Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

USAFChief

Community Moderator
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by USAFChief

  1. Just wanted to say I appreciate the spirited but respectful debate in this thread. Great work on the thread starter! AndLots of good posts on all sides of the equation. TD is a great place, even when we're debating something we'd all privately admit has virtually no chance of happening. My two cents.
  2. Boyer, Fien AND Duensing. For LuCroy. Three for one. Too much, maybe?
  3. I'd be extremely happy if both Buxton and Sano were better than Tulo in 2017. I just wouldn't bet on it. I wouldn't bet on either being better, much less both. BTW, if we aren't winning a championship in 2017 with Tulo as the best player, how the heck are we winning one if he's not even on the team?
  4. He has poor range, a mediocre arm, and a lack of athleticism. I don't see him as "very solid." In my opinion, of course. I've been wrong before. On the other hand, it's clear the Twins have been reluctant to give him an extended run at SS.
  5. A sweetheart deal for Sano would be cheap over the next five years, and the Twins can afford both. Easily. A deal for Buxton, too, if necessary. As for the question, I'd rather have Tulo and Sano over the next five years than Gibson and Sano and whatever the Twins do with the extra money.
  6. No, this argument also includes the remaining years on Tulo's contract. He's not going to retire this winter. It confuses me the "play for 2017, not 2015" proponents are opposed to this idea. There's an excellent chance Tulo would be the Twins best player in 2017.
  7. Gibson is having a better year than Radke ever did? Do not concur.
  8. Concur. Except about Gibson...I'd rather give up Berrios. But I wouldn't let that be a deal breaker if the Rockies insisted on Gibson.
  9. Maybe safe to say, maybe not. He's been a 5 WAR player in 5 of the last 6 seasons, including 2014.
  10. Forgive my ignorance...isn't WAR advertised as context, league, and park neutral? Perhaps that explains not finding home/road WAR splits.
  11. I would certainly agree it'd be better to keep Gibson and still acquire Tulo. But IMO that wouldn't be a deal breaker. And I might be in the minority, but Im not the least bit interested in winning the "WAR per dollar spent" championship. Or the "wins per payroll dollar" championship. I want the actual one. I don't see the Twins getting one by hoarding cheap players. I want good players. Tulo is still one of those, and the whole "decline phase" meme has gotten completely out of hand. He's 30. Good baseball players have usually stayed good into their mid 30s since the 1800s, and will continue to do so.
  12. First...Tulo replaces Danny Santana/Eduardo Escobar, May replaces Gibson. You don't think that's better than current team? Second...We both know using WAR is problematic at best, but Gibson is a 3 WAR player, and Tulowitski is a 1.6 WAR player? C'mon Brock. Third...instant gratification? Tulo is not a rental. Concur with WTF, though.
  13. "When the Twins optioned Danny Santana to Triple-A in early June, they were making a commitment to Eduardo Escobar at shortstop" They were? He didnt start three consecutive games at SS during Santana’s absence. (He still hasn't, all year.) I think it's pretty clear the Twins don't view Escobar as capable of playing SS every day. FWIW, I concur. If he gets the job, my guess is he won't hold it. Santana has been disappointing, no doubt...but I think he's got a better chance of being a good SS than Escobar.
  14. I was thinking more like weeks ago, but yeah...at least this.
  15. I don't understand why Arcia is still in Rochester, while taking one rookie out of the lineup leaves Nunez to DH.
  16. I'm more questioning using May in a blowout, rather than a tie game in extras, and using O'Rourke for mulitple innings tonight. He's been effective as a LOOGY, but prolly not available tomorrow, when he might have proven useful in a close game. After Boyer let the game get out of hand tonight, let him finish the GD thing. Or at least 2 innings pitched.
  17. Hey, just checkin' in. What time's the Twins game start tonight?
  18. Why do you hate children? And Alex Meyer?
  19. Do you think the Twins will sign an ace in free agency if they DON'T have Tulowitzki on the roster?
  20. Twins Wins: 37.5 OVER Mauer's OPS: .815 UNDER Dozier HRs: 14.5 UNDER Sano HRs: 9.5 OVER Hicks: .350 OBP UNDER Sano OPS: .900 UNDER Hunter HR: 8.5 UNDER Perkins Saves: 22.5 OVER Gibson ERA: 3.25 OVER Santana ERA: 3.50 OVER Hughes ERA: 3.75 UNDER Arcia PA: 150 UNDER Buxton PA: 150 UNDER Trevor May Starts: 5.5 UNDER Mike Pelfrey Starts: 5.5 OVER Alex Meyer IP: 6.5 OVER Jose Berrios IP: 15.5 UNDER Kurt Suzuki OPS: .600 OVER RP acquired via free agency and trade: 1.5 UNDER Catchers acquired via trade: 0.5 OVER Trevor Plouffe OPS: .775 OVER Brian Duensing ERA: 3.80 OVER Blaine Boyer ERA: 3.80 OVER Casey Fien ERA: 3.80 UNDER
  21. Once you remove Sano and Buxton, this list is pretty weak, IMO.
  22. Maybe so. Doubtful, IMO, but maybe so. But that's not directly related to "What's his worth in a trade to other teams." He HAS had a tough season, and it hasn't even been in the big leagues. And he's not THAT young. He might be a big side of a platoon, which knocks his value down, and he's probably not going to become a much better OFer, further knocking his value down. In any case, he's definately not part of "too expensive" when talking about getting back a catcher that you hope fills the position well for a number of years. Same for Meyer. I know many prospect fans don't want to hear it, but the luster is off Meyer, at least in terms of what he's "worth." At this point, he's just another struggling big arm, trying to find success at AAA (and not finding much of it, BTW) for more than a season. History of arm problems. Most teams have similar players. And most of those guys end up not becoming good big league players.
  23. If two players with multiple years of AAA experience, neither of which are currently deemed good enough to be on the 2015 big league team, is too expensive, then it will not be possible to upgrade catcher through a trade. Teams are not going to improve the Twins out of a sense of charity. At this point, both Meyer and Arcia would be viewed as suspects more than prospects by everyone except us. And rightly so.
  24. To belabor a point...or beat a dead horse...or make a pest of myself...if it's his last rodeo, then what do we care if he is getting everyday play in Rochester, or a few PAs a week in Minnesota?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.