Everything posted by Platoon
- Article: A Central Of Historic Proportions
-
Robo Umps
I don't remember saying we can't do it. I do remember saying that even after we went to the base and foul ball version of Robo, we still don't eliminate the disagreements. But what we did do is extend the game time, and allow more free time for bathroom breaks. And we made the game just a little less liveable in some people's minds. My argument against Robo umps has nothing to do with their inability to be perfect. I accept that. I just don't think the difference will warrant upsetting a long time component of the game. By the by, if I was a proponent of, or insistent on perfection, I highly doubt I would be on TD! . .
-
Article: Why The Twins May Opt For Short-Term SP Commitment
IF I had any belief, or the Twins had any history of signing a top flight FA, I could buy into the strategy of evaluating the questions in this years staff, May, Gonsalves, etc. Then when those results are in, buy a mid season rental, or a big signing next year. But there isn't anything in the Twins DNA that shows that a legitimate possibility. NADA.
-
Robo Umps
It seems our closest proximation to Robo Umps would be instant replay. I think tennis may have something closer for line calls, but I kept getting a kink in my neck from watching it, so I quit. And even with the aid of instant replays, tags and foul balls and HR poles shown to the N-th of a degree, we still cannot always agree on the result.
-
Robo Umps
If robots have aspirations, whether they are used for plate umpiring will be the least of our problems.
-
Robo Umps
The plate umpire didn't figure into that bit of heroic narrative at all.>>>>>>>>. And that is the goal of the very good umpire.
-
My prediction for which FA pitcher the Twins pick up is....
Duensing. Not because he would help the SP, but without him who are we all going to offer in a mid season trade for Mike Trout when Buxton runs into a wall in late June.
-
Robo Umps
I don't think so. Rightfully or not, catchers and umpires end up with a "relationship". They get beat up together, and each have the same view of the game. A good catcher will never tell his pitcher a ball was a strike, it makes the pitcher upset, and the umpire more so. I showed up to do a game once for the same team the third time in about 2 weeks. I mentioned to the coach that we sure seem to see a lot of each other. He said, "makes no difference to me, my catcher likes you, that's all I care about".
-
Robo Umps
I will have to paraphrase somewhat since its been a long time since I heard this. Maddux once was asked after a game about his pinpoint control. He said something to this extent: If I throw 100 pitches in a game, I hit my spot about 80 times. I will miss badly enough on around 15 which you won't be able to hit anyway. That leaves you 5 pitches to hit in a game.
-
Robo Umps
There is a difference between accepting the fact that human beings officiating sporting events are not perfect, and contending that a segment of the fans enjoy that fact, or embrace it. To the contrary. I don't enjoy watching a crappy job, whether it be a touch foul basketball referee, or an inconsistent plate ump, or someone who cuts me off on the freeway and then drives 57 mph. Accepting the fact that the preceding issues happen in the course of a day is a lot less stress. And trying to remedy each to the point of perfection will in all likelihood make all of them worse.
-
Article: Open Windows
When using a deep playoff run, not just a one and done second WC as a bench mark, I think that window is open, but not as far as I had thought it would be a few years ago. The failure of so many of the high velocity BP arms to produce, the continuing lack of a legitimate #1 starter, and a fairly mediocre level of defense in the IF makes this a far more difficult project than I had anticipated. Spring training will flesh out the roster issues somewhat but it seems the SP issue will go unresolved, some due to options, and some due to indecisiveness. And the Sano issue could be an all season problem for any of several reasons. If the division is as weak as it seems we may pad our win total to allow a second WC appearance. Yawn.
-
Whine Line Investigation: Explanation for a Boring Off-season
Your article never addressed the most compelling question. What exactly did you guys decide to eat? Or did you even manage to order before the lunch menu time frame expired? Instead of the intern you should have taken me. For one thing I have never been to a Cheesecake Factory. And for another I will go with anyone who picks up the tab. Plus I am decisive. I would have immediately went with the spaghetti and meatballs, likely the cheapest option. This also would have given you a closer comparison to what being Falvine is really like. .
-
Robo Umps
While I am sure Sam will have his own answer to the above, a couple general points come to mind in several sports. Basketball crews are well known for having different tendencies in how close they call a game, or even a half. If it gets too rough they tighten it up, later in a game they often "let you play". Some football officials call holding endlessly, others don't as often. Some baseball umpires have a low zone, or a big outside corner. All that said, I highly doubt that the results of many games will change. But I think the way the game is played, viewed, discussed, and appreciated will. Far more than many think.
-
Robo Umps
What I detest about instant replay is the delay so the manager can get input from someone on a replay to see if he should challenge. That's BS. If the call is so obviously wrong, throw the flag or beanbag or whatever. If it takes a microscope to determine the difference then you really have no idea what happened. But if you think you were wronged, go for it. One wrong challenge is all you get. That also would speed the game.
-
Robo Umps
The solution! Holographic (3D) umpires. Maybe use Leslie Nielsen in 'Naked Gun' as the prototype?
