Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Randball: Buxton on a roll
Oh yes, all those elite talented pitchers the Twins have drafted and signed that were on the fast track to the majors only to be ruined when they got to AAA.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (5/9): Rodriguez Slams Lookouts To Win
On the hitting side there was Sano, Buxton, and Vargas. And Polanco sort of made that jump too, although that was mostly as an emergency backfill. (Edit: Kepler and Rosario barely spent any time at AAA before getting to the majors too) Can't think of recent examples on the pitching side, but then again we haven't had any quality pitching to promote in the last decade except Berrios, who we can now see wasn't ready to jump straight from AA. Chargois was being slow-played last year coming back from injury, otherwise he might have gone straight from AA. Burdi might be the first pitcher they've had that is good enough and also in the right position to do it. It seems Twins pitchers tend to go to AAA to refine command against before being promoted. Hopefully a live arm like Burdi is good enough to skip that step.
-
If then.....a trade for pitching question.
I think we have the makings to put together a competitive lineup for sure. But you can't regularly out-hit the kind of damage that our pitchers can do. We showed that last year when we lost over 100 games despite an average-ish offense. If Berrios and Mejia both establish themselves by midseason and Santiago doesn't turn into a pumpkin, and Hughes holds on to be marginally effective, and Duffey comes back to the rotation and holds his own, and the bullpen turns over throughout the year with young guys sticking, then maybe you can think about this being the start of something real. But that is a whole lot of "ifs" to get to that point.
-
If then.....a trade for pitching question.
Fans support actual winners. Perennial winners. Not teams that play over their head for a couple months. That's why Target Field is still only 1/3rd full despite being over .500 and even spending time in 1st place in the division in May.
-
If then.....a trade for pitching question.
As painful as it would be to gut a competitive team after years of despair, it's the smart approach. Otherwise this team could end up right back in the gutter next year like they did going from '15 to '16. This team isn't going anywhere until it gets sustainable pitching and that's not going to come from within the organization or in free agency in the next few years.
-
If then.....a trade for pitching question.
I think you'd almost have to in order to get any real value back, assuming other teams value the player(s) also. I don't think we have any non-pitching prospects that would generate serious interest in a trade partner other than maybe Nick Gordon or a package of several A-ball & rookie league players. As much as I like Rosario/Polanco/Vargas we are in a good position to replace them internally or in free agency next year. Sano, Buxton, and maybe Kepler are my only untouchables. I'd still be willing to listen on Kepler if the return pitching was crazy good.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. Red Sox, 5/6/17 @ 1:10pm CT
-
Article: The Joe Mauer Quagmire
Or it just means he doesn't hit a lot of weak popups, which historically has been true for him. He typically is one of the top hitters in baseball in terms of avoiding pop-ups. That removes a lot of in-play balls with low exit velocity that bring the average down. On the other hand, stinging balls into the ground to 2nd base doesn't accomplish much despite looking good on exit velocity charts.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
-
Berrios and the Front Office
I highly doubt they'd be that petty or unprofessional. I do believe that they didn't want him to go to the WBC, but that was because they wanted more time to work with him during a critical phase of his development. That was a big opportunity to utilize a controlled learning environment where the games don't count and everyone can watch him. Maybe he'd have been ready to come up by now if that were the case. Instead, he went off to rot on a bench for weeks, away from the coaches that know him and have his best interests in mind. That resulted in a setback that he's having to work through now.
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
- Game Thread: Twins vs. A's, 5/4 @ 12:10PM CT
-
Berrios and the Front Office
How can you be so certain that he's much, much better? If he was the same guy at the start of this year as he was at the end of last year then it's more likely that Berrios would be costing us games than winning them right now.
-
Berrios and the Front Office
30 of those starts were before his 2-month call-up to end last season, which was hopefully the wakeup call that made it clear he needs to fix some things. Only 5 starts have come since he went back down to work on those things. I think that's the important number to watch. He didn't look any different in spring training or the WBC, by the way, so I don't see evidence that he corrected those flaws in the offseason. If he's up after another 3-4 starts are we really going to care that he spent an extra few weeks at AAA? If we're still sitting here mid-summer and he hasn't gotten a look yet despite continuing to dominate then I'll be right there with you. I just don't think we're anywhere near the point of unreasonableness yet.
-
Berrios and the Front Office
There are plenty of things the Twins have earned criticism for, and I've been pretty vocal about a lot of them. I just don't see how a few weeks this way or that way on when they call up a young pitcher who failed spectacularly in previous call-ups is really the issue worth raking them over the coals for. This isn't as anywhere near as egregious as their handling of other prospects (particularly May and every centerfielder the last several years). I mean, Berrios had 14 starts last year and only two of them were big league quality. He averaged 4 1/2 innings per start. I'd say they gave him a pretty fair tryout and it isn't unreasonable that they wanted to see some changes before they throw him back out there for another go at it. And they probably want to be confident that his next call-up will be successful instead of yanking him back and forth or disrupting the good thing that's going at Target Field right now.
-
Berrios and the Front Office
How patient would everyone be if his struggles are as bad as last year? Comparable to Buxton's ineptitude for months at a time? Would you be willing to take this first-place Twins team and just forfeit 20% or more of their games for the next month or two? At what point would even you throw up your hands and say send him down until he straightens out his flaws? It wreaks havoc on a team and a bullpen when a starter is getting knocked out in the 4th inning every time out, and those effects are felt for the next 2-3 games as well. I'd be fine if Berrios were called up now, but I'd also expect to see a drastic improvement from last year before I'd extend his stay beyond 3-4 games.
-
Berrios and the Front Office
I don't think he was "passed over" so much as they think he fills a critical role in the bullpen right now, which is also serving to help set him up for success. We'd be castigating the team if he were getting yo-yo'd back and forth between roles just as much as they're apparently getting castigated for sticking to a defined role for more than a month at a time.
-
Berrios staying in the minors?
Tepesch is just a warm body with an arm. He isn't up because they think he's the better player or prospect. I wouldn't get worked up about him other than it means the team failed to provide any depth to buffer between their prospects and their starting staff. If they dumped Gibson tomorrow it still wouldn't necessarily mean Berrios will be promoted. It might just mean they find another filler candidate for the rotation that nobody will like either.