Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Deduno Abides

Provisional Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Deduno Abides

  1. Gardy is a proven winner like Matt Capps is a proven closer. Sure, he had some good seasons in the past (although, geez, history sure would be more in his favor if he won more than one post-season series in his career), but . . . oh, my, he should go before he figuratively falls down chasing a ball in centerfield, to mix metaphors. To use another analogy, a manager with four straight seasons of 90+ losses seems equivalent to being a left fielder with a .625 OPS. People saying Gardy should stay are using the same message the team used when Johan Santana was here and said was a reason he wanted to leave - "it's going to get better next year (or the year after that)." After a while, the scholarship is over. I am not familiar with many few organizations in any line of business that keep a leader after four straight years of terrible results and, of the small group that does, I'm not aware of any that see improvement under that leader. By the way, my prediction is that Gardy will return in 2015, unless he chooses to leave. Few good external candidates would want to come here without being certain of a total housecleaning in management, player development and pro and amateur scouting. Team leadership could not contemplate that more than twenty seconds - mass change is not their style and they would worry about the message fans would infer from wholesale changes (not that different from companies that keep bad leadership in place under the stated belief that investors and employees would get scared if the bad leader was fired). Instead, Twins leadership would consider it more palatable to muddle along for a few more years, hoping the fans continue as long as possible to buy the dream that one day Sano, Buxton and Meyer will turn into Cabrera, Trout and Verlander in his prime and lead the remaining players to the promised land. Further, Bill Springman, the minor league hitting coordinator, has already been identified as the fall guy for 2014, despite the fact that players with 0-3 years of major league experience, i.e., recent recipients of minor league hitting instruction - are the predominant reason for the team's offensive improvement this year.
  2. Wikipedia says Ron Davis retired in 1988. Maybe people that say you can't trust everything you read on Wikipedia are right.
  3. Strong optimism for 2015 with the present roster and minor leaguers requires the following: (1) Phil Hughes not to develop an elbow or shoulder issue or otherwise repeat his historical pattern of one good year followed by one or two bad years; (2) Joe Mauer to return to the physical skills of ages 24-28 during his 32nd year of living, and not to require extended time on the DL or fatuous excuses from management, and to recover his batting eye or bat speed or whatever it was that caused his BB/K ratio this year to be his career worst by a long shot; (3) Byron Buxton at age 22 to perform like Andrew McCutcheon when he was 25, even though McCutcheon had a .770 OPS in AAA when he was 21, whereas Buxton had a lost year in A/AA at the same age, and McCutcheon did not fully approach dominance until his fourth year in the majors; (4) Miguel Sano to perform at age 22 like Miguel Cabrera performed at age 22, even though Cabrera at 21 was a major league all-star, an age at which Sano did not play, and Cabrera received major league MVP votes at age 20, an age at which Sano played A/AA; (5) Alex Meyer to be healthy and effective (and given a meaningful chance and not criticized publicly by his coaches or their media mouthpieces every time he doesn't look like Roy Halladay in his prime); (6) Ricky Nolasco to be, not just better, but significantly better than he was this year, even though the only year in his career he was more than a 1.8 WAR pitcher was 2008, when he was 25; (7) Danny Santana and Kennys Vargas not to significantly regress and Oswaldo Arcia to significantly improve; (8) Kurt Suzuki to confirm that he has reached a new level of performance and not to regress into the Suzuki of 2010-2013; (9) Trevor May to significantly improve (this may be the most likely item on this list); (10) Tommy Milone and/or Mike Pelfrey to be serviceable major league pitchers; (11) The team to rebuild its bullpen and hope that Glen Perkins stays strong and Casey Fien of 2015 doesn't turn into Jared Burton of 2014; and (12) One or two minor leaguers with question marks - Pinto? Hicks? Rosario? - to figure out what's holding them back and make an impact. If you're comfortable that the negative items in this list are unlikely and the positive items are likely, then you should be comfortable not making significant moves this winter. If, on the other hand, you are pessimistic about several items on this list, the Twins should either go after Max Scherzer and/or James Shields and a couple of bats, or push even harder to rebuild the minor league system by trading for top prospects like the Cubs did in getting Addison Russell and others. My guess is that some of these items will be positive, while several will be negative. Sure, the team looks more hopeful this year, with the emergence of some young players and the pitching of Phil Hughes, but the team is once again collectively a 90+ loss team. If all else holds even or improves (e.g., Dozier, Cabrera, Gibson, left field) and these items are on balance mildly positive, the team likely would still be sub .500. To truly compete for the post-season without major changes in the roster, these items must on balance be mostly positive and the Doziers, Gibsons and Cabreras must be much better.
