Everything posted by DocBauer
- Article: Catching Up In A Stream Of Consciousness
-
Article: As The Defense Goes, So Goes The Twins
Ugh! This one just killed me! On a 103 loss team you felt you had to audition an OK defensive journeyman who is a AAAA player with limited bat for what reason? So you could consider him as a viable 4th OF candidate on your young and rebuilding 2017 team? Again with a massive UGH! You didn't even have to promote anyone else, just let other guys on the roster play and see if they could show something. Sheesh! And this team could easily afford to go out and sign one of a few potential solid 4th OF types. (Doc bangs head against wall)
-
Yorman Landa Not Tendered a 2017 Contract
I know this thread is about Landa, and I don't want to hijack it. But since Dan San and Grossman have been mentioned...... Like most all the Twins minor leaguers, I followed Dan San's career with interest. And I admit a bit of a man crush on him after his rookie season. He really didn't play poorly in the field, especially being rushed, and being spooned in to an unfamiliar position. I saw the quick wrists, a good arm, speed, some pop, and all around athleticism and was very intrigued. I felt his BA would certainly come down, but experience and natural progression would see at least some rise in contact and BB ability. I thought he had a chance to develop in to a nice, sometimes dangerous, and exciting, versatile role player. But it just hasn't happened for whatever reason. But it still could. But at this point, he has to be one of the first guys to be taken off the 40 man to make room for a FA signing or traded for player. He COULD still find the right team, maybe bounce around for a year or two, and be what I hoped he'd be for the Twins, but I'd be willing to live with that. However, if he went unclaimed, I'd sign him to a milb contract in a heartbeat. Grossman is a different story. Look, the times I saw him play defense last season wasn't always pretty. I'm sure some of you saw him more than me. I saw him play OK, and I saw a couple really bad plays as well. I'm still not sure how good or bad he is defensively. But I do know this, the guy can be dangerous against LH pitching. He has a potential role on this team as a 5th OF, OCCASSIONAL OF, PH and DH. I'd like to keep him. We complain over and over again the Twins have too many 1B/DH types...TYPES...but we are still unsettled there despite numerous options. We have Mauer...a shell of his former self, but good defensively, solid OB and still around. We have Vargas, who I still argue needs an opportunity, and not just playing a couple times a week or being discarded after a bad week, to see what he can really do. Park is solid defensively, has potential, but also needs to be healthy. Vargas and Park both have options, which is good. But we'really really not sure yet what and who we have in this glut of 1B/DH situation we always talk about. I think Grossman is a decent "option" to have in the mix for now.
-
Yorman Landa Not Tendered a 2017 Contract
To me, and I'm not speaking of Landa directly, I'm not overly concerned with a prospect...with good live stuff mind you...that walks 4-5 per 9. Is a concern? Definitely. But everything in regard to pitching takes time; gaining control of breaking stuff, feel for a change, setting up hitters, etc. Learning better control, walking fewer, repeating motions, etc, is part of the learning process. I don't say to automatically rush someone just because he has a good arm, but I do believe you need to challenge guys sometimes. And at each level, they should learn more as they are exposed to better and better hitters. In fact, they should end up challenging themselves in the process. And in that process, they should not only learn, but they may learn something different about themselves from themselves, as well as their next pitching coach.
-
Article: As The Defense Goes, So Goes The Twins
Personally, full seasons next year from Rosario, Buxton and Kepler have me believing our OF will be good to excellent. Now go find a quality, versatile 4th OF in the market somewhere. Mauer, Park, Vargas is fine at 1B. I have every confidence in Polanco being solid and becoming good at 2B. Sano may not be good at 3B in 2017, but he will be OK and continue to get better. Better cknditionjng, more work, and being allowed to play the spot daily and concentrate on it will all help him improve. I do question SS. I like what we saw of Escobar in 2014 and 2015 with both glove and bat. Injuries and inconsistent playing time hurt him last season. Now, IF he is THE GUY there, and it's possible he could be, can he do it over a full season? We need another solid utility guy brought on board. I'm sorry, I find Vielma exciting and interesting, and I'm even more excited about Goodrum as a really nice and versatile utility guy. But I think it's just naive to expect either to jump to the ML level and perform at this time. We either need another nice option to spell people...I mentioned Drew in my blueprint...or we need to find a real, everyday defensive SS and let Escobar be that really nice utility guy. Either way, we need another infielder, even short term, with Dozier moving on. Some combination of Castro, Murphy and Garver will give us better all around catching than we'very had in some time. Needs: quality 4th OF and another infield option.
