Everything posted by glunn
-
Paris Attacks
I see a few important differences from appeasing Hitler. First, Iraq was controlled by the Sunnis until we took out Saddam, then they had to endure brutal repression and humiliation at the hands of their most hated enemies, the Shiites. Unlike Germany, the Sunnis actually had their backs against a wall. Second, I see little reason to worry about ISIS scientists developing modern weapons and ISIS factories churning out much more than swords. ISIS believes in science less than the Republicans, whereas Hitler was developing atomic bombs. Third, ISIS believes that there will be a climactic battle in the plains of northern Syria. If we can get them out in the open, this is a battle that we will certainly win. The only way that we could lose that battle will be if Allah intervenes, as ISIS believes. I am more than willing to take my chances on that. I understand the problems that arose from putting Native Americans on reservations and from the State of Israel, but it seems to me that there have also been benefits from giving people a homeland. It also seems to me that after the fall of Saddam we should have done what a lot of smart people suggested -- divide Iraq in to three countries, one for the Sunnis, one for the Shiites and one for the Kurds. These groups are mortal enemies and in hindsight it seems foolish that our experts expected that they could overcome the level of hatred that exist. I am also not worried about ISIS taking Mecca. I blame the Saudis for a lot of this and if Mecca gets taken or is destroyed, then only Muslims will be to blame, and I am sick of our troops getting killed and getting PTSD from Muslim civil wars. I acknowledge that there are holes in my proposal. The biggest hole is that ISIS will probably be unwilling to negotiate a deal that involves fixed borders. In that event, I would still like to provide one way air fare to anyone who wants to move to the caliphate. I would rather have them there than here, and ideally we can have as many of them as possible on the plains of northern Syria on a day where the world will learn whether Allah is really going to help them defeat a modern army in open battle.
-
Paris Attacks
If the shoe was on the other foot, I would be glad for the fact that I am well armed and a very good shot. Why can't people understand why they want to kill us?
-
Paris Attacks
I see your point about barbarism, but more than 10,000 children die every day of starvation. Why not focus on feeding them? These children are unarmed and are not capable of terrorist activity. Feeding starving children does not cause our people to suffer PSTD. From this perspective I see no close call. Feeding starving children would relieve a lot more suffering at a much lower cost. I still think that we should give ISIS their own country then enforce the borders. A prerequisite would be an embargo on weapons and ammunition. They could live within their borders in the 7th century and all radical Muslims around the world should be given free airfare to join them. They should have water, building materials and other 7th century technology and we should live with the fact that they choose to be barbaric to their own people. I don't see us invading Africa to stop genital mutilation, so why are we so focused on the middle east? I am seriously committed to cut the number of children who die from starvation, and it seems to me that a trillion dollars spent on this is would yield better results than another war.
-
The Front Office and Settling For Mediocrity
Moderator note -- please be gentle in holding other posters accountable for posts that they made in the past. I am glad that Dave took this in stride, but such exchanges sometimes lead to bickering.
-
Lurkers and rookies please post here
It's good to have you aboard. We can never have enough stat mavens.
-
Paris Attacks
I think that any solution must come from the answer to that question. It seems to me that terrorism is hard wired into our DNA. Please ask yourself whether you would ever join a terror group that is planning to kill millions of people. Then please consider what you would do in the following scenario. Radical Muslims develop a virus that kills 99% of all Americans. Your loved ones all die and you are one of a few million survivors. The Radical Muslims then take control of the United States and enslave almost all of the survivors, raping the women and castrating the men. You manage to hook up with a resistance cell, and they have a plan to release a virus that will cause most of the Muslims to die horrible deaths. You can help in this effort, knowing that you will be killed during the mission. Would you participate? When I think about this scenario my sense is that I have an innate impulse to get revenge and my heartbeat increases and I feel good about dead Muslims. I see two ways to go here. We can ask France to join us and twenty or thirty other countries in sending 5,000 troops apiece to wipe ISIS from the map. Countries that come immediately to mind include England, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Germany, Russia, Ukraine, China, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Kuwait, Iran, Pakistan, India, and Turkey. With enough allies, this should be a piece of cake, and ideally this would promote good feelings among countries who have bad relationships, such as Russia and the Ukraine. History shows that nothing brings countries together as quickly as a common enemy. One very bad thing about this plan is lots of people would die, including innocent women and children. Another bad thing is that it would likely result in more terrorism. These killers in Paris were not cowards -- they knew that they would die. If we wipe out ISIS, it