Everything posted by Paul
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
I know how you feel
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
The non-snark crowd? Where do they hang out?
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Ben, you took issue with my "lace 'em up" jab. Sorry. Didn't mean to insult anyone. But if you want to find out about making bread you ask the baker. Not the bakery's accountant. And I don't consider this "outside of that psychology", but some players handle pressure/stress better than other players.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
I'm not sure what opinion you feel is bull. The aspect referred to in the comment you cited was the mental aspect. Do you believe applying your mind to baseball is bull? Do you believe all ML players handle stress/pressure the same? I agree with you about clutch as I've commented earlier in this thread. To save you any searching I'll paraphrase what I said earlier. I believe what people see as clutch is the ability to confront a high pressure situation without whithering. Without back down. Without backoff. However frequently or infrequently. While the competition whithers to a degree. What is mistakenly seen as "stepping up" is in reality "not stepping back" with the competition.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Thank you, jokin. I was thinkin the same thing... "A lot of opinions being thrown out in this thread with little understanding of the importance of this aspect." I'm thinkin I could pick out the guys that laced 'em up.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Brian, I know this is not my business but, why do you apologize to someone who attacks you? Your comment added to and furthered the discussion. There was absolutely nothing positive in his comment.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
"That's all well and good, but this isn't little league or high school baseball or whatever" I used to play with a guy who roomed with Bret Saberhagen in AAA. I recall a conversation we had where I asked him about the mental aspect of the game at that level. I was curious as all the witness I had borne indicated that the higher you go the greater the impact of the mental aspect. His opinion was at the ML level that's all there is. That's the one variable you work on to control. We're talkin bout focus, composure, poise (great word), control of emotion, work ethic, durability, etc. The handling of pressure situations and the attendant endocrinological (sorry bout this word but it's the only one that fits) issues most certainly falls under this heading. After all "this isn't little league or high school baseball or whatever". In the ML everybody throws hard and straight and can catch a ball, and runs fast and hits hard. Harnessing the mind separates one from competitors. So I guess in my final analysis most of "the top 1% of the top 1% of the top 1%" have the same human frailties as us lesser beings.
-
Attention Mauer Haters!
Rocketpig and Jokin, I'd like to offer my take on the "No guts. No glory." thing. I think it's a real thing. With real viewed results like jokin has seen. But the cause is misunderstood. And rocketpig is correct. This is no superhuman feat by guys like Jeter. What I see is the ability to confront the situation without whithering. And act. With no back down. With no backoff. This coupled with the slight whithering of other competitors, in high pressure situations, results in what is viewed "stepping up" rather than the reality of not stepping back.
-
Article: Mauer Elected and "Fans" Revolt
"He is not worth 23 million." To me, this statement statement is the epitome of the Maurer non-love. At best this statement is completely subjective and ignores the marketplace reality. I happen to think Ferraris are not worth 280 grand. And Harleys are not worth 25K. And softball bats are not worth $350. And $180 is too much for a baseball bat for my 11 yr old grandson. And gas is not worth $3.30. But in the end I buy some of this stuff. Begrudgingly, but with an understanding of the market reality.
-
Brian Dozier Is Not Ready
This is my case: The minors obviously exist for a reason. The gradient aproach works great for any kind of education. But students successfully skipping grades is not unheard of either. To oversimplify, in baseball the higher the grade the faster the game is. Also the higher you go the greater the weight psychology has in the equation of success. Sometimes what a viewer sees as a "beating" is just part of the process. Sometimes the fact that "we aren't seeing progress" doesn't mean it's not occurring. Gardenhire has the final say in this kids education. And just maybe he knows what he's doing. (Somehow he's convinced a lot of people he does.) He determines where the kid is going to play. He's there observing every day. He sees what you and I see on the field. And a whole lot more in the dugout, in practice, in the clubhouse, and on the road, that we don't see, but nevertheless informs him. I don't know but, perhaps he feels the speed of the game is not the issue. Maybe some kids need more of a "beating" than others to feel they belong. Maybe Gardy feels the "beating" is not something he can even get in AAA. Whatever Gardenhire feels, rest assured he has talked to Brian. And Brian knows the program.
-
Nick Blackburn and Sunk Costs
Thank you Brian. As to your critique of the "nasty attack side of this thread", I enjoyed it, and the concept of giving diamonds to ducks springs to mind for some reason.
-
PioneerPlanet.com Article Dredges Up Mind-Melting Gardy Chestnuts
C'mon Brian, that never happens on the internet.
-
Nick Blackburn and Sunk Costs
I know a little about pitching. I hope this helps. The sinker that is Blackburn's bread and butter is a real finesse pitch. I believe the Twins staff, me, and plenty of others, were enamored with Blackburn because of his fleeting mastery of the pitch. And the belief that his simple mechanics put the unfleeting mastery of the pitch within his grasp. I have to admit that I haven't watched much of the Twins the past year so I really don't have an opinion on what's wrong now. I do know that the sinker must be mixed with at least 1 other pitch, and a SP needs to be able to change speeds. Because it tips the pitch, ML pitchers rarely succeed with different arm slots for different pitches. Unfortunately different arm slots work best for different pitches, so finding a slot that works best for the mix is challenging. Arm/shoulder/elbow pain can put a pitcher at odds with his body and render a particular pitch ineffective. If a sinker don't sink, or a cutter don't cut, or a slider don't slide, you ain't exactly helping out. Finally, you can hang a sinker just like a curveball, so if you aren't commanding whatever you're throwing you won't succeed. Blackburn could have 1 or all of these maladies, I don't know because I haven't seen him. But one thing's for certain, he's not carrying his end right now.