-
Article: Arbitration Decisions Looming
Just off the cuff my answer would be yes. I know wins and ERA don't tell the entire story, but Santiago actually has some quality ML experience and some decent numbers, far superior to Dean or Albers. Is he a long term solution? I would say absolutely not. But we don't know about Hughes at this point. I think the world of Berrios and his potential as well as his future, but he's still young and getting his feet on the ground. I feel good about a HEALTHY May. But we don't know for sure if Santana will be kept, or traded now or during the season. Same for Dozier. Mejia isn't probably ready just yet, nor is Gonsalves. Our other prospects will be in AA and AAA to begin the season. We need starters for now, options, and during ST, or before depending in trades, or during the season someone like Santiago may be moveable.
-
Article: Arbitration Decisions Looming
Kintzler is the only question mark for me. I've been advocating signing one of a few bounce back potential closer options and still believe it's a good idea; shores up the pen, buys time for the prospects, helps the Twins actually win the games theyou can, may be flippable, etc. I don't think you need/keep Kintzler if this is the case. But then again, doubt this happens quickly enough. Escobar is a yes, He showed what he is/may be capable of in 2014-15 and could be a solid everyday SS for now, or a high quality utility guy. Pressly showed me enough to believe he will be solid if not overworked. Also a pair of yes's to Gibson and Santiago. Unless/until a Dozier trade we need the arms and we can afford them. Gibson's previous two seasons were solid. I know Santiago pitched lousy when he first came over, and is no savior, but his previous three seasons were solid with an all star appearance mixed in. For now, at least, we need arms. There can be trades made later if we, gulp, actually find ourselves with depth via Hughes, May, Berrios, traded for TBD, etc.
-
Mike Napoli
He provides a veteran presence and possibly leadership and a big power bat to offset the lost of Dozier. I doubt he'd be overly expensive or long term. But absolutely nit unless you are going to somehow, someway move Mayer-Vargas-Park for something. Grossman can also DH some. Just doesn't make any sense unless there is some house cleaning taking place.
-
Some landing spots for Dozier?
The Dodgers almost makes too much sense. I agree to seek out other options and play up keeping BD in the media, but this is an ideal match. Bollinger, one of the top pitchers ML ready and another lower level prospect would be fine with me. It's one thing to hoot for the moon and another to capture it. I also think Santiago makes sense to be included here, though I wouldn't be adverse to maybe a relief arm of AA SP included. But I had this crazy notion last night of all 3 traded and go ahead and toss Puig in the deal as well. Twins trade 3 and come away with 4 or 5 in a good old fashioned blockbuster of sorts. Both teams are inexpensive payroll wise by doing this, the Dodgers rid themselves of a headache, Puig gets a fresh start, and the Twins end up with a not too expensive reclamation project of sorts that could pay off big.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
I would like more uniformity between all the umpires and their zones/calls. But I'd also like more uniformity in football regarding pass interference calls and the such. But I also don't want a computer making that kind of determination or even a guy in the booth playing big brother and overseeing every single play either. (Except as replay dictates) I still want and enjoy the human element. Sports is played by humans with rousing success and utter disappointment both. I believe humans should control the game as well. But it's also inexcusable in today's world of information sharing and technology for MLB and other sports not to review and instruct and preach as much uniformity as possible.