seems inevitable that their brethren will seek revenge. That leads to the other way to go, which is the path of peace. I think that such path requires dropping any pretense that the Western powers are innocent in all of this. Let's face it. The record of the Western powers in the middle east has been abysmal. To name a few of many examples, we put the Shah in power, we sold chemical weapons to Saddam that he used to kill a lot of people, and we are the main prop for the disgusting Saudi regime. More recently, the war to remove Saddam cost hundreds of thousands of Iraqi lives. It seems obvious why are we hated. It's human nature for people to want revenge when their countries are invaded and occupied and their loved ones are wounded/killed and they see pictures of their countrymen being tortured in a prison like Abu Grabe? Summing this up, if I were an Iraqi and my family was wiped out by a stray American drone, my first thought would be how can I kill as many Americans as possible. And it would take a lot to restrain that primal impulse. However, it seems indisputable that violence begets violence. Consider Rome versus Carthage, England versus France and the Crusades -- humans are capable of carrying on wars for decades and sometimes centuries. Each group sees itself as the good people and their enemies as the bad people. How do we break this cycle? Peace is hard. It requires admitting past mistakes. It also requires compromise and accommodation. My experience in making peace is that it is critical to address the core interests of each side. In this case, ISIS wants its own country -- a caliphate that would be a theocracy. I think that we should put this on the bargaining table. Frankly, I like the idea of having as many of these radical Muslims in one place as possible and I can live with the fact that they will oppress their own people (who choose not to get out while the getting is good). Thus, I would let them have their caliphate, subject to an agreement of all civilized countries not to sell them any weapons or technology. Let them live in the 7th century and leave them alone as much as possible.
-
The Front Office and Settling For Mediocrity
Moderator note -- there is too much bickering here. If it continues then infractions will be assessed against BOTH sides. Please STOP the personal squabbling.
-
Is moderation on this site fair or bias?
I am the moderator who deleted jimmer's post and my reason was that it was reported as trolling and it seemed like trolling to me: "Just trust Ryan. All the moves he makes, and doesn't make, are the right moves. And every great prospect we have was a result of moves Ryan made. That is why our farm system (including Sano who graduated) is so good. All Ryan. Trust in Ryan!" I have not deleted the other posts that jimmer quoted, because they seem borderline to me. On the one hand, such posts were clearly less civil than they should have been. On the other hand they had some substance that could and did lead to intelligent discussion. As for moderator bias, we have some mods who are ready for TR to go and some who seem to be in the middle. I don't think that any moderator is a strong TR supporter. Finally, if we were bothered by attacks on TR then Dave would have been banned for life a long time ago. Feel free to attack every decision by TR, but be please be substantive and refrain from attacking other posters, bickering and trolling.
-
The Front Office and Settling For Mediocrity
Moderator note -- I have just deleted a number of posts that contained personal attacks and bickering. Posters need to follow TD policy or their posting privileges will be suspended. Our policy can be found here: http://twinsdaily.com/topic/8228-twins-daily-comment-policy-latest-revision-september-2013/ As ChiTown and others have noted, we seem to plow a lot of the same ground whenever TR makes a move. The same posters tend to say the same things over and over, and there are clearly two extreme factions and a lot of people in the middle. Let's just try to be more civil.
- Article: Twins Trade Aaron Hicks To Yankees For Catcher
-
Article: Torii Hunter To Retire
Here is a nice article about today's ceremony: http://www.cbssports.com/mlb/eye-on-baseball/25364308/torii-hunters-retirement-press-conference-too-sore-to-play-anymore It appears that he was having soreness problems: "The last two years, I've been sore," Hunter said, responding to a question about what's different this time. "I've definitely been fighting some soreness. My wife has to push me out of bed. It took me an hour and a half or two hours to get warmed up just to stretch. "I never thought I'd get there this soon. Forty? Man, It's time."
-
Does Torii Hunter get unfairly crushed for his stance on SSM?
Our founding fathers enshrined slavery into the constitution. Women did not get the right to vote until 1920. Looking back at history through the lens of our current beliefs, our ancestors appear bigoted. It seems to me that this does not mean that they were bad people. If I was taught from an early age that slavery was a good thing and, after all, it is sanctioned in the Old Testament, then I think that it might take some outside enlightenment to change this view, which is ultimately what happened through the efforts of the abolitionists, journalists and novelists. As for Torii, he should know better, but so should millions of other people, including people who are now running for President. We each evolve at our own rate. Now that Torii will have more free time, maybe he will evolve faster. But I am far more concerned about people who hold archaic views who may be nominating Supreme Court justices who have the same views. Finally, let's tone down the bickering in this thread. We are better than this.
