Everything posted by prouster
-
Minnesota’s Return for Berrios Continues to Look Better
This is factually incorrect. Pro scouts and MLB front offices use age+level as a factor in their decision making all the time, whether it’s the draft, trades, or roster management. It’s not the only factor obviously, and it’s not as simple as “this guy is only 18 and is playing against 21 year olds, therefore he’s impressive.” If a prospect is younger than the competition and he’s performing well, then that means he has advanced skills and is therefore a real prospect. It’s also a factor because younger guys are more projectable. Especially at the lower levels, they usually aren’t done maturing. So if someone is hitting homers as a lanky 19 year old in A ball, it’s easy to imagine him mashing in the Majors. As far as guys in their early 20s in the high minors, that’s actually a sign that their organization views them highly. It’s also a sign that they are legit, because most guys their age are still in college. 21 year old pitcher in AAA vs 21 year old in the SEC? I know who I think has a better shot at impacting the MLB team. There’s a reason why people lose their minds when someone like Juan Soto cracks the big league roster. The filler guys in the high minors are never in their early 20s. That just doesn’t happen. Here’s an article that lays out some of this stuff. It’s kinda old at this point, but still interesting and informative. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/for-prospects-age-can-be-more-than-just-a-number/
-
Celestino
FWIW, my defense of Celestino is just that I think he’s a pretty good ball player who fills a need on the roster. He and Gordon have shown about the same offensively, but Celestino’s defense is pretty clearly better. Plus he’s three years younger . He’s never gonna be an elite player, but I think he does the job he’s asked to do quite well.
-
Celestino
Celestino has so far put up a 103 ops+. Not world beating by any means, but perfectly fine for a fourth outfielder who plays very good defense. I don’t understand why you send a guy like that to the minors.
-
Power Starters, Middle Relief Aces, oh my - how the Twins could manage their pitching
I don’t think this is true. They traded for Duran, Smeltzer, Alcala, and Ryan when they were still in the minors. They went out and got Gray (although I’m not sure how much credit they should get for “identifying” his talent, since any baseball fan could tell you he’s a good pitcher). They drafted Winder and Ober. The Rogers trade wasn’t exactly good, but I can see the logic of getting however many years of Paddack for a single season of Rogers. Pagan hasn’t done his part. Maybe they overestimated his abilities. At any rate, it sure does seem they were trying to follow the Rays model to an extent, but with a Twins spin on it. Gray, Ryan, Paddack, and Ober are guys who can give you 5-6 good innings most times out. Bundy and Archer seem like they were brought in to go through the order twice without blowing it. I’m wondering if the plan was for one or both of them to pitch more “bulk bridge” innings along with Winder as the season went. They fit the profile described in the article. Really, it has been injuries that have screwed things up. Other than Smeltzer, Bundy, and Archer, I think every pitcher I’ve named has spend time on the IL or Covid list.
- Guardians 5, Twins 3: We've Seen This Ending Before
- Guardians 7, Twins 6: Another Bullpen Meltdown in Extra Innings Loss
-
Managerial questions
He already used Jax and Duran in the 7th, 8th, and 9th in a tied ballgame. Moran threw two innings in the nightcap the day before, so he wasn’t available for the tenth. The options were Pagan, Thielbar, Thornburg, Duffey, and Cotten. Thielbar has an ERA over 5.00 and pitched in the morning game the day before. Thornburg is not exactly a trusted commodity. Duffey has been as bad or worse than Pagan. Cotten of course gave up the winning homer after Pagan set the table. I’m not saying Baldelli is Connie Mack or even Tom Kelly, but when these are your options…there are no good options.
-
Managerial questions
You’ve yet to name the small town paper or Wordpress site where we can read your trove of analysis. Maybe that will help others understand where you’re coming from.
-
Managerial questions
Your weird partisanship about Baldelli is annoying. I’d guess most people who post here are Baldelli agnostic. There’s a few, like yourself, who hyperbolize his ineptitude and assume everyone who disagrees is “pro” Rocco. Let’s have an interesting discussion, not a Facebook thread.
