Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Platoon

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. Is this observation inclusive? :!
  2. Since the title is about the perceived mediocrity of the FO I have these thoughts. You can, and I do, opine about any trade made. It depends on your view of the game. Defensive, offensive, pitching? Each philosophy clouds the view of the transaction. My issue with the FO is based more on long term results. Results that over 17 yrs are exactly the mediocrity the post refers to. It also is based on the total lack of accountability in this orginisation. 13 years of pretty much nothing lets you resign, but keep your hand on the tiller. 3 yrs of, it's actually hard to say, leaves Bill Smith with a job in the FO. And 3 more years, which culminated in chasing the much sought after 2nd WC slot unsuccessfully is considered laudatory. As is keeping a manager through 4 90+loss seasons. And spending a significant amount of payroll dollars on SP which has been somewhat south of satisfactory. And yet , unless someone has not been paying attention, Ryan will ride off into the sunset at his own time, with the platitudes and fare thee wells of the Twins ownership. To be replaced by Ryan's hand picked replacemant, Rob Anthony! Thus continuing the "Twins Way". That is in essence the true meaning of the mediocrity of not only the FO, but the ownership as well.
  3. .......and winning the Park bid, and moving Sano to the OF'is not going to increase his leverage for Ploofy, in fact it should decrease it! Bill Clinton, like him or hate him, is fond of saying "it's the arithmetic"! And the arithmetic shows 4 players, Mauer, Sano, Ploofy, and Park for 3 spots. I think Park and some of our Canadien readers would need to do the math metrically, but it still don't come out. One of them is going to RF, the bench or the airport!
  4. .......and winning the Park bid, and moving Sano to the OF'is not going to increase his leverage for Ploofy, in fact it should decrease it!
  5. It's a little known fact that games in the first two months of the season don't count, nor do games that the rookie you brought up late needs to acclimate count. The only games that count are after the AS game! . The ones where you are -9 in the standings, but battling 5 teams for the second WC spot. That said, this trade will make more sense if Buxton starts in CF off the bat. If they keep him back for service time, and Kepler, and move Sano to RF because they did not trade Plouffe for a catcher instead, then the trades real ramifications will be felt. This trade, as it stands did not happen in a vacuum.
  6. . I reversed these, but the point remains! If you are gonna do monthly stats, you better throw Doziers and Hunter's in there also!
  7. 50 OF starts for a 4th OF means you start almost a third of your games without your optimum talent in the OF. And btw, I like Robinson as a 4th OF. As long as he remains a 4th OF.
  8. " Even with the league's caveats (lower velocity, smaller ballparks, juiced baseballs), hitters do not reach those totals that consistently without being a special talent." Agreed! You have to be able to make solid contact, and have an obvious power stroke. But will he be able to overcome those three caveats, in a non HR friendly park, and still put up numbers that will be any better than cheaper options? To me, one of Arcia, Vargas, or Walker will turn into a DH power threat. And IMHO for less money and less risk.
  9. Oddly it's possible both are correct. Since it seems that Plouffe is not going to be traded, for the time being at least, that left an OF to trade for a catcher. Whether the value was fair is open to discussion. But catchers are harder to find than OF, so looking for a tit for tat trade might be overly hopeful. To address #2, Ryan seems to put an inordinate amount of weight on personality and attitude when making roster decisions. He is loathe to trade a trusted veteran who makes no waves, but has often jettisoned far more gifted players who do not fit what many sarcastically refer to as "The Twins Way". Ryan is lauded by some for his patience in "developing" players such as Plouffe and Dozier. But that patience was notably absent with Gomez, Hardy, Garza, and others.
  10. Please do not tell me that we would sign another OF! We have lots of them already. If the Twins decide to start Buxton and Kepler in Rochester for service time, fine. But that is not a reason to acquire another OF. If that's the case, let Santana and Arcia play. Who knows, one of them might end up like a Dozier or Plouffe. Had to play despite production, figured it out, and became acceptable MLB players.
  11. Your leverage in a Plouffe trade is lost once you sign Park. That said, I think no team will see the Twins as desperate to unload Plouffe in any case.
  12. I do hope we did not trade Hicks for a platoon level catcher! But it would fit the Ryan risk adverse model. Mid level deals, mid level risks, mid level success, mid level failures, and needless to say, mid level in the AL!
