Everything posted by Platoon
-
Thanks DaveW
It might be called "Hot Stove League". Every winter is rumors innuendoes and conjecture, sadly in the Twins case, cruel jokes have been played out mostly as the result of actual moves.
-
DaveW: Dodgers trade for Dozier to be completed within the next 24 hours
Repeat after me...... Pitching,pitching, pitching. There pitching, and then there 8 other guys standing around to see if the pitcher needs help.
- Article: Twins, Please Don't Trade Brian Dozier!
-
Article: Twins, Please Don't Trade Brian Dozier!
Ironically? That you will be on 104.7 The PURR? Or, ironically that anyone would sign Whine Line to a contract? Wait, that would not be ironic, that would be puzzling. :). All kidding aside, when I travel anywhere outside NE Mpls The PURR quits purring. Any chance WL could get picked up by Sirius/XM as I am moving to Canada on 1/20/17.
-
Article: Twins, Please Don't Trade Brian Dozier!
Pre-begging forgiveness from the lady in Chicago, I would like to clarify a point on the person which we are not allowed to reference. While I wont identify him by name, he plays first base, used to catch, and is from St. Paul. My point on said player we can't mention is that contractually there is only one option available. I was not endorsing or suggesting it. Actually I was trying to make a point whilst trying to be polite, that discussions over the future of this person are a waste of digital ink. (As my post will most likely be construed by some) That said, I am sure Whine Line, uncumbered by the philosophy of sticking to any one topic, will explore this in depth. Sadly that's the same time I will be listening to my tape of Sid Hartmans greatest interviews.
-
Article: Twins, Please Don't Trade Brian Dozier!
In fairness to the post, if one looked at Dozier simply as a fan, of course you would keep him. But it would be this fandom which would keep the Twins from eventually improving as a team. One only has to look back a year at Plouffe to see the future folly of not trading Dozier. I know Plouffe didn't have as high a value, but whatever he would brought will always be speculation, because we kept him, he had a poor year, and we released him. Zip! On a contending team I keep Brian Dozier. On this team, several years out, I trade him now for as much as I can get. His history of lengthly hot and cold spells make it a big gamble to wait for the trading deadline. Plus besides the obvious need for pitching , keeping Dozier forces the Twins to keep Polanco at SS. And please, no more Mauer contract talk! Ugh! The issue with Mauer if one has one has to be dealt with by the manager. The FO has only one option, release and pay. Even I think BD has a better chance to hit 50 HR than that happening!
-
Kennys Vargas
Actually you have a valid point. Like so many players, once Santana's hitting fell off, his defense started getting picked apart. I realize he isn't anywhere near perfect, but for me his flexibility with short benches puts him up on Grossman. For all of DanSans faults, he doesn't approach RG's ineptitude with a glove, or arm. Keeping Grossman as a 4th OF is hopeless. He can't throw well enough for LF, let alone RF, and certainly can't run enough for CF. he did validate one of my long held beliefs about hitting though. If you stand there long enough, and the pitcher isn't paying attention to who he is throwing to, you can eek out a walk. If he does, you get called out o strikes!
- Everyday Shortstop
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
Sometomes I regret that TD only allows a simple like, not one that can be elevated to say a 10. One of the hardest things to find is an elite glove at SS. Simply trying to justify substandard leather at that position, with offensive chops borders on delusional. We have spent so many years looking at mediocre defensive SS, we have become complacent about the importance of the position.
-
Article: As The Defense Goes, So Goes The Twins
I want to semi like this! . But until Molitor proves he will handle a 4th OF as a 4th OF, any moves in that area are kinda scary. That said, if he uses a R. Grossman that much, maybe there is nothing to be done. I just hope if Molitor doesn't change his ways, the axe is swift and early. I can't watch another year of auditioning veteran AAAA players, while the future sits on the bench!
-
Article: As The Defense Goes, So Goes The Twins
I was surprised to find Keplers MiLB reps were that low in RF? I do think he isn't going to be a defensive problem in the future at all. I also think Sano will be an astounding 3rd basemen. He will astound you with a great play one inning, and astound you with a horrible play later. But you have to give him a shot, it's one of the cores to getting back on track. I have never saw Vielma play, but all accounts say he can pick it. There are various pieces that have to all be moved to make this happen. Dozier for a pitcher, getting Polanco to second, and a glove at SS. There will no doubt be a few struggles originally with offense, but teams who play what I call "clean" baseball are more successful and can improve. As someone else here said, this team is not as far away as some think. I agree. But it all hinges on putting this jigsaw puzzle together.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
All in all very valid, and well written. But it ignores one simple fact. The team is not winning with its offense at second base. Nor will it improve greatly if you keep Dozier, and replace the at least 15 HR's he won't hit this year with Sano's, Buxtons and Keplers. It's still going to leave you weak up the middle, and short of pitching. Now if you replace Dozier with a pitcher, and find Polancos second base defense a wash, and his hitting for a higher avg and plenty EBH's , and superior speed, you still have what better be an improved Sano et al in place, plus I would hope at a minimum a #2 starter. And move on a defensive SS upgrade ASAP. There's nothing wrong with keeping Doziers hitting, but frankly he's needed for bigger things. Pitching. As for the Twins relying on BD for power, if in two years he's your best power hitter, the problems this team now faces, are minsicule.
