This is a bit off topic, but since I am posting 4 days after the last post I think it is fair. Here is a different way of looking at it. Would you want Taylor Rogers back? If your answer is yes, take a closer look at Rogers and Pagan's numbers. They are shockingly similar. Rogers pitched 1.1 more innings, but they both faced 274 batters (all stats per baseball reference). They both struck out 84 batters, but Pagan gave up 7 more walks. To even this out Rogers hit 10 more batters! Pagan gave up 5 more home runs, yet Rogers gave up 3 more earned runs. Rogers had better FIP, Whip, and SO/W ratios. Meanwhile Pagan actually had a lower ERA and ERA+. Pagan's ERA was going in the right direction, while Roger's ERA stats (ERA, ERA+, and FIP) got significantly worse in Milwaukee. Given these numbers, I don't know that I would want either, it is all a matter of dollars and who's roster spot they are taking. What I do know, is that Padres did not "win" the trade. Either the Twins will win or we both lost, depending on what happens with Paddack over the next couple of years.