Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. I am no "grammer police either"! I am the "grammar" spell check vice squad! I quit liking English class when I found out I could not use the F word as an action verb!
  2. And the term "personal effects" effectively means your future has been affected permanently!
  3. I found the following an interesting part of Bernadinos talk with Suzuki on pitch framing. I think his observations are mostly spot on. His views on how strikes should or should not be called, and on who to call them on are interesting. While in theory calling a strike zone using these parameters is unfair, it always was done that way. Having umpired myself for some years, there is no doubt the human element is in place. And I guess while it's great to get all the calls right, I do miss the part of the game that instant replay has in essence replaced. But like it or not, it begs the following question. Since instant replay is so in vogue in all sports, ie, a desire to make no mistakes officiating, why is the robot strike zone not being implemented? The technology apparently exists. I am not an advocate of such a move, but if a catch, tag, or foul ball is important enough for a replay, why not a missed third strike? What follows is the part of the interview pertaining to Suzukis take on the strike zone. Then again, accurately measuring a catcher's defensive contributions with analytics? Suzuki isn't ready to admit that is even possible. "You can't do it," the nine-year veteran said. "It's pretty cool they're trying to come up with those numbers, but at the same time it's the toughest thing to do. It's becoming a part of the game. It gets more people involved on the creative siFfde of the game. It's good for baseball and it's not good." The former Johnny Bench Award winner as college baseball's top catcher at Cal State Fullerton misses the days after he first came to the majors in 2007 and was groomed by old-school catcher Jason Kendall with the Oakland A's. Back then, even with the QuesTec electronic evaluation system, umpires seemed to have more latitude to factor in the so-called human element. The reputation of a given hitter or pitcher could be layered into the ball-strike decision in a way that rapidly seems to be disappearing in the PITCHf/x era, when umpires' ratings and ultimately their employment are tied to their performance against the eye in the sky. "I think you earn your stripes," Suzuki said. "I think as a rookie, you shouldn't get the same calls as a Torii Hunter or a Joe Mauer. Guys like Torii and Joe, they shouldn't have that borderline pitch called on them. It's that respect factor. That's just how it should be." In recent years, the strike zone isn't just skewing significantly lower. It's also becoming identity-blind. "It really puts the umpires in a tough position," Suzuki said. "They have that box they have to (adhere to), and I know a lot of them don't like that box. They're getting graded on it, so they've got to do what they have to do. For the most part, I have a really good relationship with all of them. They tell me and they talk to me about it." What's more, it wasn't that long ago that pitches that hit a catcher's target without requiring even the slightest twitch would bring automatic strike calls. Those that forced a catcher to reach across his body almost without fail were called balls. That dynamic has changed as well, and Suzuki doesn't like it. "Now it's just becoming more of, 'Shoot, if they think it's in the box, they're calling it a strike,' no matter what," Suzuki said. "That's good for catching but bad for hitting. When I first came up, you never saw that happen." He took note of the July 28 independent league game in California in which former Oakland A's outfielder-turned-broadcaster Eric Byrnes called balls and strikes from the stands with a laptop hooked up to the PITCHf/x system. That same system, by Sportvision, is installed in all 30 big-league stadiums. The concept of a robot umpire calling balls and strikes might not be so far-fetched anymore. "It's getting a little ridiculous now," Suzuki said. "It's getting a little out of control." What about the human element that baseball had always worked so hard to protect in the century before replay review and pace-of-game clocks? "It's gone," Suzuki said, shaking his head. "It's gone." Follow Mike Berardino at Twitter.com/MikeBerardino.
  4. . Duensing! Ok, now you are just getting a little bit too crazy. I don't care if you give away the farm, but not Duensing!
  5. [quote name="jimbo92107" post="386009" timestamp="1439398861 A better short term move would be to bring up Stewart Turner in September. Even though Turner is hitting just .269 in AA, he's still reportedly a real stud defensive catcher, and calls a good game. Twins could then decide next spring whether to keep Turner around or send him to AAA to keep working on his hitting. Then I'd promote all the catcher prospects a level for the remainder of the season, especially Garver and Navaretto. A question I have asked numerous times. We currently have a catcher who can't hit, or catch. Why don't we at least get a catcher who can catch?