-
3 proposals that could pry Dozier away from the Twins
I buy the value of both Dozier and Santiago to the Dodgers but don't buy Perkins. Unless there are some good reports and expectations on Perk that we haven't heard yet, like mid-season healthy return or similar, I'd almost think including him and his contact would hurt the Twins side of the deal. I want to say it was Seth who mentioned including Van Slyke in a Dodger deal to add a solid veteran 4th OF. I find that idea interesting. If Bollinger is a no-go in the deal but Van Slyke was included to deepen the OF along with the listed pitchers, I still think I'd make that deal. But I confess to not knowing enough about De Jong and Estevez to know how this proposal shakes out on the Twins side.
-
Twins Establish New Era In Free Agency
Great first move! I hope there is more to come. Not going to sort out the rotation this way, but a bullpen arm, a quality 4th OF and an infielder after the expected Cozier trade are on my list.
-
Utilizing an extra roster spot
To me its clearly another bench bat/platoon bat. Even in today's baseball world, most teams, IMO, would carry 12 pitchers and 13 max. But the benches are getting pretty short these days. The 3rd catcher idea makes sense to a degree, but would make more sense if that 3rd catcher was also a DH/1B/OF. I just don't know day in and day out if a 3rd catcher who would seldom play is wise usage of the spot.
-
Dodgers make inquiry on Dozier
Really, I think I'm being dispassionate in this debate when I say I'd absolutely go for Dozier over Kinsler if I were the Dodgers. No knock on Kinsler, who is an outstanding ballplayer, but you have to get him to bypass his no trade, which probably brings about more guaranteed money, and he's already making far, far more than Dozier. Even a team with the pockets of the Dodgers have to recognize value and financial restraint at some point don't they? Dozier is younger, less likely to see sudden regression in the next couple of years, and may be slightly easier to pluck from the Twins, prospect wise, if Detroit's demands are to be believed. Not saying the Twins shouldn't shoot big or settle, and thee difference in prospects/players traded may be minimal, but is Kinsler that much better...short and long term...than Dozier? I'd think not. Even straight up trade value to both teams, Dozier is younger and cheaper.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
Agree with your sentiment here. But I'm going to take the opposite stance. Yes the team is rebuilding. And yes we have a number of really nice looking arms that are ready/close and need to be looked at. But I still believe the Twins can be a better, more competitive team, without necessarily blocking anyone, but upgrading where they can, including the bullpen. In my blueprint for 2017, and in other threads, I've argued for a couple bullpen arms to be brought in. And remember, typically there are 7 spots to fill here, and I'm not sure it's prudent to just open the door and have a bumrush of prospects filling out said spots. There are a couple really interesting bounce back closer options out there that could settle the back end of the bullpen, at least for a time, and could be flipped later, OR, re-signed as they are young enough to keep around. Wouldn't we all like to see the young, rebuilding Twins actually win games they are in? How about a LHRP on the rebound, or a failed SP being converted to join Rogers from the port side? Let's say you sign said closer and a lefty to team with Rogers, Chargois and Pressly. Let's put Duffey in the pen as well. That's still a young group, especially for a bullpen, IMO. You still have a last spot for the last man standing coming out of ST. Guys like Hildenberger, Jones, Burdi, Reed and Melotakis are still coming out of AA. You improve the pen, you may have a flip candidate or two, nobody has to be rushed straight from AA so they get at least some AAA exposure, and injuries and ineffectiveness always happen. I think there'should room here to make said moves without breaking the bank or holding anyone back. Sorry...got a little off topic here.
-
Twins Turkey of the Year
Confession time, never noticed that section or looked in to it before. Am I missing out here?
