Everything posted by DocBauer
-
Article: Examining Alex Anthopoulos
Ownership probably thought he was over qualified.
-
Molitor 2017
Just a thought, nothing concrete to back it up, but I think it's just bad verbiage in order to "sell" optimism to the fan base. A new GM, as stated previously, would probably keep Molitor for now anyway, with some suggested changes to the staff. The roster, and the entire developmental staff are probably of greater concern initially than ridding oneself of the manager.
-
Article: Unanswered Questions
First...the positive.... And now to address your issues. LOL But seriously, while sooooo much of the roster shows Flux and guys still developing, the truth is, called this or not, the team really has been going through a rebuild and youth movement. This had to happen. If you discount Mauer and Dozier...possibly Plouffe if he is indeed gone...the entire starting OF, the left side of the infield, probably DH and catcher as well, will all be manned by young players in 2017. And we have absolutely seen glimpses of their potential. But on to your list. Sano: Play him and have him lose a couple of pounds. Cannon for an arm, charges balls well, and his hands seem OK. Sure he's had some bad throws, what young 3B doesn't from time to time? The biggest problem has just been some badly botched plays. But not only is he still young and developing, but the whole RF issue has to have messed with him this season. IF there is any concern over his elbow being anything other than minor, maybe bring back Plouffe on a friendly deal after his poor season. It's easy to assemble a 12 man player roster, for the most part, for next season. Who is #13? Maybe Plouffe as a 3B/1B/DH/PH who could play some spot OF. Might not be a bad idea as long as you're not committed to playing him every day. But put Sano at 3B daily and let him play and develop. And if it really doesn't work, move to 1B after Mauer. May: He could be, body willing, be an excellent bullpen piece. And maybe his injuries this year were as simple as simple as flare-ups and adjustments. But for a team in such need of SP, to insist on moving a strapping, hard throwing young SP to the bullpen is ridiculous. They may have wasted an entire season of his potential growth with this move. Put him back in the rotation! Hughes and Perkins: Expect and plan on NOTHING. Perk is probably done. Hughes has a shot, but he's a dark horse. He could rebound back in to his 2014 version, possibly reinvent himself as a strong bullpen arm, potential closer...throw harder buy shorter...or also be done. What happened to both is unfortunate. But don't plan on either one when building the next team. Jay: Agreed Jay doesn't belong on this list. You stated yourself hus rotation move would take some time. I was very encouraged by what he did at A ball. He'll begin next season in the Lookouts rotation. Let's at least wait until next year before adding him to a list like this. SS: Some bad luck here and more mismanagement by the Twins. As long as he got time off to not wear down over the course of an entire season, we've seen enough of Escobar the precious 2 seasons to feel relatively good about him...if healthy. Polanco doesn't play a single milb game at SS to make room for a journeyman? And then, once promoted, he's put back at SS! The fact that he's looked this good to this point is a testament to previous experience, talent and potential. You roll with these guys for '17. Both have talent, both are young and quite young, and you ARE in a rebuild. Catcher: You have some options to work with in Murphy, Centennial, Garver and the upcoming Turner. But it's not enough. But Suzuki is not the answer. You need one more option here. You can either identify one quality vet that you think can rebound and help lead the team for a season or two, OR, you can identify a guy via rule 5, DFA, milb FA that you think has a legitimate shot and go get him. I almost lean toward the younger FA question mark guy. Poor planning on the Twins to this point. But Murphy could rebound. I've seen some good from Centennial. I like Garver's potential a lot. If Turner's bat could come around a bit more he could be solid. But again, some poor planning. Bullpen: IMHO, it's not as bad as you make out. Roger's and Pressly have looked pretty good. So did Tonkin before being turned in to a long reliever. Add a closer as you develop one, find another decent LHRP somewhere, use Duffy as a long and middle man and spot starter, then audition for the final spot. I don't think the bullpen is that far off. And we sure have a lot of live young arms to audition in 2017. But you are absolutely correct that they waited too long to look at some of them. Rotation: We all know this is the #1 issue facing the Twins. Some talented kids aren't ready yet, and there are question marks surrounding who's available. But Santana has pitched well enough to believe he has at least one more good season left in him. We've seen Gibson do a lot better, and I'm talking just last season. Just a bad year or injuries, or do we need a different pitching