Everything posted by Platoon
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
It's a circular reference!
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
Some valid points. But like all things, circumstances need to be taken into consideration. Down 3, leading off the bottom of ninth. Morrison AB. Bunt for a baserunner, or the slight chance of a HR, or a single against the shift? (No Morrison jokes please). Same situation 2 on, 2 out? I know these are simplistic variables, but one can see how each AB does not call for a cut and dried action.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
From Joe P. "But they don't because the shift is more than a defensive strategy. The shift is a psychological game, and has been since the days of Ted Williams. It is meant to convince hitters that they don't really have the option to bunt or chop the ball the other way. To do that, the shift suggests, is to hurt yourself and the team.". This is most likely why more players don't bunt. And I think you can add one or two others. Certain players have been, since they started playing, known for their hitting more than any other part of their game. I have no doubt that many view bunting as beneath their status as an offensive threat, and............... The money is in home runs, not in bunting. This could or could not be what Joe P. meant by "hurt yourself", but it is how I would interpret some players insistence on hitting against the shift.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
Well a .666 BABIP isn't bad either, but I am not sure it's that simple. Does it delineate if it's one foul or missed bunt attempt, and then a ground ball to the pocket man? As for the amount of attempts? From listening to active players and former players it seems there is a definite lack of enthusiasm for the tactic. I get the impression that it's almost viewed as not only disrespectful of the game, but also not playing fair. I don't agree and I do think if it becomes a more regular weapon it will grow in acceptance.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
Agreed. But also noted that if one has enough bat control to change change his launch angle, one can learn to hit a 30' wide patch of grass with a bunt.
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
I have a ton of opinions on unwritten rules, for another day. And btw I love to discuss those rules. And in retrospect maybe I should have left Dozier and the unstolen base out or the OP. I am more interested in what teams will do to combat what is becoming a plethora of shifts. They used to be reserved for big power pull hitters, or so it seemed. Now it causes almost more discussion when their isn't one. The other question is, what if not bunts, are the options?
-
William Tecumseh Sherman
Nice story. . Interesting, and it certainly puts Doziers theory on bunting against the shift the other day in perspective. Btw, good thing the game was not as organized in those days. The catcher who threw the potato to third in MiLB was, I think, banned for life? Just think if the potato was loaded?
-
To bunt, or not to bunt? That is the question.
While a lot of the angst over the bunt against the shift the other day focused on Berrios's none no hitter, the unwritten rules of the game, and Dozier's somewhat confusing statement (see attached) on the bunt in that situation, the actual question of bunting against the shift remains. I always wondered, why not? At the same time I heard pundits like Dan Gladden question it, because you give up the chance for an extra base hit. Supposedly. In theory Danno is correct, in practice it's not that clear. The shift's intent is to prelude not only the extra base hit, but any base hit. The shift is effective in keeping runners off base, and of course producing outs. But it also has what I consider an insidious effect on the game in a more general and negative way. And, to preclude the "sports evolve" discussion I will stipulate that discussion is valid, and frankly true. The question is: Is that change always for the better? For me, the negative impacts the shift has produced are the lessening of the impact a premier defensive player brings to the game. Shortstops no longer are responsible for large areas of real estate, and in many cases neither are center fielders. If you have a "pocket man" your outfielders need less range, and if you are one of three players on one side of the IF, it severely changes your coverage area. Basically, you become a team of hitters, not baseball players. There is of course a second side of this issue. Hitters. You want to eliminate the shift? Go the other way. In theory it's a no brainer. But in the context of that other side of the game, an emphasis on slugging, and a deemphasis on strike outs, it's hard to imagine enough hitters with the talent to perfect opposite field hitting and a power stroke at the same time. In general it's one or the other. Shifting also impacts baserunning, making what used to be no steal scenarios very plausible i.e., stealing third with two outs. It's no longer a cut and dried no-no. It will be interesting to see how the game evolves around this issue. The most obvious deterrent to over shifting is the bunt, but I am sure there will be more to follow. While I hope some day to see the shifts become far less severe and less prevelant, I have no desire to see it done via rule change. There's been enough of that as is. Here is a take on this issue from Ed Thoma's Baseball Outsider blog that I found interesting on the topic. http://fpbaseballoutsider.blogspot.com/ .
-
Twins Upset Over 9th Inning Bunt
I also remember when Rosario took an open third with the shift on. Clean open base.That one sent Molitor into spasms, and I think Rosario either to the bench, or Rochester?
-
Twins Upset Over 9th Inning Bunt
While this discussion will die an early death, I for one, hope teams bunt the shifts to death. I know there is a statistical rationale behind them. But I just think they are getting out of hand. At least for me.
- Miguel Sano Appreciation Thread
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
There's so much cholesterol on this page even my iPad has slowed down..........
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Now we are getting just a little personal..........
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
That's always bothered me....... I wonder if she wasn't really that into him after all?
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Well then I won't tell you what happened at the end. .
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Oh my, I hope it turned out better than the last time I heard that song? The ship sunk.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
IIRC they had him out in that area several years ago?
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
You need new clients!
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
. .............the suspense is killing me.......
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Which one is Ash?
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Xavier would have exceeded the maximum amount of letters in each name by 2.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Having left strict instructions NOT to take the second car out whilst we were out for the evening I was surprised to see it still in perfect position upon our return. The next evening, at supper, I made mention of the luck I had in the morning not breaking my jaw getting into the car. How is that daughter #1 asked? I said it was because she had forgotten to move the seat back after using it the evening before. Lol. So despite putting gas in it, marking the parking spot with pebbles, and readjusting the rear view mirror, they forgot to slide the seat back. They tried so hard, and always were so amazed that they failed so miserably!
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
Was he the same guy who took out some of those paving stones on Superior St? Or did they have a separate specialist for that?
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
I made all the kids learn to drive a stick first. No wimpy automatics. The two girls got to the top of the hill in our local town, and could NOT get going after stopping for a stop sign. They ended up rolling back two blocks to the bottom of the hill and starting over. They said they called me every name they could think of!
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Orioles, 3/31/18 @ 6:05 PM
IF the "same dishwasher for 37 years" was not a reference to marital bliss, and your panel is electronic, there ain't much to fix. I tried to repair my daughters d/w. The panel wasn't repairable, and a new one cost about the same as a new one. And installing a new one is a job for a contortionist with really small hands!