Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

John Bonnes

Administrator
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by John Bonnes

  1. Hmm. This could be what the Twins have in mind if they try to save some money on that 4th overall pick. If the first three go Gray, Appel and Bryant & Twins can take one of any of the next college pitchers for a discount AND get Manea in the 2nd round, I'll be doing backflips.
  2. Fun read. Thanks for sharing. But how DARE you besmirch Ah-Ha.
  3. Rumors persist that the Twins might make a deal for less than slot with a lower ranked prospect to allow them to use that money on their second or third round pick. On it's face, and given the payroll cuts the Twins had this year, this made me a little nauseous. After crunching a few numbers, I'm wondering if it might not make sense. The slot for the 4th overall pick is slotted at $4.5M. Their 2nd pick (43rd overall) is slotted at $1.3M. Together, that's $5.8M. If the Twins offered 5th overall pick money (instead of 4th overall money) to several of the players (everyone except Appel, Gray and Bryant) they would save $750,000. If that was added to the money for the 43rd overall pick, it would be like having money for the 20th overall pick. Similarly, if the Twins talk down the money paid to the 4th overall player, here's the "slot" that their 43rd overall pick improves to: 1. If they offer #5 money, they can improve from 43rd to 20th. 2. If they offer #6 money, they can improve from 43rd to 16th. 3. If they offer #7 money, they can improve from 43rd to 14th. 4. If they offer #8 money, they can improve from 43rd to 13th. 5. #9 => improves 43 to #12 6. #10 => improves 43 to #11. They way this would likely work is something like this, I think.... 1) someone with high contract demands falls past the slot where they're happy being taken. So a player who wanted top 20 money (~$2M) ends up falling out of the top 20 and has made it clear that if he doesn't get $2M, he's going to (or back to) college. But when the Twins come up at #43, they can offer that $2M even though that's way over slot, because they saved money by paying the #4 guy the amount given to the #5 guy. 2) Someone is not ranked as high as they think they'll eventually be. A players is told they will likely only get drafted in the 2nd round, but they want 1st round money, so they're already committed to college. But the Twins approach that player and make sure that if they offer $2M (mid 1st round money) that player will sign. Then, when it's the Twins turn, they choose that player in the 2nd round, but give them 1st round money. I think what encourages me the most is that there is so much extra money between the 4th and 5th pick: ~$750k. If they are neutral between Frazier and Meadows, or Manea and Stanek or Stewart, it makes a ton of sense to go through and offer them #5 money and take the additional leverage they gain with that 43rd overall pick. What does NOT make sense, IMHO, is taking a guy out of the top 10. That might get them even more money, but the incremental savings between #5 and #9 is also about $750K. I don't know that additional money is going to be able to make much difference in who they get with that 43rd (or 78th) pick. What do you guys think?
  4. Agree. We can't have it both ways. We can't enter the season and, based on the roster, say this is a 7-win team, and then when they're on pace for 71 wins, say "We need to make a change at manager."
  5. By itself, I'll be happy with those names except McGuire or Moran. I would NOT be shocked if this board is goin ballistic the day after the first round as the Twins save money on that pick in the hope of padding later picks. I wonder what thy would need to get in later rounds to justify it in our minds.
  6. Please, lord, keep these boys healthy. I don't ask for much. But please keep them healthy.
  7. It comes down to this: it's just plain laziness to copy and past instead of summarize it. It takes about two minutes to summarize and 10 seconds to copy and paste. Here, time me.... - The Twins progress can be seen in their minors and to some extent in the majors, with the debuts of Hicks and Arcia. - Miguel Sano is not only hitting like Miguel Cabrera, but he's also concentrating on other aspects of a big league lifestyle, like learning English, including forcing himself to do interviews in his non-native language. - Meanwhile, the Twins have a second high-upside guy in Buxton, who is not only impressing with his skills, but with his work ethic. "He has treated this like his profession,” said Rob Antony. - And don't over look Kyle Gibson. Final quote....