coach? After that I'm just not sure. Santiago is nothing great, but his career numbers are mostly solid. A year ago, or even the years before that, we'd have been excited to have a guy like him amongst our starting 5. You have to believe Berrios will get it together. He's just too talented, been so productive in his milb career to believe otherwise. I still like May, but due to his IP this season, he may be a 5th SP only. Hopefully Mejia is very close. Gonsalves has a real chance to contribute sometime in 2017. Is any of this perfect? Absolutely not. And once again, it's easy to point fingers at player mismanagement: poor coaching, quick hooks, in the wrong spot, etc. But there is no quick FA fix. Even if you are on board with moving Dozier, you still have to find the right trade partner and players to make it happen. (you also shuffle the deck chairs somewhat as now you have to find at least one more infield option to add to the player mix) Other than better health and a dose of better luck, could the Twins have handled this situation better? Absolutely. May should have been starting at some point. Not a single game audition for Wheeler but guys like Dean got multiple shots? And do they just not "get" Berrios or what? Right now, I really feel you have to roll with all the various options you have on hand, work with them, place them in mental and physical situations to succeed, and wait for guys like Mejia and Gonsalves to contribute.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/8): Kernels Complete First-Round Sweep
I echo the winning sentiment. Learning how to win is part of the winning process. Tip of the cap to Jake Mauer. Every year your top players leave, a few solid but not quite ready for advancement players remain, and a whole different group of players come in. And Jake has had a number of top prospects come through his locker room. But he's also had different team makeups, and this season the position players and offense were questionable. At least early in the year. But taking his team to the playoffs 4 straight years is quite the accomplishment.
-
Time to switch up the batting order
First, we know pitching is a huge issue, but this thread is about the lineup and offense. Second, while I don't dismiss varying statistics or their relevance, if you look long and hard enough, you can find stats that can support almost any argument. A guy can hit well with RISP but have little power or few runners OB in front of him, but another guy can have a lower RISP AVG but be a big RBI producer due to power and actual RISP. Sometimes it's the chicken and egg theory. A lineup has to be about the makeup of your team, do certain guys just appear more comfortable in certain spots for whatever reason, etc. I think sometimes it can be a "feel" thing and less analytical. Ideally, this team should thrive better offensively when Buxton can bring his considerable talents to the leadoff spot. Even if he's just beginning to fulfill his potential. (*note, I think Polanco is a solid secondary option here). I like Mauer in the 2 spot due to contact and OB...for as long as he's on the team and in the lineup. I believe Kepler has the ability to be the team's best overall hitter, AVG, OB, power and speed, so I think he's your future 3 hitter. Those first 3 should provide Sano and Dozier many RBI opportunities as well as provide OB opportunities for the hitters behind them. Vargas, if he continues his development, has power and solid OB ability behind those two. Rosario and whoever is at catcher, actually have a chance to hit in the lower third of the lineup with runners often OB. Then you have Polanco turning the lineup over again for the top of the order
-
Article: The Anti-Arcia: Rosario Resurrected In Rochester
A couple things: *I think he tries too hard sometimes. Your choice of the word "aggressive" to describe him is dead on. But teams also need that kind of player and personality, especially when they are as athletically gifted as Rosario. Time and experience should help Polish him though. *With his tools and potential, I wouldn't even think of making a 4th OF any time soon. If he plateaus or someone else flat out takes the job, OK. Not saying he will, but what if Granite is the real deal, plays a good LF, and provides speed and OB ahead of Buxton in the lineup, for instance? *Rosario will be sooooo much the better ballplayer if he just curbs some of that aggressiveness and quits looking like a drunk lumberjack on those pitches that are head high, in the dirt, or headed outside toward the dugout. With his natural ability, just a little more restraint will make him that much more effective and dangerous. *Looking at his milb track record, he hit and produced everywhere except first his "second" stint following his suspended first half a couple years ago. And while he has never been a BB or OB machine, I believe he never had a AVG vs OB differential that was lower than around 40-42%, meaning he wasn't immune to a walk. Again, a little more Polish and restraint, and look out. A dynamic 6-7 place hitter with quality defense.
