Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. Anyone who has ever watched a Ryan/Gardenhire team, and thought that Pinto had a snowballs chance in Tuscon of ever catching once Suzuki was signed, has not been paying attention. I am not arguing that Pinto was better or not, for that discussion is a moot point!
  2. Ryan has made it clear that after he signs a FA, he will not flip him. (See Willingham) He considers that disrespectful to the player, and has said this will discourage other FA's from signing here in the future.
  3. Without a hint of sarcasm, we don't trade or promote "stuff". "Stuff" is exasperating, it leads to walks and strikeouts. Ground balls are far safer and more consistent. "Stuff" on offense results in high swing rates, home runs, and swinging strike outs. It's far safer to work the count, and take an enormous amount of called third strikes, followed by the requisite perplexed look at the umpire on the way back to the dugout! Again, no sarcasm intended, it just the way I see the decision making process at One Twins Way.
  4. This might be my biggest issue with the FO, an inability to react. They move so slowly, take no chances, and almost always defer to the stable veteran, than the upsided rookie. This is what breeds mediocrity. If something is not working, try something. Who knows, you might end up with more than one Tyler Duffy in a year? I may be wrong, but I think the era of 26 yr old rookies is coming to a close.
  5. It took them 12 years. The Twins rebuild took 4 years. Does that mean that TR/Bill Smith get 3 times the credit Dayton Moore got? Are we that sure we are "rebuilt"? We missed the second WC by 3 games. And the general consensus is that the lineup that goes north next year, will greatly resemble the lineup that played last Saturday. I am not sure if that is what I want to be considered a rebuild.
  6. Ryan has been the Twins GM for what? 17 of the last 20 years. It is him who does not have Jeff S and the college kids, and the high velocity relievers. I am not saying all Ryan's decisions have been bad, but they have been Ryan's decisions. Btw, this thread has resulted in one good thing, if none other! The Chief and Dave being in agreement! :).
  7. For several seasons the Twins have been linked, correctly or not, with the Cubs and the Astros as the teams with the best minor league prospects, depth and talent. After watching the other two teams the last two nights, and over the course of the season, I wondered if we have fallen back in the pack? Have the injuries to Sano and Buxton been that detrimental? Have we/they over rated our players? Or have the other two teams been more aggressive? Or lucky? And more importantly, if we are behind, will we catch up?
  8. Ego? Or competiveness? As Sherlock said, "that is the question"? I do agree with the thought that there is no sense in trading a corner IF for another corner IF.
  9. I guess I come from the old school of baseball. But I don't think our unwritten rules were quite as intricate. Last nights Cubs game reminded me of an exact situation we experienced in amateur ball. The other teams star pitcher buzzed or hit our top two hitter several times in the season, and in our playoff loss to them. And pitchers hit. So our guy plunked him in the butt his last AB. He knew he was going to get hit, and our guy hit him low, and he jogged to first base, and not a word was said. Next year his control improved remarkedly. My point, there are unwritten rules in all sports. There is and was nothing wrong with them as they were for years. But To extend them to bat flips, and excitement on the bases is juvenile. If Molly and Kurt want to make fools of themselves on TV for a minor bat flip, go for it. To the teams credit they left it at that. As it should have been.
  10. I really would like to think Plouffe will be traded, catching will be upgraded, Hunter will not be back, and we will find a left handed hitting DH to balance the lineup. That's what I would hope for. ( I am not delusional enough to hope for a #1 SP) But reality and past history make this seem wishful thinking. There is nothing, not one thing in Ryan's history that makes me believe anything aggressive or innovative will happen.
  11. This is going to be one of the most interesting off seasons in years. I just hope it does not turn into one of the most frustrating? Your comparison to the Cubs is interesting, and fairly relative. Some of the same opportunity lies in front of the Twins, but it's going to take some really proactive movement. Will we grab the opportunity, or be satisfied with the more traditional "tweaking" that has become the "Twins Way"?
  12. I don't know whether Mays comments on his hip being a problem when relieving vs starting is factual, or the opening salvo in an attempt to talk the team into moving him back to the rotation, but it is factual that he was not healthy in the pen, and missed some important games. They should trade Plouffe, hopefully for a catcher. But trading Gibson, probably there steadiest young arm, and keeping middling veterans with spendy contracts, would mean it's business as usual at One Twins Way. It's gonna be a fun winter!
  13. I don't remember Butera dominating at several levels below the majors, I don't think he was a #1 pick, and it takes about 4 years to accumulate 2500AB's. Trout wasn't Trout at the 120 AB level either. Patience, patience patience!
  14. Without being critical to this post at all, I am always surprised by how reactive we are to immediate, current, and somewhat short term performances. We celebrate Hicks finally getting it, after having determined as recently as this spring that he is basically a failure. Now we, and again, I am not referring specifically to this poster, have determined that Santana and Arcia have little chance of succeeding. There are like rumblings about the offense of Buxton after approx 120 AB's. Which is 5% of the 2500 AB's many consider to be the demarcation line for evaluating a potential career. It took KC severl years for their young talent to mature into what it is today. They took their lumps, stuck with them, and have been rewarded. This is not going to happen overnight, or likely next year. As for the current SP, having 8 #3&4 starters is not the definition of depth I would consider a recipe for success!
