Everything posted by John Bonnes
-
Souhan: Free Agent Pitchers Not The Answer
Mike, thank you for the reasoned and civil comment to get this thread back on track. You too Gunnathor. Just a warning to the rest that seem to relish throwing a personal dig into an otherwise salient point - leave out the dig. It serves no purpose other than to: a) generate a personal dig as a response which degenerates that thread demonstrate a level of emotional immaturity that lowers your reputation in the eyes of 80% of the people reading this stuff c) jeopardize the substance of your post with possible deletion. I've said it before and I'll say it again - if TD moderators feel like they're spending too much time regulating personal feuds, I am actively encouraging them to just ban the feuders. It is an easy fix and the community will recover from losing any one of us - of that I'm sure. Ok, let's get back to the topic....
-
Article: Twins MLB Draft Profile: Reese McGuire, C
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1784-Twins-MLB-Draft-Profile-Reese-McGuire-C
-
Twins MLB Draft Profile: Reese McGuire, C
- Twins MLB Draft Profile: Reese McGuire, C
[ATTACH=CONFIG]4181[/ATTACH]Who IS This Guy? Reese McGuire is a left-handed hitting high school catcher that is already ready for the majors defensively, but will need several years to develop similar offensive skills. He has been projected to go anywhere from the top five in the draft to 20th overall. The Twins have been linked to him by Jim Callis of Baseball America and are definitely interested in him. Besides McGuire’s skill set, he is intriguing for another reason: by signing him at a below-slot level value, the Twins could bank that leftover money for more aggressive (and expensive) draft choices later in the draft. Who Could He Be? His floor would be Drew Butera – a poor-hitting but defensively superior backup catcher. McGuire’s “pop” time – the amount of time it takes for him to receive a throw and get it to second base – is already at a major league level. Offensively, he is not nearly as developed but he projects to have some left-handed power (10-15 HR) and in this video Keith Law thinks he can hit .270 or .280 in the major leagues. Those stats would line him up to be something like AJ Pierzynski only with Yadier Molina’s glove. How Soon Could He Be Playing In Target Field? The last first round catcher the Twins drafted moved up in two-and-a-half years – but that was Joe Mauer. Four years is a much more realistic timetable, so he would debut in 2017, when Mauer is 34 years old, and a year before Mauer’s contract expires. If the Twins Draft This Guy, They Messed Up Because... If they Twins draft McGuire the Twins are likely going to be widely criticized, some of which is fair and some of which is not. Perception is that the Twins need to add pitching, that they are too enamored with defensive catchers and that they are unwilling to spend money. Drafting McGuire would reinforce all of those paradigms. But beyond the public relations problem this would cause, there are some real concerns. They will have passed on three college-age arms – Braden Shipley, Ryne Stanek and Sean Manaea - that all could help reinforce a desperate need in the organization. They will also have passed on a high school pitcher with as much upside as any arm in the draft – Kohl Stewart – and several other high upside talents. Finally, high school catchers are inherently very risky draft picks. In last night’s Gleeman And The Geek podcast, Jeremy Nygaard listed the high school catchers drafted in the first round since Mauer in 2001. The only one who has made any kind of mark is Neil Walker – and he had to move from catcher. If the Twins Draft This Guy, They Nailed It Because... The Twins are in the unpleasant position of drafting fourth in what is widely considered to be a three-player draft. In any other sport, the wise strategy would be to move down in the draft, but MLB draft picks can’t be traded. However, if they sign McGuire for #7 money instead of someone else for #4 money, they can use the money they saved for “overdrafting” in later rounds, essentially adding two first round picks. For instance, if the Twins draft McGuire and sign him for #7 money, they would have an extra $1.3M to add to their budget for their 2nd round (43rd overall) pick, which is also slotted at $1.3M. So they would have $2.6M to offer to the player they chose, which is as much as the 14th overall pick. That’s important in the MLB draft, because players drafted in high school or as a junior in college don’t need to sign. For instance, Manaea’s stock has been dropping as he dealt with injuries. Once he falls into the second round, he’s unlikely to sign with whoever drafts him and teams know this, so he just keeps dropping. But the Twins could grab him there, offer him close to the money he originally thought he might get, and end up with (essentially) two first round picks. Or, if the Twins feel like the value in this draft is in later rounds, they could use similar tactics in rounds three through ten. That’s the best case scenario, and the Twins would be taking a lot of risk that a player like Manaea falls to them and is willing to sign. This also requires a lot of preparation – you don’t want to draft a player if you’re not SURE they’ll sign. MLB Draft Player Profiles: Monday, May 20-- Sean Manaea, SP Tuesday, May 21-- Austin Meadows, OF Wednesday, May 22-- Trey Ball, OF Thursday, May 23-- Ryan Stanek, RHP Friday, May 24—Clint Frazier, OF For MLB Draft Day Coverage, make sure you follow @TwinsDaily on Twitter!- Twins MLB Draft Profile: Reese McGuire, C
