Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. This is maybe a simplistic version of whether to buy or sell. But, the Twins should no more make their decision on buy/sell on the Oakland series, than on the Dodger series. They should make it on what they need to do to be (truly) competitive. Whether they sweep the A's or get swept their strengths and deficiencies remain in place. They have 3 shortstops, one can't field at a high level, one can't hit, and one can't currently do either. They have a ground ball closer who is starting to be abused. They have no bench bat. They have some excellent young positional talent. They have an expendable second baseman, DH (RG) and the aforementioned closer. None of this changes this weekend. Beating Oakland is the same as losing to the Dodgers. You still retain middle of the pack mediocrity. Let's use Dozier or Santana as an example. Those who say that both will help the Twins next year are to an extent correct. But unless you use them, or some other players who would also fall in that category as trade chips, it's a moot point. You cannot win with this roster, and whether it's Santana or Dozier or ???, that is the problem. And it does not change no matter the outcome in Oakland.
  2. I understand your point, to a point. That said, I can't see either Santana or Doziers trade value increasing. But it could easily decrease. I should have added Robbie Grossman to the list. Some have considered Rosario. I at this time would not. Granted he does not play baseball like a rocket scientist, but he has talent. I remember when KC had all that youth. I also remember it seemed to take much longer for it to come to fruition than the good folks in MO thought acceptable.
  3. I wrote a shorter version of this the other day. There is no worse place to be than treading water. . I had made the observation that the Indians were not being curteous enough to run away from the division, and that was unfortunate. It would be nice to believe this team is "there", but it isn't. So far Falvine has resisted the temptation to trade off the future for a faux run at the second WC, and their stated intent is to keep that philosophy. I also hope they add this thought to their operating modus. Trade Kintzler, Dozier, and Santana for the best talent you can get. None of them will be an asset when and if this team is relevant. I waffled on Santana as he is a pitcher, but he has reverted to what he always was. Jekyl and Hyde Santana. And focus on pitching, pitching, and more pitching. I still think the offense will mature. I know the opinion stated is not popular after the last 6-7 years, but if we don't want another lost decade, we need to improve the roster for the next 5 years, not the next 5 weeks.
  4. This almost has to be about roster flexibility. I am not a Gibson fan. He has "stuff", he just gets nothing out of it. But as noted above, he finally pitches a really nice game, and POOF, he ends up in NY, and I don't mean with the Yankees. Really weird. But I guess it's understandable. Colon has been outstanding, getting us unscathed through the first four innings. You on the other hand, Gibson is normally only good for about four innings before he falls apart. Easy decision!
  5. My question on today's BP management was mostly about Kintzler to hold an already one run deficit. He got 4 outs yesterday, and throwing again today does one of two things. Precludes him from throwing tomorrow night, or risks him being rode hard by a manager who is known for that practice? The only reason I could imagine bringing in Kintlzer down one, was that they consider the Colon game tomorrow night a throw away. Plus, is it just my imagination, or do closers seem to perform poorly in these hold em close assignments. I seem to remember Perkins get hammered in those types of situations.
  6. No denying that. 2015 was fun. And 2016 was great for those of us who enjoy the dark side of humor. But in a manner you clarify my premise. I hope Falvine does not make decisions on whether we will enjoy August and September, or whether they can sell another 100,000 tickets. I hope decisions are based on long term sustainability.
  7. It's been nagging me for a few weeks. The thought that this is sort of like 2015 all over. That the Twins will be stuck in a neutral universe. Too good to sell, and to bad to buy. I know that there are lots of teams that are on the periphery, just within playoff contention. But there are differences in these teams. Some have the talent to be there, but have not played well, and some don't have the talent, but have played over their head. I find the Twins in the latter group. There should be no conceivable way they are contending with this pitching staff. Credit must be given to Cleveland for their absolute refusal to run away from a weak division. But that curtesy does not change the fact that the Twins are still deeply flawed. Their many attributes are cancelled out by their many deficiencies. Leaving them what they are. A .500 team at best. As discussions here have shown, being a buyer or a seller is largely a matter of personal preference by fans. But I hope when Falvine makes their upcoming decisions they put more weight into what is best for the long term sustainable success of the franchise, than the short term feel good of yet another faux #2 WC chase.
  8. When I first heard the Twins announce the Colon signing, I assumed he was going to be a host at Twins Fantasy Camp, and hang with Bert and The Boys. I had no idea that Fantasy Camp rules require you to have actually played with The MLB Twins before you can become a host. Full Disclosure: I realize the foregoing is not true, but I wish it was. It would be far better than the actual truth!
  9. Polanco is way too young to give up on! He has always hit. He will most likely hit again. As for his defense. When you put a player in a position that his tools do not align with, you get what you deserve. He certainly seems more suited to second base. But I won't rehash that. Just because Molitor thinks he is a SS doesn't make him a good one. He could squeeze by in the position if one was willing to settle for a mediocre team. Btw, I don't consider his bat when I say this. SS is a position where you live and die by the glove. Hitting should be optional. If you rationalize a poor fielding SS, because of a good bat, it's akin to saying a lousy pitcher who can hit sure looks good in the lineup!
