Everything posted by Ryan Atkins
-
Article: Twins Trade Pieces Not That Valuable
All great points. I don't understand the zeal for trading Brian Dozier. As others have pointed out, there isn't much of a void at 2B across the league right now so demand is low and return would likely be disappointing. Dodgers wouldn't budge, in part, because they weren't competing with anyone else for Dozier. Meanwhile, I too don't believe there is a logjam at 2B in the Twins organization either--certainly not yet. There does seem to be a budding logjam in the OF with the emergence of Granite. It could be argued that we now have 4 everyday OF for 3 positions: Buxton, Rosario, Kepler, and Granite. It will be interesting to see how that shakes out.
-
Don't look now
Yes! This team is a contender (at least as much as any other just-over-500-team) and has two ways into the postseason. Half game out in the Central and half game out of Wildcard. But the 1 game WC is really not much of a post-season if you lose that one game. I would love to see them take the division.
-
Article: Twins 4, Yankees 2: Pitching, Defense, Timely Hitting Lead to Victory
I don't think it would have been overturned, but it seemed worth the challenge being that it was a crucial run and already late in the game. When you challenge, does anyone know if you can you specifically ask that they look at whether the catcher was blocking the plate? I think that would be the only reason to overturn as I didn't see compelling evidence that the tag was not applied.
-
Interesting stat on Buxton
Then someone better tell Mr. Byron Buxton to change his approach and aim for the sky... “My approach is just try to hit a hard groundball to second base,” Buxton said before batting practice Thursday. “That helps me keep my hands through the ball and helps me see the ball a little bit longer.” -- June, 2016 “[The goal is] putting the ball in play more,” Buxton said. “Putting it on the ground more to get it out of the air." -- June, 2017 So, he's known for at least 2 years now that he is better off focusing on keeping the ball out of the air until he learns how to consistently get on top of the ball and drive it (and we know he can do this as evidenced by occasional flashes of power). My choice of words was poor, but this is what I meant and what Buxton has been aware of at least since last summer.
-
Interesting stat on Buxton
I can't see much value in the IFFB% statistic. Who does it help to know this info? It won't help Buxton--he already knows he's supposed to hit the ball on the ground. It doesn't help the opposition as far as positioning fielders. It's not useful for evaluating a player that is already at the MLB level and will stay there as long as he continues to play superior defense and hit .200 or better. It doesn't distinguish between line drives (good) and pop-ups (bad). It's interesting and I enjoyed reading this thread, I just don't think Joe Maddon, Paul Molitor, or anyone else in the dugout spends anytime thinking about it. If they are pondering putting a Hit-and-Run play on, it might be mildly valuable to know this number to avoid being doubled up, but I image they are far more concerned with simply knowing how often the hitter makes contact (of any kind).
-
Possible Trade Partners for Dozier
Also, for whatever reason, the Twins historically have not conducted many trades with the Texas rangers. Only 7 trades in their history (not including any Washington Senator non-sense). Maybe that will change under new regime since they have ties to the Rangers. The last time the Twins made a trade with Texas was when they brought back Eddie Guardado in exchange for a Hamburger.
- Article: Twins 20, Mariners 7: Twins Set Franchise Record With 28 Hits
-
Possible Trade Partners for Dozier
Agree. I live in the DFW area and even though I follow the Twins more than the Rangers, all the sports talk is about the Rangers (well, actually it is 95% Cowboys even in the summer). Nevertheless, I can attest that the Rangers main problem right now is pitching and I can all but guarantee they would not give one thought to trading a high-ranked pitching prospect for Dozier or any other middle tier non-pitcher vet.
-
MLB.TV
I've been a MLB.TV subscriber for years now and watch the games on my Roku streaming device. The quality if terrific (wasn't always that way). The gotcha to look out for is the blackout restrictions. Being a Twins fan living in Texas works out great for me as I can watch nearly all the Twins games Live except when they are playing either the Rangers or the Astros (which is ridiculous as I'm nearly 5 hours from Houston). To a cord cutter like me it's a great deal for just a little over $100 per year as I have no Cable TV or Satellite contract on top of that. The other major gotcha is the post-season exclusive contracts. For example, when the playoffs are on TBS, you can ONLY watch them on TBS. Fortunately, this has been solved in the last couple years with services such as Sling TV.
-
Twins TV analyst
I voted for Jack! He "tells it like it is" more than any of the others and I enjoy that honesty and it meshes well with Dick's homerism. I will say that I was very impressed with and thoroughly enjoyed listening to LaTroy Hawkins in his first go-around. I just have not heard enough of him yet to rank him 1st, but he may be headed there. I also like how they mix in these guys and give us a break from Bert, who is enjoyable all the same. It must be a bit of a challenge for Dick Bremer to adjust to the rotating color man, but he is a pro and does a brilliant job IMHO. Now, how about another poll/thread on favorite side-line reporter? My favorite is Marney Gellner, but Audra and Gorg do a good job too.
-
Article: Key Twins Quarter-Mark Questions
The Twins have been equally poor at home. They need to learn how to win at home. It should be an advantage, not a liability. If their road domination were to continue, they would only need to play .500 at home to have a good chance at the post season. And most importantly, I agree, beat your central division foes.
-
Park or Polka... Pick your Poison... Vargas should be DFAd... asaP
I agree with this, see no reason to drop Vargas at this point in the season. However, if Vargas went down or out, I would be more inclined to promote Matt Hague than either Park or Palka. He had a really good spring and is doing well at Rochester. And he can fill in at 1B or 3B, so if a trade of Escobar materialized, you would still have a 3B backup.
-
Article: Backup Backstop Battle Royal?
