Everything posted by USAFChief
-
Identical Record to 2013
I tend to agree. Still, they have to finish better to be better, IMO. Counting chickens, unhatched, and all that.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Royals, 8/17 @ 1:10pm CT
It was time to trade the 'Hammer, but I'll miss him. He put one in the third deck, but not one ounce of showboating. He followed the flight of the ball briefly off the bat, realized immediately it was gone, put his head down, and started a fast trot. Not even a glance at where it landed. Professional. Respectful.
-
Identical Record to 2013
IMO, if you don't win more games, you're not a better team. This isn't Olympic Figure Skating...you don't get style points. YMMV.
-
Game Thread: Twins v Royals, 8/17 @ 1:10pm CT
I'm incredibly encouraged by Vargas. I know it's early, but to me he looks like the best hitter the Twins have brought up in quite some time. I like him better than Arcia, for sure.
-
Debating WAR
To me, the problem with comparing offense and defense and attributing it to "luck" is this: While it most certainly is true to say that (to pick a name at random) Pedro Florimon was "lucky" to string together a good month and hit .400, it is not at all true to say it didn't really happen. No matter now lucky it was, we know for a fact he hit .400 and the value of that cannot be disputed. He had 100 ABs, got 40 hits, and hit .400. Nobody contends he didn't really hit .400. It represents exactly what happened on the field. Compare that with what the designer's of UZR say...a good or bad UZR doesn't mean that's what happened: ...a player’s UZR, be it one year, one month or 5 years, is not necessarily what happened on the field and is not necessarily that player’s true talent level over that period of time either. That is why we regress, regress, and regress! A player can have a plus UZR and have played terrible defense, because the data we are using is far from perfect. If it doesn't represent what happened on the field, I have a hard time giving it any credit. If we're going on opinions, I'll go with the opinions of professional baseball people, or myself, rather than MGL. You can't have a .400 BA and have hit poorly. Luckily maybe, but not poorly. Those hits actually happened. But if you can have a plus UZR, and "played terrible defense," the measurement system needs work. EDIT (meant to include this with the original post): As for regression, I'd say if you're "regressing" data to represent what happened in the past, you're doing it wrong. I can understand regressing data to guess at what might happen in the future. But what happened, happened. It shouldn't need to be regressed to more closely represent truth, should it? Does Baseball Reference regress Joe Mauer's 2009, because it probably doesn't represent his "true talent level?" No. Nor should it. While I'm at it...I'll take a shot at the "UZR is accurate in large sample sizes" argument as well. (Unsurprisingly) I don't buy that argument. If it's innacurate in small sample sizes, it is innacurate in larger sample sizes as well. Adding up several small bunches of innacurate data gives me one big bunch of innacurate data, IMO. Not to mention, if WAR is being used to compare players across eras, there isn't PBP data for any players except those from the last decade or so, so "WAR" for Babe Ruth, for example, is derived without even the flawed data used to derive WAR for today's players. Personally, I don't understand how smart people pay any attention to it.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Winnah!
-
Debating WAR
Fair enough. My bad.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
We're good cooks, too, Mrs Chief and I. She cooks, I eat.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Is beer still vegan if you use it to wash down the Filet Oscar?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Nice job, Mr Hughes.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Since food seems to be the topic du jour, Chief and Mrs Chief are in the process of cooking dinner: chicken fried steak mashed potates (with a little cream cheese, sour cream, and onion salt) gravy candied carrots We're...uh...not vegan.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
They serve that at a nice Italian place in Saskatchewan.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Me too. At the nice steakhouse down the street.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Chief might have been making a snarky guess. Maybe.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Yup, he didn't know what they were, but he et 'em anyway.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Soy beans?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Ick.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
Re-he-he-he-he-he-lly.
- Article: Everyone's a Doctor: Joe Mauer, the Injury Bug and the Notion of Toughness
-
Article: Everyone's a Doctor: Joe Mauer, the Injury Bug and the Notion of Toughness
I don't think Mauer gets mistreated by many fans in the upper midwest. But I do think that whatever "mistreatement" he gets from fans and media would be mulitplied several fold if he were playing in Boston (or another major media market, where people expect to win), taking up 25% of the payroll, and putting up a .717 OPS after missing a lot of time over the past few years.
-
Debating WAR
If I shouldn't use it to compare players, which is what it's designed to do, and which the designers say it does, what should it be used for? And why should I pay any attention to it?
-
Game Thread: Twins vs Royals, 8/16 @ 6:10pm CT
I hope you baked enough for EVERYone, missy.
-
Next Commish
"With the bases unoccupied..." I don't think pace of play is an issue with bases unoccupied.
- Article: Everyone's a Doctor: Joe Mauer, the Injury Bug and the Notion of Toughness
-
Debating WAR
If you're interested in learning how WAR is calculated, go to Fangraphs and read the explanation: http://www.fangraphs.com/library/misc/war/ Baseball Reference does WAR a bit differently: http://www.baseball-reference.com/about/war_explained.shtml If it's a debate about its value, you might google it...there are dozens of articles out there discussing the subject. If it's opinions from TD'ers you're looking for, my personal opinion is WAR is so flawed as to be worthless. I am probably in the minority with that opinion. One minor point about the question you pose in your last sentence...WAR isn't intended to be predictive, it's intended to be a record of what happened.