Everything posted by John Bonnes
-
Miami Kryptonite?
I'll reply to this honest question, just so we're clear. I'm often asked by people who have been banned or whose posts have been deleted "I just want to know where the line is." Or "I just want to know what the limits are." Here is the answer: We are working in a very nebulous and dynamic environment. We are figuring out our policy for maintaining civil discussion as we go along. There are five moderators with different opinions. Every time each of those moderators checks in, they're in a different state of mind. And finally, we all have limits to the time we can donate to these forums. So there is no line. There is no limit. There are a lot of them, and they're always changing and that's the way it has to be. So just stay the hell away from it. And frankly, that shouldn't be so hard. In fact, I can objectively PROVE it isn't that hard. Here you go: - We have 2757 users right now on Twins Daily. - Every day, we have about 300 active posters. - We keep needing to delete stuff or warn about 5 to 10 members. When about 97% or our community can consistently stay away from the line, I'm confident that the other 3% can figure out a way to, too. And if you are unfairly penalized - deal with it like a grown up. Re-do your deleted post in a more civil manner so you can still make the point. Sit out of the forum for three days (or seven days) and just read things. Maybe see how others stay away from the line. Or enjoy another site. Or do something else. You'll live. Let me share one last thing. I've talked to several people who run national sites much bigger that TD and here's how they do things - they see a post that makes them think they probably don't want that guy on the board and they just block the IP address. They do not think twice about it. No deleted post. No warning. No temporary ban. This is common, because they just don't have the time (or, frankly, the incentive) to rehabilitate anyone who looks like a moron. When they told me that a year ago, I was aghast. It seemed arbitrary and unfair. Now, with as much time as I find having to moderate or explain the process of moderation to others, I'm a lot more sympathetic. To be exceptionally candid, my life would be a lot easier with permanent bans on about seven members. And as stretched as we are right now with time, that might be enough reason. That might be the new line. Again - this isn't that hard. Be civil. Leave your ego out of it. Don't try to "win". Stay away from the line.
-
Article: Is There A Market For Morneau?
I think there's a middle ground here that tends to get lost if we're not talking about specifics. I was disappointed that the Twins didnt't sign FA pitchers, but I also wasn't lobbying for Greinke/Sanchez. I seem to remember lobbying for Dempster and Ervin Santana, and probably a few others that didn't work out as well. I think you can find some players which balance the risk or even use it as an opportunity to create an asset - like Willingham and his contract - that can provide a benefit to the season AND something other teams could value. But I'll also say - I'll be surprised if the Twins do that. It's not Ryan's MO. I wish they did more of that.
-
Article: Q&A with Antoan Richardson
Suddenly this org has all kinds of CF filler
-
Article: New swing helps Twins' Clete Thomas contribute
As of today, his 730 OPS is close to his career average, though maybe he's platooning less now? He sure looks a lot better. I honestly wonder if the Twins might stick with him when Hicks comes back, and let Hicks learn to dominate AAA.
-
Buxton tops Baseball Prospectus' Mid-Season Top 50
There's a lot to be excited about here, but I'm curious as to why Rosario isn't in the top 100 on these lists. A 923 OPS in High A as a 21-year-old and he did well last year, too. I always hear: "He might not stay at second base" but the fallback is center field, which is up the defensive spectrum, not down it. Can anyone give me any insight? What's not to like? Unlike Arcia, he was also a pretty high (4th round) draft choice, so it's not like he's surprising people, is he?
-
Updated Comment Policy Thread
bump
-
Article: Geeking Out: OPS Minus Batting Average
Thanks. I think this suggests that OPS and OPS-BA are essentially equal in their importance for a team. OPS is SLIGHTLY more important, but that's splitting hairs. They're essentially equivalent. So whether you count the hits once or twice, it's about the same, although it might be just a little better to count the hits twice, for whatever reason.
-
Article: Geeking Out: OPS Minus Batting Average
I can't run the numbers myself - I'm a little busy this morning - but would anyone like to do a quick correlation between Seth's OPS-BA stat and Runs scored and share it with us?
-
Article: Gibson Gets the Call
This gets to the heart of the matter. I'll publish proposed Comment Policy changes for feedback tomorrow, but consistent unrelenting negativity turns into trolling. Right now, it looks like this.... #2 Trolling - Trolling. Trolling is often subtle and is hard to define, but can kill a forum in a hurry, so we take it seriously. Here are some examples: - Making ridiculous or obviously stupid assertions and then defending them with illogic or drama. - Persistently negative comments, especially if they're in a thread or topic that derails the thread. Our purpose is not to discourage negative viewpoints or debate, but in a forum dedicated towards a team, such behavior eventually crosses into trolling. If you are approaching that point, you'll need to practice extra caution, staying away from overly negative rhetoric and presenting coherent points. In short, you probably have less leash to work with, because the very act itself is bound to cause some reaction. - One-line comments that add nothing but question everything. There are more and we're learning them (much to our chagrin) so we'll try to keep adding examples. If you're warned for falling into this behavior, understand that we have become extra sensitive to those kind of posts.
-
The Twins Way: The Worst Way?
The Twins have not, as a team, run the bases well with any sort of consistency regardless of whether they were good that year or not. I'm puzzled by this conclusion. Is "0" average? Ar the Twins not above average in eight of the 12 years? Or am I reading the data wrong?
