Everything posted by Taildragger8791
-
Article: MIN 5, SDP 2: Don’t Need a Closer When You’ve Got Erv
You'd be wrong. Only one year in the last 10 has there not been a starter with 5+ CGs (there were several with 4 instead), and usually there are multiple. It's a great feat and indicative of a very good pitcher, but it doesn't make someone an ace. His ERA is over 5 since the start of June. It's still over 4 since the start of May. That's because he's been highly volatile, flipping between good/great and poor. Like I said, a very good pitcher and is a decent #2 or very solid #3 as it stands today. But given the choice there are probably 15-20 pitchers that you'd take before him to start game 1 in the playoffs. That alone kind of knocks him out of the argument of being a #1 on a contender. Also, his FIP is a run and a half higher than his ERA because his peripherals are much more middle-of-the-road. Not that I think his FIP represents the 'true' Santana but it does point to some underlying issues which manifest during his blow-up games.
-
Article: MIN 5, SDP 2: Don’t Need a Closer When You’ve Got Erv
In a typical year that's good for somewhere in the 6th-8th range, but you're still talking about a pretty useless statistic. It's a rough indicator of performance, at best, with a lot of randomness and external factors built in.
-
Article: MIN 5, SDP 2: Don’t Need a Closer When You’ve Got Erv
Going to be tough when he already has 7 losses and has a pattern of crapping the bed every 2nd or 3rd start. I'd peg him around 17 wins. Still very good but not a #1 for a contender if that's what you're implying. He plays up to that level at times but the differentiator is consistency. There's a reason his FIP is 4.81 and career ERA is 4.08. He's a very solid #3 that can play up and pass as a #2 for stretches. If the league saw him as more than that then he'd have had a much hotter trade market. Teams would kill to get a true #1/#2 pitcher for only $14 million per year.
-
Article: Twins Need Sagging Bats To Rev It Up
Unfortunately, our OF doesn't provide much power or have the potential for it. The most you can reasonably ask for is 15-20 HRs each from these guys, maybe a few more down the road in peak years. Dozier has power but it's way too inconsistent and mostly shows up in empty base situations (only driven in 2 runs besides himself on homeruns, both times it was Chris Gimenez oddly enough). He's stated he doesn't want to hit middle of the order so he's not really compensating for Mauer's and our DH's below average production. If this team is going to take a step forward offensively next year they'll have to address 1B/DH, reducing Mauer's playing time significantly. He'll make a fine parttime player, backup, and bench bat while he rides out the final year of his contract.
-
Article: Twins Need Sagging Bats To Rev It Up
I didn't say 'easy', just 'easiest'. We're not replacing any of the young outfielders. SS, 2B, and 3B are going to be held for players currently on the roster or in the minors. Catcher is what it is. 1B and DH are the only spots that aren't locked down by produtive veterans or young talent. Those are also the spots where more affordable offense-first players can be readily hidden. Whether or not the stars line up to make it happen...who knows.
-
Article: Twins Need Sagging Bats To Rev It Up
1B and DH should be the easiest places to find upgrades in free agency this year. They need more XBHs and run production out of those spots, because we aren't going to get it from up the middle players on this squad (Dozier's solo homers excluded) and Rosario/Kepler aren't exactly destroyers of baseballs either. I don't know what this means for Mauer, and he hasn't been bad by any means, but there is so much more opportunity for offense out of the position he occupies. A 60-RBI first baseman, even with gold glove defense, just leaves too much on the table.
-
Article: Twins Trade Pieces Not That Valuable
I totally understand the zeal - a lot of people recognize that he's the most immediately replaceable veteran on the roster that actually performs at a league average level while also being on a reasonable contract. A slugging 2nd baseman is a luxury on a losing team anyways. That should have made him the best trade asset we've had in a long tim but unfortunately the demand just wasn't there. Oh, and the 2B logjam will be there starting sometime next year when Polanco, Gordon, Dozier, Escobar, and Adrianza are all trying to find playing time. I don't see a logjam in the outfield yet. Granite is likely a 4th outfielder so he fits in just fine. Grossman is an OF by technicality only, he doesn't play out there any more than necessary. There aren't any OF prospects beating down the door next year, and starting in 2019 we'll have an opening at 1B to rotate guys through as well. I see that situation working itself out with minimal pain.
- Article: Rule 5 Addition Discussion
-
Article: Official Twins Daily July Trade Deadline Day Thread
Playing in the launching pad known as the PCL, where Oswaldo Arcia is hitting .350/.434/.686. So a grain of salt should be taken with the numbers. But to his credit, Calhoun for his career does have a low strikeout rate which should boost his odds of success.
