Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Taildragger8791

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Taildragger8791

  1. Berrios had a 14 game tryout in the majors last year, almost half a season's worth of starts, in which he showed no progress or trend towards competence. So they asked him to go back down and work on a couple things and he's had 5 games to do that. I can understand disagreeing philosophically on how many starts before bringing him back up but that sounds awfully reasonable to wait more than a few games before yanking him back up. We complain about yo-yoing guys up and down and it seems like the Twins are trying to avoid that here yet they're getting castigated for it.
  2. Our impatience with prospects is such a catch-22. If a guy struggles then nobody says a word. They want to see success before a promotion. Yet at the first demonstrated success there are loud calls for promotions and complaints that the player is overqualified and being held back. You can't have it both ways. Personally, I'd be pretty bitter and upset with my employer if they threw me into situations I wasn't properly prepared and trained for only to watch me drown when they could have thrown me a lifesaver. There's a reason we don't hire college grads for critical roles on projects. Sure, you might get lucky once a generation and get a genius powerhouse that can't fail. Most likely though you'll just get an overmatched kid and everybody ends up with egg on their face.
  3. Many people said before the season that the key for Berrios to get back to the majors wasn't going to be easily discerned from the box scores. It's not about dominating again or "proving" anything by getting results on the scoreboard. He dominated before and he'll continue to dominate (hopefully). It's about his mechanics and how he executes pitches. Nobody should be surprised that he's putting up great stats, so why bug out that he isn't insta-promoted after every strikeout?
  4. Coaches and teams aren't going to tell us everything, or be 100% open and honest, so you just have to accept that. Yes, command of his pitches is one issue, but pitch tipping exacerbated that because anything he threw in the zone was going to get crushed when major league hitters have already eliminated the offspeed stuff. At that point all they're looking for is one speed and type of pitch and just have to read location. That is a cakewalk to those guys. No, it's not indefinitely. He's still young for a pitching prospect. It isn't unreasonable to send a guy up and down while he works on things. Every team does it. That's part of the development process. And pitchers have a disproportionate impact on the team so it's much more important that they be able to achieve an acceptable baseline of performance before you let them struggle it out in the big leagues. If he's cemented in the big leagues by the end of the year is anybody going to remember that he spent an extra few months figuring it out in AAA to start his career?
  5. They talked pretty specifically this spring about him taking the ball straight back more to help with command and not tipping his pitches so much. I don't think his problem was exclusively command, but that he also tipped his offspeed stuff which allowed hitters to pick what they want to swing at. That forced him to nibble more and live out of the zone because he was getting crushed.
  6. Because he still has the same critical flaws to fix. Maybe Berrios just didn't realize how serious they were about it until he faced major league hitters. It's hard to really internalize what someone is telling you about your mistakes until you feel the effects of them. So yeah, he has 200 innings, but only a small percentage of those have come since he's gotten that wakeup call.
  7. I don't see how Mauer rubbed off on Sano in any way. Sano just learned how to lay off unhittable pitches and attack the others. That's just experience. He did it in the minors, so it follows that he'd eventually figure it out in the majors. If he learned from Mauer then we'd see him watching grooved fastballs instead of sending those balls into people's faces in straightaway center.
  8. Man, everybody sure seems to think the entire Twins organization is either incompetent or evil for their handling of Berrios and other prospects. I understand the team hasn't earned any equity or benefit of the doubt but this isn't an example I can get behind. Berrios is 22. He's still pretty darn young. An extra month or two to make sure his next call-up to the majors is successful and hopefully his last is a worthwhile and responsible way to handle him. They aren't keeping him down because they think he's trash or don't want to pay him. They aren't going to keep him down indefinitely and then lose him. They just want to make sure he doesn't hit a brick wall at 100 mph again like he did last year. Yes, I want to see Berrios up here soon too. But I trust that the front office is taking the long view and want to be convinced he's set up for success before his next promotion. Meanwhile, let the current rotation sort itself out so we can finally clean house on marginal pitchers. An overmatched starting pitcher is far more damaging to a team than an overmatched 9th hitter that brings excellent defense. That is why Buxton gets to figure it out in the majors despite being the WORST hitter in baseball for long stretches, whereas no team is going to give that kind of leash to the worst starting pitcher in baseball. Also, please spare the argument that Gibson pitching over Berrios means they think he's better and are too dumb to see the reality. I've been as done with Gibson as anybody but even I can understand their desire to exhaust every possibility with salvaging him while he's still cheap. He'll be gone soon enough at this rate.