Who IS This Guy? Reese McGuire is a left-handed hitting high school catcher that is ready for the majors defensively, but will need several years to develop similar offensive skills. He has been projected to go anywhere in the draft from among the top five to 20th overall. The Minnesota Twins have been linked to him by Jim Callis of Baseball America and are definitely interested. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] Besides McGuire’s skill set, he is intriguing for another reason: by signing him at a below-slot level value, the Twins could bank that leftover money for more aggressive (and expensive) draft choices later in the draft. Who Could He Be? His floor would be Drew Butera – a poor-hitting but defensively superior backup catcher. McGuire’s “pop” time – the amount of time it takes for him to receive a throw and get it to second base – is already at a major league level. Offensively, he is not nearly as developed but he projects to have some left-handed power (10-15 HR) and in this video Keith Law thinks he can hit .270 or .280 in the majors. Those stats line him up to be something like AJ Pierzynski only with Yadier Molina’s glove. That's a very valuable player. How Soon Could He Be Playing In Target Field? The last first round catcher the Twins drafted moved up in two-and-a-half years – but that was Joe Mauer. Four years is a much more realistic timetable, so he would debut in 2017, when Mauer is 34 years old, and a year before Mauer’s contract expires. If the Twins Draft This Guy, They Messed Up Because... If the Twins draft McGuire they are likely going to be widely criticized, some of which will be fair and some not. The widely held sense is that the Twins need to add pitching, that they are too enamored with defensive catchers and that they are unwilling to spend money. Drafting McGuire would reinforce these perceptions. But beyond the public relations problem this would cause, there are some real concerns. They will have passed on three college-age arms – Braden Shipley, Ryne Stanek and Sean Manaea - each of which could help alleviate a desperate need in the organization. They would also then have passed on a high school pitcher with as much upside as any arm in the draft – Kohl Stewart – and several other high-upside talents. Finally, high school catchers are inherently very risky draft picks. In last night’s Gleeman And The Geek podcast, Jeremy Nygaard listed the high school catchers drafted in the first round since Mauer in 2001. The only one who has made any kind of mark is Neil Walker – and he had to move from catcher. If the Twins Draft This Guy, They Nailed It Because... The Twins are in the unpleasant position of drafting fourth in what is widely considered to be a three-player draft. In any other sport, the wise strategy would be to move down in the draft, but MLB draft picks can’t be traded. However, if they sign McGuire for #7 money instead of someone else for #4 money, they can use the money they saved for “overdrafting” in later rounds, essentially adding two first round picks. For instance, if the Twins draft McGuire and sign him for #7 money, they would have an extra $1.3M to add to their budget for their 2nd round (43rd overall) pick, which is slotted at $1.3M. So they would have $2.6M to offer to the player they chose, who will be the 34th player chosen, which is as much as the 14th overall pick. That’s important in the MLB draft, because players drafted in high school or as juniors in college don’t need to sign. For instance, Manaea’s stock has been dropping as he has dealt with injuries. Once he falls into the second round, he’s unlikely to sign with whoever drafts him and teams know this, so he just keeps dropping. But the Twins could grab him there, offer him close to the money he originally thought he might get and end up with (essentially) two first round picks. Or, if the Twins feel like the value in this draft is in later rounds, they could use similar tactics in rounds three through ten. That’s the best case scenario, but the Twins would be taking a big risk that a player like Manaea falls to them and is willing to sign. This also requires a lot of preparation – you don’t want to draft a player if you’re not SURE he'll sign. MLB Draft Player Profiles: Monday, May 20-- Sean Manaea, SP Tuesday, May 21-- Austin Meadows, OF Wednesday, May 22-- Trey Ball, OF Thursday, May 23-- Ryan Stanek, RHP Friday, May 24—Clint Frazier, OF For MLB Draft Day Coverage, make sure you follow @TwinsDaily on Twitter!- Article: Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 95: MLB Draft & Free Fallin...
