Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. To expand a little on Jimbo's take. My lifelong neighbor was a very good amateur catcher and later a very good plate umpire. He always told me pulling the glove is useless. It's too obvious. But turning your body in to the plate, and catching the corners with the glove turned in shows the umpire the baseball. As does getting low and ease of movement. While I know that the line between balls and strikes in MLB is much finer, the principles are the same. In some of the frames shown Castro seems to be blatantly pulling the ball. On that point, as an umpire, when my friend heard a catcher question a non strike call after the catcher had pulled the ball over the plate he would ask the guy, "if it was so good, why did you have to pull it"? That was generally the end of the discussion. That said, I know that there are MLB catchers that are better than others at framing. The seemingly recent discover surprises me though. But then you read the Gladden comment, and wonder how Danno got a job as an analyst having not noticed something that I taught my kids
  2. By the end of this off season, one should have a fairly good handle on the Twins new MO. But, it may be not as new as we would have liked. It could be the "new improved" version of their old MO. At this point they do not seem serious about a big buck FA acquisition, nor have they made any indication of making a blockbuster trade for a frontline SP. which leaves us with the upgraded TwinsWorld2. This version continues the ever popular economically conservative roster tweaking, and combines it with a modern system of analytics, scouting, drafting and player improvement. As an added attraction, a change in the motif of one of the drinking establishment in Target Field will be included at no additional cost. . Sarcasm aside, it is not an undoable process. While it does rely on being smarter than everyone in the room, it is also the only competitive alternative to a controlled payroll and limited trading philosophy. It could work, but if and when it does, the core group of players on this roster will not be involved in the result.
  3. Dangle Darvish. Sign Miley. I don't know about baseball, but in retail I think that's called bait and switch? .
  4. There is a difference between hoping the Twins would shell out the money for a high profile FA, and seriously thinking they would. For the latter, Lucy is still holding that football on the ground waiting for you.
  5. And that should be the narrative, it it comes to pass. If nothing else, if this all fizzles as it now appears it may, we can resume normal operating procedures. No longer a need to daydream about shiny new toys. The light at the end of the tunnel will have to be drafting, development, innovative trade moves, and maybe a little more agression in retaining core homegrown players. I have no real problem with that scenario if all of these operational philosophies are in in use. But if we get squeamish and greedy about trading to fill needed spots, that whole business plan collapses in a pile of mediocrity.
  6. It's exciting to see JP so fully invested in the hunt for high profile after all these years of just mouthing the words. I have no doubt he will soon open the vault and make a big splash signing! ............................ OK, I WAST JUST KIDDING,
  7. I would also prefer the pre Tommy John, pre leg condition, pre accusation, and pre conditioning issues, Miguel Sano. If I thought that was what I was keeping. But I don't think that's anywhere near a certainty. And that is what, at least to me, makes his value subjective and elusive. Or as Shelock said, "therein lies the question".
  8. Sano is all the things you mentioned. But the health, conditioning and "baggage" issues mitigate those pluses. What Sano is not is a pitcher. One could easily say that Sano is too valuable to trade. And if that's ends up precluding a SP acquisition, then Sano will likely end up his Twins career as a fairly decent DH on a team that is always on the fringe of the second WC slot. The Twins dilemma is not about upgrading a position like RF or even SS, it's about upgrading the entire team with one core player. And you are not going to get such a player at a market price. The Twins are in a "what can you do for me now" period.
  9. I would prefer Archer over Darvish, and keeping the prospects over the money. But those two preferences clash. So would Sano, with his warts, mitigate the prospect cost? I know this is harsh, and I don't know if other GM'S would feel the same way, but if I am the Twins trading Sano to get an Archer level pitcher would be a plus/plus. While I still expect Sano to be an elite level hitter when on the field, I just cannot see that happening. I highly doubt he wants to be a full time DH, and it doesn't seem an unhappy Sano makes a contribution to the roster. As for our glut of MI, I would not worry. There is plenty room for defensive improvement in the MI.
  10. My top three would be P. Jones, B. Smith, and D. Toles. Now some may question whether these names appear on either the Twins MiLB or MLB payrolls. I have no idea, but with the spelling Police out in full force, I considered this much safer than someone like Hosae Berriohs .
  11. So we are simply left to accept your eye test of the Radish as fact? It's well documented that personalities affect the perception of a Radishes worth. Old line FO types in the Radish league are getting very hard to find. It's a new era. Show us the facts.
  12. I know RF is considered tougher at Target Field than left, but I sure would prefer that arm of his was in RF vs LF. Especially when Robbie G. Is in RF!
