Everything posted by USAFChief
-
Utley-Tejada
Concur. It's a force play. Anything other than a hard slide--feet first or head first if you wish--directly at the second base bag slows you down, and is therefore not an attempt to reach base safely, it's by definition an attempt to interfere. Enforce the rule already.
-
Why so much love for Plouffe?
I'd still probably take it, but Vargas and/or Arcia at DH isn't the only gamble I'm worried about. I'm worried a little about Sano's continued ability to hit, and worried a lot about his ability to play third base every day.
-
Utley-Tejada
Me 'n the choir are both trying to reach the few sinners still too blind to see.
-
Utley-Tejada
I couldn't disagree more with this take. What Utley did has been allowed to happen, but it doesn't make it right. Even MLB doesn't think it's right...there is a written rule against this specific thing on the books, with an explanation that specifically mentions taking out infielders on a double play. Because of that, MLB had to go through the contortions of sanctifying ignoring ANOTHER rule, the force play, and we get the BS of the neighborhood play, along with the inevitable problems of deciding what is, and what isn't, such a play. And we haven't even discussed the ridiculousness of replay in this case...overturning an out call without clear evidence, ignoring interference because that's somehow not reviewable, putting a runner on a base he never reached safely, and radically altering a playoff game. Thankfully, this will change before next season. Too bad it had to come to this, but at least this will force change, hopefully for the right reasons, but at the least because MLB realizes it screwed up big time, and there can BE no rational explanation.
-
Trade: Joe Mauer +30 million for Justin Morneau
We should all be curt to 90-something year olds.
-
Why so much love for Plouffe?
But -1 for poor use of asterisks.
-
Three Teams
If we're talking "moving goalposts," you might want to reconsider your "83-79" post, which was in response to a post that asked us to consider the Ryan yearS, not year. I'll save you the trouble...Ryan's tenure has a record that is sub-.500, and includes one playoff series win.
-
Utley-Tejada
I'm not sure how MLB could have handled this any worse. They have ignored the interference rule for decades now, giving runners a free shot at middle infielders. These are force plays at second base...anything other than a direct slide into second slows the runner, so there can be no claim the runner is doing anything other than deliberately interfering. All they had to do....years ago...was enforce the rules. Slide as hard as you want...directly into second. The "neighborhood play" is a ridiculous invention as well. Force plays require contact with the base everywhere else, why not second base? You just open yourself up to impossible situations when you start intentionally ignoring rules, and this is no different. Enforce the interference rule, and the neighborhood play isn't necessary anyway. Middle infielders have three "safe" sides of the bag to bail to. All that said, you can't really single out Utley for much blame, this has been going on forever. The blame lies with MLB. And now they want to suspend him?? For what? He was ruled SAFE on review, for Pete's sake. MLB is going to overturn the out call, say there's no interference and no neighborhood play, and then turn around and try to suspend him? Does anybody think this could have been handled any worse?
-
Utley-Tejada
In what possible way was that not a "neighborhood" play? He was attempting to turn 2.
-
Utley-Tejada
Concur. Although I don't think they need to change a rule. Just enforce existing ones.
-
Utley-Tejada
I don't think he was trying to hurt Tejada, but that's not important. It isn't necessary to try to guess at that. He was in violation of a written rule, that isn't typically enforced but should be.
-
Another school shooting (Oregon) - Ho hum
I think what is disgusting is the actual shooting. Second would be attempts to deflect from the shooting by blaming "politics" while throwing massive amounts of money and political clout against any and all attempts to develop rational and enforceable gun legislation.
-
Utley-Tejada
Setting aside the unfortunate injury... I hope this provides the impetus for MLB to start enforcing rule 6.01 and/or 5.09 and declaring automatic DPs when runners clearly interfere rather than attempt to beat a force play with a "slide." Utley's slide was a clear violation of an existing rule. And the entire replay fiasco that followed was ridiculous.
- Article: Will Kurt Suzuki's Offense Continue?
-
Another school shooting (Oregon) - Ho hum
Non school shootings are so much less harmful.
-
Three Teams
Maybe so, but that wasn't the context of the claim.
-
Article: Did You Know?
awesome work, Parker!
-
Souhan's solution to the "Mauer Problem"
It would seem to me an article suggesting making Mauer a utility player is, indeed, the definition of an "original" idea. Whether it's worth discussing is in the eye of the beholder. What isn't original is "Let's ignore Mauer's actual performance."
-
Souhan's solution to the "Mauer Problem"
http://www.startribune.com/a-solution-to-the-twins-joe-mauer-problem/331496821/ The gist: Plouffe at third, Sano at first, Mauer to super-utility player.
-
Three Teams
My belief is also that the Cubs will constantly be looking for the next Arrietta, and if they think they may have found one, they'll do what it takes to get him. I don't have confidence the Twins won't simply settle for the next Stauffer.
-
Three Teams
You think Berrios and Duffey are going to equal Lester and Arrietta next year?
-
Three Teams
It's pretty questionable how much value Hughes has in a trade today. He's 29, pitched 200 innings once in his career, has a career ERA over 4, topped out with a 111 ERA+ in his best season, has posted below average ERAs in 3 of the last 6 seasons, currently has lingering and unresolved injury issues, and is owed $49M over the next four seasons. BTW...Compare that to Hamels, who you don't want: 31 yrs old, has a LOW pt of a 104 ERA+ over the past six seasons and has been as high as a 152 ERA+ as recently as 2014, has pitched 200 or more innings in each of those seasons, and is owed 77M over the next three seasons (including his buyout). It doesn't make sense to me that somehow Hamels would "cripple" the Twins, but Hughes is a bargain. Yeah, Hughes costs less. He SHOULD cost less. A lot less.
-
Three Teams
Maybe. It might depend on which beat reporter you trust more: http://blogs.twincities.com/twins/2014/10/28/twinsights-contact-twins-joe-maddon-source-says/ In any case...the Cubs saw something they felt was a good gamble, and they went out and got it. The Twins didn't. That's sort of the point.
-
Three Teams
Concur. There's something to be said, but I don't think it's what you think it is.
-
Three Teams
A: I could be misremembering, but I thought it was pretty well established that the Twins DIDN'T contact Madden. B: You're missing the forest for the trees. The overall point is larger than the individual details of one specific person. The Cubs think big, and look for ways to excel. They worry less about the potential costs than the potential gains. The Twins think small, and look for ways not to fail. They worry less about the potential gains than the potential dangers. Yes, the Cubs have a few resource advantages. Focusing on that, yet again, misses the point.