  6. That's not only an update, it's a day to day occurrence!
  7. Texas was the epitome of the Wild Wild West, yet some our best gunslingers, murders and train robbers came from the great Midwest! Jesse James, Wild Bill, Billy da Kid, and Cole Younger and his brothers. After Northfield some of the Younger brothers not only did not get any younger, they didn't get any older! I don't even think the Earp boys and Doc Holliday were Texans! Name me one decent criminal that came from Texas?
  8. I have been all over Texas, and frankly have no idea why Davey Crockett put up such a big fight for it?
  9. I remember Staying on So Padre Island and the woman at the motel told me how lucky I was to be there when I was. I asked why? She said cuz next week all the college kids were there, music, noise, drunk guys, girls taking off their shirts! I asked if my room could be extended a week!
  10. Dick just told us there was a players only meeting today! And there was the Molitor meeting, and the expletive fueled Hunter rant. Maybe they should take batting practice instead of all those meeting? Ok, that was snarky, and I apologize profusely!
  11. He has an editor? So the stuff he writes isn't all his fault?
  12. They used to allow passing on the yellow, it was accepted that the oncoming and the passed car would move over on some of their wider two lanes. Sadly they don't tell u that at the border. At first it was quite disconcerting. I think they outlawed that now.
  13. NO! NO! NO! But they will sign him. Without a doubt. Dangling Torri Hunter in front of Ryan, is the equivalent of dangling a carrot in front of Hannah's horse. Plus, he won't sign and sit on the bench, he will be in RF, Arcia will be hitting HR's (and striking out), both at a phenomenal pace for someone else, and Kepler will be probably dawdling around in Rochester. It's the Twins Way!
  14. John, in your second paragraph, during your attempt at amateur psychology, you point out that some people want the team to give up, so they in essence no longer invest themselves in a losing cause? Or is it possible that many of these same people see it differently. Either those who see this as another in a long line of decisions that almost invariably go towards a veteran presence over raw talent. Or, those of us who never thought Hunter should have been signed by this team, this year, and saw his signing as a sop to the casual fan base. The "Hey Torii's back" group! Frankly I am in both of the aforementioned camps!
  15. If the Texas Rangers were named for the Texas Rangers, should they not be the Texas Rangers Jr.? If I get stopped for speeding in Texas, (which btw is almost impossible to do) how will I know which Ranger I am talking to?
  16. "Thank God for Mike Pelfrey" I never thought I would see those 5 words consecutively in TD, or for that matter anywhere !
  17. This is exactly why I was, have been, and will be against Hunters signing last year, and this coming year. First it made an uncomfortable and all ready defensive RF move to LF this spring, and now he is not only blocking Buxton, he will end up costing either Rosario, Arcia, Hicks, or more likely Kepler a ML job next year. It's decisions like this that have turned the term "Twins Way" into such a derisive term.
  18. We are so loaded with talent, we have won exactly how many series since the AS break? We can't find playing time for the top prospect? The only part of that paragraph I agreed with is the part about Terry Ryan composing his resume. So if they are putting him in AAA for a couple weeks, what changes in a couple weeks? Sept call ups won't make anymore room for him. Torii Hunter should not be blocking a player of Buxtons pedigree. And Robinson should not be taking innings away either. Not on this team, in this situation. All I can say, is that if Buxton cannot move a declining 40 yr old out of the way, either he is not as good as advertised, or the people making the decisions aren't.
  19. I agree with Jimmer. We are now basing our developmental decisions for next year on a 40 yr old OF vs an important cog in any chance of future team success? And for the record, what exactly does a top of the order hitter look like? Frankly we currently do not have one. And if someone can think of anyone on this team that would fill any batting order of a contending teams 1, 3, 4, or likely 5 spot please list them. Doziers power in the 2 hole might play, but he's is the only one.
  20. He doesn't have to start the world on fire, he has to get some acclimation time in so next year he possibly can start that fire.
