Everything posted by John Bonnes
-
Poll: Draft Scenario 2
Glad my nagging had an effect. :-)
-
Poll: Draft Scenario 2
I thnk that's accurate. But that's a pretty good thing oth a #4 pick, because they don't come along real often. (Though it might next year.)
-
Gardy Needs a Refresher Course in Lineup Construction
The studies I've read (and they go back some time, like to Bill James) concluded that the difference between an absolutely optimal lineup (which is basically putting the batters 1-9 by descending OBP) and the worst (the exact opposite lineup) is about 60 runs per year. It also concludes that if you chose a lineup at random - like Billy Martin would do if his team was in a slump (the players would draw their lineup position from a hat) - it's about 30 runs per year. The lineup folks are advocating - Mauer batting second with the rest of the linuep as is - isn't optimal though it's close because the guys or more or less in the right order, so we're giving up a few runs there. The lineup with Dozier batting #2 is still very close to optimal - it's got most of the guys in the right order, with one extra guy in the wrong order. So how close to that desired lineup are we talking? Five runs? Three runs? Seven runs? And over the course of a season, that small of a difference is awfully close to nonsense. No sabrmetrician would say he can realistically predict the number of runs a team will score within that kind of margin for error. (He/she certainly wouldn't bet that he/she could). And that kind of difference could be made up by any number of ways. Maybe Mauer is more motivated when he's a #3 hitter. Mabye Dozier is more patient as a #2. Or maybe he prepares a little differently when he knows he's batting at the beginning of the game. Or maybe they come up in a little better way in high-leverage situations. Or maybe a butterly flaps its wings in China. The amount of runs is so small as to be insignificant. Virtually every study lays out two rules for lineup effect: 1) Within reason, it really doesn't matter. 2) To what extent it does matter, trust OBP. But I think because there are two rules, they are perceived as having equal weight. They don't. #1 is 96% of what we need to know. #2 is there mostly to make us feel better and better define "Within reason." This is why I get more worked up about people who get worked up about lineup construction than I do about lineup construction. Gardenhire is well "within reason" and it doesn't matter where the hell Dozier bats.
-
Gardy Needs a Refresher Course in Lineup Construction
Sorry I didn't see this earlier. For the record, we actively encourage this at Twins Daily. We want readers to find independent bloggers and we want our readers to be able to find as much content as possible. By all means - post links to your blogs silly in the threads. For that matter, if corporate media wants to post their links in the threads, we would encourage that, too. We would like to ourselves, but have trouble keeping up.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
I'll add that I think Law's logic for the Astros going with Moran seems rock solid: It seems odd, but the way this draft works with slots, etc, really seems to encourage the top teams to consider going for a player much less than slots like Houston did last year and might do this year. At least unless there is a clear-cut star like Harper or Strassburg. Boy, would this be good news for the Twins. I'd be doing backflips. And I'm WAY too big to do backflips.
-
2013 Draft: The Mocks
I'm sorry, but if Gray is available, there is no way they take Stewart. Howeer, it is good to hear that the Twins are comfortable with Stewart's price tag. BTW, is anyone else surprised that the Rockies seem fixated on adding a hitter if Appel or Gray are on the board when they pick? They could use pitching as much as anyone, I think.
-
Poll: Draft Scenario 2
Something happens in the top three such that the pitchers Appel and Gray are taken BUT Kris Bryant (today's profiled player) is still on the board. With the 4th pick. You have the same options as in yesterday's poll, but now you can add Bryant, who is widely considered the best (remaining) player available, but who is a hitter. Do you choose: a. Kris Bryant b. Kohl Stewart, RHP with the most upside but most risk AND he won't be arriving to majors until 2017 most likely c. a college pitcher like Stanek, Shipley, Manaea, etc. - less risk, less upside, but a probably arrives by at least a year or two before Stewart. d. Reese McGuire and use the $1.3M on other picks Again, I'll love your votes (which I'll try to open up to non-members) but I'd really like your comments. Ugh. There is no option to open this up to non-members. Please register with Twins Daily to vote on the poll.
-
Poll: Draft Scenario 1
I voted Stewart. I'm a BPA guy, and to me, BPA = Stewart. But that might not be the case for the 2nd poll that I'm putting up today....
