Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Taildragger8791

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Taildragger8791

  1. Kepler had to be put on the 40-man starting in 2014, so an option was burned even though he stayed in A+ ball the entire time.
  2. I don't think Dozier has demonstrated that he's going the other way with his swing yet, so I'm not sure what's changed other than a little luck and squaring up a few more balls. He still only has 4 opposite field hits all year, batting .182 on balls hit that way. Looking at spray charts it seems he is hitting up the middle a little more which could be a sign of progress, but it's hard to tell. I don't have time right now to break down the month-to-month and compare it to previous years to really tell, but that might indicate a change in approach.
  3. You're going to have to pick and choose which of the young players you want to give MLB time. You've argued to have everyone from Buxton to Kirilloff playing with the big club right now. This isn't beer league softball so someone has to sit. Buxton, Kepler, Rosario, Sano, Arcia, and I'll throw in Grossman (he's shown potential value and is actually performing) all need to play as much as possible.
  4. Sano has clearly produced with the bat, but I think people were expecting more of a well-rounded hitter like Miguel Cabrera as opposed to the boom/bust "three true outcomes" type like Giancarlo Stanton. Obviously you'd be happy with either player, but the prolonged slumps and untimely strikeouts that can accompany the latter player profile are frustrating at times. I think some are still hoping that he shrinks the holes in his swing and brings up the overall average.
  5. I got that from looking at their total career ERAs. The gymnastics you went through to show how it's "reasonable" to think that with upside and hopes of improvement these players would be at 4.00 again just reinforced my point. Gibson also had an ERA of 6.53 over 10 games in his debut season. Yes, I know it was his debut season but they still count and I'm trying not to pick arbitrary data points here. So his career ERA is 4.55. I understand he had a good year last year, but if you're hoping for improvement or a repeat of his best season instead of regression then you're still taking a chance. He's always been kind of hittable and isn't a big strikeout guy. That means he'll be prone to bouts of ineffectiveness, especially if his control or the defense wanes. Santana's the best bet, but he has 5 seasons of ERAs that range between 4.28 and 5.76 and then 6 seasons under 4.00. That's almost a coin flip as to which year you're going to get from him. Who knows how much those recent years you quoted were PED-assisted prior to his suspension? He certainly struggled when he returned from the bust. At age 33 and post-PEDs you're again just taking a chance that he'll outperform his average results. Maybe he's not "well" above 4.00, but he's above. Duffey only had 10 career starts in the majors coming into this year. He wasn't a top prospect. He looked good initially but the opponents didn't have time to adjust to him yet so I'm not sure you can even make a reasonable assumption about what to expect from him. You can hope for 4.00 but that should be considered the upside, not the expectation, and I wouldn't stake my team's season on it. Hughes had one good year as a starter over several years. He set the all-time record for walk rate in a season. Reproducing that after his marked decline last year was pretty unlikely. If you want to assure better results than this season you need to find 3 pitchers better than the above guys, and let the rest compete for the last 2 spots. Hopefully Berrios is one of those 3, but that's more "hope" since he isn't established yet. Santana will be a coin flip again with another year of age weighing down the wrong side of the coin. He's a fine #4 in a winning rotation at this point. I like Duffey and think we'll have a better picture of him by the end of the year. I don't know what to expect from him yet because he wasn't a highly regarded prospect and his performance so far has been volatile. I'm comfortable with him as a #5 and Gibson as a fall-back. That means Berrios needs to be at least a #3 and you still need two new pitchers at that level or better. The idea here is to anchor the upside of the rotation instead of hoping for 5 "reasonable" bets to pay off all at once. You'll lose that bet almost every time, which is how Vegas consistently comes out ahead despite giving huge odds on those 5-team parlays.
  6. The list seems pretty agreeable except I'd have a tough time putting Kirilloff into the top ten already. His floor/ceiling spread is huge since he's a total unknown (like most players after the top 5-10 picks), being anywhere from perennial all-star to AAA-washout. He has power, doesn't offer premium defensive value, and could prove to be fatally flawed with this swing length/speed. That puts names like Arcia/ABW/Vargas/Palka/Colabello in my head. Hard for me to push that projection above guys with a floor of actually contributing at the MLB level.
  7. Adding to that, Arcia hit for nearly a .300 average with power over his minor league career, with a high but not unmanageable 20% strikeout rate. Albeit with a somewhat low walk rate. That track record suggests he should be better than this, and we've seen that in glimpses. For some reason his development seems to have stagnated after getting to the majors. The drop off from those numbers to his major league numbers is just so stark that it's hard to believe there isn't some untapped ability still there.
  8. 25-30 HRs in a platoon role would be a fantastic addition to a team. Why can't we make that work here?
  9. Not picking on you Eddy, but this closing sentence in your post is exactly what I was referring to. We're already resigned to stumbling into next year with effectively the same pieces, plus a rookie in Berrios, and just hoping for better results.
  10. Do a lot of other teams regularly have struggles with players like this? It seems like we've had a handful of talented hitters, especially power guys, that show reasonably well in the minors and turn into one-dimensional-hitting strikeout-machines in the majors. They appear to have no idea or plan of how to utilize and improve him but they are aware he's much too talented to toss away, further validating that they don't know how to develop guys like him. At this point I agree we may as well cut him because you aren't getting any use out of him, and he has the feeling of a player that will go somewhere else and succeed in a system that plays up his strengths. Maybe he's a bit of a knucklehead with taking instruction, but he seems like an overall good guy in the clubhouse and deserves a chance to prove himself elsewhere.