-
Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
It may be, it may not be. But I don't see any reason for hard feelings and I'm not sure why you're suggesting there is. Nobody is talking about him taking a discount to come back here either, so you can drop that argument. If the Twins put in a competitive offer and he enjoyed his time here, which his comments suggest, then they have a shot to get him back. And if not then he was probably going to walk at the end of the year anyways and we're in the exact same position we are now, with no Kintzler on the 2018 roster. Except now we have one more lotto ticket in the system. Edit: And I say "the only significant contract he'll ever get" because he turns 33 tomorrow and has had a pretty unconventional career path to date. He's not going to be getting any multi-year deals when he's 36+.
-
Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
Kintzler himself already suggested it was a possibility, so obviously he doesn't share your sentiment. I also doubt he's too upset about getting to leap from a non-playoff team to a World Series contender where he can showcase himself for the only significant free agent contract he'll ever get.
- Article: Twins Trade Kintzler To Nationals
-
If Dozier is dealt...then what?
Gordon wouldn't burn an option unless he got optioned for for 20 days or more. We're only a couple weeks from being within 20 days of rosters expanding to where that's not going to be an issue. But I'd still agree with letting him continue to marinate in the minors this year, based on his recent performance.
-
Article: OAK 6, MIN 5: Deja Vu
That was my thought too. He gives a little power protection to keep pitchers honest, and even if he is a bit streaky you still have to respect it.
-
Article: OAK 6, MIN 5: Deja Vu
10 K's for Dozier in the series. Ouch. Does he really make the most sense as leadoff hitter at this point? He's hitting .247/.329/.438 which also happens to be almost exactly his career slash line. Looks more like a mid-lineup guy.
-
Article: LAD 6, MIN 5: Uff Da
Saying they "should have won" kind of hand waves away the reasons they didn't win though. They lost because their starting pitching is wobbly and the bullpen is overworked and lacks both depth and high-end talent. Those are real flaws that they haven't been able to fix for too long now. Even the offense has been streaky and too dependant on performance from a few core hitters, lacking the depth to compensate when those guys occassionally can't come through. Over several games these things starkly separate us from the upper echelon teams and make it difficult to beat them consistently. I think that's all people are expressing here, not that they're outright terrible.
-
Can selling now improve 2018?
There are reasons for optimism but we're still a very flawed club. We're going to have to replace Santana's early season otherworldly production in addition to getting 2-3 more reliable starters, and replace almost the entire bullpen. There are no promises any of the young arms in the system (or May/Perkins) will be impact players, so we're going outside the organization to find all that production which is expensive, unreliable, and difficult. There's also going to be significant shuffling going on at SS/2B/1B/C/DH the next couple years. That's a lot of moving parts to find and make work in the short term with limited trade/payroll resources.
-
MLB.com midseason prospect list
There was a mention of it in the second item of this short article. Edit: Forgot the article. http://www.startribune.com/berrios-trainer-spots-a-flaw-other-postgame-notes/435496263/
-
MLB.com midseason prospect list
That was the report a few weeks ago. There was a new report in the last week that now they think it's just a shoulder impingement again and he's going to try to pitch again.
-
MLB.com midseason prospect list
He's a reliever, and an injury-riddled one at that. That's going to suppress his ranking a little bit unless he's just utterly dominant and rocketing towards the majors. It sounds like they're still trying to work out exactly what his current issue is too, which doesn't inspire confidence. He had bicep tendinitis, then a mysterious nerve/shoulder impingement, then they thought it was TOS and needed surgery, and now a few weeks later it's totally not TOS and he's going to try and pitch through it. Sounds like they aren't really sure what's going on either. Fingers crossed.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins @ Dodgers, 7/24@9:10pm CT
Ahem, he's only 3/4. Not that anyone is complaining about 2 doubles and a jack. Raised his OPS from .790 to .817 in one game.
- Game Thread: Twins v Yankees, 7/18@7:10pm CT (5:10pm PT)
-
Article: Astros 5, Twins 3: Defensive Shortcomings Spoil Solid Start From Gibson
I didn't see the game so I'm having a hard time understanding reports that Gibson pitched really well when he was at 96 pitches with 6 hits, 3 walks, and 3 runs after 6 innings. Not bad for a back-end starter but still seems inefficient and the WHIP is again too high. If we're grading on a scale then I suppose I understand the faint praise a little more, but even for a 5th starter that line should be more the norm than the exception.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (7/16): Romero Strong in Short Start, Rooker Homers Again
The comparison isn't quite that even. ABW's K rate in college was also about 19.6% his last year and he was only 20 years old in Elizabethton, not 22 like Rooker. I'm not making any assessment about what this means, just pointing out that their situations weren't as equivalent as you suggest.
-
Quintana to the Cubs
Those mid-level players are easier to acquire than top-end pitching though. Free agency, the draft, and international free agency are all more reliable for finding decent position players at reasonable cost. Really good starting pitchers are more of a crapshoot to develop and are rarely available in free agency for less than a mint.