  15. I am nowhere near the stats guy that some on here are, so correct me if I am wrong. This appears to be a very very average team, with the middle of the order considerably below that? My perception of the Twins this year, and in the recent past is that they have no "true" #1,3, or 4 hitters in the generally defined definition of those spots in the order. Hopefully as the roster turns over in the future, some players will emerge to fill those slots. A baseball season is a long drawn out affair. And if you have a roster of nice, average, solid players you will always be competitive. But that is not the same as being a legitimate contender for one of, at least, the final four teams in the playoffs.
  16. We should have done this, this year. But May got in the way! And I ain't talking about Trevor either. Will we look back at 2015 like one looks back at a very big, very fun party? It was a great time. But the "hangover" will hurt?
  17. Nada. We do have a lot of these posts, but that was the first quote I saw from him that clearly said playing part time was not acceptable. And if it would not be next year, you can about imagine what the negotiations were last year.
  18. Re: Hunter. If I had a dime for every veteran player who said he was retiring immediately after the sudden end of a season, I would be retired and trolling on TD.............. Hmmmmmmm
  19. This quote from Hunter in late Saturday's online Trib. Not only does this seem to quash the thought that he would be a 4th OF/DH, it tells you that his playing time and position were likely negotiated prior to his signing. It also explains the puzzling (to me) OF switch for Arcia. There’s a possibility this could be my last game,” Hunter said in a somber clubhouse after the Twins’ hopes of a postseason invitation were officially dashed Saturday with a 5-1 loss to the Royals. “There’s a really good chance.” That’s because he doesn’t know, in the immediate bleakness of elimination, whether he really wants to play past 40, and whether the Twins will invite him back. The latter has been considered a mere formality once Hunter began smashing home runs — 22 in all, with 81 RBI — but he knows better than anyone how many talented outfielders roughly half his age are on their way. If the Twins suggest he return with quasi-emeritus status, perhaps play half the games? “I wouldn’t come back for that,” said Hunter, who has started 135 games this year. General Manager Terry Ryan has not discussed his plans for the team’s oldest player, but said, “We have a lot of things to talk about.” Hunter is proud of his season, and proud of the influence he has had on the Twins, having transformed a library-quiet clubhouse into a rollicking, supportive bunch in his return after seven years away.
  20. Last year when Dozier went into the HR hitting contest at the AS game should have been the first clue. The fact that he hits only one pitch, to one spot in the seats should have been another. It seemed to take pitchers longer than usual to figure out that of the 9 spots on a hit chart, he only consistently hits in two of them. Anyway, once they found out that he would not move the away stuff to right field, and had a hard time laying off the breaking ball, the results were fairly easy to forecast. He became in reality a better fielding version of Arcia. His problem was very succinctly summed up by the Chief, a regular TD contributor. His take: BD thinks he's a home run hitter, but hes not! I concur! Conditioning is always an easy unquantifiable excuse. If BD does not change his approach next year, look for post AS game numbers to be the norm.
  21. Trevor May has already alluded to the fact that relief pitching impacts his hip/back issues. When starting, the days off allow his back to "heal" and when RP the day to day grind does not allow this. True? I don't know. But if it is, there are two options. Back to the rotation, or a trade before his back does a Perkins on the Twins. Catcher? Kudos to Kurt for being one tough SOB. He would be a wonderful backup catcher. But you can deal with a defensive catcher who can't hit, or an offensive catcher who can't field, but the combo of both is not good. As for EE. Unless Santana pulls a Hicks and does a turnaround, which is very possible, or someone comes out of the minors earlier than expected, he is the best option at SS. But after you watch guys like a Corria, Lindor, or even his namesake in KC, the lack of range, and arm is stunning. To expand on another post. Can he play SS in the majors? Yes. Is he the SS on a consistent pennant contender? Not likely.
  22. MVP Sano. Why? This teams offense was poor and getting worse when he arrived. It's been so long since we had a stick like this I don't think we knew what we were missing. Without him holding down the 4 hole this team would have been done two weeks ago. ROY.... Co winners. Duffy because without him, there would be no playoff game this evening. And Rosario, because he gave us a second above average defensive player in the OF, and had a lot of big hits. His strike zone discipline can be cringe inducing, but so can his triples to the opposition. Most improved. Hicks in a landslide. Escobar was the starting SS last year, and ended up the starting SS this year. Hicks was what last year?? Vs what this year. That's not even close. Most valuable pitcher. May. Pretty good starter, then moved to the bullpen for reasons that could be debated, but won't be here. Adjusted well and was the type of 8th inning guy we need, and likely still would be if his hip/back were healthy. Gibson a very close second. On a side note, Mays comments about his back a starter vs as a reliever might preclude his return to the pen next year.
  23. Since the Twins have an excess of healthy and high quality pitchers, I can see no reason for them not to initiate a bean ball war today! Besides none of the suspensions would likely be served until 2016!
  24. Pelf should have been in the pen, and May in the rotation. But Pelf got the veteran/big agent treatment. I know GM have to keep agents happy, or else FA and contract negotiations become even more difficult, but this capitulation cost dearly.
  25. If he had bunted, or been on base and stole third with that big lead, yeah that's rude! Excited about hitting, for him, a rare HR, that's mostly youthful exuberance. BTW, is there any clear audio of what Molly was saying. To touch on Daves point, it appears to me that Molitor was showing Suzuki not only a better arm angle when throwing to second, but the actual general location of the bag.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.