Everything posted by USAFChief
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Fair enough.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
And it's not a one year anomaly.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Along with a year less of control.
-
Royals Ventura dies in car accident
Awful news.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Wha??
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
That's part of it.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
And desperate people often do stupid things. Lets hope the Twins don't.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
Um...yes? Sorry, couldn't resist.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
One post above, you stated "A team shouldn't have to give up two very strong prospects for two years of Dozier." It's hard for me to keep up with your position on this.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
So then there's no trade to be made, IMO. The Dodgers want to give up De Leon and nothing else of real value. You're ok with that. The Twins want more. I'm ok with that. The ball is in the Dodgers' court.
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
And yet, if one is to believe WAR--which I believe I've seen you defend--he's accumulated over 16 fWAR over the past four seasons. It's not just one year. He's a very good player, in the prime of his career, on a cheap contract, which is why the Dodgers want him. They want him because he's pretty much an exact match for an area of extreme need. So they can either pay up, or find some other, lesser option. It's really that simple. I hope they pay up. If they don't, I'll enjoy watching Dozier play for the Twins, and hopefully enjoy watching the Dodgers be good yet again, but not good enough, yet again.
-
Article: Twins To Deploy More Platoons In 2017?
Leave the roster size alone, or maybe expand by one. Put no restrictions on positions. Heck, let 15 man staffs evolve. If reducing the bullpen and expanding the bench is really an advantage, let some smart GM/manager use it to their advantage. Let "market inefficiencies" resolve the issue. Let baseball be baseball. The last thing I want to see is baseball become more like football, with offense, defense, special teams, nickel packages, etc etc ad nauseam.
-
Article: Twins To Deploy More Platoons In 2017?
Platooning has become very difficult with the ever expanding pitching staffs, no doubt. But at least for a position or two, not impossible. Every team will carry at least 4 outfielders, there's no reason a GM can't set it up so a platoon advantage exists for his weakest offensive outfielder. Every team carries two catchers, and a spare infielder. Same deal. Of course, the manager has to take advantage of his roster...
- Article: Don't Sleep On Phil Hughes
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
In any case, back to the topic. If the every day roster--minus the pitching--on this team isn't an above .500 unit, there are bigger problems. I think the pitching will be somewhat better, below average but better. So I expect the everyday lineup to be enough to get them close to .500. I agree with the OP.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
As I said, I believe luck is a factor. But I'm not prepared to write it all off as luck. That's not only a lazy explanation for why your model doesn't work, it wouldn't match any other human endeavor involving skill and competition. There are reasons, for example, why Joe Mauer has hit third most of his career and never drove in 100 runs. One reason is luck, but that's not the only one. It's not even the primary one. And a math model isn't going to capture that.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
I'd be all in favor of a RH hitting OFer, but isn't Grossman a SW hitter?
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
Certainly luck is a factor. But I doubt it's the only thing causing non-random distribution of events like hits. Certainly not over long time frames, like seasons.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
Good post, but a quibble...I'm reluctant to completely ascribe "sequencing" to luck. I don't think there's much evidence of that. And in fact, in at least my experience in other pursuits, to quote someone relevant, "luck is the residue of design."
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
I hope Robbie Grossman has fewer games played than Byron Buxton, unlike 2016. Kepler semi full time. More infield stability, less Eduardo Nunez. At least some improvement at catcher. Injuries and/or poor performance can alter any plan, but at least to start, this will not be a copy of 2016. Frankly, if the position players aren't already easily capable of 80 wins, this team is in real trouble. The "top farm system" of the past half decade is here. The question marks had better be primarily on the pitching side.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
All true, particularly injuries, although the defense will be better this year. And a 21 game improvement IS enormous. But smaller than a 24 game drop.
-
Article: The Twins Are Going to Win 80 Games in 2017
Significant advancement from Sano and Buxton has to be almost a given, right? Berrios and Kepler seem likely. Now you'd need only two or three more in your scenario, from the "possibles." I know the pitching needs to improve, but it should, just by accident. And from there, if the position players aren't good enough to get to around .500, then they likely never will.
- Article: How Does Keeping Dozier Fit With Long-Term View?
- Article: How Does Keeping Dozier Fit With Long-Term View?
-
Dozier Trade Discussion Thread
That's why the "surplus value" argument isn't worth the paper it's written on. Ignoring the problems with WAR itself, if your goal is to win baseball games: 10 WAR over 2 years >>>>> 10 WAR over 6 years. I would hope Falvey and Levine are smart enough to find 1.5 WAR pitchers without giving up 5 WAR players.