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1780-Gleeman-and-the-Geek-Ep-95-MLB-Draft-Free-Fallin- Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 95: MLB Draft & Free Fallin...
On the best Minnesota Twins podcast, Aaron and John talk about the Twins' free fall, options for the No. 4 pick in the draft with Twins Daily's Jeremy Nygaard, a ton of roster changes including losing Joe Benson, sending down Oswaldo Arcia, not calling up Kyle Gibson, what happened to Justin Morneau's power, Chris Parmelee in center field, leveraging Glen Perkins, a WHOLE lot more about the draft and meeting listeners at the Apple Store. Here are: the podcasts the rss feed if you want to subscribe and the podcast on iTunes. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] Or, just click on the link below:- Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 95: MLB Draft & Free Fallin...
On the best Minnesota Twins podcast, Aaron and John talk about the Twins' free fall, options for the No. 4 pick in the draft with Twins Daily's Jeremy Nygaard, a ton of roster changes including losing Joe Benson, sending down Oswaldo Arcia, not calling up Kyle Gibson, what happened to Justin Morneau's power, Chris Parmelee in center field, leveraging Glen Perkins, a WHOLE lot more about the draft and meeting listeners at the Apple Store. Here are: the podcasts the rss feed if you want to subscribe and the podcast on iTunes. Or, just click on the link below:- Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 95: MLB Draft & Free Fallin...
On the best Minnesota Twins podcast, Aaron and John talk about the Twins' free fall, options for the No. 4 pick in the draft with Twins Daily's Jeremy Nygaard, a ton of roster changes including losing Joe Benson, sending down Oswaldo Arcia, not calling up Kyle Gibson, what happened to Justin Morneau's power, Chris Parmelee in center field, leveraging Glen Perkins, a WHOLE lot more about the draft and meeting listeners at the Apple Store. Here are: the podcasts the rss feed if you want to subscribe and the podcast on iTunes. Or, just click on the link below:- Miller: Saint-Twins Partnership Is Strong
From the Twins Daily newsroom.... In today's Strib, beat writer Phil Miller notes that the relationship between the Saints and Twins has thawed considerable since Dave St. Peter took over, and that's part of why Caleb Thielbar is in the Twins organization. This raises the question, of course, that when the new ballpark for the Saints is built, could they somehow become the Twins Low A affiliate? I know there are challenges on both sides, but can you imagine the buzz in this town right now about the Twins future if Byron Buxton was doing his thing in St. Paul? Or if the Twin Cities would have been introduced to Miguel Sano last year? That would have to be a good things, right? Souhan: Look within for starting pitchers, or do without | StarTribune.com- Souhan: Free Agent Pitchers Not The Answer
From the Twins Daily Newsroom.... Jim Souhan had an interesting and well-researched story in today's Star-Tribune. His initial point seemed to be that Vance Worley stinks, which I'm not ready to agree with yet. But his larger point is that the Twins have had tremendous success finding starting pitching from the minors and have mostly failed miserable to find starting pitching from the free agent market. This is maybe my biggest concern about the Twins organization under Ryan - that he might be incapable of using the free agent market as a tool to fill gaps, and it's a handy tool for a lot of teams. On the other hand, Souhan details all the pitching they have acquired and just how darn good they have been at getting minor league pitchers that eventually had a great deal of success. I don't know that I have a discussion question here, but it's worth the read. I guess the question is - how do the Twins become adept at getting the pitching using both methods? Souhan: Look within for starting pitchers, or do without | StarTribune.com- Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