  11. I'm not sure why you'd assume the group of Santana, Hughes, Duffey, & Gibson would be around 4.00 when all of them have career ERAs well north of that. As does Nolasco. Banking on all 5 of your starting pitchers to outperform their career averages to date seems like a losing gamble. Like betting a 5 team parlay for March Madness and being surprised when you got 1-4. I'm tired of having rosters built on hope and wishes for players to do something they've never consistently done before. When you go into a year needing X, Y, Z, A, B, and C to all fall your way that means you built a poor roster and are straight up gambling on a lucky turnout. If we go into next year with that rotation you mentioned, which I basically expect as well (also Nolasco somewhere), it's going to be an exact repeat of this season and we'd be foolish to expect any different. The only hope here is that Gonsalves, Stewart, Jay, and Berrios all magically work out and are up for 2018 ready to go. Past results suggest that's a long shot, but there's no way this rotation next year won't be a god awful cesspool of incompetence again.
  12. Even Killebrew went back down to the minors after his bonus baby year in the majors (when that was a thing) and that was in the mid-50's. It's beyond outrageous, that's easily exhibit A in your plea for insanity if you're on trial this week.
  13. Comments like that just make all the other believers in super aggressive promotions look conservative. There is a line somewhere, between letting guys gradually develop in the minors and pushing them up as fast as possible, and you pole vaulted right over it.
  14. The Twins hardly even publically recognize their Senators history so it's funny to think of them as having a third championship under their franchise. You'd think with Clark Griffith having such a long history with the Senators, and his son Calvin being the one who moved the team to Minnesota, that they'd feel more of a tie to those years. It wasn't even that long ago. Hell, Killebrew was there 6 years before relocating.
  15. If you dump him and replace him in the offseason you aren't very likely to do much better, and now you've just added significantly to your payroll for no real improvement. The Twins aren't exactly a bunch of miracle workers are picking up free agent pitchers.
  16. Why does everyone keep saying to dump Santana? He's one of the few SP above AA with a shot at being decent. You still need to fill out a rotation this year and next and there aren't 5 solid SP behind him. Without Nolasco/Santana/Hughes you'd have Gibson, Berrios, and Duffey as the only decent starting pitchers for next year. Possibly May on the unlikely chance he jumps back to starting. I don't consider Dean a real prospect and the rest of the names are pure lottery tickets. If the Twins went into the season with no reliable #4 and #5 starter, an no options for fallback or injury replacements, it would be absolute mayhem again. Stewart, Gonsalves, and Jay aren't going to be ready for the start of the season and may not even be ready by midseason. I'm not clearing out the major league roster for them this early.
  17. Good list. Unfortunately it's fantasy to believe Terry Ryan will change his stripes and suddenly start clearing out vets, dumping expensive contracts, or trading someone at their peak of value (Abad). This is going to be the same roster next year except for the pieces that we let walk away for nothing. No creativity or gumption.
  18. Barring a setback, I'm expecting Chargois will be up within a month or so which would still give him 2-3 months to adjust at the MLB level in preparation for next year. That would still be an impressively quick rise for a guy who has only 86 innings over 1.5 seasons played in the minors (not counting missing 2 full seasons due to Tommy John surgery). He hasn't been held back at all. The catch-22 we seem to keep running into here is that you can't promote a guy who hasn't demonstrated sustained success at his current level, but as soon as someone does demonstrate that sustained success there are screams to promote and quit holding him back. Yes, there are some guys who have legitimate gripes about lingering at a level, and Chargois is not one of them (yet). The Twins have been moving top performers faster over the last few years and if anything they have moved some guys too fast through the upper levels. Though I do wish they'd flip flop on the handling of pitchers (too slow at times) and hitters (too fast at times) based on the limited shelf life of many pitchers and fewer adjustments needed.
  19. It's a nice outdoor stadium in the middle of downtown, and for some it's still seen as a fun way to spend a nice day on a weekend. A number of people will still show up if tickets are going cheap enough, and then spend a decent coin on massively marked up concessions and team gear. Pretty tough to not print money with that setup.
  20. My guess is season and single game ticket sales will be drastically down next year, and subsequent years until they demonstrate sustainable success. But as the Marlins and Astros have shown that can still be pretty profitable as long as payroll is low enough, and the Twins will be in a position in a couple years to have almost entirely minimum contracts. Especially if they manage to shed some pitchers. So the pressure to win won't come from the financial side of things. The Twins will always print money, especially with that ballpark and MLB revenue sharing.
  21. I think the rule is that you have to wait until the end of September. But once the offseason starts you can no longer look back at this season, of course, because it doesn't have any bearing on next year. It was just a blip and the product of contagious non-hitting throughout the roster. SSS, cherry picking, past performance isn't predicative of future results, etc etc etc.
  22. Is there any word on what Jake Reed's struggles are at AA? He walks a few too many guys but he's very hittable as well. The shine is wearing off him quickly and it doesn't look like he'll be helping the big club anytime in the near future unless there's some yet-unidentified adjustment to be made. It's too bad he and Burdi haven't put it together at AA at all, they were really pushed as surefire MLB relievers that should move quickly. What's the health status on Burdi?
  23. I'm still looking, but so far I haven't been able to find the car in the photo. Are you sure it's the right picture?
  24. This is basically my feeling about any trades like this. The Twins need all their hitting prospects to pan out as it is, because there isn't another wave of talent pushing its way up to the big club in the next few years. I wouldn't be trading any of the top talent. I also can't stomach another decent NL pitcher coming over and getting shelled for 3-4 years after we invested in him. Clearly something isn't translating well in the Twins' evaluation of NL pitchers so I'd hope they keep the phone in the pocket.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.