Everything posted by scottz
-
2018 Rule 5 Draft Discussion
How do you feel about Rule 6?
- Article: Rundown: Sonny, LeMahieu, Non-Tenders and More
- Article: Twins Claim 1B CJ Cron
-
2019 Twins depth chart
I don't think you need to worry that the depth chart listed on twinsbaseball.com is the one being used by the front office.
-
Article: Twins Claim 1B CJ Cron
This is a perfectly fine get for nothing. He just had a nice season, he's 28, and it's late November. He hits lefties and righties pretty equally. His arbitration number won't be huge. Our new manager just spent a season in close proximity and maybe likes what he does. Maybe they see him as Tyler Austin with less strikeouts. If they do nothing else, we should yell and scream and gnash our teeth and rend our garments. If they made a bet on an incremental improvement over Tyler Austin and make other incremental improvements and/or a big improvement no such yelling, screaming, gnashing, and rending is necessary.
-
2019 priorities. Literally, a group wide priority list
Bullpen and Middle Infield are my 1 and 2 priorities. I don't hate the "trade for Starlin Castro" angle above as a bridge to Lewis joining the big league team. He's signed through 2019 with a club option for 2020. Bullpen I expect that we'll sign 1 guy, not 2 or 3 like some want or think we need. That's not everything, but that's a big start. If they can sign/trade for a good starter, I'm on board with that, but I'm starting to wonder if they will run out a bunch of our pitching depth as openers and attempt to legally manipulate the DL and/or 40 man shuffle to staff that kind of approach.
- Article: Twins Claim OF Michael Reed From Atlanta
-
Perry Castellanos, many other strength coaches let go
We all make our choices. A troublesome woman can lead to many great adventures.
-
Article: A Tale of Two Paths for Twins
Of all the players listed as free agents, I'm only interested in premium prices for Machado and Corbin. I don't think we will get either, but either would make our team better. What I don't want out of free agency is bargain shopping for guys with no real top end. So maybe you bargain hunt with Josh Donaldson because if he's healthy, maybe he has something left. But LeMahieu has had exactly one elite year (2016). Hard pass on him. Maybe Keuchel is worth looking at, but he's going to look to get paid big cash, and he's on the wrong side of 30 for me to want to pay a premium. On the trade side, I'd call the Mets about their pitchers to see what the prospect asking price is. If Thor or DeGrom are available, I think you have to at least consider it.
- Article: Miguel Sano Detained In Dominican Republic
-
Perry Castellanos, many other strength coaches let go
I'll never forget the day that I woke up, looked in the mirror, and discovered that I was G Cinco. I walked around that day with new legs. I saw with new eyes. And everywhere I went, the world turned to watch me pass. Some smiled and waved. Others stood with mouths agape. But all saw me. G Cinco. And so I lived as G Cinco lives. I woke up. Put on fresh kicks. I was the man. I was with your girl. Gucci sandals. I got a group of friends. There was nothing they couldn't handle. I was G Cinco. I was the man. She knew that. I had a Rolex. I told people who saw me to use exclusively Kodak products for photos. My boys had my back in this approach. We balled big. That's just what we did. I drove a Bentley with a rather troublesome woman. I wondered where my money was briefly. Then I found it. She knew. I bathed in it. One hundred dollar bills. I bathed. And I couldn't just choose one companion. I was G Cinco. I was the man. I flexed. I drove recklessly. Your girl continued calling and texting. I wouldn't lose, because I was the best. I could spend my money foolishly. The women liked riding with me in a convertible. Some people hated me because I was too attractive. I couldn't help it. I lived big. I bought anything. I couldn't lose. I was the man. I kept my money and my friends with me. I did what I wanted. There was nothing my friends couldn't handle. I was the man. And then just as quickly, one day arrived when I woke up, and I was no longer G Cinco. I was a 47 year old who did Communications work for an Engineering and Architecture firm. I was no longer G Cinco. But I will always be the man.
-
Article: MIN 9, DET 3: Vive La Tortuga
Points of interest in tonight's game for me include that Gonsalves was awarded the win, apparently because he threw the most innings. I know it is scorekeeper's choice, but I'm not sure why the choice was Gonsalves other than the team was ahead when he exited. Magill should have been honored with the random W. Also, boy I find the opener strategy to be less interesting baseball. So I guess that is a point of non-interest. Astudillo for President. Wait, he's from Venezuela and he's only 26. How about Astudillo for a 2019 Roster Spot? It's nice to see Polanco having another solid bunch of statistics with his OBP approaching 35% and his OPS at .783. His suspension at the start of the year was a big bruise for the lineup. Stay off the juice, Jorge. Finally, that Vikings defense looked like Pro Bowlers out there tonight. Or rather, played like the defense at a Pro Bowl.