-
Article: Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 99: Gibson Time
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1943-Gleeman-and-the-Geek-Ep-99-Gibson-Time
-
Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 99: Gibson Time
- Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 99: Gibson Time
[ATTACH=CONFIG]4526[/ATTACH]In this week's Minnesota Twins podcast, Aaron and John talk about expectations for Kyle Gibson's promotion, where Aaron Hicks rehab stint will take him, Wilkin Ramirez' setback from a concussion, Trevor Plouffe's trade value, Antoan Richardson's eye-popping OBP, Oswald Arcia's quiet success, trade speculation, the upcoming zombie apocalypse and answer mailbag questions. You can listen by clicking below, download us from iTunes or find it at GleemanAndTheGeek.com.- Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 99: Gibson Time
In this week's Minnesota Twins podcast, Aaron and John talk about expectations for Kyle Gibson's promotion, where Aaron Hicks rehab stint will take him, Wilkin Ramirez' setback from a concussion, Trevor Plouffe's trade value, Antoan Richardson's eye-popping OBP, Oswald Arcia's quiet success, trade speculation, the upcoming zombie apocalypse and answer mailbag questions. You can listen by clicking below, download us from iTunes or find it at GleemanAndTheGeek.com. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK]- Article: Gibson Gets the Call
I'm glad to see Gibson. I wonder if we'll ever know why they took their sweet time in making this move. But the timing of this is, at best, odd. I wonder if they Twins will reconsider things tomorrow, possibly adding him to the 25-man roster later this week. He can still hang out with the team for a few days. I don't know why they would short themselves the opportunity to have another bench bat (or maybe even more necessary after Saturday, a bullpen arm) for those four games. The only thing I can think is that they want Gibson available as long relief for those four days in case one of the starters gets knocked our early.- Oswaldo Arcia as a Rookie of the Year Candidate?
As you noted.... He's more than a legitimate candidate - he might be the frontrunner. We talked a little about this on the GATG podcast today - we may not be celebrating what is going on right in front of our eyes enough. Arcia could be pretty special. I wonder if there isn't something here about prospects and how we rank them based on their history. Arcia was ranked #41 overall because....well, looking back it's not exactly clear why. He's super young. Had success at every level. Had all the tools. But he wasn't super-highly regarded when he first signed, so at every step he's had to climb the prospect ladder as opposed to starting at the top.- Twins not looking to trade Correia
Just a reminder to the community - if you have a point to make, then make it. But continually throwing one-liners out that questions everything but add nothing to the discussion is close to the definition of "trolling." And we ban trolls.- Pressly to the starting rotation?
I wouldn't be shocked if the Twins try him as a starter next year, in say, AA or AAA. But for a Rule 5 guy, and with options like Gibson already struggling to find room in the rotation, I don't know why anyone would mess with it.- Byron Buxton and the Trout timeline
Just a reminder to everyone - rather than comment on inappropriate posts, please notify administrators using the icon at the bottom of each post that looks like a triangle with an exclamation point it it. FWIW, mike wants wins did just that after his quote, but just a tip for everyone else.- Twins coaching staff and front office meeting today
FWIW, I think for the most part the figures in that web site are correct. They look to me like they were pulled from USAToday's tracking DB, which is widely recognized. The problem is that the 2013 numbers were never updated. They match the 2012 numbers exactly.- The Twins Time is Now. Have to consider trading Buxton and Arcia.
I can. I'm closing this thread and sending a warning about trolling.- Should Plouffe Be Shopped?
While we wonder whether Morneau or Willingham are worth trading, there is a name that is brought up a lot less often: Trevor Plouffe. If the Twins are convinced Sano can stay at 3rd, Plouffe is looking more and more like a cheap, productive, everyday player at a position that is hard to fill, similar to Denard Span a couple of years ago. Now there is a name that could bring back a pitching prospect, right? And would you?- Kyle Gibson, Andrew Albers and consistency
Mmmmm. Cake. I'll ask..... How much of the concern over where Gibson spends his July is due to: 1) I think he could help the Twins right now 2) I think he could benefit next year from 40-50 innings in MLB this year 3) I think he could benefit long term from 40-50 innings in MLB this year 4) I just don't like the way this current administration does things 5) I just want to play with my shiny new toy Personally, I'd go with 1 - 5% 2 - 30% 3 - 5% 4 - 10% 5 - 125%. (Of, I guess just 50%). I'll add - I can't get too worked up about this. The only real tangibile benefit is maybe how he pitches next year. And it is likely easier to protect his arm (especially given the undue attention he is already given) by keeping him in Rochester.- Florimon or Dozier?
It's an interesting question. Given their minor league careers, Dozier would seem to have more promise, but he's also in a position to be squeezed - and Rosario is looking like the real deal. I think whoever said "neither" might be right. I'm still not convinced that Florimon will last beyond this year - the Twins aren't afraid to go nab a bargain gloveman at SS in the offseason. So I guess I'd go with Dozier. If he improves enough or if Rosario does well in AA, Dozier could be kept around to keep the seat warm, even if it's just through next May.- Article: Series Preview: Twins vs White Sox, 6/18-6/20
I suppose I shouldn't be surprised thta looking at the pitching matchups, things look a little bleak in all 3 games. Fortunately, there is also offense to consider. For instance, despite the Twins sending out a 6.12 ERA tonight, they're favored today (very slightly) by Vegas. - Gleeman and the Geek, Ep 99: Gibson Time