-
Twins Turkey of the Year
Star Trek, episode "Miri". And I'm not getting any younger myself. Lol
-
Twins Turkey of the Year
Disagree on Pohlad, with all due respect. I understand the opinion and where it originates from. But he's also the one who acknowledged said failure, fired Ryan, took some very bold steps to bring in the new FO, and seems to be giving them pretty much free reign for wholesale changes. (The status quo of Molitor notwithstanding, which could have happened anyway) My turkey of the year is Ryan. In the past, I often supported him, but also called him out...more and more the past couple of seasons...and I hate to pile on a good guy who lost his job, but he clearly set the Twins up to be where they are now. We can debate forever how prospects should be handled, and how quickly they should be good, and some of that was beyond Ryan's control. And we can question Molitor's usage of young players, lineups, etc, but a lot of that was within Ryan's realm of control as well. Not necessarily daily lineups, but he was the GM, the buck stops with him, and he seemed to lose a feel for his job and the pulse of the team. Just consider a few of the situations set up by Ryan: * The rushing of both Hicks and Buxton with no viable backup option. * The signing of Park...who himself is not to blame and may turn it around...when the team had other obvious needs and created log jams at 1B and DH and lead to the Sano in the OF mess. * Blame Sano, if you will, for not working hard enough in the OF and on his conditioning last season...and he is young and still maturing...but as the lead man in the organization, shouldn't you have a clue what is going on with your top young player? * Hughes getting hurt is NOT on Ryan, but why on earth extend him after the 2014 season with 2 more years on his contract? * Moving May to the pen in 2015 is debatable, but should have still been Pelfrey for all the obvious reasons. And maybe May would have been hurt a majority of the 2016 season even if he were in the rotation. We'll never know. But for a team starving for talented young starting pitching, we may have wasted an entire season of May's potential development by keeping him as a reliever last season. Why? Because... * The bullpen was a mess and the biggest area of need Ryan wanted to address coming in to the '16 season. And the only thing he did was sign Abad and keep May there? Just a few headscratchers that make Ryan my choice of Turkey of the year.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
Castro as a LH hitter vs RH pitching: .247 career BA/ .328 OB%/ .424 SLG%/ .753 SLG%/ .310 BABIP I believe someone posted these earlier, but I wanted to look them up again myself and repost. I hate stating the obvious, but the majority of pitchers Castro or anyone will face are RH. I don't have a breakdown comparison vs league average...maybe someone else does or would take the time to look it up...but those are quality numbers any way you slice it for a catcher. Yes, his numbers are pretty awful against LH pitching, Butera like since he's been brought up, but not only is the catcher position still a defense first one, but his platoon partner, Murphy or Garver, each hit RH so difficiencies in this area can easily be mitigated by simply being half way intelligent with your platoon days. I am not overly informed on pitch framing, but have become more educated with the more I read, mostly right here at TD. And I dont put complete faith in today's advanced metrics because it's still a game actually played on the field, by human beings who still have to perform, and it's not a role playing game where you just roll dice and hope you hit your percentage mark. Nor do I believe for a second that stealing a couple strikes a game guarantees any sort of overwhelming game or season winning effect. But I do believe it does have an effect, especially WHEN that extra strike or two a game is called. Imagine runners in scoring position, or the bases full, and that really close pitch "stolen" leads to strike 2 or even a punch out to end an inning. What if the batter hits defensively with a 2 strike count and only hits a weak single scoring a single run instead of a double or HR? I still believe calling a good game, working well with a staff, and providing a nice, comfortable target for the pitcher is most important of all a catchers responsibilities. And I can't tell you how good Castro really is at these things at the end of the day. But surely framing pitches well, bringing experience and a new perspective to the team, the staff, and our young catchers, while still possessing a solid bat has to help a team that has really struggled the past few years. Castro is by no means a stud or savior. But he qualifies as an upgrade to me, a step in the right direction. And at worst, he provides a solid, veteran presence until someone else proves themselves worthy and ready to take over.