  13. I cannot see anyway Kepler starts here in spring, and in today's Trib Rob Anthony already alluded to Buxton possibly starting in Rochester when he said the Twins had options in CF like Danny Santana. I would not be at all stunned to see an OF of Rosario, DanSan, and Sano. Starting Buxton in Rochester for service time I can understand, but I simply do not get the Sano thing at all. Athletic, sure. But to expect him to learn the OF in spring? Maybe there's a secret plan to bring Arcia back?
  14. Ugh! Two of the worst defensive catchers, and definitely the worst two arms, platooning! It's enough to make me change my screen name!
  15. I don't know what the Twins roster will look like when the smoke all clears. Ryan is quoted as saying he is not trading Plouffe, not getting rid of players, only adding, and starts out the odd season adding another 30 year old "lottery ticket". If he does not trade Plouffe, can't trade Mauer, and was clear he wanted Hunter to return, that seems the dealings of a GM who thinks he has a veteran team, missing just a couple pieces. They are not the doings of a GM with a loaded minor league system which should be coming to fruition. If you aren't going to trade a Plouffe or Dozier, that leaves only one area with which to improve the catching depth. Trading a pretty good young player or two. And unless he can get a really talented starting young catcher in return, it doesn't make sense. Maybe he will surprise, but so far his initial actions and comments to the media are more indicative of a man looking to make a splash quickly before he re-retires, than a man building for the long haul?
  16. Sano is way quicker, and faster than Willy, Cuddy, or Ploofy! And his arm easily plays well in the OF. Can he catch fly balls? I can, so I imagine he can. Will his pitchers end up crouching down and holding their head in their hands after a ball lands that Hicks, Buxton, Rosario, and yes even Hunter would have caught? Very likely. What I dread is him coming in and diving for a ball, and seeing him holding his shoulder. Big guys like him do not land like cats!
  17. The failings of Arcia, Vargas and Santana? Over one season at their age?? First of all, that is not the definition of the word patience. And secondly you might as well include another Santana, Johan and some big guy in Boston as examples of players who were not necessarily out of the gate success stories. What's TR going to do if Buxton comes up in June, and does his usual "I need 3-4 weeks to get going in a new league" thingy?
  18. I learned several things by watching the Park HR video. 99 meters is 324' and 118 meters is 379'. Those were numbers I saw on the fence down the LF line and in CF. those are not big parks. Dozier would love that LF measurement. The other thing I picked up was how to yell "touch em all Park" in Korean!
  19. Why was he stung? Almost no player comes up and is an instant success. For those few, the dreaded sophomore jinx awaits. The practical fact is it takes into the third year, well over 1000 AB's to be what you're gonna be. That's why I refer to Plouffe, Dozier, and more recently Hicks as examples. With them the Twins had no options so they had to stick with them. And they leveled off. AS grade? Not really, but very capable. I like Sano and Buxton. But I figure the growing pains next year will be painful. And with the exception of service time, Buxtons future is not going to be helped playing in northern NY.
  20. With the Park deal, somebody's gotta move somewhere! You can't put two ton of corner IF in a one ton infield!
  21. If I read the articles correctly Park whiffs at a 25% rate. Where will that number go facing ML pitching. When analyzing this, remember he doesn't get to bat off Twins pitching!
  22. So if Park is signed, and Plouffe isn't traded, Sano has to play OF. Period. That could be exciting? Or they could start Sano in Rochester for OF experience, but then they couldn't answer the phones at One Twins Way. This whole deal could have made sense if they had an opening at 1B. Or the ability to make an opening at 1B. But they don't. There are so many things the Twins needed, but a 1B/DH wasn't on the list. If I was Hicks or Rosario I would not take out any long term apartment leases. If he trades Kepler, well then it's time to wonder what the long term plan really is?
  23. He was also clear in one article that Sano can catch routine fly balls! As can I. But had trouble approaching the fence, routes, and other minor intricacies of the OF. This team spent several years bemoaning Arcias defense, regardless of whether he was hitting or not. And this is their next move? I don't know if the Twins are playing poker here, or not. But it certainly appears that it's yet another case of Ryan not being able to part ways with a veteran favorite.
  24. Per Bernadino: http://blogs.twincities.com/twins/2015/11/06/twinsights-behold-the-miguel-sano-experiment-in-left-field/ I find the whole idea maddening and predictable all at once. The maddening part is self explanatory. The predictable part is the Twins just now getting him reps in the OF in an attempt to hedge the supposedly soft market for Plouffe because he is arbitration eligible, and has only one year of control left. Silly me, I thought those numbers were all spelled out in the players agreements?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.