I don't know exactly why they're being so cautious w Gibson. I can think of three reason, and they all speak to them valuing him more than I expected: 1. The innings limit - protecting his health 2. The consistency - protecting his confidence 3. The service time - protecting the ininvestment Whatever the reason, I don't see Joe Benson as being worth enough to change it.- Percent confidence in management
The Twins were a championship caliber team from 2002-2010. I wonder, would one expect a successful run for a period of longer than nine years? How many other teams can I find with that long of a run of success? There is a natural cycle that organizations face that is driven by the aging of thir players and is accelerated for non-rich teams by the financial cycle in the CBA. They load up on cheap, young players and they get better and then watch them become too expensive or grow old and need to find a way to renew their talent. With that as my paradigm, I'll answer my own questions: 1) No. I would have expected it to end by 2007 and maybe 2006. This organization developed two generations of players and reloaded them on the fly 2) With the Twins payroll level - none. Not Oakland. Not Tampa Bay. Maybe St. Louis? Ryan is not without his faults and blind spots. But By almost any metric, Ryan squeezed more talent and wins out of fewer resources than any other GM in professional sports for a decade. That might lend itself to some confidence.- Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
Well, I'll go down as approving. I'll be honest - I'm more shocked that there is some actual outrage about this than I am about the move. In fact, this is what I suggested would happen yesterday. Any outrage I would attribute to an outdated expectation of who this guy is. Sometimes a guy just isn't who we want him to be. Even if we write off his problems last year to injury (which is kind, considering he wasn't hurt until midyear) we still have a 25-year-old who was hitting .192 with 50 strikeouts (vs 10 BB) in 164 AB. He was going to need to be demoted to AA to find himself for the second straight year and indeed - that's where he new team stuck him. Plus he's out of options. So here is the scenario where this somehow turns into a disaster: within 3 months he rights himself at AA, carries that success into AAA (where he now has a .187 batting average over 272 PA) and makes it to the majors to stick for the next couple of years. As.... a 4th outfielder? Finally, it's not like the Twins gave him his walking papers. It was certainly a reasonable gamble that nobody would pick him up and he would get through waivers. Good lord - even Drew Butera hit .211 in Rochester. He even struck out HALF as often as Benson. Sometimes a guy just isn't who we want him to be.- Is it time to call the Red Sox?
The way I would choose to think about this question is this way: would I want the Twins trade Mauer if he was made $1M/year? Because I have no faith the Twins are going to turn that $23 million into any real assets, at least not in the near future. And the answer to that is no.- Spelling
It was a dark day for questionable spellers when Mientkiewicz rejoined the organization.- Who gets DFAed?
