Everything posted by jimmer
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
My FIP argument doesn't change by using Pino and Swarzak. It's the same argument, just to different levels A 4.30 FIP isn't horrible. It means his ERA, based on what he did, should have been 4.30, but due to really poor defense, his ERA ballooned over 5.00. RA Dickey's FIP was 4.32, yet his ERA was 3.71. No one talks about how horrific he was. Shelby Miller was a key component in a good size trade this offseason, his ERA was 3.74, but his FIP was 4.54. Alfredo Simon, FIP of 4.33, ERA of 3.44, gets praise from most. All pitchers need quality defense. Like I said, he wasn't good for sure, but it's exaggerated as to how bad he, himself, was due to his horrible ERA. Our rotation was pretty close to average in WAR, but due to such a bad defense, our rotation ERA was a full run over the rotation FIP. Also, the injury needs to be taken into account. Nolasco definitely should have revealed it earlier, but it certainly contributed to his poor performance. I like that Nolasco had such a good September (except the dbacks game). He does need to improve though.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
If we look at Nolasco's FIP (4.30) instead of ERA, we see he wasn't as bad as many seem to think, though not as good as some thought he might be. He just needs a good defense which is something we didn't have and likely won't have this year either, since it hasn't really been addressed in a positive way this offseason as of yet. Additionally, Hughes was even better than many think.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
Jim Pohlad's own words leads one to believe Ryan has serious job security. Perhaps his own words and actions are misleading, but he's given that impression. From an article on ESPN 1500, September 29th 2014, ' After that press conference to announce the contract extension, Twins owner Jim Pohlad said that as long as Ryan would like to be the team's general manager, the job will be his.He has the keys for life.' Ryan said he appreciated the words but wouldn't hold Pohlad to it. Glunn, a moderator here I believe, made a whole post about that interview and said he found that quote interesting:http://twinsdaily.com/topic/15098-interesting-interview-with-terry-ryan/ And as far as the phrase man up, it's a commonly used phrase. Maybe 'own up' is better. Step up might be even better. Pretty much the same thing. And I will say, once again, I'm not saying he should be fired, like some have said. Some have said he doesn't deserve to stay GM, but I'm not one of them I think it's a good thing he has admitted he has some fault in the problems. I stand by the idea that when you know you aren't getting fired, that the owner has basically decided to follow your lead, it is much easier to admit mistakes.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
That's a good question. If I was one of the people maddened by it, I might have an answer. Doesn't change the fact it's easier to man up when you have the kind of job security he has.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
Media hasn't turned on Hoyer cause they hardly acknowledge he has the GM position. They look to Epstein who is new to the organization and has won a couple W Series, the first breaking the media created 'curse'. They likely give him the benefit of the doubt, not unreasonably. It likely has a shelf-life though. In any event, I NEVER SAID he doesn't deserve to stay GM.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
Even accounting for misinterpretation of my post, which I don't really get since it makes assumptions on my reasoning for not thinking Ryan should keep his job (something I've never said) by saying things like , 'And if you're going to say "no, he was here under Bill Smith" then ... ugh. And if you're going to say "He left the cupboard bare for Smith" relook at the cupboard first.' Those assumptions would be based on practically no posting history on this site as to wear I stand on Ryan. No matter what, it certainly didn't warrant the kind of response I got from gunnarthur in his second part of his post. Additionally, even with your belief that Ryan may have acted differently if in another market, that's no quarantee those moves work giving him deserved extreme job security he currently has. On top of that, it still doesn't change my actual point, that job security would likely not be so secure in a bigger more scrutinized market if losing like we have been was occuring. Your argument seems to be just be about how he would do different things in a bigger market, the team therefore would be better, and that he'd still have as strong of job security as he has here. I doubt that's true and even if it was, the job security comment I had also referred to ownership being pressured by big market media because of losing. Easier to have job security when winning.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
It has to do with pressure from local media types (media markets) that put pressure on teams by way of asking hard questions and writing critical articles for public consumption that can make owners make decisions in personnel they may not feel need to be made to calm the negative publicity. And that's just local reporters. There are markets that get much more national attention as well that might play to the fans displeasure of a losing team more to put pressure on a team. Twins don't usually get that kind of press locally and certainly not nationally. Minnesota reporters are a pretty softball-tossing bunch, with few exceptions and even the critical ones aren't normally overly so, even with all the recent losing. So having that kind of media market to deal with compared to many others, an owner is more likely to stick with someone they believe is up to the task because they aren't always getting slammed by reporter after reporter.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
Was there somewhere in my post that suggested he didn't DESERVE the job security he has? Or did I just point out that when you have job security like that it is much easier to take the blame?