-
All Star Changes Are Only Half The Battle
Making the ASG the determination of home field always made me wonder how Selig ever got to a position like his in the first place. Yes, I know money had a lot to do with it! But if you make that kind of thin skinned decision over the outcome of a glorified exhibition game, just think of what happened when real pressure was placed on him. All ASG are about players, not "teams". Who gives a rats rear end whether the NL or AL wins. The NBA seems to have the best handle on this. Shoot early, shoot often, and don't get hurt!
-
Ryan Speaks About Leaving
Terry Ryan made a few comments about his leaving last summer. The article said he dispelled rumors of a difference of direction with Pohlad. But Ryans quote, "I better not get into that" seems to infer that all was not duckies and bunnies. And while Falvey had made a comment that TR would be welcome back into the orginisation in some capacity, that also seemed to be somewhat in question. Two other tidbits included. One on the Twins new hitting coach, and Bill Smith leaving which is already another post on TD. http://www.startribune.com/ex-twins-gm-terry-ryan-i-just-didn-t-win-enough-games/404151466/
-
Mike Napoli
I personally like Napoli, and in a different time in Twins history would be all for this. Giving up the roster spot, to win a couple more games in what promises to be a mediocre season makes no sense to me. I would rather roll the dice with Park and Vargas, and I am not even a big believer in Parks abilities. But since you can't get anything for either of them now, one might as well find out if you have something or not.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
Teams "hide" poor gloves on the corners. But to do that you need the middle guys to take as many chances as possible away from them. Polanco doesn't do that, and Doziers range isn't elite either. Buxton fulfills that criteria in center, but we have become so complacent to substandard SS play that many were content with Nunez? Good grief. One can just not afford to underestimate the impact a quality middle IF brings to a team, especially one with a PTC history. This team butchered double plays last year in an alarming fashion. That alone needs to improve.
-
Article: Twins New Front Office Off To Strong Start
I liked the Castro signing and some of the 40 man pruning, I don't really care if they overpaid for him, something had to be done behind the plate, my only concern with his offense would be Molitors seeming lack of interest in platooning. That would nullify the theory of Ryan picking up the RH at bats. And leaving Plouffe walk started the process of clarifying the direction of the roster, a process which is going to take well into next year to accomplish in full.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
The things I would trade Dozier for: 1. Pitching 2. Pitching 3. Pitching 4. Someone to flip for pitching 5. An elite defensive SS. Teams that pitch and field well, always have a chance to win. And a chance to win improves the overall attitudes and efforts of everyone. Too many games played with MiLB talented SP, who give up 2 runs in the first inning wear on a team. Hitting would improve also, it's always easier to hit when your ahead. Bottom line, nothing this team does, or trades for should use offense as a criteria. No player like Puig. Pitching and improving defense, especially up the middle.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
When I consider trading Dozier I take several things into consideration, and as one poster said, some irrational and likely baseless. Dozier has peaked and is going into his thrities. I personally have never considered him an actual power hitter, and I think that anyone who tried to use him in the middle of the order would find that out in a hurry. He would definitely get pitched differently. We needed the good Dozier twice in the last two years. The end of '15 to finish of the drive to the second WC, and the beginning of '16 to get off on the right foot. He was nowhere to be found. And lastly while Polanco will likely not hit the number of HR's, he will end up a better hitter overall, and no worse a second baseman. Plus it removes Polanco from SS, a position that the Twins really need to upgrade past his level.
-
Article: Dozier Trade Talk Heating Up?
Short of trading one of the building block young players the Twins have almost no other means of acquiring some talent in the starting pitching dept other than trading Dozier. And with our dirth of SP I would take the best offer out there this off season. With another player, I might roll the dice and wait for 2017 to see if we could capitalize on his value with a contender desperate for help in the middle of the year. But Doziers history of lengthly cold spells makes that a real gamble. Which BD would one be trading next July? In this case I would go with the bird in the hand option.
-
3 proposals that could pry Dozier away from the Twins
Or, heaven forbid, he baited the trap with just the right amount of cheese?
-
Article: Twins Add Six Players To 40-Man Roster
Robbie may be like Larkin, but that was when bench spots were easier to come by. The seemingly 24 man pitching staff makes roster decisions different now than then. That said, RG just cannot be left loose in the OF. He makes DanSan look like Torii Hunter. And whether he could be construed a s a DH bat, that's a position over populated already. Watching Robbie play OF is bad for the analytical crowd. They see him on the field, in action, and end up throwing their laptop at the tv!
-
Twins Turkey of the Year
I totally agree with you on the hands off owner viewpoint. I wish he had extended that philosophy to Molitor. The business connection between their descendants could be a conflict, or it might not be. But his attachment to Molitor seems excessive.
-
The Path To A Competent Rotation: A Shorter Trip Than You May Think
I do think the FO plans for Murphy to be the "yin". I just hope that Molitor does also. To me the big unknown will be whether Molitor will change his style to coincide with the FO vision? And if not, how big will Pohlads safety net be?
-
Twins Turkey of the Year
I understand the Ryan "fans", but he was just being Ryan. The Turkey was Pohlad who allowed him to continue in his position far longer than any owner who had an interest in a competitive team would have. Whether it was from what I believe was the use of the bottom line to asses the teams success, or Pohlads actual inability to discern Ryans failures, is a moot point. At my feast, Molitor would have been the yams, Ryan the dressing (or stuffing for some), but JP was the grand entree!