-
Eye Test - Polanco at Short
First, let me come clean that I haven't watched enough of Polanco at SS to form an overly accurate opinion, though I have watched him some, and have seen a couple replays, and heard general praise on the radio broadcasts, (for what those are worth). But I also haven't seen...or heard...anything that says he can't play the position, or that he's looked bad out there. You HAVE TO PLAY HIM to see what you have. FINALLY they are. And as young as he is, getting his first real taste of ML ball, and havingto re-a climate himself to the position somewhat after not playing there the entire season, I think he's done quite well. In fact, considering those factors, the fact that he doesn't look awful may be the best indicator of what is to come. If you take the time to do a little research...and I have previously...you would be surprised by some of the error totals accumulated by "top" SS early in their careers. And the point is well taken that not all players excel in both sides of the game. Top defense can help offset average or less offense in a player and his net worth, and quality offense can offset average or slightly below defense. Polanco, and we could/should include Sano in the same breath, looks like he can do the job while swinging a quality stick. Like Sano, he has the ability to continue to improve, but only if given the chance. IMHO, Sano at 3B just about every day, Polanco the same at SS...though he still has to earn it over the "has looked better before this season" Escobar...Dozier at 2B, Mauer and Vargas at 1B with Park in a "get healthy and prove it" position. Escobar makes for a fine utility guy who will probably still play a lot.The defense on the right side will be solid to good. The left side will be a work in progress. But so what? Really, we're talking about a couple of young, budding talents. And with the exception of a couple of veterans, we're talking about a very young and rebuilding team. And you're not willing to live with some mistakes and errors from such talented youngsters? Give me our starting OF next season, hopefully a quality FA 4th/fill-in OF and a solid closer, (hopefully 1 more decent LHRP) to help ease all of the Twins young RP arms in to their roles, and I'm actually feeling pretty good about a lot of things.
-
If This Is It, Thank You Trevor
For many reasons, I feel it's time for Plouffe to move on. But I have been a fan and supporter for some time. I think because he wasn't an all star and didn't play on winning teams, some fans are harder on him than he deserved. Nice solid player who will find a home. From a strictly selfish baseball reason, I wonder, IF the Twins decided to bring him back in 2017, would a down and injury filled season allow them to do so cheaply?
-
Article: Twins Daily 2016 Minor League Hitter Of The Year
Palka's SO numbers don't concern me at this point. He's also shown the ability to hit for AVG and still take some BBC for decent OB. A dip on his promotion to AAA shouldn't be surprising. I wish I knew more about his defense, but I could see him as an OF/DH/1B candidate. I just want to see Gordon continue to develop PERIOD. But if I were to nit pick, I'd like to see the OB come up a little more. Granite intrigues me. Could he be a solid hitting, speedy 4th OF? Could he be a legitimate every day LF and leadoff hitter with Buxton hitting a spot or two lower with his power potential?
-
Article: Twins Daily 2016 Minor League Starting Pitcher Of The Year
Revisionist thinking is always interesting, but I remember being down the Twins didn't grab Gonsalves in the 2nd round. Man was I happy when they later snagged him and felt they got a potentially huge steal. Despite a rough introduction to the majors, Berrios has everything needed to be successful. So does Gonsalves. Jury is still out on Stewart and Jay, but the talent is there. Jorge looks good, Romero excellent. Man, if he could follow the fast tracks of Berrios and Gonsalves next season, things start to look bright.