  8. Twins Twerp, I appreciate the feedback. We get feedback on both sides of the equation - some really like that part and some want no part of it. It's kind of a balancing act for now. I don't really know a way around that. Thanks, John
  9. He just hasn't had any kind of sustained success. Holding AAA hitters to those numbers isn't particularly impressive. I see some bad starts, some great starts and a lot of mediocre starts. If he wasn't "former 1st rd pick Kyle Gibson" he wouldn't even be considered right now. I don't have any faith that Pelfrey or Hernandez couldn't match his numbers in AAA, so why would I believe he'll outperform them in the majors. Im not down on him long term. I just like to see people kicking butt before they are called to the majors. And until they do, I can only be so critical of spending more time in the minors.
  10. I don't have a problem with bringing up Gibson, I'm just neutral on it. Like I said, I'd be perfectly OK with moving Hernandez to the bullpen and I'd have Pelfrey on a very short leash. But I think the true long-term thinking is to promote him when you think he's ready, and that has nothing to do with the guys in front of him. And I don't think he's really shown he's ready. I don't see a point in rushing him just because he has an inning limit. And I don't see a point in rushing him if you aren't sure he's going to be better than what is currently here.
  11. Before I put this topic out here, I'd like to request that this be a positive thread. If you want to be critical or a writer, start your own thread. Who is your favorite local baseball writer? I'm asking for two reasons: 1) I'd be interested in which of the local writers is making an impression on most of our members and 2) I'm wondering if some fans of these writers would like to try and post links to their favorite stories in the forums as they appear. So I'd be interested in both - who is your favorite and why do you think others should read them?
  12. I'm a little baffled by the vehemence being expressed that Gibson needs to be in the rotation right now. It feels like it has more to do with frustration of Pelfrey, Hernandez, etc than belief in Gibson. I'm trying to come up with a line of reasoning for promoting Gibson that talks about Gibson, rather than trashes the current rotation. The best I can come up with is.. 1. He was very good two years ago and even pitched a little in AAA. 2. He hasn't been bad this year in AAA. 3. He'll likely be better in the future. 4. I'd like to see him. That's a pretty thin case on which to build much outrage. Am I missing something?
  13. Huh. I gotta say, I had overlooked this 27-year-old completely. And I don't mean this year. I mean every year. He's been pretty good for three years now - not the greatest strikeout rate, but he walks nobody and his ERA through 5 years in the minors is 2.56? But I don't know anything about the guy. Who is he?
  14. I can't get too worked up about not promoting Gibson - the "no scholarships" thing should apply to him, too. Let's be honest - he hasn't exactly been kicking the door down. One could make a case that Deduno (or even Walters) should be promoted ahead of him, if it's based strictly on performance. However, I'm officially intrigued by making Pedro Hernandez a left-handed reliever. His splits are astounding. The questions is which reliever do you send down for him. The obvious answer is Pressley, but he's a Rule 5 pick. Next on the list might be Roenicke, IMHO. One last point - I think Pelfrey's time is limited. The Twins often make changes between mid-May and the beginning of June each year. I won't be shocked if Pelfrey isn't on this team one way or the other by June 1. I'll be a little surprised if he is.