  4. "See me, pitch me, touch me, crush me-ee-ee-ee-ee"
  5. Well, I guess that's the end. Deduno abides. I don't know about you but I take comfort in that. It's good knowin' he's out there. Deduno. Takin' 'er easy for all us sinners. Shoosh. I sure hope he makes the finals.
  6. Package Correia and Suzuki to a team needing a pitcher and a catcher, such as the Orioles and Cardinals. See if you can get one of their top prospects. Dream on Oscar Taveras. Include Arcia as a sweetener, if necessary. Try to get a Top 50 prospect for Dozier, plus maybe a class A player with potential. Don't trade if can't get a good return. Get whatever you can for Willingham, Morales, Burton, and possibly Duensing. Also, free Colabello. Someone will value his ability. Finally, stop tying up payroll in mediocre $5M to $10M players and mediocre $2M to $3M middle relievers, with "mediocre" defined as "never going to the All-Star game unless he buys his own ticket, unless he receives the Ron Coomer exemption."
  7. It's a good thing Pinto and his terrible, horrible, no good, very bad receiving hasn't been catching the starters during this series or who knows what could have happened!!
  8. M. Birdwatcher, it seems that every time someone criticizes Ryan, for example, someone in his defense points out something he did well, as if he should not be criticized until everything he does is a mistake and it can be easily seen that he is the worst GM in the league (which he isn't and which should not be the litmus test of continuing in his job). If you believe the reasons listed in my earlier post are not the defenses commonly given for retaining TR and RG, please identify the reasons why you think they should be retained. These are good baseball people we are discussing and there could be very good reasons for retaining them that I am missing (although I think they have grown very stale as members of the Minnesota Twins organization - as Bill James sort of said many years ago, usually people get hired to bring certain skills to an organization and usually they later get fired because those skills are no longer the ones the organization needs), and I would be interested in hearing these reasons.
  9. Two thoughts. First, sometimes it seems that people wishing to retain Ryan and Gardenhire have perhaps two or three key arguments. None of these are good arguments for continued employment. The arguments are the following: (1) they're not the worst in the league; (2) they've done pretty good jobs in the past; and (3) they deserve a chance when the next crop of stars reach the majors. These arguments are not that good. (1) "Not the worst" is true, but does not mean the best or even near the best. Their track records are long enough to know what Ryan and Gardenhire bring to the table and how they go about their jobs, and it would take at least six hits of the lucky stick for them ever to come close to the World Series. (2) It's true that they've done a decent job in the past, but their best result has been getting crushed in the ALCS twelve years ago. After that, the Twins were a competitive team for most of the decade and made the playoffs frequently, but each playoff appearance was a splat. (3) When Sano and Buxton make the majors, with the team as currently constituted, they will both need to be better than Mike Trout to lead this team deep into the playoffs. It's not likely that they will both be that good that quickly, which means that people saying TR and RG deserve a chance with these players will then say that TR and RG deserve a chance when these players hit their primes, which is probably going to be around 2018 or 2019. Is that really what people intend - let's give TR and RG until 2018? Because, if it isn't, then the time is now to make the change. Second, my hope for manager is Terry Steinbach. I don't have much against Molitor, but Steinbach was a winner as a player, he played a central position, and his post-retirement story is of someone who loves baseball. Several retired catchers are leading managers today, perhaps because of their experience dealing with pitching, batting and game strategy. Being part of the Tony LaRussa tree will be a benefit, also.
  10. The Sox waited until A.J. left before bashing him, if we give credence to the article by a radio talk d.j. who quoted anonymous sources. In fact, it has been suggested that the Sox waited until he left to voice their dislike. The Twins, on the other hand, frequently let public criticism escape about players still in the system, particularly if they are young and/or several years away from free agency, e.g., Baker, Neshek, Slowey, Perkins, Lohse, Garza, Bartlett (first time around, before he became a good clubhouse presence without health or skills), Hardy (a little), Colabello, Hicks, Pinto and probably others. Sano got a little taste of it last year. Even when Mauer was young, Gardy would comment publicly about mistakes he made. It would be unlike employees in nearly every other company if the broadcast team didn't know or figure out what their bosses were thinking and shape their commentary accordingly.
  11. He was looking up helpful quotations from Dr. Leo Buscaglia.
  12. We can't have it both ways. When the Twins don't sign someone, the Pohlads are called cheap seven ways from Sunday. Then, when other teams that spend more have more success, fans bemoan the apparent resource disadvantage. Further, several teams have demonstrated that total salary is of less importance than collecting the right players and having a strategy that identifies skills that are cheaper than the market values them, e.g., compare the success and payroll of the 2014 Oakland A's to the success and payroll of the 2011 and 2012 Minnesota Twins. In this era, management decision-making is of more value than ever, and perhaps has more impact on success than does total spend. The Red Sox have shown more willingness to recognize what works and what doesn't, and to quickly change when things aren't working.