  9. This statistic is often repeated and is as broken and misleading as the one claiming women make $0.77 on the dollar relative to men. When you consider only American-born players roughly 12% are African American, which is pretty close to the national average of the population. I can't really get too worked up with this gripe that African Americans aren't fairly represented in baseball relative to American population demographics. NFL is at 68% and NBA is at 75%. I don't see anyone complaining about tilted demographics in those sports. Why is it a crime to be normally represented instead of overrepresented? And why is this complaint always based on the idea that players born outside the 50 states somehow don't count?
  10. Don't forget Vargas was signed that year too. That's 4 out of 9 guys in our recent lineups signed by Bill Smith in one year.
  11. That's possible, and I'm open to it. I just don't see how everything would come together at a point that the Twins both want to sign him and they'd agree on a price they're willing to pay. If we think his baseline is lower than he does based on the way this season played out, then he may want to bet on himself in his contract year to bring his value up. It'll be the only opportunity he ever gets for a big contract. If he establishes his baseline as being sky high then he'd suddenly be worth a mint on the trade market and may be gone anyways. At that point it still might make sense to wait a year and make him prove it again since he won't get any more expensive. Like I said, I just don't see how it all comes together.
  12. Extending Dozier after what was almost certainly a career-best outlier of a season is how you end up with an albatross contract and a player you can't move off of an important starting position for several years. He won't sign cheap right now, especially until he knows if he's getting traded or not. If they don't trade him then I'm totally fine letting him play out his contract and see where his value stands at that point.
  13. They might have fit into the budget, but how do we know that Bill Smith wasn't providing some different direction/priorities at the time that led us to signing those players vs others? It sort of stands out when some of our best international signings the last 10 years came in the short span Smith was at the helm.
  14. The average may come down but the power will remain. And when you hit the ball as hard as he does consistently, the BABIP will be elevated from the norm anyways. So it shouldn't fall off the table completely.
  15. The statement I was making is that Berrios has a big range right now of where he could end up. Few guys can really maximize their talents and hit their absolute ceiling because another gap in their game holds them back. My point was if he is one of those guys I could see him topping out as a #2 pitcher, but that's really hard to do and I like to set realistic expectations. So in my view his more realistic ceiling, the point at which I think everyone should be pretty satisfied, is if he settled in as a mid-rotation guy for a long time. That's very doable for him and would represent the best pitcher we've developed in quite a while around here. But first he has to get over whatever is holding him back from successfully making the jump from AAA to MLB. Lots of guys don't figure that step out and I wouldn't take it for granted that he will. In other words, I was trying to describe his probability of success as more like a curve. 5% chance he's a #2, 40% chance he's a solid mid-rotation pitcher, 35% chance he's a back-end rotation guy, and 20% chance he busts within 4 years. Only a 20% chance to bust is pretty good and well below the rate we've experienced around Minnesota for the last decade. And of course these numbers are very arbitrary and loose, but I hope it helps better illustrate the point I was making.
  16. Looks like they just cut the whole hockey department too, doubling down that bet on football and basketball. They should just rename it "E!spn" since their time is increasingly spent reporting on tweets, debating drama that they themselves manufactured, and offering up superficial analysis like "which team wanted it more". Half the time I turn it on it's just Screamin' A. Smith yelling at me for some reason. I still haven't figured out what he's so angry about so I just turn it off as soon as I see his dumb face spraying slobber at the camera.
  17. Get it all out of your system in one game boys. It still only counts as one L and we'll still happily take the series win.
  18. He actually has 44 plate appearances which is a little more meaningful since he's been drawing a lot of walks. And only 4 strikeouts, which his impressive. I'm not making any statements on the situation, just didn't want that to fall through the cracks. (slowly backs out of the conversation)
  19. Apparently Sano forgot he's not actually superman trying to stretch that double while weighing in at 265 lbs.
  20. I hope Santana is keeping the arm loose. Heck of a long time to be sitting in the dugout.
  21. Looks like Napoli got cheated on that throw.
  22. Looks like control is still a little iffy. 3 walks in 6 innings (102 pitches) and 62% of his pitches for strikes. The strikeouts are nice, as are the low hits/runs totals. I'm guessing he didn't punch a ticket to the majors today though.
  23. Is it Mauer? It's Mauer, isn't it. If I've learned one thing from reading STrib commenters it's that it's always Mauer's fault.
  24. I think that's pretty much the consensus. Nobody is saying he's toast or to give up on him. Just that there are legitimate concerns because of the ongoing severity of his struggles and ineptitude to this point. I just don't think pointing to mini slumps that other players have had really says anything useful one way or the other about Buxton. Particularly when those slumps don't really compare all that well (different root cause, different types of players, different era, etc). It would be more helpful to find cases of talented players that had his level of strikeout and pitch recognition issues and actually overcame them.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.