Signing Upton Hurts Twins' Trade Options
Who? They have Pastornicky and Ahmed, both of whom project as utility guys. We're not getting Andrelton Simmons for Span. Dozier is absolutely just as good and maybe better than Pastornicky.
-
Article: Does Torii Hunter's Contract Bode Well For A Josh Willingham Trade?
Gardenhire doesn't understand the value of true platoons, so by dealing JW the Twins could end up with six lefty bats in a row to get mown down by some chump loogy, instead of the four in a row that never see a rhp now after the 5th inning. But they're going to lose anyway. If they're semi-smart and give up on the season, they could actually maybe get some good return for JW.
-
Article: Twins Should Target Trevor Bauer
Yeah, Bauer commands Sano+. No? Then Arizona will take Bauer and easily trade him to a team with good hitting prospects. The Red Sox would easily part with Bogaerts to get Bauer. Cleveland would give up Lindor and anything else Arizona wants. Bauer has the value of a young Curt Schilling, circa 1993. We could get him, but Sano and Rosario would be the return. What they should do is see if Texas will give them Andrus and one of their good prospects like Rogned (sp). Their middle infield could be set for years.
-
Article: Twins Talkers: Your Twitter Questions
Hey, wtf?
-
Article: On Writing, Coaching and Paul Molitor
There are probably three very distinct reasons why Molitor is "not a good fit." Either: 1. Molitor does not want to be a full-time coach. He doesn't want to travel. 2. Molitor has some unknown recently that reflects poorly on him and would on the organization if he were full-time. or 3. Molitor is the replacement if the team lets go of Gardenhire, and they can claim they went outside the organization. There's also the possibility he doesn't know how do simple things like access stats on the internet. :-)
-
Article: Twins Pitchers Who Could Contribute to a Playoff Team in the Future
I have this major criticism. In the Deduno blurb, you need a comma after "of" and before "well, baseball." That's the only thing that could have made this a more cogent account of the state of Twins pitching. Nice job. Speaking of Deduno, though, my intellectual side totally agrees with you. My emotional side has me just a tiny bit intrigued. I fully realize that he is the contemporary portrayal of all those pitchers I've always wondered whatever happened to: Les Straker, Roger Erickson, Terry Felton, Mike Smithson/John Butcher, Allan Anderson, Tom Johnson, Bluegill Hughes. All, except for Felton, had good years out of nowhere and basically sucked the rest of their careers. Felton somehow fits as a less successful Deduno.
-
Was Morneau the Dodgers' first choice?
Fine. Name those offered. Why would you say this unless you also mentioned the names? Sounds like hyperbole to me. Ryan made a huge mistake here. Worst case, clearing salary.
-
Christensen: Mauer Needs To Swing
What's up with Joe C.? He followed that lame one up with one on five pitchers on their way to help that basically illustrated entirely too clearly that the Twins have nothing to be waiting for, at least compared to other teams. I actually wonder whether Dave St. Peter wrote it.