-
Nishioka
Perhaps someone who compares a SS offensive stats with a backup catcher's should not be considered credible. I wonder if Gardy would "take him back in a heartbeat"?
-
Nishioka
For Hardy's entire career, save 09 when the Brewers dicked him around and 10 when he was battling an injured wrist, he has been well above average ON BOTH SIDES OF THE BALL.
-
Article: Patience Probable with Prep Picks
You're welcome and deserving!
-
Article: Patience Probable with Prep Picks
MWLFan, Seth and Riverbrian, I think this is a first. I can't remember reading 4 posts in a row on this site that had this level of intelligence and insightfulness rather than emotion and incitefulness. Thank you.
-
Nishioka
I take solace from only one aspect of the whole Nishioka / Hardy swap. And that is that the lessons Gardenhire learned will stick. I don't know the problem between Gardy and Hardy, I can only speculate, which I've done plenty on this site in other postings. But, can you imagine the frustration Gardy felt, and the aging it caused him, when he had to watch that kid stumble around 2B until he broke his leg? And then, because of the investment, be convinced SS might work better because he couldn't avoid the runner as a 2B. And then have to watch that kid stumble around at SS, the place your leader on D plays. Remember the Pavano emotional display in the dugout? You think he was the only player that felt that? No, that was a rough clubhouse last year. So anyway, I take a little solace in the fact that, because of the magnitude of the pain, the lessons will not be forgotten. I just hope the aging on him doesn't cause him to wanna be shut of this place.
-
Article: Liriano Rediscovers the Slider
Another nice job Parker. It's hard to weigh the worth to the team in keeping Frankie vs flipping him. I'm at about 51% on my mental scale that he should be kept. For 2 reasons: 1. Pitchers, even stupid pitchers, get wiser about their job as they get older. And pitchers can stay in the game until their stuff erodes and no one wants to pay them anymore. Frankie's stuff is great. 2. There's SO much potential.
-
Article: Where Did Plouffe's Power Come From?
Parker, nice job. Great article. Great analysis. I know I'm preaching to the choir here, and you know this as well as I. There're plenty of successful batters with all kinds of hitches, glitches, faults and various weirdnesses in their swing. There's such a fine line between success and failure at hitting ML pitching and so many factors that come into play. Probably first and foremost would be the batters comfort level. Especially with Plouffe. Look back to when he first came up. He was a mental wreck. He lost the position he owned his whole life because he couldn't throw straight. That's nerves. I agree with all the improvements you noted. But the big thing with this kid is he hit a few bombs and now he BELIEVES he belongs. He found a comfort level that works for him. He's seeing the ball well. He's gaging the zone well. Now he's got confidence. Personally, I'd like to see him push Dozier to 2B.
-
Dan Gladden haters
Dad, is that you? Kidding aside...well put.
-
Dan Gladden haters
I don't think we disagree that much. I should've been clearer in my post. I was trying to make a distinction between the way Souhan and Gladden may be viewed. I don't necessarily think Gladden is a saintly and kind soul. He may be, I don't know. But he does know baseball and adds a lot ,for me, to the broadcast. Souhan...not so much. I'd like to add that not everyone hits the wall that Souhan has his nose against, the brightest realize the sheer volume of finer points there are on any subject and are normally humbled by that.
-
Dan Gladden haters
I dislike Souhan because he's smug and arrogant with no justification. It may seem to some that Gladden is also smug and arrogant but, there's an important distinction to be made. Gladden has walked the walk. There's a concept I've seen refered to as the "arrogance of ignorance". It's that point in anything some rookies reach where they believe they are now expert, though they are light years away from understanding the subtleties. You see them on most job sites and places of employment. Souhan seems firmly entrenched at this point concerning baseball. Gladden probably passed this point when he was 18 or 20. To me, Gadden adds tremendous value to the broadcast. I like him a lot.
-
Trevor Plouffe comparable . . . ?
Exactly. I'd add that his throwing problems were probably mental rather than what appeared as mechanical. You don't spend your career at SS and suddenly forget how to throw. I'll further add that if the Twins make him available he would be attractive to a team that is looking for a SS solution.
-
Jim Souhan Haters
I'm reminded of an older movie. I forget the title, but it has Robert Redford and Michell Pfiefer. Redford plays a TV producer for the nightly news. Pfiefer is an up and coming news reporter who is treated dismissively on air by the news anchor. She is upset and complaining to Redford, who has a confused look on his face, about what a dickhead the guy is. Redford's confused look fades as he realizes what she doesn't understand. He says something to the effect of " He's an anchorman."