  15. A Beatles homage : "Come together, right now - over me."
  16. You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1720-Geeking-Out-Pitch-To-Contact-and-Team-Batting
  17. [ATTACH=CONFIG]4085[/ATTACH]Numbers can be so clean. Until they aren’t. Yesterday we studied strikeouts/game and runs/game for teams and found a “correlation coefficient,” which is a number between -1 and 1. 1 means there is a perfect correlation, like the temperature in Fahrenheit and the temperature in Celsius. -1 means there is a perfectly negative correlation, like the amount I spend and my checking account balance. And 0 means there is no correlation, like the amount I spend and the temperature in Celsius. Unfortunately, the number we found was not 1, 0 or -1. It was .54. So what does that mean? It means it is somewhere in between. Our number shows that strikeouts aren’t everything, but it also shows that they’re something. Can we find something comparable? We can if we look at a different set of correlations. The most obvious place to start is in another realm of baseball – hitting. If we do the same exercise – compare the runs per game a team scores to their basic stats for 150 recent teams, what kind of correlations do we see? (The full results are at the bottom. Also, here is a link to the data.) The strongest is what you might expect – OPS, which has a .96(!) correlation. In fact, it is this crazy high correlation that drives the interest in OPS. The stats which make up OPS – OBP and SLG – also have high correlations: .87 and .92, respectively. The most widely used traditional stats for evaluating offense fall a little lower down the list. Batting average is .76. Home runs are .70. I even worked out HR/AB and HR/PA and they ranked a little lower: .67 and .65. We still haven’t found the stats that have a correlation close to the .54 that K/9 has to runs given up by a pitching staff. The stats closest to that level are At-bats, Walks and Doubles, each of which has a correlation around .60. Converting the last one to a rate statistic, I find that Doubles/At-Bat has a correlation of .547, which is almost dead on. So we might want to evaluate pitchers by strikeouts about the same way we evaluate batters by doubles. For instance, given a choice between two players, one who hits a lot of doubles, and one who doesn’t, we probably want the guy with the doubles. We also might mention how many doubles a player has as a data point to demonstrate that they have extra power. Doubles are far from a worthless item to track. But here is probably what we wouldn’t do. We wouldn’t say a free agent is worthless because he ranked behind others in doubles. We probably wouldn’t comb through an organization’s minor league affiliates and suggest that their hitting philosophy is messed up because none of their teams are hitting a lot of doubles. And we wouldn’t suggest that a team scoring runs won’t be able to maintain their pace because they rank dead last in the league in doubles. The bottom line is that there isn’t a real clean break point here. Strikeouts are important. They might even be the most important stat we can easily evaluate for pitchers, due to a combination of impact and predictability (though we haven’t studied the latter). But it is exceptionally easy to get carried away with strikeouts, and I think most of the sabrmetric community has, including me. It may be time to step back and admit what we don’t know. And acknowledge that clean numbers aren’t always so clean.
  18. Numbers are so clean. Until they aren’t. Yesterday we studied strikeouts/game and runs/game for teams and found a “correlation coefficient,” which is a number between -1 and 1. 1 means there is a perfect correlation, like the temperature in Fahrenheit and the temperature in Celsius. -1 means there is a perfectly negative correlation, like the amount I spend and my checking account balance. And 0 means there is no correlation, like the amount I spend and the temperature in Celsius. Unfortunately, the number we found was not 1, 0 or -1. It was .54. So what does that mean?[PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] It means it is somewhere in between. Our number shows that strikeouts aren’t everything, but it also shows that they’re something. Can we find something comparable? We can if we look at a different set of correlations. The most obvious place to start is in another realm of baseball – hitting. If we do the same exercise – compare the runs per game a team scores to their basic stats for 150 recent teams, what kind of correlations do we see? (The full results are at the bottom. Also, here is a link to the data.) The strongest is what you might expect – OPS, which has a .96(!) correlation. In fact, it is this crazy high correlation that drives the interest in OPS. The stats which make up OPS – OBP and SLG – also have high correlations: .87 and .92, respectively. The most widely used traditional stats for evaluating offense fall a little lower down the list. Batting average is .76. Home runs are .70. I even worked out HR/AB and HR/PA and they ranked a little lower: .67 and .65. We still haven’t found the stats that have a correlation close to the .54 that K/9 has to runs given up by a pitching staff. The stats closest to that level are at-bats, walks and doubles, each of which has a correlation around .60. Converting the last one to a rate statistic, I find that doubles/at-bat has a correlation of .547, which is almost dead on. So we might want to evaluate pitchers by strikeouts about the same way we evaluate batters by doubles. For instance, given a choice between two players, one who hits a lot of doubles, and one who doesn’t, we probably want the guy with the doubles. We also might mention how many doubles a player has as a data point to demonstrate that they have extra power. Doubles are far from a worthless item to track. But here is probably what we wouldn’t do. We wouldn’t say a free agent is worthless because he was one of the worst at his position in doubles. We probably wouldn’t comb through an organization’s minor league affiliates and suggest that their hitting philosophy is messed up because none of their teams are hitting a lot of doubles. And we wouldn’t suggest that a team scoring lots of runs won’t be able to maintain its pace because it ranks dead last in the league in doubles. Yet we do all of that when talking about strikeouts and pitching. The bottom line is that there isn’t a real clean break point here. Strikeouts are important. They might even be the most important stat we can easily evaluate for pitchers, due to a combination of impact and predictability (though we haven’t studied the latter). But it is exceptionally easy to get carried away with strikeouts, and I think most of the sabrmetric community has, including me. It may be time to step back and admit what we don’t know. And acknowledge that clean numbers aren’t always so clean. ~~~ Below is a complete list of the correlations we have found, both for hitting and for pitching. The hitting ones are compared to runs scored per game, while the pitching ones are compared to the runs given up per game. ~~~
  19. I uploaded my spreadsheet to Google Docs and provided a link in the story. Thank Willihammer for reminding me we could do that. That BB%-R number is a little alarming. When you say "going back to 2004" are you saying you took all 30 teams and combined each team's numbers back to 2004, so you only have 30 items in your correlation? If so, that doesn't seem like enough to trust, though I don't know what that threshold should be. I did team-years, so I grabbed 30 teams for five year for 150 data points, just because I wanted to have at least that many. (Or it could be that I have an error in my spreadsheet, too. It's certainly possible, which is one of the reasons I provided a link to it.)