-
2019: The Nature, Organization, Augmentation of the Rotation
But why? The only downside to DeGrom is that he is 30 and coming off a career year. But his 4 previous years are all significantly better than anyone on our team. And he isn't a free agent until 2021. What's the negative in trading prospects - are you afraid that they will all turn out to be gems? Why wouldn't it make sense to have a guy with a career 2.67 ERA (2.81 FIP). For reference, Berrios has a career 4.53 ERA (4.25 FIP). If not DeGrom, what about Thor? Are you concerned about injury? I can at least buy that. However, he's only 25, and isn't a free agent until 2022. His career numbers are 2.99 ERA (2.68 FIP). How does it not make sense to even hypothetically trade for one of these guys? Not all of the prospects we give will all turn out, even if it were Lewis, Kiriloff, Thorpe, and Graterol. And by the way, it might include two of those four, plus 1-2 lesser but good prospects. I don't understand why fans aren't OK with taking some bigger risks in trades if the opportunity is right, even if it means watching a former Twins prospect turn into a MLB regular for someone else. Whether the FO thinks the opportunity is right is another story.
-
Article: MIN 8, DET 2: Gonsalves Stymies Tigers
Austin Astudillo Adrianza They seem like AAA hitters.
-
Arizona Fall League 2018
As reported by Phil Miller (https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1035228636633292800): Griffin Jax Class A RHP Hector Lujan Class A RHP Alex Robinson Class AA LHP Devin Smeltzer Class AA LHP Travis Blankenhorn Class A 2B-3B Jaylin Davis, Class AA OF Luke Raley Class AA OF Brent Rooker Class AA OF
- Article: Matt Magill Making His Improbable Case
-
Article: Matt Magill Making His Improbable Case
I agree, especially with the first and second paragraphs, and I thought as much when I typed my comment. Like pretty much everything, there are many tangential and sometimes opposing concepts around a single thought. As far as your last paragraph, I think players that are drafted high get longer leashes and therefore might keep an otherwise "really, really good" player from getting a chance. Similarly, when a player signs a big contract but doesn't perform, that can tend to keep some of those non-prospects from getting a chance. I'm not screaming "it's not fair" or anything like that, but those are business-related things that keep some guys from having a cup of coffee in MLB or even scratching out a year or two big league career. I don't think anyone has to stretch too far to think of those kinds of examples.
-
Article: Matt Magill Making His Improbable Case
"...the business side of baseball sometimes prevents some guys who are really good at playing baseball to get to the big leagues.” This is something every fan should always remember. Every player that goes through a streak when they can't seem to get a single batter out or when they can't hit their way out of a paper sack is still really, really good.
-
2019 40 Man - Who is gone from the 2018 40 Man?
I generally agree there's no reason to roster Wilson, except for the fact that familiarity is a good thing out of catchers. A bad catcher that has been in your system and knows your pitchers is kind of the devil you know. If they don't go after a FA, and Castro starts healthy, but then gets hurt, you'd rather have Wilson than some other Wilson. But yeah, he can go on the "not" list.
-
2019 40 Man - Who is gone from the 2018 40 Man?