  13. You mean the guy that belittled Scott Baker and Pat Neshek for not competing, before it was learned that they were injured, and kept pitching Nick Blackburn and Mike Pelfrey because they were "good guys" even though everyone could see they were ineffective pitchers, before it was learned that they too were injured, and wants players to be "old school," may be setting a culture that doesn't succeed in the post-Moneyball era?
  14. It sucks for anyone who loves baseball when an exciting player having a fantastic year has it abruptly and negatively changed by injury. We are reading about UCL injuries almost every day now. I don't know why, perhaps because it's affecting what had started out to be a historic season, but this particular ACL injury feels like the one that broke the camel's back for me to make me feel worse about the rash of elbow injuries being suffered by great (and not-so-great) players. Tangent for the old-timers: how much closer would Jim Kaat have been to the Hall of Fame if his 1972 season hadn't been ended by breaking his wrist sliding into second to break up a double play? For those who aren't familiar, look up his statistics for that year (look at batting, also) and project them to a full year, then look at what happens to his career stats. It's always a shame when players having great seasons have unfortunate injuries.
  15. Another example of the difference between the Red Sox and the Twins. Management selection: Red Sox: bad year in 2012 leads to the firing of a two-time World Series winning manager. Twins: three consecutive 90-loss seasons leads to a two-year contract extension for a manager who has won one play-off series in his career. Drafting and player development (recent examples): In 2011, Red Sox drafted Henry Owens, Jackie Bradley, Jr. and Mookie Betts after Twins drafted Levi (sure thing) Michael. In 2010, Red Sox drafted Brandon Workman and Garin Cecchini after Twins drafted Alex (sure thing) Wimmers. Advanced metrics: Red Sox: invested heavily and early, including hiring one of the gurus of advanced metrics. Twins: "after being one of the last teams to pay attention to advanced metrics, we hired this guy named Jack, who you never heard of before, and we can't really tell you the specific ways he provides input to our decisions." Roster strategies: Red Sox: team not meeting expectations in 2012 and 2014 - reduce veterans and salaries, bring up young players to get them experience and see how they perform. Twins: team not meeting expectations in 2011, 2012, 2013 and 2014 - "let's get more veteran players who have never or rarely been considered all-star quality and if they have the best year of their career, well, let's keep them for future years instead of trading them for players who can help in the future;" also, let younger players know they have to "prove it" in the minors before bringing them up, unless roster planning emergencies cause "no other choice" promotions. Red Sox: three World Series titles in ten years. Twins: three top ten draft choices in three years (and closing in on four in four).
  16. Hicks is a very talented young man. He also, however, has shown that he is not ready for major league baseball, even if he is more talented than other players on the roster. He needs to work on, among other things: (1) mentally preparing for each baseball game, including developing strong skills at studying pitchers and defense; (2) deciding his approach to hitting, whether it be switch hitting or solely batting from the right side, and whether he is going to be one of the most passive hitters in the league or start attacking a little more, which could be in line with his physical skills; and (3) learning to enjoy baseball and deciding if he really likes playing baseball. I believe he can offer something to the major league team today. However, it is clear that he needs to work on these skills and that he was not able to make progress at the major league level. Therefore, he belongs in the minor leagues. At this time, placing him on the Rochester roster would require removing someone else from that team, which could be the recently-promoted Daniel Ortiz, and there may not be anyone obviously deserving of being removed from a team that is playing pretty well. Therefore, instead of removing someone from Rochester, the team decided it would be better to put Hicks into the spot in AA that Ortiz had held. This makes sense; either AA or AAA will provide a similar opportunity to work on the skills he needs to improve. (Note that he doesn't really need to work on defensive skills and Eddie Rosario is currently playing a lot of CF for New Britain, so Hicks should play any position that gets him into the game and we should not read too much into his defensive position. TR, Gardy and everyone else knows what Hicks can do in CF.) If he starts raking and demonstrates a good approach in NB, it will be easy to promote him to AAA or even back to the majors. We shouldn't read too many long-term messages from this action.
  17. Aaron Hicks seems like the anti-Tony Gwynn. Among their nearly complete opposites are their physical and mental tools. Although every athlete would choose Hicks' physical make-up over Gwynn's, he seems to lack all of Gwynn's mental skills, including positivity and preparation. Whereas Gwynn epitomized the maxim "Have a plan for each at-bat" and prepared thoroughly for each pitcher, we know that Hicks doesn't study pitchers and now it appears that he doesn't even have a plan for which side he's going to hit on. Further, unlike Gwynn, who exuded joy to play baseball, it's not clear from Hicks' actions or comments that he even really likes baseball. It's not fair to compare him to Delmon Young, because he hasn't had the "socially aggressive" incidents Young had, but an interesting comparison could be Billy Beane, the player, who also had amazing physical tools but never really wanted to play baseball and eventually washed out as a player. IIRC, when he was drafted (in the Twins terrible 2008 draft, in which they also took Gutierrez and Walker Hunt, two other players upon whom management may have placed wishes instead of cold analysis), other teams shied away from him because they wanted him to pitch and he said he didn't want to. It was an early indication that, instead of saying, "Great, I'm going to play professional baseball!," Hicks prioritized being in control of how and what he was going to do over his enjoyment of baseball. It's possible that some portion of "My dad didn't want me to play baseball" is also the thinking of the younger Hicks.
