Everything posted by USAFChief
- Article: Twins Mailbag: Kohl Stewart, Mauer Extension, DH Options
-
2017-2018 International bonus money
huh...I'd take one yr of Cruz over all the remaining Braves prospects.
-
2017-2018 International bonus money
San Diego will be offering the exact same salary as another team. Just a smaller signing bonus.
-
Article: Falvine Ready To Flex Muscles
As noted above, I did not say a playoff spot was an obvious outcome. I said they were clearly in the chase for a playoff spot. Which they were, and had been all season. As for Fangraph's "playoff odds"... well, let's just say that's a pretty dubious number. Obviously.
-
Article: Falvine Ready To Flex Muscles
A lot of those things had been going right from April 1st to late July. There was no need to try to guess whether or not the Twins were in a chase for a playoff spot. They clearly were, and had been all season. Things would have had to go wrong for them NOT to stay in contention, rather than the other way around.
-
Article: Falvine Ready To Flex Muscles
Whether or not the Twins actually won the 2nd WC, or didn't, is NOT the point. The point is, they were in contention, should have recognized that, and didn't. That's what ultimately matters.
- Article: Can Phil Hughes Surprise Us?
-
Article: Falvine Ready To Flex Muscles
"...The playoff run was surprising." Maybe when viewed from the perspective of last March, but by July they had been in the hunt for a playoff spot since day 1 of the season, and one week in late July doesn't change that equation. Falvine didn't just wake up one morning in late July, read the STrib, and discover "Holy cow...we're IN this??" In fact, they traded FOR help one week earlier. "...it's not like we didn't make the playoffs." This is not a point in favor of your argument, or in favor of Falvine's actions. This is a point AGAINST their actions. The fact they made the postseason in spite of Falvine trading away pitching is just more proof they misread the situation badly. They clearly should have been trying to boost the team's chances, not reduce them. "...did we lose games we would have won with Jaime or Kinz?" This is after the fact reasoning, and also completely misses the point. "...Houston or Cleveland would have ousted us..." Again, completely misses the point. The bottom line is...Falvine misread the situation, and traded from, not to, a team in contention for the postseason. That's a mistake, and I believe they both would privately admit the same.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
We’re measuring value now? I thought we were measuring wins.
-
Article: Minnesota Making Strikeouts A Priority
The 8 or 9 pitch AB happens a lot for pitch to contact pitchers, too. Actually more IMO. They can’t get strike three past a hitter, leading to lots of foul balls and long ABs. Typically, the guy starting the 5th inning with 82 pitches isn’t the guy with 7 K’s at that point, it’s the guy with 2. The error in analytics is not in thinking K’s are a positive for pitchers. Rather, the error is in thinking K’s aren’t a negative for hitters. As Ash notes above, an out is NOT an out. Nobody ever knocked in a run on a K.
-
Article: Twins Mailbag: Extensions, 2020 Line-Up, Darvish, Ohtani
I stand corrected. 29 MLB teams, not 30.
- Article: The Twins Should Be Shopping Ervin Santana
-
Article: Twins Mailbag: Extensions, 2020 Line-Up, Darvish, Ohtani
But that’s part of the attraction of Ohtani. Ohtani will be treated like any other MLB player who comes up from your system. The same as Berrios, for example. Three years of serfdom, followed by three years of arbitration-eligibility. He could be extended, but doesn’t HAVE to be extended. There is zero salary commitment over and above what ANY rookie gets. He can’t be a FA sooner than when ANY rookie can be. Are you sorry the Twins spent $6m on a signing bonus for Buxton, and now have to worry about paying him? $3m on Sano? EVERY team in MLB would sign him if he said yes.
- Article: The Twins Should Be Shopping Ervin Santana
-
Article: Twins Mailbag: Extensions, 2020 Line-Up, Darvish, Ohtani
Obtain CAN'T get too much money. He'll be playing for the MLB minimum.
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
Sorry Jim, but this is where you and others lose me. The entire idea behind WAR is that runs=wins. Contribute X number of runs on offense, you have contributed Y number of wins. And they've got entire databases of, uh...data that they use to say a single is worth a certain number of runs, a double, a stole base, etc. Same thing on defense. Deny the other team Z number of runs, well, that equals Y number of wins. Forget the fact that the measurements used to determine Z are problematic at best, that's the theory. It's math...what matters is how many runs. And then they throw the whole thing out and say if a first baseman contributes 30 runs, and saves 10, he's delivered fewer wins than a shortstop who contributes 30 runs and saves 10. Quite a bit fewer, in fact. So it's not math?? Both of those players accounted for 40 runs.
-
Zack Granite's Impressive Plate Discipline
I'd prefer a RH hitting 4th OFer with some power.
-
Article: Twins Mailbag: Extensions, 2020 Line-Up, Darvish, Ohtani
Cody don't know who's on third.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
As I said, I’m skeptical. But it’s not like he just continued the same things and had a good stretch. I think someone convinced him to change his pitch mix. Easier to control the four seam, up, at 94-95, than the two seamer at 91-92. More called strikes, more swings and misses. Pitching ahead more, instead of always nibbling with the two seam and often 2-0 and 3-1. Being ahead in the count makes the slider more effective. We’ll see. Probably a mirage. But IMO he wasn’t the exact same guy.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
While I’m skeptical of Gibson, IMO there certainly is a chance of sustained improvement, due to what I believe was less emphasis on two seam and more emphasis on four seam fastball use, combined with more/better use of his slider. Gibson, IMO, is exhibit A in the argument against “pitch to contact.”
- Article: The Twins Should Be Shopping Ervin Santana
-
Vegas Underwhelmed with the Twins at 60:1
link?
- Article: Sho Time: Could The Twins Really Land Ohtani?
-
Re-opening the WAR debate
concur with every word. I also don't agree with the idea that a single from a first baseman is worth less than a single from a shortstop, which is another assumption baked into WAR.
- Article: Sho Time: Could The Twins Really Land Ohtani?