Everything posted by gil4
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
That's part of my point. With my massive blind spots and zero access, I came up with two examples. (Three - Ted Williams) With his full access, he could think of one. It's not like we're dealing with massive numbers - it was 1 vs. 10.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
His exact quote was "I think I only heard a white player called “not a winning player” once, because he was on the DL, as opposed to at least ten players of color called that." He didn't name names, but one is one. I came up with two off the top of my head, and I follow the Twins, completely ignore 3/4 of the league, and half-way pay attention to the rest. Heck, Ted Williams was "not a winning player" (all about his stats). I think KLaw just forgot about the examples that didn't set off the alarm he was listening for.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
He said he had one example of a white player being called "not a winner." I follow one team to the point that I could probably name more starters from our MiLB affiliates than I could from 2/3 the teams in the majors, yet I could think of two prominent examples off the top of my head. (One might have been the same as his, because he mentioned "because he was on the DL", so maybe he was talking about Mauer.)
-
Article: Can Hector Santiago Elevate and Dominate?
I agree with you - a lot of work went into the article and it does make a pretty good case. I had a hard time getting past one word in the title: Dominate. That is not a word that comes to mind with Santiago, and the article itself really doesn't argue that he can. If he can keep his ERA around 4 and stay in the rotation all years, I would consider that success. I think he can do that. Many around here would consider that overly optimistic. I can live with that. That's not dominance. Johan dominated. Liriano dominated that one year before he hurt his elbow. I almost didn't read the article because I saw the title and answered "Hell, no. Next question."
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
Torii Hunter and Kirby Puckett were "winning players." Morneau and Mauer were/are not. At least, that is the conventional wisdom I have gathered from this site and several of its predecessors.
-
Column: Does a Robbie Grossman Trade Make Sense?
If last year was an indication he figured some things out at the plate, he could have some real value, especially if he can return to being an almost-average fielder. His trade value is still close to zero now, especially with everyone crunching their rosters at the end of spring training, but someone could see him as a useful piece if they have and injury hole to patch or need another bat off the bench.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
We have no trouble hearing about the ugly Americans traveling abroad and behaving like they are in America. We even have a saying, "When in Rome..." Why is it now racist for Americans to ask for international players in our leagues to not behave in a manner that many of us consider rude. I know, international tournament might be different, but I think American teams that have toured Japan in the past have at least been somewhat aware of the different cultural attitudes of the host country and have attempted to conform, rather than just labeling their expectations as racist.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
I clicked the link in the box score and it went to a picture of him and his stats (last pitched in MLB in 2012.) It surprised me, too.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
It might be interpreted differently because of the history of the game in the two locations. Baseball is THE game in Puerto Rico, while it's a cultural afterthought in Australia, and an Australian win would have been a massive shock. I'm sure if Puerto Rico won the FIFA World Cup, wider latitude would be given than would be for, say, Germany, because there is no expectation they would act like they have been there before (because they haven't.) Full disclosure: I couldn't get to the link, so I have no idea what Kinsler said. OK, I have a general idea, but I don't know the specifics.
-
Is this racism or culture clash in baseball?
No kidding. It went past my bedtime and I'm not even on the east coast. I went to bed after Berrios' good inning, and thankfully missed his not-so-good inning. Apparently he had some help from our old friend J.C. Romero, who I couldn't believe was still pitching. I guess he is still just 40, but it seems like it was almost that long ago he pitched for the Twins.
-
2017 MLB draft thread
NFHS has a rule change this year that directs state associations to develop "a pitching restriction policy based on the number of pitches thrown" rather than the previous requirement to limit the innings pitched. Pulling him after 52 pitches may have been a strategic move, or a required move if he had a recent prior appearance. I don't know what his state rule is, or even what state he is from. I don't even know what our state rule is, and I umpire. (The only role for the umpire is to recommend they contact the state association if they believe someone has violated the pitch count rule, so I don't have to know, but I wish they had told us because now I'm curious. Plus I have a son who pitches, so I'd like to know for that.) I just know that now there is some restriction on the number of pitches he can throw that didn't exist before this year.
-
Game Thread: ST game #24-Twins@Blue Jays, 3/20 @ 12:07 pm CT
It doesn't prove it, but it can imply it. I'd say it deserves further study.
-
Game Thread: ST game #24-Twins@Blue Jays, 3/20 @ 12:07 pm CT
As long as they don't take the pie
-
Game Thread: ST game #24-Twins@Blue Jays, 3/20 @ 12:07 pm CT
DAY off? Did the chief just give us the day off?
-
Game Thread: ST game #22-Twins vs.Red Sox, 3/18 @ 10:05 am PT (12:05 pm CT)
Is he a non-left-fielder or a left-non-fielder? You'd think after Sano in RF last year I would know this...
-
Jordan Schafer, P, Los Angeles Dodgers
Awesome reading. It was interesting to see Pinella in there twice - he never struck me as a think outside the box kind of guy. It was also funny to see that he did it 16 years apart. Are the situations where it would be useful that rare? You'd think that he would either a. Decide it was useful and employ it at least occasionally throughout his career, or b. Evaluate and reject the idea as not useful.
-
Article: Slegers Solidifies Status With Strong Spring Showing
I'm sure the coaching staff saw a lot more of him during spring training than the 2.2 IP he had in the games. They sounded happy with his performance and he sounded happy with his performance. I'm not ready to shuffle him off to the pen yet, but he is still a longshot to be more than a guy who hangs around at the fringes of a MLB roster in case someone gets hurt and a team needs a warm body to fill in for a few weeks. Of course, we could say that about 75% of the guys pitching at AA, and some of them come up with that one more pitch or the FB command and/or the couple of MPH boost needed to be more than that.
-
How To Stop The May Fallout
I agree. It looks like he might pitch and might not be a disaster, and I saw the FB velocity as an encouraging sign, not a red flag. Like you said, many pitchers ramp it up, and Hughes said he wasn't throwing at his max yet.
-
Polanco/Buxton ready to lead off? Or just spring training hype?
So we have to bat around every inning? I'm OK with that.
-
A Twins Surprise In Filling Out The Bench
Does Murphy still have options? (I know, I could look, but that clicking seems like a lot of work.) Are you planning on a 13-man pitching staff, or do we get to add one more name? (Od do you have someone (Vargas?) penciled in as the primary DH? Keeping Park would require a 40-man move. Is Adrianza on the 40-man? (That clicking thing again.) I'd hate to dump Escobar and then find out that Adrianza really, really can't hit. I also don't want to rush Granite and dump Grossman because I think Grossman is more likely to maintain his performance at the plate (esp vs LHP) than in the field (I don't think he had ever been that bad in the past and might return to being marginal.)
-
Twins Throwing Burners Out Of The Gate
It seems like I remember someone joking that Gibson was on pace to average 18 K/9 after 1 inning of his first outing, so I think there's one more.
- President Trump brands Baseball-Reference redesign "Enemy of the People"
-
GameThread: ST Game 1, Twins v Rays, 2/24 @ 6:05pm CT
Won that trade
-
GameThread: ST Game 1, Twins v Rays, 2/24 @ 6:05pm CT
It's up on the scoreboard at 10:24 a.m.? That's going to be one long AB for Buxton.
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #1 Fernando Romero