  10. Gibson has not been good. Yes I know that's obvious. And he is aggravating to watch. But he does have some inherent ability. It wouldn't be quite so bad if he was our solid #5, instead of what is supposed to be a mid rotation slot. We don't even have a #5 at the present time. I once had a 20 ish year old pitch for me in amateur ball. My impression of him was he had a division 2 arm, and a division 6 (pitching) brain!
  11. I would love Bautista, and am no fan of RG. I still think Vargas has at least an upside. But to me, any money, prospects or veterans traded, should solely go into the pitching pool. Abysmal doesn't even begin to describe our pitching.
  12. I can't see there winning % continuing for many of the reasons stated above. And I can live with that because frankly they just do not have the arms to contend. And it's not just one arm short, it's basically half a staff, with no realistic way to acquire them in time to help this year. It has been written by some that the Twins "owe" it to the fans and players to go all in for this year? I think what they owe the fans is to finally put together a sustainable orginisation that plays fundamentally sound baseball with a decent roster construct. Basically, I hope Falvine and Molitor don't do any serious damage in a vain attempt to make this team something it isn't. Every move made should be to improve the team so that the young core of this roster can succeed in the next 4 years.
  13. I had an acquaintance who thought Harmon Killebrew was a bum. And I was a huge Harmon fan. So every time he saw me, or for that matter anyone who would listen, he would blast The Killer. So at the most 3-6 people heard him rant after Harmon struck out with the bases loaded. For broader distribution, he would have had to type a letter and mail it to an editor who would not have included it in the daily newspaper. By that time Harmon might have hit three more HR's. I don't know if life was better then, but it was simpler. With no one particularly in mind, the the lack of technology allowed you to express your opinions mostly to people who already knew them, and had judged you thusly.
  14. I thought Granites catch was "not too shabby". But that was about it. I find it hard to believe that Buxtons defense is being challenged by someone who managed to run back on a high fly ball and not drop it. Barring injury Buxton should be a fixture in CF for years. If Molitor starts jerking him around so he can play Granite, I would find it necessary to take up a Twitter, so I could tweet my displeasure in real time!
  15. I would be of the sell mode, and it would Dozier, and Grossman. Rosaio if I got more than I expected, and Santana in the same frame. Sadly, I doubt you will get any young pitching for anyone other than Erv. As one can see by watching this years baseball pitching is not easy to come by. But in general I would be in sell mode. Not tear down mode. Sell, with emphasis and tweaking the SP. Sanatana is the problem. He is the only practical value we have to trade, and we don't have enough pitching to trade pitching.
  16. I would believe that dealing with Arcia would drive veteran staid baseball men like Molitor and Ryan BS crazy. And Oswaldo didn't help himself either. I have watched his MiLB numbers a bit. He will resurface. Guys with his power are like high velocity pitchers. You can't teach it, so they keep getting a look. I still think he will make it. MLB is full of bat guys in the corner positions that are not adept with a glove. I hope he makes it, I loved watching him hit a baseball.
  17. As to the steal, the runner on third had to have broken very early, otherwise the way it was defensed gets him. Even with Doziers arm, which btw seems to be getting a "little less stronger" lately. Dozier did what he could, chasing the guy at first was not going to keep the run from scoring. On another point, yes we could have electronic everything, but why stop at balls and strikes. 3 video umps per game. (the older ones who stopped at the brat stand too often) . They watch every play. See a shoulder twitch, BALK! A close play, REPLAY! A player mouth the F word. EJECTION. There would be no end to the level of technology or insanity, the amount of replays or the length of the game. Ugh!
  18. Oh please, please, let's not have electronically called balls and strikes. I managed,and hated umps! Then I umped, and hated managers! But they have to be part of the game. i watched most of the game, but missed a few parts. I read that the Twins suicide squeezed with two outs? And had no one to PH for Castro in the 9th as we were carrying 9? relief pitchers? Maybe we also need electronic FO people, and an electronic manager? Too bad someone doesn't invent a game we could play on like a TV screen, and eliminate all the human beings completely!
  19. There are a lot of things for Twins fans, and the Twins themselves to worry about. Byron Buxton is not one of them.
  20. Good point. The Pohlads adversity to opening up the vault is sometimes overstated. Cases in point. Several weeks ago Jim handed out free replacement tickets to that 6 hour rain delay game, that was over in 6 minutes. And just last winter he kept a friend of his gainfully employed, in tough times, when all logic would have done otherwise.
  21. I would not want to try and straighten out this pitching mess. There aren't enough assets to trade, nor enough cash that will be ok'ed to make this staff functional in the near term. But I do know that if I was Falvine, and I considered this an evaluation year, I would stick with my original plan. There is no foreseeable route to the playoffs with either this pitching staff, or anything they could scrape together given the above limitations. Hopefully they continue to clarify the roster, and keep adding pieces the best they can. Any attempt at a quick fix will be regretted for years.
  22. I tried to find a Chinese restaurant in Ames one evening. It was not easy. Ames is a huge city!
  23. With all due respect to the OP, this is what happens after watching a "pitching" staff operate at this level for oh so many years. Desperation for a silver lining in any cloud sets in!

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.