Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

dbminn

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dbminn

  1. Dozier is 3rd in Fangraphs WAR from 2014 to 2016. Only Kinsler and Altuve are ahead of him. Considering age and recent performance, I wouldn't trade Dozier for any on the list except Altuve. Cano and Kinsler are excellent but will be 33 and 34 yrs old for the 2017 season.
  2. Thanks for putting up the blueprint, Brandon. I won't quibble with Castro and Gomez, although I don't think Gomez is going to be had on a one-year contract. There are a couple of changes I would make: Trade Dozier as long as the return reflects a cheap player in his prime that has outperformed the league the last three years (13.9 fWAR total).Trade Ervin if the return is above value.Key positions in return would be young SS, SP and RP in order of priority. No need to rush Gordon. There's no problem if he develops quicker than expected. It will be easy to trade from an excess of shortstops. I have no problem if Dozier is traded and the primary return is a SP. They're close in priority. Lesser changes: The trade window has passed on Plouffe. Time to let him go.Keep Santiago but trade him if a real prospect can be had. That may seem outrageous but the free agent SP market is really thin.
  3. A lot of good comments re: development, pitching, big moves etc... Another way to emulate the WS teams is to improve the defense. The Cubs were the best defensive team in the majors this year. Cleveland was the best defensive team in the AL (9th overall).They graded out at 175 and 85 runs better than the Twins. Upgrading defense will immediately improve the team and give needed support to the pitching staff. At SS, the Cubs and Cleveland graded between 30 and 40 runs better than the Twins on defense. I'd like to see the Twins get a solid defensive SS to bridge the gap until Gordon arrives. (Trade Dozier, Polanco to 2nd base) In the OF, the Twins were -30 runs to Cleveland and -80 to the Cubs. In this case, improve the defense by subtraction. Grossman caused the most damage (-20 in 99 games). Release him and pick up a defensively competent 4th OF to fill the gap until the next prospect arrives. Otherwise, let the youngsters play. Finally, acquire a veteran defensive catcher. Garver, Centeno and Murphy can battle for the backup (or co-starter) spot to start the season.
  4. Fine article, Thrylos. I would disagree on only a few moves, mostly based on maximizing value. I wouldn't move Gibson at his point of lowest value. There is little risk to keeping him until at least mid-season, especially since you have opened 16(!) spots on the 40-man roster. Trading Santana would depend on a premium return. I think there is value to keeping a solid veteran pitcher while the youngsters develop. Vargas or Walker could be included in a trade package to improve the return. Same for Duffey or Mejia, if the trade package brought the Twins a high-ceiling starter.
  5. The Twins will start 2017 with an outfield that averages 23 years old. With Sano (23) and Polanco (22), the Twins have an incredibly young lineup. All have had at least some positive MLB experience. They need to be more consistent, which is a problem that will be solved with time. It's hard to say these five youngsters haven't quickly developed. There are only 39 MLB players 23 or younger with at least 100 PA this year and the Twins have four of them. All will be in the lineup next year with some games under their belts. That is not failure. Pitching? Yeah, been bad for years. Let's hope the new Pres/GM can improve development of the good young prospects already in the pipeline.
  6. His peak seven years were as a catcher, as is 90+% of his total WAR. Is that enough to define him as a catcher? I think so but others may agree with you.
  7. One method used to determine if a player is HOF-worthy is the "JAWS" system created by Jay Jaffe. It looks at both career WAR and 7-Year Peak WAR. There are 14 catchers in the HOF. Mauer is ranked 11th all-time in career bWAR and 5th all-time in 7-year peak bWAR. (JAWS uses Baseball Reference, not Fangraphs) By these numbers, Mauer should get into the Hall. Arguments against him include lack of championships, down years late in the career, and not playing in New York, LA or Boston. I'd vote for him.
  8. Sometimes a commenter's insight is exceeded by their grace. Nice comments, Jimbo
  9. Sano has responded to the demotion talk (my earlier comment included: "I wouldn't mind seeing him sent down"). His last few games have proven two things. Sano: Lost his focus for a while.Has the talent to respond in a couple of days.Please stay focused, Miguel
  10. Plouffe could have more value now than in the offseason. The Indians need some additional power and the Tigers need a full-time 3B. He should clear the other teams in the waiver process. There's no reason for a developing team to take him and the other contenders have 3B covered. (He could get "blocked", I guess) It's not likely this will all fit together but there is a chance. Hopefully, it works out for everyone - Plouffe moves to a contender. The Twins get both a low-level prospect and an open roster spot. I'd be willing to put Plouffe on the roster for a week to see if anyone bites. Send Vargas to AAA until something happens or September 1.