-
6 Hitters the Twins Could Target in the 2022 MLB Draft
I agree with you on pretty much all of this. Berry’s bat is enticing, but they’ve drafted numerous guys like him over the past few years. Cross would be unexciting to me—basically another Larnach but taken 15 or so spots higher. I would be okay with Susac, but agree his bat is a concern. Joey Bart is apparently a comp some scouts like, which to me isn’t in his favor. If Collier or Parada are there at 8, they’ve gotta run to the podium and take one of them. Ultimately I think it will be Neto, and I think that would be a really nice pick. He has some stuff to clean up with his hitting mechanics, but the hit tool is there, he can run, and the glove is legit. He’s maybe a little like Nick Gordon in that none of his tools are elite, but he does everything well. Unlike Gordon, he seems like a decent bet to stick at short and develop some real game power. Honestly he strikes me as a player the Dodgers would take.
-
Managerial questions
I haven’t looked into this specifically, but a superficial glance at league-wide IP leaders the other day showed that only about 12 or so pitchers (give or take a few) in all of MLB are averaging 6.0 innings per start or higher. It stands to reason that starters are throwing fewer pitches as well, and that it’s not limited to one or even half the teams.
-
Guardians 3, Twins 2: Pagán Melts Down Again as Smeltzer Gem is Wasted
Here it is. The secret formula.
-
Guardians 3, Twins 2: Pagán Melts Down Again as Smeltzer Gem is Wasted
I’m guessing this will start happening more often.
-
Guardians 3, Twins 2: Pagán Melts Down Again as Smeltzer Gem is Wasted
The “fire Rocco” stuff is gonna be all over this website every time they lose until he’s no longer the manager, isn’t it? The fact of the matter is that players are paid to be effective. The one person with by far the most control over Pagan’s performance is Pagan himself. This is Major League Baseball. There’s no blaming the coach when you fail. As for Baldelli, who is also the main factor in his own performance, I think it’s perfectly defensible not to use Duran in that situation. If he goes two innings, he may not be available for the rest of the series. If he only pitches the 8th, then it’s probably Pagan in the ninth and neither are available for the nightcap. I’m sure it feels good to call for Baldelli’s head every single time they lose a game.
-
Chris Archer, Iron Man?
Bob Feller is our measuring stick for a backend starter now? Tough crowd.
-
Is this team in free fall?
Agreed. Going through some adversity could help them later in the season when the pressure ramps up, too.
- Twins 6, Rockies 3: Buxton Falls HR Short of Cycle in Series Win over Rockies
- Twins 1, Guardians 0: Devin Smeltzer Throws 6 Shutout Innings and the Bullpen Holds on
-
Guardians 6, Twins 5: Twins Drop Winnable Opener to Guardians
Correa came up with the winning run on second base and nobody out. You have your 3, 4, and 5 hitters in line to drive that run in. By letting him swing, your giving the team three chances to drive the run in instead of two. I just don’t think it’s good baseball to have your three hole hitter bunt, especially when the winning run is looking at him across the diamond.
- Guardians 6, Twins 5: Twins Drop Winnable Opener to Guardians
- Guardians 6, Twins 5: Twins Drop Winnable Opener to Guardians
- Guardians 6, Twins 5: Twins Drop Winnable Opener to Guardians
-
Minnesota Twins 2014 Draft Retrospective: Swings and Misses
This is a good retrospective. I recall the Twins being tied to Turner for a while. Boy would that have been nice. I wasn’t excited about him as a prospect. Was I wrong. At the time I wanted them to take Nola. Those first few rounds were a bit perplexing. I believe that was during their run of drafting relievers with the idea of converting them into starters.
-
Rocco Baldelli's mindset on close games is annoying
I don't necessarily disagree, although I think there's some pretty sound logic to Rocco's thinking. Regardless, this is Major League Baseball. If a guy is asked to pitch, it's his job and his job only to get outs. Talent isn't an excuse when you're on the 26 man roster. You're there to get the job done.
-
Would you Trade Correa this year?
Haha. Well, the Yankees won a couple, too. There was also that whole course thing, if I recall.