-
Article: Thoughts On Brian Dozier
NOT saying don't trade Dozier if you could really add a #2 type starter, or a top, top prospect ready to burst on the scene, plus someone else to balance the trade. And maybe I'm selfish about BD or short-sighted, but as much as we need pitching, especially SP, and as much as I like Polanco as a young talent, I'm still not sure if losing Dozier's bat, and replacing him with a high end starter gets us to where we need to go. It might a lot, don't get me wrong, but whether it's our current coaching staff, bad luck, whatever, Berrios finding himself would be huge. May could really help, IMO, and Gonsalves could be ready...along with Mejia...at some point in 2017. And you can also mix in, of course, Santana and Gibson along with maybe Santiago, for now. There is a big part of me that says this is smarter in a 2017 approach. BD won't turn 30 until after the season starts. He's not old. He made some nice adjustments this season. He is cost controlled, could possibly be resigned,(just not another big long term deal please), and would probably have mid-season trade value next year.
-
Breaking Down The Twins 40 Man
Generally agree with everything stated. I'd like to keep Boshers around, if possible, but don't think I'd risk a 40 man spot on him. Too many guys to add this year. The one guy I'd quibble about is Centennial. The Twins need help at catcher. While Centennial is nothing special by any means, he's generally OK behind the plate, at it, and hits LHRP. I'd really like to keep him for ST 2017. But you also have to protect Murphy, Garver and Turner, so I get it. May not have room. But I still may quibble a bit on him.
-
Time to switch up the batting order
Ultimately, if he can play SS, would be awesome to see a combination of Polanco and Buxton in the top 2 spots. I understand your thoughts on some combination of Dozier/Sano hitting that low. I've thought about that also. My thought process is Mauer may be of more value in the 2 hole rather than new the bottom. I also feel Dozier/Sano in the 4-5 spots should provide...pretty regularly...runner (s) on base when they hit. Other than poor clutch hitting, one thing that has hindered the offense is a lack of runners on base when the Twins hit dangers. Dozier/Sano also do a pretty good job of getting OB themselves. This means some opportunity for the next DH and Rosario. Just my thoughts. Not sure if they are right or not. Lol
-
Time to switch up the batting order
Ultimately, I really like Kepler in the #3 spot. I like how he looked there earlier in the year. He should provide AVG, OB, and a fair amount of power with decent speed. Then I like some bombination of Sano and Dozier in the 4 and 5 spots. The only thing I'm not crazy about is a pair of LHRP hitters followed by a pair of RH hitters. But again, I think Kepler is the perfect #3 hitter...eventually at least.
-
Management Continues Mysteriously
Makes little sensearly! As of now, Suzuki will be a FA and would seem to be out of the Twins plans for 2017 entirely unless the new GM loves him for some reason. Not saying he shouldn't get to play a game or two here and there, but he's been paid decently by the Twins. And not to sound insensitive, but he should be paid now to sit and let Murphy and Centeno play out the remainder of the year. I mean, seriously, playing Suzuki at this point could mean...maybe...a win or two more. Maybe. And that potential win or two, if even possible, does nothing for Murphy, Centeno, or the 2017 Twins.
-
Why I want to see the Twins win in Sept 2016
I believe winning can help winning in the future. It helps build confidence. And it sure is more fun than losing! But what's most important right now is playing the youngsters, getting them experience to be more prepared for next season. That's more important than the wins themselves at this point. But, if we could do that and still finish with the top pick, we'll, that's just a nice little reward for having to suffer through this season.
-
James Beresford, Vargas, and Duffey called up
Good for Beresford! He deserves it, and really deserved it more last season. I'd like to bring him back again next season, milb contact or not. This might entice him to return. About time Vargas was back up! Now play him Molitor! I have not given up on Duffey as a starter. Last year, and at times this year, we've seen what he is capable of as a ML SP and it can be good. But there is a definite need for a true long man in the pen. He could be that guy and your #6 starter when you need that fill in guy.