I would like to see them wait a bit longer. Maybe if they were to trade Escobar, then it could make sense to bring up Murphy as a 3rd catcher. But if we're starting to characterize a .232 BA at AAA as a "strong start", then it suggests he can't do much better than that. And those numbers probably drop at the big league level (down to say Castro/Giminez level). Either way, this seems a low impact decision whichever way they go. In unrelated news: Chris Herrmann (.185) hit a walk-off HR for the D-backs a couple nights ago. Folks, there just aren't many Buster Posey's out there. The 7th top hitting catcher in MLB is hitting a whopping .214
-
Article: Five Takeaways From A Fun First Week
Many great posts here already. My takeaways are: 1. Defense. Aside from the blown rundown of the busted squeeze play the other day, the D has been outstanding. 2. The strong early play from Jason Castro, Miguel Sano, and Jorge Polanco. So important when you have the likes of Buxton, Dozier, and Mauer starting slowly. 3. Pitching. The key to any team's success. Santana has lived up to being out #1. I was impressed with Hughes. Underwhelmed be Gibson and Santiago, but they did OK. Mejia, we'll see, deserves a few more starts. Bullpen is strong and I think that can continue if they don't get overworked (i.e., starters continue to do well).
- Article: Five Takeaways From A Fun First Week
-
Article: 2017 Twins Player Predictions: Eddie Rosario
I think we would all be thrilled with that. I also hope he improves on his 50% career success rate on attempted steals. It would be great if at least one of Rosario/Buxton/Sano had a major breakout season.
-
Article: 2017 Twins Player Predictions: Brian Dozier
I think your prediction is spot on and has a very good chance at realization. My hope is that his overall hitting continues to improve slightly while the HRs drop just a bit. I'll go with: .270 BA, 28 HR, 88 RBI, 25 SB, 102 R I would like to see him steal more bases. With Molitor as MGR, I have been surprised by how poorly this team runs the bases. It is perhaps a skill you just can't teach. But Dozier (83% over the last 2 years) has been good, just not frequent enough. Dozier leading off with Mauer or Grossman (both of whom can work a count) batting 2nd should allow for a few more SBs.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Batting Order Time!
Oops. That sample wasn't a subset, it was for the entire 2016 season. The same stat across Dozier's entire career is even more telling: 42.6% of his ABs came when batting in the 1st position 53.2% of his RBIs came when batting in the 1st position So for the tiny subset of Dozier's entire career, he has been more productive hitting lead off than anywhere else in the lineup.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Batting Order Time!
I would suggest that if Miguel Cabrera played for the Twins, he would still be batting #3 and Dozier would still be batting #1. Dozier and Kinsler are very similar players. The problem is that we don't have a Miguel Cabrera The % of Dozier's RBIs while in the lead off position should be far less that the % of Dozier's ABs while in the lead off position if it were always true that RBIs came easier from a lower batting position. But alas... 49.7 % of ABs came from Batting 1st 49.5 % of RBIs came from Batting 1st Now, I am sure that is an anomaly of sorts. And it is true, in general, that you have more RBIs batting 3rd or 4th than you do batting 1st. But maybe there is actually a dependency on the human player and the others on the team as far as where each fits in relative to the others. All we can really do is put our trust in Paul Molitor since he will be setting the lineup. And it wouldn't surprise me if he has Dozier leading off in game #1.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Batting Order Time!
I agree it is not ideal to have Dozier as a lead off hitter, I just think in his current situation with this team, it is the best option right now--that could always change. But I love the idea of hitting Buxton 3rd and hope that will really launch his career. Keep in mind that over the course of a season, the lead off hitter will also have more plate appearances than any other batting order position. Sano - 8 HR with men on base in 2016, mainly hitting 3rd or 4th Dozier - 12 HR with men on base in 2016, mainly hitting 1st
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Batting Order Time!
I am comfortable having Dozier lead off and he is obviously most comfortable there as well. There IS a statistical trend with Dozier. The trend is that for 5 consecutive years (his whole career), he has increased his H, HR, and RBI totals every year. So, why make him uncomfortable, just enjoy the ride. Just because you hit lead off doesn't mean you never hit with men on base. That is only guaranteed to happen once per game. Similarly, just because you are not leading off doesn't guarantee that you will be hitting with men on base. 68% of Miguel Sano HR in 2016 were solo. 71 % of Brian Dozier HR in 2016 were solo. Really, not much difference there.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Squeeze Play
Rest assured that by June 1, the pitching staff will have been jostled numerous times due to injury or ineffectiveness. So, whoever happens to go north in April isn't terribly significant except for Mr. Rule 5 guy.
-
Article: Report From The Fort: Squeeze Play
I agree with the article. If it were up to me, I would go with Mejia for starter #5, return Haley, start Berrios in AAA, and add Duffey (long man) and Chargois to the Bullpen. Haley has been unimpressive, but if the brass insists on keeping him, then I would hide him in the bullpen and Chargois would be sent down.
-
Article: Twins Roster Projection 2017: Version 3.0
This strikes me as a rather "safe" roster, nothing unexpected. I like what I've seen from Matt Hague this Spring, but I don't think there is any hope for him save for an injury. I hope that management decides to take at least one gamble. And for me, that gamble would be to put Adalberto Mejia into the rotation for at least 5 starts.
-
Park
Its always interesting to see who gets a lot of playing time early in Spring. I think for guys like Park, Stubbs, and Shuck--they are going to see a lot playing time early on because I don't think any of those guys are necessarily expected to make the club, but they have probably all been promised a fair shot at it. If they do well early and sustain it deeper into Spring, they will earn a spot if someone else (e.g, Vargas, Grossman) falters or gets hurt.