-
Poll: Draft Scenario 1
So what did you pick in the poll?
-
Could Jose Berrios be promoted?
Just checked out Berrios' stats in Cedar Rapids. I know he's young and started late and only has six starts, but wow. Do people who are close than me to ths think he could have a shot at Ft. Myers this year?
-
Article: Twins 8, Brewers 6 and Stealing Bases
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1811-Twins-8-Brewers-6-and-Stealing-Bases
-
Twins 8, Brewers 6 and Stealing Bases
[ATTACH=CONFIG]4250[/ATTACH]The Minnesota Twins won last night, swiping (and sweeping) the season series from the Milwaukee Brewers. The victory raised their record to 23-28 which translates to a 73 win pace over the course of a 162-game season. But I want to talk about some different swiping that happened, or more accurately, did not happen. In the bottom of the sixth inning, Aaron Hicks was caught trying to steal second base. What struck me as strange at the time was that there were runners on the corners and one out. It seemed like a stupid decision to attempt that at the time, as it can short-circuit a good scoring opportunity. However, one always looks stupid when one is caught. So I wondered, was it as risky as it seemed? It turns out – I studied this exact situation last year on 5/11, only it was Denard Span that was thrown out. Here’s how that went: Tonight, though, I want to take it a step further. How does it compare to other situations in which one might try to steal a base? There are 12 situations where a runner might try to steal a base without coordination with the other runner. Here they are: Runner on 1st, 0 outs Runner on 1st, one out Runner on 1st, 2 outs Runner on 2nd, 0 outs Runner on 2nd, 1 out Runner on 2nd, 2 outs Runners on corners, 0 out Runners on the corners, 1 out Runners on corners, 2 outs Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 0 outs Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 1 out Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 2 outs And here they are again, ranked by just how risky they are. The percentage indicates how often one needs to succeed for it to be a good decision. 92.51% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 2 outs 91.10% - Runner on 2nd, 2 outs 79.67% - Runner on 2nd, 0 outs 77.69% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 0 outs 77.25% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 1 out 75.31% - Runner on 2nd, 1 out 74.74% - Runners on corners, 2 outs 71.39% - Runners on the corners, 1 out 70.73% - Runners on corners, 0 out 65.20% - Runner on 1st, 0 outs 63.41% - Runner on 1st, one out 60.06% - Runner on 1st, 2 outs So it wasn’t patently stupid, like trying to steal 3rd when you’re already in scoring position. But it was the 2nd riskiest situation in which to try and steal 2nd base. The only thing that would have been worse was if it could have ended the inning.
-
Twins 8, Brewers 6 and Stealing Bases
- Twins 8, Brewers 6 and Stealing Bases
The Minnesota Twins won last night, swiping (and sweeping) the season series from the Milwaukee Brewers. The victory raised their record to 23-28 which translates to a 73 win pace over the course of a 162-game season. But I want to talk about a different type of swiping that happened, or more accurately, did not happen. In the bottom of the sixth inning, Aaron Hicks was caught trying to steal second base. What struck me as strange at the time was that there were runners on the corners and one out. It seemed like a stupid decision to attempt that at the time, as it can short-circuit a good scoring opportunity. However, one always looks stupid when one is caught. So I wondered, was it as risky as it seemed? It turns out – I studied this exact situation last year on 5/11, only it was Denard Span that was thrown out. Here’s how that went: Tonight, though, I want to take it a step further. How does it compare to other situations in which one might try to steal a base? There are 12 situations where a runner might try to steal a base without coordination with the other runner. Here they are: Runner on 1st, 0 outs Runner on 1st, one out Runner on 1st, 2 outs Runner on 2nd, 0 outs Runner on 2nd, 1 out Runner on 2nd, 2 outs Runners on corners, 0 out Runners on the corners, 1 out Runners on corners, 2 outs Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 0 outs Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 1 out Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 2 outs And here they are again, ranked by just how risky they are. The percentage indicates how often one needs to succeed for it to be a good decision. 92.51% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 2 outs 91.10% - Runner on 2nd, 2 outs 79.67% - Runner on 2nd, 0 outs 77.69% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 0 outs 77.25% - Runners on 1st and 2nd, trying to steal 3rd, 1 out 75.31% - Runner on 2nd, 1 out 74.74% - Runners on corners, 2 outs 71.39% - Runners on the corners, 1 out 70.73% - Runners on corners, 0 out 65.20% - Runner on 1st, 0 outs 63.41% - Runner on 1st, one out 60.06% - Runner on 1st, 2 outs So it wasn’t patently stupid, like trying to steal 3rd when you’re already in scoring position. But it was the 2nd riskiest situation in which to try to steal 2nd base. The only thing that would have been worse was if it could have ended the inning.- Poll: Draft Scenario 1