-
2017 roster
Agree with most of your list. A couple changes/moves I'd like to see the GM make: *Sign another catcher. I'm looking for someone needing a chance or a change of scenery. Maybe someone available and getting squeezed out. I hate to use his name again, but a John Hicks type to battle it out with Murphy, Centennial and Garver. *I'd sign a legitimate 4th OF type. He doesn't have to be able to play CF, though it would be nice if he did. *Take a flyer on a couple LHRP options, look for another Abad surprise hopefully. *I'd think you keep Kintzler OR sign a veteran who can close initially at least. Either someone on a comeback type season, or looking for that one final season like Hawkins did a year or so ago. This allows someone, maybe Pressly, to be groomed in to a closer role. *I'd like to see the best AAAA middle infielder and 3B I can find. A couple of guys who have had a cup of coffee or two at the ML level. This helps fortify Rochester, and gives more depth if a call up is necessary without bringing up someone who would embarrass themselves. My idea lineup: Buxton Mauer Kepler Sano Dozier Vargas Rosario Catcher Polanco or Escobar Backup catcher, like the starter, is unknown right now. I've already stated signing a proven 4th OF. The Escobar/Polanco "loser" gives a quality and versatile utility guy.The final spot could belong to Plouffe. It could be a versatile utility player not on the roster right now. It could be Grossman, but I'd see him at Rochester. Park? Maybe. He, Vargas and Mauer, whoever is not in the lineup, provides a nice bat bench, but limits lineup possibilities. Rotation: Santana Gibson Berrios May Santiago or Mejia I'm torn on keeping Santiago, but it's hard not to keep a veteran LHSP and allow Mejia a little more time. Bullpen: Vet FA or Kintzler Pressly Tonkin Duffy OPEN AUDITION Roger's OPEN AUDITION There ARE a lot of bullpen arms seemingly ready or close to it at AAA and AA, plus the couple of LHRP I'd sign. Hence the OPEN AUDITION slots in the pen. How good is this team? How many games might they win? It's hard to say. But for the most part, youth is still served, and more youth will be up at some point. I like my team as listed and healthy. There's a couple guys that could be flipped at some point as well. An 80 win team? I think that's doable. Playoff contention? Maybe if the kids keep improving.
-
Nobody cares, but.... Plouffe is doing well post-DL
Despite being a fan and general defender of Plouffe in the past, I feel it's best to move on, especially considering the contract amount he's probably going to command. Other quick points: 1] I remain convinced, at this point, that I have seen enough from Sano to believe that healthy, and given time, he will be solid at 3B. Probably never great or very good, but solid. 2] Not playing Vargas just about every day is a huge mistake! So he cooled down some. He was still taking quality AB and getting walks and could just as easily have gotten hot again. There is usually an ebb and flow to a hitter's season. You owe it to yourself to see what you have in him. 3] As of now, my ideal player roster for 2017 includes 2 catchers TBD, Mauer, Vargas or Park, Dozier, Polanco, Escobar, Sano, Rosario, Buxton, Kepler, and a quality 4th ML OF who can step in and play if Buxton needs time. That's 12 and you need 13. Plouffe as a 3B/1B/DH and possible spare OF wouldn't be the worst idea, or insurance, if his contract was decent and your staff wasn't committed to him being a full time player. Not saying the team SHOULD keep Plouffe, but I can see merit in this scenario.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/2):Slegers Shuts Down Jackson
Slegers has quietly put together a pretty nice season. Despite his size, he doesn't have the power or SO ability you'd think. But he's looking like a fairly decent prospect
-
It is time to end the insanity
Just a few thoughts after reading a series of comments: 1] There IS a logjam at certain positions. But it's not caused by the "jamming" players, it's the FO and or the staff creating the logjam. They are being incompetent beavers! see what I did there?) NO WAY Vargas shouldn't be playing daily, much less being sent down at all. And I like the apology idea. 2] Unless he really is worn down, and I doubt it, and his performance wouldn't seem to indicate it, there is no reason for Garver not to be given at least a little ML time in September before heading to the AFL. He has to be added to the 40 man this year anyway. He could be a viable option behind the plate, has caught less games than he probably should have, the AFL-CIO is not a long term grind, and he still has time to rest up before ST. 3] I can get Dean or Albers earlier in the season to fill a temp role due to injury, etc. But at this point in the season, unless your over riding concern is Rochester and a potential playoff spot, NOW there is no excuse for guys like this starting. There ARE other options that could actually gain something from ML playing experience. 4] I believe Kintzler, or another veteran FA to close games next year on a last year or make good contract, is a good call for the team. With no set young closer option, you can begin to audition/prepare someone, and preserve the games that you can win. Winning helps breed winning, IMO. 5] In regard to a mention of Tonkin specifically, I think he did quite well for most of the season. But he's been entirely miscast as a long reliever. I think he's wearing down. He's a 1+ IP pitcher for a 6-8th inning role. Badly miscast as a long man.