  21. I think there used to be a tv show, "That Was The Week That Was". The Twins version would be "This Was The Year That Wasn't" While we are not mathematically eliminated from the playoffs, mathematicians are not very good ball players. This begs the question? Now what? There are far more of those questions than answers, some don't have specific answers. Following are a few thoughts from watching this team. Starting at the top: Terry Ryan. While I doubt he will, and if he does I fear it will just end up being Rob Anthony, it might be a good time for him to retire. And it will have to be retire, as he has more job security than the Pope. Some of his decisions and player movements, and lack thereof this year have been head scratchers. Some guys are brought up, Tonkin, Fryer, Hermann, Fryer, Hermann, Duffey, Santana, et al and then sent back down when they did not perform. Others not performing just sit here, their under performance overlooked or ignored. My problem isn't moving players, my problem is that there is no rhyme or reason. TR seems very reactionary, unwilling to do anything until backed into a corner. He has had 4 years to prepare this team for an influx of younger players, and still hasn't got a discernible grip on the roster. I will only mention in passing, extending Suzuki, Pelfrey, and not letting several RP go during arbitration. And I really do not think that Torii Hunter was the fit for this team. It's not that he can't play some. We just did not need a 40 yr old OF. But I will give Ryan credit for having the cajones not to make an idiotic deadline trade. The holes in this team are to widespread to fix that way. Molitor? I like some of his out of the box thinking, his expanded shifts and his calm demeanor. I am not a huge fan of his love affair with the bunt, his use of the bench, and what appears to be a major dislike of pinch hitters. I am also disappointed he has not dealt with the Mauer in the top of the order problem. I was hoping some of the sacred cows would no longer be sacred. Plus the handling of May is and was very strange. The pitching staff? It's a mess. Loaded with expensive #4 pitchers, low strikeout rates, and no one that can pick you up and drag you back into the win column when all is seemingly lost. A bullpen who strikes out no one, and to whom inherited runners are people to be gotten off the bases as quickly as possible. Shortstops? None! Lots of guys playing there, but not one who excels at either the glove or the bat. The worst of two worlds. Dozier: Since they have started pitching him almost exclusively away and down, he has become a miniature version of Arcia. About the same amount of SO and home runs. The biggest difference is Waldo can hit almost any pitch over the fence, and admittedly swings at most of them. And he plays poor defense. BD basically will hit only one pitch over the fence, but tries desperately to pull the rest. And plays good defense. The corner IF: Much rides on this decision. Someone has to go. Sorry Trevor. Mauer is not going anywhere, and neither is Sano. Plouffe should be packaged up with some prospects, and dealt for a catcher. This does not mean I think Plouffe is a poor player, it's simply that he is the odd man out, and you can't hit Sano in the DH hole all next year. And please do not tell me they will bench Mauer. Please! As for a rotating scenario of the three, there's nothing like not knowing where you will be playing everyday to make you consistent. Catcher: If it's so hard to find a hitting catcher, and if yours isn't into doing either very well, then for heavens sake, put a defensive catcher behind the plate and bat him ninth. If your bench is constructed properly you can PH on occasion. Again, the worst of both worlds. As for Pinto, see below. OF: Get Buxton up here. If he can bat in Rochester, he can hit here. To the best of my knowledge the bats in Rochester are also made of wood. Correct me if I am wrong. He needs the reps in the majors. Same for Arcia. Let Arcia, Hicks, Buxton, and Rosario play there the rest of the year. Let Torii be a very limited fill in and PH for the rest of the year. He can still mentor, play the boom box, and lace the dugout with expletive loaded tirades. But the cynic in me seems to think that they are seldom useful, or it would be done daily. This winter thank him profusely and promise him good references. The BP: Sheesh. Nothing seems to work. I guess I would try to emulate some of the Cards theories and move in some minor league starters and relievers who throw hard. And I would let them settle in, not bounce them back to whence they came after a couple outings. This does not mean keeping the course of endless jogs out to the mound to remove the latest disaster. It's just a realization that RP have a day to day existence. Unfortunately we have taken that and made it a month to month,or more, existence. Bench? Clear the bench of Robinson and Nunez. IF Pinto passes his concussion tests, and gets some rehab time in, get him up here. There is no reason he can't be the backup catcher/DH/PH next year. In closing, this whole year should have been all about the future. While it's true that some youth appeared, there were still far too many non contributors left on the roster. Whether the crazy month of May caused the plan to change, or as I suspect there was no plan, it was not handled well. By this time of the year, we should have had a very solid idea of how next years roster will look. Instead, we really don't seem to know what's going to happen. This year is starting to look an awful lot like last year and the years before that. Someone has to take the lead, and make some inventive, tough, and costly decisions. Sadly I don't see that happening.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.