-
Dozier Lone Twins Gold Glove Candidate
I find it interesting that Wilson Ramos is in the running for the AL catcher gold glove.
-
Sporting News Names Molitor Manager Of Year
Congratulations to Molitor. It seems to me that this is well deserved.
-
Article: The End Of The Road
Moderator note - please tone down the personal attacks and bickering. I just deleted a bunch of posts and we will start handing out infraction points if the bickering continues. I appreciate the strong convictions on both sides of this, but the integrity of our forums depends on keeping the discussion RESPECTFUL.
-
Changes to CF at Target Field
The "Catch" lounge seems to me like a skybox area at a bargain price. At 120 people, this seems like very small potatoes in the context of a stadium that seats more than 39,000 people -- far less than 1% of overall capacity. I suspect that this is just a toe in the water and the plan is to expand this if it is successful. I agree that it would be great for some families to have areas where kids can blow off steam. I also respect those who don't want kids distracting from their enjoyment of the game. It seems to me that everyone could be better off if there were attractions for kids adjacent to seating that is designated for families. This would make games more appealing to families and would siphon kids away from adults who don't want them distracting from the game. Also, for very little money the Twins could add a female bear and have a contest where kids vote on a name for the bear. A unique approach might be to replicate the Catch lounge for families and family groups-- a juice bar instead of alcohol, some small batting cages using tees, extra visits from TC bear (and new female bear), face painting, etc. This would keep the kids far away from those who would be annoyed by the kids, and the parents could watch the game without worry that the kids can leave the safe area (which would be secured). Yes, this would be somewhat like Chuck E Cheese, but if it were walled off like Catch, then it would not disturb the hardcore fans. Question for those who have kids -- does this sound appealing? Maybe the Twins would not consider this, because the revenue per kid would need to be much lower than the revenue per adult at the Catch. However, it seems to me that until the Twins can get back to anything near full attendance, this would be profitable, even if less profitable than Catch. A seat that brings in $30 of net revenue is not as profitable as a seat that brings in $80, BUT an empty seat brings in $0. Also, over the long run this would create more customers and higher TV ratings. Also, if this does not work, the same infrastructure could be converted to a bar.
-
Article: Available For Preorder: 2016 Offseason Handbook
Only 7 more days. I wish that I had an Eric Cartman time machine.
-
Post your prospect lists here
These are some excellent lists. Nice work and a good discussion. Kudos to Diehard for starting this thread. I hope to see more lists.
-
Democratic Debate
It seems to me that FDR was more of a socialist than Bernie. FDR advocated top marginal tax rates of more than 90% and created government agencies that provided millions of jobs.
-
Democratic Debate
If I were Bernie I would treat FDR as the Democratic party's Ronald Reagan. FDR brought us Social Security, a socialistic program that has kept tens of millions of seniors out of severe poverty, and FDR's tax policy was much more socialistic than what Bernie is proposing. Compared with FDR, Bernie's policies seem conservative. I would also counsel Bernie to focus on doing more with less taxpayer funds. There is a lot of waste and inefficiency in almost every department of the federal government, and this should be a bipartisan issue. My best guess is that with better organization and greater accountability we could cut expenses by $200 billion per year or more while ending up with a military that is more suited to our needs and social programs that provide better results for our fellow citizens.
-
The Martian - movie
I agree that Damon was good in this, and I am not a Damon fan.
-
Article: Arizona Fall League Preview: Walker Provides Intrigue
It appears that Taylor Rogers had a good game today -- he started the game and had one earned run in 4 innings and 5 strikeouts. Interestingly, neither Twins catcher played, and ABW DH'd and went 1 for 4 with a walk and two Ks. http://mlb.mlb.com/milb/stats/stats.jsp?gid=2015_10_14_srrwin_scowin_1&t=g_box&sid=l119
-
Trade: Joe Mauer +30 million for Justin Morneau
At a game in Anaheim two or three years ago I watched Morneau give autographs to young Twins fans for about 15 minutes. He was friendly and focused on singing as many items as possible. No other Twins player gave autographs that night.
-
Souhan's solution to the "Mauer Problem"
Moderator note -- too much bickering in this thread. Obviously, there are some strong disagreements here. Please focus on facts and refrain from characterizing other people's positions as silly.
-
Injury news?
Hopefully this is nothing, but it's hard not to worry. http://www.startribune.com/dozier-to-have-mri-ryan-sees-lots-of-areas-to-upgrade/330909051/ From the article linked above: "the soreness is not considered serious, Ryan said, and the magnetic resonance imaging test is more a precaution than a precursor to surgery."