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
While I agree his swoon was regrettable in many ways...and could happen again of course...I am of the opinion he has, possibly still is, matured as a hitter. He seems to have made some very real adjustments this season. While he still pulls for power, and most guys with power do pull quite a bit, he seems to have stopped looking to do so constantly, and has really adapted to going the other way when the opportunity presents itself.
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
I'd like to just a different idea out there, if I may. First, again, I'm not saying don't look for a deal for Dozier and see if you can find a great fit and get a bug return, i.e. a #2 SP or a top, top prospect ready to go and maybe another quality prospect as well. But I lean toward keeping him at this point: his power and overall production, though streaky at times, is awfully good. And he provides a veteran bat in an increasingly young lineup. When his current contract is up, he'll only be 32 for the 2019 season. Hardly a gray beard, and playing a position that doesn't usually see as sudden a decline as say catcher, CF or SS. Further, he could not only be resigned at some point potentially, but also possibly move to 3B (short on the arm but good athlete and less range required) or possibly 1B to replace Mauer. If the new GM decides not to keep Santiago and to not sign Plouffe, by my figuring, the Twins will cut over 36M from their payroll this season. Now, there will be raises, of course. And I believe the team should invest in a real 4th OF who can start if needed, possibly a back end RP on a 1 year deal, a couple low cost LHRP auditions, etc. But they will definitely be cutting costs. If I'm not mistaken, Perkins is off the books after next season? That's another 6M+. Santana, and Mauer if memory serves, would be signed for 2018 and then done. What if this new FO is more aggressive overall, and uses this money on a top FA SP NEXT off season when the market should be better, and we keep Dozier, and his offense, and continue to work with and move up the young rotation candidates? Thoughts?
-
Posting styles discussing our frustrations about the Twins
NICE!
-
The Key to the Twins Offseason is....Brian Dozier?
No question the Dozier, and Santana, topic and what to do, or not do, is the new hot topic these days. And it's a good article and it's anot interesting topic of debate. But the real key first and foremost, to state the obvious, is the change in the front office and who's going to be running the show. The new guys in charge will, hopefully, be progressive in their thinking. Despite Pohlad claiming Molitor is the manager next year, I don't believe he and his staff are truly safe. I don't believe the milb staffs are safe either. Somewhere along the line there appears to be a disconnect in the handling of prospects. Dozier COULD bring back a top of the rotation arm, or at worst, a top, top rotation prospect ready for prime time. But you also lose his offense, and then need another infield addition to replace him and create depth and competition. (And don't get me wrong, I'm a huge Polanco believer and supporter). But I have to ask, if you felt comfortable and confident that Berrios, May and Mejia would be ready to take a step forward next season and be reliable, would you still be in favor of moving Dozier? Granted, there is no way to automatically instill such confidence at this time. And moving Dozier, if you can find the right trade and trade partner, could be a savy move. But he'll only be 30 next season, could still be moved later, or signed to an extension, while Polanco and Escobar form a nice SS/utility mix/battle and you roll with Santana-Gibson-Berrios-May-Mejia with Santiago maybe here, maybe gone, and guys like Gonsalves getting close. NOT saying don't trade him if a big value is there, but I have to wonder if the smart move isn't keeping him, examine changes in the field staff and how prospects are handled, and go with the names mentioned above.