  18. We have to get over the "blame Bill Smith" mentality and the implication that he represents everything bad in a GM. 1. He wasn't an individual cowboy. He worked within a system and had many of the same advisors, including the present GM, who are running the team today. 2. Under his direction, the team went out and got Miguel Sano. It may have been less money than the free agent contracts for Willingham and Nolasco, but it was still the biggest signing in Twins history. 3. People I know who got to know Bill Smith while he was GM say that he is one of the most decent people they know. Other stories suggest that he is and was very hard working. 4. It's hard to say that he is the only "GM who hands away talent like it's not big deal." Kyle Lohse was a good starting pitcher on playoff teams when he was here, then ran into social issues with management (there's another theme) before being given away for an old-for-his-league A-ball pitcher with low strike-out rates. Last year's opening game starter was given away for a small stipend. David Ortiz was handed away for . . . nothing. Besides, if you truly believe Bill Smith was a terrible GM, comparing TR to him and considering TR a success for exceeding the low grade you give to Bill Smith still does not mean that TR is any great shakes as a GM. How about instead comparing him to other good GM's around the league? Off the top of my head, I consider Ryan to be a worse GM than Mozeliak, Beane, Sabean, Jocketty, Friedman, Cherington, Epstein (although let's see what he does with the Cubs), Rizzo, Wren, Dombrowski and Daniels (can't tell with Luhnow or Cashman; the only ones I consider clearly worse are Moore and Towers). Perhaps we can do a more statistical analysis of success in bringing up young players, picking up free talent off the waiver wire, attracting free agents, and upgrading the team through trades, but it does seem that these GM's and possibly others produce better results in many of these areas than TR. We can't blame Bill Smith for that.
  19. Pinto is a nice player. He may not be Johnny Bench, but he's not the Edward Scissorhands some of the posts seem to imply. One player that he may be similar to is John Jaso, a good hitting, below-average fielding catcher that the first place Oakland Athletics thought was a better choice than . . . Kurt Suzuki. If you show confidence in young players and be regular with how you play them, they will have a better shot at producing. On the other hand, if you grumble about them and yo-yo their playing time, then, surprise, surprise, surprise, their performance often slips. Suzuki is having his best year in years, in fact, the best BABIP, OBP and OPS of his career, yet he's still just a league-average fielder at best, and a likely candidate for regression to the mean at the bat. That's probably why we aren't aware of meaningful contract talks. Pinto has a much better chance of having a better future and, if shown confidence and given a regular role, could have a better chance to positively impact the rest of the 2014 season. The way the Twins regularly favor journeyman veterans over promising young players is probably my least favorite thing about how the team is run. I do like the Morales signing, because it improves the lineup, but I think the lineup would be even stronger with Pinto in it than with Suzuki. Hopefully, this move is not too deflating to Pinto and he rakes in Rochester, then comes back as the regular catcher later in the year to improve the lineup when Suzuki hits his likely reversion.
  20. I don't mind publicly defending a struggling vet (at least not that much - I wouldn't mind if Gardy said something a little different, like "We're paying him a lot of money and have a lot of expectations for him. He knows we have those expectations, he shares those expectations, and we believe he will get it done.") However, what I do mind is, in contrast, the long-time criticism of struggling younger players, many of whom with more talent and upside than the struggling veterans. Sometimes this criticism is done directly by Twins on-field or upstairs management, and sometimes it is done through favored proxies in the press corps. It seems to be in contrast to the style of teams like Tampa, Texas and Oakland, who have had good success at plugging in new players. The criticism of young players also seems to delay or prevent their success. (For another recent local example of publicly criticizing young players, see Smith, Tubby.) In summary, I don't mind publicly defending a struggling veteran, even if he's struggling to achieve his usual mediocre results, but I really don't like the contrasting behavior of publicly criticizing struggling young players.
  21. Just took a little bit off the end.
  22. I'd sure rather see Trevor May in a long relief role to see what he can do, with Swarzak moving to shorter relief, and Guerrier moving to, oh, I don't know, maybe activities director at the Villages in Florida. It gets all three of them closer to their futures.
  23. RB, I know people who hunt game, but I don't know anyone who threads it.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.