  13. I don't think Rosario ever ran exceptional routes to a baseball. But what he did do was throw the ball with velocity and accuracy better than most. That certainly impacts the eye test in evaluating his defense. Some of those throwing opportunities are now gone, the extra base ones where there was a reasonable chance to get an out. Players seem to have quit taking the dare. One other question, or point. Did Rosario spend more time this year shuttling around the OF filling in for Kepler, or some time spent in CF? Or is that simply my perception.
  14. From what I could see this year, most of the Packer fans had already jumped off the mountain voluntarily. He must have been the last holdout?
  15. I won't even begin to try and put numbers on a Buxton extension. But as a general point, if I was going to extend anyone, maybe anyone in MLB, it would be him. His ceiling is stratospheric. And his floor is only going to be determined with an injury, which is unforseeable. His defense is already elite, as is his speed and baserunning. His hitting may not end up elite, but I bet there will be a lot of guys on the stat sheets looking up at him. As for whom, Buxton or Sano to tie down first? I don't see that as much of a decision. Injuries and other issues have riddled Sano with question marks. He, not Buxton would be the one I let settle in for a year. Btw, I totally agree with the poster that said without some more quality pitching, this whole conversation may be irrelevant.
  16. So? In other words you operate just like everyone else on here, myself included. :)
  17. You had me until you said "market deal". Perhaps I am jaded by years of MN sports history, but when one lists the Twins, Astros, and Cubs in the hunt, it doesn't seem a market deal will suffice.
  18. I am nowhere near a metrics guy. But this one seems so flawed by its inability to consider location. Pitching is like real estate, location, location, location. While this seems a good tool to measure "stuff", it would sure seem to ignore control. While I am sure there are far better examples, Samuel Deduno comes to mind. Electric "stuff", but couldn't hit a barn door with it.
  19. Baseball is an entertainment business. As such it relies disproportionately on the fans perception of their products likeability, unlike say a plumber. Their product is a sum of its parts, players and staff. This makes Sano's alleged behavior(s) part and parcel of his value. The relationship is inescapable. This would apply whether the act was as alleged, or if it was shoplifting, armed robbery, or a DUI. For each act there would be consequences to the player. Civil, criminal, and MLB related. From there on it is also unavoidable that each FO, field staff member, advertiser, and fan would form their own opinion of how they would proceed with not only their perception of the player, but in some cases his continued financial value to them, be it on the field or as a trade piece. These considerations are inescapable. I don't know whether Sano did what he was accused of, nor do I know what MLB will do in regards to it. But there will be fans who do not go to games because of it, and fans who do not care. That is to each their own decision. I don't live in their world, nor do I have to approve of their values. FO's types will use a far more calculating metric on the moralities of his alleged actions. Each has different types of constituencies to consider. And those groups will impact Sanos value to that GM when he considers whether it's feasible to put the teams uniform on his back. Like it or not, the recent allegations about Miguel Sano will remain intrinsic to his value for a long time, if not the entirety of his career.
  20. While I disagree that there is a 50/50 chance on Darvish coming here I liked the rest of your comments. The place where something like WAR gets over emphasized is when specific needs are ignored. This is such a case. Gordon's rankings and future seems to be going downhill lately, and I cannot believe that with the exception of his really cool name Zach Granite is quite easily replaceable. Jay would be a concern, but one has to give up something to get anything. To me, and I would imagine many others, the Twins need for SP is so desperate, that while not throwing caution to the winds, it certainly impacts their leverage in trade considerations. While that is not a best case scenario, it is what it is.
  21. If I could find a trade partner whose team is in a market that could overlook recent issues that have surfaced, and those teams do exist, then I would trade Sano if I could get some reasonable return in the starting pitching department. There are so many flags here, both on and off the field. And that's a shame, I was very much looking forward to his career with the Twins. I thought he would end up something special. I am not sure that will ever happen.
  22. None of the numbers seem overwhelming, but one seems underwhelming. Buxtons BA. I think it will be north of .270. That's the good news. But Sano is the bad news. I doubt that suspension or not he will be ready to play effectively this spring. For years he was, and I thought he would be, a cornerstone of the offense. I am not so sure that is still a given.
  23. One more thought before I move on with my life. I am sure JP does make an attempt to make the Twins more appealing, on or off field. He is a businessman and knows the need to market. But all businesses also decide whether money's spent on improving the product get a desired return. Some fans think Pohlad should spend some of his "own" money to bring in high end FA simply because as an owner he should also be a fan. There are a few owners like that. JP is not one of them. Therefore while I would liker to see a legitimate big name signing, I won't be disappointed when it doesn't happen. Nor would I bash Pohlad. It simply is what it is.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.