  11. RP - Chargois, Light (with a good August) SP - Wheeler, Mejia C - Garver (Murphy, if Garver to AZ) IF - Beresford, Park OF - Palka
  12. I don't watch much minor league ball. When I do watch, I like to see a compact, balanced swing. Wade has it. He's a long way from the majors but I wouldn't count him out. He could be a good one.
  13. Lack of an apostrophe can make a world of difference.
  14. I totally agree with you, spycake. I was a little clumsy with my words. This is a big issue, especially (I think) for the Twins system. TR stressed that he wanted the young Latin players to learn English. He never understood that cultural issues - especially discussing difficult topics - are a big deal. This thread started about Sano in particular. I still believe Sano has to work on his game. I don't think Molitor and Bruno were out of line in their particular comments - they've waited many months before making their thoughts public. It is frustrating to know that there might not be a mentor for Sano, with his background, available to talk about it.
  15. Totally agree. Maybe a long-term report during the offseason by the crack TD crew is in order.
  16. I've been irritated for years by the lack of Latin-American mentors in the Twins system. That being said, it's hard to say the Twins have kept LA players down. They have been playing Centeno, Vargas, Polanco, Escobar, Sano and Rosario, with Santana and Rodriguez on the mound. Only Sano has had his work ethic called into question. Not every bump in the road is caused by management. Sano needs to work some things out and I think he will.
  17. It's great to see the prospects starting to reach their potential. I'm optimistic Sano will report a different player next year, partially because some of his peers have (temporarily) passed him by. There will still be some ups and downs, but the bottom has been left behind as far as hitting is concerned. Hopefully, the starting pitchers will start to catch up with the position players in the next year. At least they will have some options: Santana, Gibson, Berrios and Rodriguez likely make up the front four. Mejia, Duffey, Wheeler or May could be fifth to start the season. I wouldn't rule out Gonsalves after the all-star break. I don't think the pitching outlook is as bleak as most think. Of course, a big trade for a high-upside SP wouldn't hurt. The Twins have enough depth to trade position players from either the MLB club or the farm system. Along with pitching, I'd like to see them pick up a SS who plays excellent defense.
  18. Like many that have already posted: Let Plouffe rehab for the maximum stint. Plouffe on waivers. Maybe the Indians will bite. He'd fit well on their bench as a part-time player/PH. Vargas sent down with assurances he'll be back 9/1, although Sano needs the remedial work more at this point.
  19. I'd be fine with sending Sano down for a couple of weeks. He's pressing both at the plate and in the field.He doesn't look mentally prepared.Polanco, Dozier and Vargas have earned their starting positions for now.AAA is exactly the place to work on getting his rhythm back. Take a look at Rosario and Vargas. Both went to Rochester and significantly improved their plate discipline. (Rosario still isn't walking a lot but his swing and contact rates are way better).It's not the end of the world to work through a few issues away from big league stadiums.Sano, IMO, is going to have a great career. He just needs to get his act together.
  20. I've said for the past year, the team will be good once the prospects figure it out. They're closer now and they're still young. There's depth at every position except C,SS and SP. If you don't want to enjoy the ups and downs with this team from here on out, it's your problem.
  21. True, spycake. Having Susac also gives the Brewers negotiating flexibility and leverage with any potential Lucroy trade partners right now. They don't look nearly as desperate, now that they have a mlb-ready C. They also don't need to get a C in return - should open up negotiations.
  22. Nice article, Thrylos. Pretty clear the Twins had drafts somewhere between bad and horrible in 2008, 2010 and 2011. (Rosario still has a chance to make the 2010 draft look a bit better). I don't think WAR is a good evaluator from 2012-present. By WAR, only 9% of the cumulative average value in Thrylos' chart has come from players drafted beginning in 2012. The Twins will soon have five players from the 2012 draft on their roster (Chargois being the last of the five). All have a chance to contribute in the coming years. We can't say either way at this point whether that draft was a failure.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.