-
FanGraphs: Top 24 Twins Prospects
And that's part of what I'm asking and getting at. We have no idea, a few years from now, just how much someone like Berrios and Gonsalves and others could improve and who could emerge. (Nor does anyone, do they?) I don't pretend to be an expert on scouting or projecting. Whole lot of people smarter and more experienced than I am on these matters. I think the more good player, or pitcher, options you have available, the better chance you have to find that guy or two to really step forward. And I do agree that some teams have done better at finding this talent in the past. The Ray's and Cardinals come to mind. But I think the question is still valid, how many other teams have prospects that are "identified" as true top of the rotation starters. I ask this out of honest curiosity as a long time baseball fan who has seen many completly washout that were supposed to be virtual locks to be stud pitchers, and others who evolved in to all star talents. So should there truly be great angst that reports like this list the Twins with a number of solid but not top of the rotation arms? Or is that how most teams prospect lists look. I guess I'm just saying I don't know how many teams out there truly have virtual locks vs almost everyone just hoping to develop what they have to the best of their ability and see what happens.
-
Article: REPORT: Twins To Sign Jason Castro
I swear I posted earlier but I guess it didn't take. No matter. I like this move a ton. But I admit I'm shocked. I just didn't see it happening, or so quickly, and frankly, as rumors flew, I thought it would take more than $8M per. In my blueprint, I talked about Castro. I just honestly didn't think it would happen, so I quickly moved on to other ideas/options. Look, Castro is not a savior for the team as a whole, or the pitching staff as a unit. But a catcher who can call a game, throw decently, steal some strikes, etc, is a real quality get for this team. The fact that he bats LH and does well against RH pitching is a huge bonus. A catcher can't play every day. Murphy and Garver provide an interesting back up/platoon scenario that can work really well if the manager just approaches it logically. Now, another infielder when Dozier is traded, one bullpen piece, and a competent 4th OF piece and I'm really encouraged. First step done!
-
FanGraphs: Top 24 Twins Prospects
And that's kind of my point actually. Does anyone really check out other team's projections like this? Are there many milb arms that are rated as #1 or #2 types? I'm asking because it helps put things in perspective, yes? If the Twins have some guys listed as #3 types with at least some projectability, and so do most teams, then we'really pretty much in similar company. However, if there are quite a few teams that have young pitching prospects fully expected to be a quality or 2, then that makes me feel more nervous about our kids. I've seen guys that were supposed to be studs flame out, and I've seen solid guys who turned out to be high end 2's and even 1'Santana that weren't supposed to be. I understand projecting things like this an inexact science, to say the least. I'm just wondering how we stack up to most or all other teams when it comes to these kind of projections.
-
FanGraphs: Top 24 Twins Prospects
A question in regard to pitchers, especially starting pitchers, and I'm really curious if anyone has an answer. It's been my experience over the years that an ACE pitcher, a true #1 guy, is hardly ever just drafted. It's not that simple or easy. (There are some exceptions, of course) It seems more than you draft and develop pitchers...some wash out, some make it...but true top of the rotations are guys that learn and develop over time. When I read things like this about Twins rotation prospects, they are always #3 starters or solid 4's, etc. But really, how often does someone get "projected" as a true top of the rotation starter while still developing in the minors?
-
Article: Falvey Has Seen The Value Of Patience
Patience is important, and no two prospects develop exactly the same. Which is part of the reason I get frustrated, and almost laugh at times, when I read things about how Buxton, Berrios, etc, should be moved or given up on already. The truth is, we as fans need a different kind of patience than was required the past few 90+ loss seasons. Before, we were impatient with injuries, poor trades or not making flip trades, poor to mediocre FA choices or no FA choices, etc, while eagerly awaiting the arrival of a wave of talented prospects. NOW, we have a new FO in place and we already here about some changes and expansions they want to make. But it won't all happen overnight. Further, with young talent in place, and more coming, this different form of patience must be exercised. At least now, it feels as though there is a new and hopefully forward moving plan taking shape.
-
Article: Turning Trevor May Into Andrew Miller
What I think we just don't know for sure is whether the back issues were directly caused by his being in the pen. He was effective there in 2015. But he was also showing signs of turning in to a solid SP that year before the bullpen move. For a team so much in need for starters, and so many interesting bullpen arms close to contributing, how can you not let May do what he has always done before and start? He was a quality SP in the minors, which us why he was acquired in the first place. His BB went down in '15 and a partial season in the rotation isn't enough to make any final judgments.