I'd like to apologize for setting up the poll so that only registered members can vote. I assume that is a default flag that I didn't know was turned on. For future polls, we'll try and turn that off. By the way, great comments.- Poll: Draft Scenario 1
Let's assume that the first three picks are Appel, Gray and Bryant (as seems likely). Let's also assume that Kohl Stewart will sign at slot, but probably not below. However, Reese McGuire will sign for less than slot - say #7 money, which would save $1.3M for future draft picks. Who do you choose: a. Kohl Stewart, RHP with the most upside but most risk AND he won't be arriving to majors until 2017 most likely b. a college pitcher like Stanek, Shipley, Manaea, etc. - less risk, less upside, but a probably arrives by 2015. c. Reese McGuire and use the $1.3M on other picks? I'll add a poll, but I'll be more interested in your comments.- Miller: Morneau Lacking Power
The Strib's Phil Miller takes on the topic of Justin Morneau's anemic home run numbers head on today, including talking to Morneau and his approach: It doesn't sound like Morneau has tried to change his approach - he just isn't hitting the dingers right now. Twins notes: RBI, but not HRs, for Morneau | StarTribune.com- Game summaries?
Some history and discussion before a call to action..... As Seth has mentioned, we have debated this since before the site has opened. Initially, we decided that what limited bandwidth we all had would be dedicated towards what we wanted to write about, rather than try to copy something that you can find in half a dozen spots already. But recently we've reopened that talk a little amongst ourselves. Why? 1) I think people really like them especially following a win. 2) It doesn't need to be a boilerplate game recap (Intro, summary, quotes, close). In fact, I think we could do some really interesting things with game recaps, sort of breaking the mold. Off the top of my head... - As suggested above, go into the sabrmetrics of game theory, like win probabilities or expected runs, or even the impact of a different lineup long term - Use an event in the game as a launching point for some research or to explain why a statistic is (or isn't) important - Just mess with the format. Instead of descriptions of what happened and quotes, put in nine questions the game raised, or a bullet point story or a minute-by-minute game diary of watching the game at home or whatever. When I first started TwinsGeek.com, I did a lot of riffing on topics that started with a game story. It's an effective way to illustrate things and challenge your own writing, because it's so fresh in people's minds. What has stopped us from pursuing this lately is the same thing that has stopped us from doing it in the first place - bandwidth. But I'll say this - if people want to throw their attempts at game recaps on blogs - especially if they're well-written or creative or go away from the boilerplate story - we'll pay special attention to them. We would love to have them.- 10 Years of Blogging - 5/29/03 to ???
What the hell does that mean?- Article: Minnesota Twins Should Promote Little-Known Antoan Richardson
- A Curious Case for Kirby
Perhaps this is a good thing - the number 34 is just so associated with Puckett in people's minds that to have a name is redundant, or uncool - it makes you look like a newbie? But that shirt thing does seem weird.- Article: Message From The King: The Best (Beer) Seats In The House
The prices are a little silly, but if I'm going to pay for a beer, it's going to be a good one.- Why Morneau's trade value is ebbing rapidly....
There is no way the Twins can give him a qualifying offer right now. None. Even if we think the Twins are going to further cut payroll, they can't just burn $7M on Morneau.- Keith Law's updated top 25 list
I was hoping we might see Meyer in that list too, but having two guys in the top 6 is almost unheard of. That is outstanding.- The Minnesota Twins Must Test the Water at Triple-A Rochester
Good story. I'll admit - this is a little uncanny. Why are do many players struggling when they make the leap to MLB after dominating in AAA? I suppose the easy place to point a finger is the coaching staff, but may of them (including the hitting coach and pitching coach) came from AAA. - Twins 8, Brewers 6 and Stealing Bases