  20. Thanks for that link. If OPS has a .92 correlation, I expect BA is a bit lower, like in the .8 range. But the more general point is that we're pretty good at knowing what additional stats (like OPS) correlate with a team's Runs Scored. The only one that is similar for Runs Against involved "hits," and I think we're poor at predicting hits. (Cracken's research suggests this, though it might be interesting to do some research on that, too.) But we certainly shouldn't treat strikeout rate as anywhere near as important as OPS. They're not in the same solar system.
  21. By the way, I don't know if I have time tonight, but if I do, I'd like to do a similar study on hitting: what stats correlate closely to the number of runs per game a team scores. This is essentially restating Bill James 30+ year-old research, but I think you find the correlations a LOT higher. If I remember right, batting average (not even OBP or OPS) has a correlation around .90 or something. And we SAVAGE batting average for not being particularly valuable.
  22. What this quick-and-dirty study shows is similar to what you're saying: strikeouts are good. But they're far from everything and we probably put too much importance on them. This is what is interesting to me about this study: that it demonstrates a logical paradox. I think the root cause of that paradox is that we take sabrmetric studies and generalize them and expand them beyond their findings. The emphasis on strikeouts comes from several different places, but the most recent study that has raised their profile is Voros McCracken's study. But his study didn't really have anything to do with strikeouts. It was about hits. Specifically, what his study showed was that when you account for team defense, there is very little correlation in how many extra or how many fewer hits a pitcher gives up year-to-year. The correlation was something like .25. That seemed low. And I say "seemed" because that .25 doesn't have any real empirical meaning - its not like it means they control 25% of things. It was just a smaller correlation than was expected. (Like in this study.) This led to a more general interpretation - that pitchers can't influence whether balls put in play are hits or outs. That's funny, because McCracken's study proved exactly the opposite - it's not completely random - it's just that they can less than we probably expected. This led to a more general conclusion - HAIL STRIKEOUTS. Partly that was because the importance of strikeouts was something that sabrmetricians had been touting for years, and this seemed like another very large brick in that wall. Finally, you can add to all of this that strikeouts are easy to sum and evaluate. They're much easier than strike percentage or other metrics. So we like to use them because they're readily available and easy to use. But the sum of each of those is that we are probably overemphasizing the importance of strikeouts. Strikeouts aren't that important. We can dance around it all we want, but the numbers aren't lying. Now, one can say "Well, it's the best thing we have." First I'm not sure that's true. But the more obvious logical reply to that is "Well, then keep looking." Instead, we seem to cling to them, perhaps at the expense of better research. And we certainly proclaim in our criticism and praise that they mean a lot more than they do. And then ignore that a team that is middle of the road in runs per game is dead last (and by quite a bit) in strikeouts. We call it lucky or small sample size or whatever. The truth is, it isn't that unusual.
  23. You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1712-Geeking-Out-Pitch-To-Contact-And-Team-Pitching

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.