-
Robo Umps
Reading is what I would be doing right now, except I got caught up in an infantile discussion started by some poster about officiating! :)
-
Robo Umps
Another thought. What will the elimination of calling balls and strikes do to the umpiring profession. Most umpires view the plate assignment as the most coveted spot. I always did. Not only did I not enjoy the base position, I also found the plate easier to handle. You got into a rhythm and on most days it just flowed. While one could argue that for the kind of money MLB umps make, there will be plenty of them, I don't want umpires who do it for the cash. I want umpires who do it because they love what they do.
-
Robo Umps
Robo or not there will have to be a human official behind the plate. Foul ticks, interference, line violations, foul balls grazing the screen, out of play calls. Rotations on the bases. I also think that Robo umps will change how players are viewed. Whether this is a plus or minus depends on ones viewpoint. But, during the 2020 WS, Brian Dozier, in the second year of a $180M deal, takes a 3-2 called third strike with the bases loaded, bottom of 9, Twins down by one run. Robo ump with a 99.7% accuracy rating rules the pitch hit the outside .25 of the plate. Twins color man Bert Blyleven says nary a word about black being part of the plate. While the accuracy of the call will be quite ok, the tenor of the off season would seem to change dramatically. As will how we watch a game. No more shots of a players pained expression after a called third strike as he trudges to the dugout, looking back at the plate ump. For him it's a resigned look, for the viewer at home, instead of a thoughtful self discussion on the validity of that call, it will be a benign yawn while you wait for the endless beer commercials to cease.
-
Article: Dozier Debate: Contract Extension? Pace of Play?
The problem with extending Dozier is you almost have to then trade some MI talent. And they haven't shown any indication of trading anything so far. If you can't count on one or two of their MI prospects making the jump soon, there is no sense in having a scouting or analytical dept. Tat said, I would not extend Dozier, and since it's too late to effectively trade him I would let it play out. I highly doubt I would then keep him. In a perfect world I would use that money on pitching.
-
Robo Umps
I lifted this link from another blogger whom I read with regularity. It's a lengthly piece on the concept of the electronic strike zone. I have never been a fan of the idea, mostly for reasons of tradition. But everyone has their own take on the concept. It's a pretty indepth discussion, maybe it will cause some to revisit their own perception of the whole issue. Regardless, to paraphrase what a very wise man said recently, "who would have thought balls and strikes could be so complicated"? https://www.baseballprospectus.com/news/article/37347/robo-strike-zone-not-simple-think/
-
The Twins should sign Yu Darvish, regardless of price
Several posters on here, Mike and Chief come to mind, have made a valid observation if I am interpreting them correctly. And that is that their is a time to "overspend" and a time not to. This would be a time for the Twins to overspend. All professional sports teams operate in windows of opportunity. While,the length of time between those windows varies for numerous reasons, the Twins are in one. And in the Twins most recent history, that is a rarity. While I wont relitigate the pros and cons of a trade v a big FA payout, the bottom line is either you pay up now and take a shot at winning it all, or you remain simply one of many competitive teams with its most important part missing. Elite baseball pitcher sand football QB's are unique in that you can surround either with an average team and win, but you cannot do the reverse.
-
I do not want Darvish, but thanks for disagreeing.
I agree three years for Yu is about the farthest I would go. But, and there is always a but, then there has to be an alternative. And I don't see one. They exist, for example a trade for someone like Archer, or signing a top end arm next year. But neither really seems plausible. The teams window is now. That is the only thing that makes me think Darvish at 5-6 years makes any sense at all. He should fill a spot when it's most needed. Five years from now, if Twins history and MLB history in general are any bell weather, Darvish and his dead contract will be a moot point. They won't have the talent to compete anyway. They will be back into full rebuild mode, and his money won't really make a difference. While I said I don't think a trade for an Archer type would happen, it would still be my preference. A Sano for Archer? Crazy? It could be if you thought that Sano would fulfill the prophecy and become the elite hitter he was projected to be. I wish he would, but I just can't see it. There's too many flags already, and I doubt we have saw the last of them.
-
Article: Report: Darvish Decision Expected This Week, Twins In Consideration
I think the impression was that the new Twins FO would make for a change in the manner in which high end FA were pursued. The Twins have always proclaimed themselves in on the newest shiny object. The Twins were always "interested", be it FA, trade possibilities, or Cubans. But so far in the SS alloted to the new FO the process is eerily familiar. While Darvish has yet to announce, it seems very much like the ever familiar "gosh, we were right into until the end, we thought we had a very good chance". This is likely the reason skepticism abounds, and optimism is bleak as regards any significant action on the pitching front. Whether one thinks Darvish is the answer or not, the fact of the matter is the Twins are never going to significantly change their position on top flight FA's. While I do believe there is a chance for the new FO to improve the roster by some better evaluation of talent, and hopefully improvise MiLB functions, I have no hope for big time acquisitions or trades. In those two instances the new FO is just like the old one, simply with more hair.
-
Article: Video: Slowing Things Down To See Jason Castro’s Silent Skill
"The goal at the end of the day is to try to help your pitcher keep as many strikes as possible," Castro said. "And to not do anything to take away from presenting pitches that are in the strike zone to the umpires that would lead them to believe that any given pitch is not a strike." Maybe the most pertinent thing said on this topic so far. Don't give away strikes being jumpy or awkward.
- Article: The Minnesota Twins Said No To Jim Thome