Below is a listing of everyone currently on the 40 man roster, sorted by youngest to oldest. Who do you think will be off this list going into 2019? If you are so inclined, feel free to expand on why you think what you do, or even who might take their place. FYI - I have done no research on who must be added (or risk losing). I think the 2019 40 man roster will not include: John Curtiss Zack Granite Robbie Grossman Logan Morrison Logan Forsythe Ervin Santana Matt Belisle Question marks: *I think Mauer plays one more year for the hometown 9. *It seems like Duffey might go bye bye. *Astudillo might also say goodbye depending on if they have or add another multi-position IF lined up.) *Depending on what they do with the catcher position in the offseason, I could see Castro, Garver and Wilson remaining (if they do nothing). If they sign a FA, Wilson or Castro goes away, depending on health of Castro. If Castro is healthy, he's back. 71 Lewis Thorpe R/L 6'1" 160lbs 11/23/1995 P 52 Zack Littell R/R 6'4" 220lbs 10/5/1995 P 58 Gabriel Moya L/L 6'0" 175lbs 1/9/1995 P 77 Fernando Romero R/R 6'0" 215lbs 12/24/1994 P 53 Kohl Stewart R/R 6'3" 195lbs 10/7/1994 P — Stephen Gonsalves L/L 6'5" 213lbs 7/8/1994 P 17 Jose Berrios R/R 6'0" 185lbs 5/27/1994 P — Chase De Jong L/R 6'4" 205lbs 12/29/1993 P 25 Byron Buxton R/R 6'2" 190lbs 12/18/1993 OF 11 Jorge Polanco S/R 5'11" 200lbs 7/5/1993 IF 49 Adalberto Mejia R/L 6'3" 195lbs 6/20/1993 (10-day DL) P 22 Miguel Sano R/R 6'4" 260lbs 5/11/1993 IF 27 1 John Curtiss R/R 6'4" 200lbs 4/5/1993 P 26 Max Kepler L/L 6'4" 205lbs 2/10/1993 OF 60 Jake Cave L/L 6'0" 200lbs 12/4/1992 OF 8 1 Zack Granite L/L 6'1" 175lbs 9/17/1992 OF 50 Aaron Slegers R/R 6'10" 245lbs 9/4/1992 (10-day DL) P 51 Johnny Field R/R 5'10" 180lbs 2/20/1992 OF 64 1 Willians Astudillo R/R 5'9" 225lbs 10/14/1991 IF 20 Eddie Rosario L/R 6'1" 180lbs 9/28/1991 OF 31 Tyler Austin R/R 6'2" 220lbs 9/6/1991 IF 23 Mitch Garver R/R 6'1" 220lbs 1/15/1991 C 21 Tyler Duffey R/R 6'3" 220lbs 12/27/1990 P 55 Taylor Rogers L/L 6'3" 170lbs 12/17/1990 P 39 Trevor Hildenberger R/R 6'2" 211lbs 12/15/1990 P 67 Alan Busenitz R/R 6'1" 180lbs 8/22/1990 P 12 Jake Odorizzi R/R 6'2" 190lbs 3/27/1990 P 68 Matt Magill R/R 6'3" 210lbs 11/10/1989 P 65 Trevor May R/R 6'5" 240lbs 9/23/1989 P 36 1 Robbie Grossman S/L 6'0" 215lbs 9/16/1989 OF 16 Ehire Adrianza S/R 6'1" 170lbs 8/21/1989 IF 35 Michael Pineda R/R 6'7" 260lbs 1/18/1989 (60-day DL) P 43 Addison Reed L/R 6'4" 230lbs 12/27/1988 P 44 Kyle Gibson R/R 6'6" 215lbs 10/23/1987 P 99 1 Logan Morrison L/L 6'3" 245lbs 8/25/1987 (7-day DL) IF 15 Jason Castro L/R 6'3" 215lbs 6/18/1987 (60-day DL) C 24 1 Logan Forsythe R/R 6'1" 205lbs 1/14/1987 IF 32 Oliver Drake R/R 6'4" 215lbs 1/13/1987 P 7 Joe Mauer L/R 6'5" 225lbs 4/19/1983 IF 46 Bobby Wilson R/R 6'0" 230lbs 4/8/1983 C 54 1 Ervin Santana R/R 6'2" 175lbs 12/12/1982 (10-day DL) P 38 1 Matt Belisle R/R 6'3" 230lbs 6/6/1980 (10-day DL) P
-
Is a .500 season possible?
It's a disappointing year in any case, but I always feel better adding wins. Let's do it.
-
Article: Week in Review: Stumbling and Grumbling
He only does it at the end of the game, correct? Do you also consider it to be showboating when the three outfielders run to center field to jump together (or when Buxton was up, miming a fade away jump shot together)? I'm curious about when something crosses the showboat line for you. Or for anybody else.
-
NERDS!
yeah, i don't know the answer to that. a team should try to win, and that might include things like changing pitchers 3 times in the 7th and 8th innings. but changing pitchers 3 times in a short period of time isn't interesting or entertaining for a lot of people (including some people who love baseball - imagine how the "baseball is ok, i guess" crowd feels about it). a team should encourage their batters to hit home runs and increase their OBP, and their pitchers to limit walks and strike out everyone, but that also isn't interesting or entertaining. i think baseball (with three true outcomes of HR/BB/K) and basketball (shoot only 3s or layups/dunks) have a similar problem. Statistically, that's how it's best played to win. But to watch over and over? Not as exciting. A team could easily be trying to employ those kinds of percentage-driven methods, but still not be winning because their players aren't as good, and that is a miserable product to watch. i don't know what the answer is. but i do enjoy some parts of baseball less than i used to. and i don't think i'm an analytic curmudgeon. some parts of the "new" game are just not as interesting to me.
-
NERDS!
I think people want to be entertained, and sometimes teams being as smart as they can might interfere with that.
-
Any Interest in a Q&A?
What's your favorite Target Field food?