My choice: Benson. He's hitting .192. He's got 50K vs 10 BB in AAA. He's either got to be DFAed or sent back down to AA as a 25-year-old. I'll throw one more thing out which is just pure speculation....did the Twins hurt him by calling him up straight from AA in September of 2011? He struggled mightily and has literally never been remotely the same player he was before that. You can write off last year to injuries (and we all did). But for a guy who was known as sort of mentally fragile (in that he gets down on himself when he struggles) was that the right move? We'll never know. That questions doesn't really have an answer. But I'll wonder about it.- Walters
OK, I'll be the contrary one. I don't believe this has much to do with Gibson's Super-2 status. It might be one aspect on that side of the equation, but it's a small thing. The big things, frankly, are that he hasn't been able to put two solid starts in a row and that they feel they can better control his innings limit (and thus his health) by keeping him in AAA. For those that feel this is purely financial, I'll ask the obvious question (which Terry Ryan himself has asked): if that's so important for Gibson, which isn't is important for Hicks and Arcia? - Hicks and Arcia are both much younger than Gibson - Both are perceived to be as valuable in the future as Gibson (and probably with less risk) - In both cases their promotion effects when they turn into free agents, which is a much bigger deal than when a player reaches Super-2. So, if this is such a driving force for the organization, why are they sticking it to Gibson and not Hicks and Arcia?- Article: PJ Walters To Fill Minnesota Twins Rotation Spot
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1765-PJ-Walters-To-Fill-Rogation-Spot- PJ Walters To Fill Minnesota Twins Rotation Spot
Jim Mandalaro of the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle tweeted today that PJ Walters told Mandalaro that Walters will be promoted to the Minnesota Twins and start a game this weekend. This solves the mystery of who will be taking Vance Worley's spot in the starting rotation and puts to rest speculation that prospect Kyle Gibson will be making his major league debut in the immediate future. How the Twins will juggle their 25-man and 40-man roster to make space for Walters is still unknown. Walters joined the Twins prior to the 2012 season as a minor league free agent, but was called up in May as the Twins rotation was besieged by injuries. He started the year with four quality starts but faded badly in June and was eventually placed on the disabled list with shoulder soreness. He returned to the majors in September with mostly poor results, ending the year with a 5.69 ERA. He was dropped from the 40-man roster this offseason. The 28-year-old has reestablished himself this year in Rochester. In nine starts, he has posted a 3.31 ERA with 46K in 54.1 IP and 16BB. Maybe most critically, he has given up only 2 home runs, which has been his Achilles Heel in the major leagues. Last year, he gave up 12 home runs in just 61.2 IP. The Twins will need to make room for Walters both on the 25-man roster and on the 40-man roster before his start. Since the Twins shorted themselves a starting pitcher this week, finding room on the 25-man roster will mean demoting a relief pitcher or carrying 13 pitchers and demoting a position player. There are several likely candidates but no obvious choice. In addition, the Twins will need to find room on the 40-man roster. Seth listed seven candidates in a story earlier today. In each case, it's possible that the Twins could lose that player from the organization.- Article: Twins Daily Wants To Promote Your Blog
I'm glad to hear it.- Miguel Sano AA Promotion
FYI - Andrew has been covering the New Britain Rock Cats for us.- Keith Law Chat (ESPN) Today 12 PM CST
It would definitely be easier for the Astros with their $7.9M slot for #1. If they sign Moran at a #3 slot value (which is more than he'll get otherwise), that gives them about $3.6M of slot money to sign someone with their #4 pick. That's the equivalent of a #5 or #6 pick. Manaea missed yet another start this week due to injuries. There is no way he goes top 5. I don't think he goes top 10 right now. And beyond that there are reasons nobody signs him below that money. His slot value is $2.8M at pick 11 and $1.8M when the Yankees pick. This isn't the old days. Teams CAN'T just throw more money at him. They're limited by the cap now. And if they can't sign him, whoever picks him just loses the pick and the money associated with it, and only get back a similar pick next year. Why would teams risk that when at best they get a high-upside pitcher that might have some chronic medical problems? It makes less sense for the Twins, after looking at the numbers. If the Twins were to sign a #4 pick at #6 money, they can pay $2.3M to their 2nd round pick. That would put Manaea at about the same level as a #16 guy. Id be a little surprised if he signed for that.- Keith Law Chat (ESPN) Today 12 PM CST
Above Gausman, who was fourth.- Keith Law Chat (ESPN) Today 12 PM CST
Re: Jose Berrios - Twins MLB Draft Profile: Reese McGuire, C