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
I doubt Amaro has the same job security. Just cause he hasn't been fired YET, there has still been rumblings. On top of that, in his 6 year reign, they've only been bad twice and haven't lost 90 or more once.
-
Terry Ryan on Souhan Unfiltered
It's probably easier to take responsibility when you have job security like he does. Job security he likely wouldn't have in any market that stressed winning.
-
Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot
People like to compare Raines to Rickey, but there's another person who might be a better fit for comparison. Raines finished his career with a .385 OBP, a .425 SLG and a 123 OPS+ in 10,359 PA Gwynn finished his career with a .388 OBP, a 459 SLG and a 132 OPS+ in 10,232 PA Raines scored 1,571 runs and drove in 980 Gwynn scored 1,383 runs and drove in 1,138 Raines stole 808 bases and was caught 146 times Gwynn stole 319 bases and was caught 125 times B-ref WAR has Raines at 66.2, good for 97th all-time. It has Gwynn at 65.3 wins, 102nd place all-time. the one real difference between him and Raines was hits. Raines had 2,605 hits and Gwynn had 3,141. That’s a difference of 536. However, Raines had 1,330 walks to Gwynn’s 790, a difference of 540.
-
2015 MLB Hall of Fame Results
Stark just did a very good article about Delgado called ‘Delgado deserves an apology’. He's talking about how he was booted off the ballot after only one time being on it. It’s a good read. Some good parts: ‘He showed up on the ballot with his 473 homers and .929 career OPS.’ He ‘Hit 30-plus home runs 10 years in a row’. By comparison, ‘Only seven other eligible players in history have even had nine (or more) 30-homer seasons in a row. Four of them — Jimmie Foxx, Lou Gehrig, Mike Schmidt and Eddie Matthews — are in the Hall of Fame.’ The other three are Bonds, Sosa and Palmeiro. ‘Only nine other eligible players have ever had an OPS of .900 or better in at least nine consecutive seasons in which they qualified for the batting title. Seven are in the Hall: Gehrig, Foxx, Schmidt, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Stan Musial and Mickey Mantle.’ The other two are Bonds and Piazza. Then he compares the careers of Ortiz and Delgado and Delgado grades out about even. Now, Ortiz has the playoff stuff and that should count as Stark says, but it should also matter that Delgado played a position his whole career.
-
Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot
Well, he was better than Tommy John and Kaat. Those two are comparable to each other, with John beinga little better and Mussina being quite a bit better than both. Problem is when you let lesser pitchers in, some even first ballot, it makes it harder to say a guy like Mussina shouldn't be in. That's what has happened. Mussina's biggest problem is that he was never flashy, he just went about doing his job professionally and didn't push for the spotlight, but he was as good as Smoltz if not better, better than Glavine and better than many others that are in.
-
The Hall of Fame Ballot / big Hall-small Hall / Hall is broken-unbroken / WAR stinks-doesn't stink / BBWAA stinks-doesn't stink thread
Raines' biggest problem is being compared to Henderson so often. I think that should be a point in his favor, not the other way around. I mean if you're good enough to have that comparison, that's awesome. A similar situation will likely occur again soon, because Hoffman may go through the same thing because of comparisons to Rivera.
-
The Hall of Fame Ballot / big Hall-small Hall / Hall is broken-unbroken / WAR stinks-doesn't stink / BBWAA stinks-doesn't stink thread
Bert's numbers went up because people got smarter about baseball and as people learn (if they are open to learning) minds can be changed, For some reason, he doesn't want to acknowledge that is the reason, but if it wasn't for the SABR people he and so many seem to despise, including him, he wouldn't have made it.
- Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot
-
Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot
I agree with most of that. Not the dominance part in regards to Morris, or Oliva being deserving, but overall I agree we want it to be the Hall of Fame. Problem is, everyone has their view on where the line of very good and great meet. Mussina, IMO, belongs. I don't even care about the Wins/Loss stat for pitcher, so, for me, it has nothing at all to do with that.
-
Article: TD Mailbag: Mauer's Future and Prospect Timelines
Mauer had an off year for sure, but his OBP is normally very high and the last thing you want is that kind of OBP buried down in the lineup. The guys that get on base the most should be the ones that have the most plate appearances. Not only that, but he normally hits very well with RISP. And the idea that he hits into way too many double plays, well that's not really true based on amount of opportunities he comes to the plate in those situations. Nor is it a lot based on overall times batting into a DP.
- Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot
- Article: Sorting Through the 2015 HOF Ballot