Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

DocBauer

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by DocBauer

  1. Thank you for the article and hard work Nick, much appreciated. But with exceptions of Cozier and Mayer, IMO, you could almost give the entire remaining infield a grade of "incomplete." I get that things go wrong sometimes and guys get hurt, but for various reasons, the entire infield was unsettled almost the entire year. At the risk of repetition: Escobar: injured and stuck on the bench behind other guys not bitten by the bug. Sano: the entire RAF fiasco to begin with Park: Korean import and hurt almost all season. Vargas: flashes but still no long term, consistent playing time and a ridiculous roster crunch demotion. Polanco: young and talented but still a rookie and playing mostly SS. ..a spot he hadn't played all season! This is not to bash the players, FO, Monitor or anyone. Rather, to me, it's a glass is half full scenario. Imagine some health, guys actually playing where they should and being used properly,and maybe/probably one more infield option brought in. Even with the trade if Dozier, we could be looking at a much improved infield in 2017.
  2. Please correct me if I'm wrong here, but wasn't he supposed to be selected earlier than he was based on pee-draft rankings? I would assume he'd begin next season at CR before a possible promotion to Ft Myers. But after college and his strong start last season, I wonder what the chances are he might skip straight to FTM to begin 2017.
  3. I agree that Santana could fall off a cliff at any time. But isnt that true of any pitcher? Injuries and overall wear and tear can affect anyone at any time. But it's also true that every pitcher is unique unto themselves. And there really is no proof, no concrete evidence to suggest to the Twins or anyone else that Santana is preparing to fall off that cliff immediately. In fact, the numbers, and other various numbers posted here, indicate how relative and consistent he was last season and the years before.I agree with an earlier comment that he is a solid ML #3 who sometimes pitches well enough to almost be a 2. (At worst, on a deep staff he's a very good 4 and not overly expensive by today's standards) Personally, I'd love to keep him to help lead the staff, but feel he is a valuable trade chip at this point. Not as valuable as Cozier, but valuable to a number of teams with an open window and a need to deepen their rotation for a run. IMO, and hope, the Twins would acquire a mix of 3 strong arms from a Cozier deal, and then trade Santana for 2 quality position players, not quantity. I believe his experience, history and strong 2016 would be worth a pair of prospects ranking in a team's top 10-15 overall. And I'd target 2 of 3 spots between catcher, infield and outfield, preferably AA or high A. For a post season hopeful team, I feel this would be fair value.
  4. Beat me to it glunn. I absolutely love my Twins, win or lose, and have literally grown up with them my whole life. Over 45 years as a fan. (NOT dating myself. I happen to be a very, very young 51yo. So hold off on the old man jokes! Lol) And I absolutely love TD and the people here who run it, maintain it, and contribute here. Without getting personal, 2016 has been a very tough year for me in real life. TD has often served as a saving grace for my sanity at times with our shared interest, love and fanatasiscm with the Twins. I wish everyone here a wonderful Christmas and New Year! And if I may impart a bit if wisdom: "Be good...or don't get caught!" Lol God Bless!
  5. I'm going to keep things very simple here and focus in just a couple points. Untouchable? Arias and Bellinger. What do I want? (And see as fair) JDL, Alvarez, and Stewart-Buehler-Sheffield. I'd be happy to stop right there and be happy as can be and call it fair for both sides. But if I could come away with Van Slyke as a 4th player and an excellent 4th OF/role player for the Twins you could color me pink.
  6. My immediate answer to the initial question is no, i wouldn't trade any of them at this time. Would I consider moving one of them if it meant making a deal with the Dodgers as mentioned above...and other places...probably. But to me the absolute best thing the Twins can do right now is acquire additional assets/prospects to work with. In my over 40 years following baseball and the Twins, I have seen top prospect after top prospect washout completely or at least fail to live up to his hype and potential. I've also seen a lot of guys picked later in the draft turn out to be all star caliber players. {Dozier?} The drafting and signing and trading for young talent in baseball is the biggest crapshoot in all of sports. There are things to really like, and very much potential in all of them. And honestly, we have NO IDEA just who will make it, who won't, and just how good any of them will be. You give me 5-7 solid young arms with potential, and I will almost guarantee one of them turns out to be a stud, one pretty to very good and one solid with the rest amounting to nothing...maybe a solid to good RP for one. You keep these 5, combine them with Berrios and Mejia, and at least 1 if not 2 similar stage/age prospects from the Dodgers and I bet you end up with what I just listed above. A little good fortune, you might even end up with another solid starter and a second quality RP. But having the numbers to work with are important.
  7. I've always liked the Dodgers though I can't say I'm a "fan" as there is only one team in my heart. And I get that no team wants to give up top prospects in a trade situation. Everyone wants to "win" a trade. But except in somewhat rare cases, trade steals don't happen. You have to give up something to get something in return. Maybe the Dodgers system, praised for talent and depth, turns out to not be as loaded as reported. But it would appear, from reports and rankings, that they are. And they are a team with a lot of talent on the ML club, and even by trading away some talent, would still seem to have a bunch on the way. And they are a serious WS contender for 2017 with a big open window to win one. Dozier really fits what they need. And prospects, the Dodgers' or the Twins', are still prospects until they prove themselves. That is the risk the Twins take in moving a known, high quality ML proven player like Dozier for prospects. IMO, I see JDL, Alvarez and another of Stewart, Buehler, etc as a fair offer for the Dozier. Do the Dodgers give up a trio of nice young arms that could turn out to be very good? Yes. But they still have a bunch of quality prospects in their system, they increase their likelihood of reaching the WS with Dozier, said prospects given up are not guaranteed of anything right now, and the Twins assume the proverbial "risk" of the future development of the prospects. To me, it's a win on both sides and fair value for both clubs.
  8. IMO, May will turn out solid at worst in the rotation given a real chance. This is based on stuff, milb history, and what he started to show in 2015. But his IP over the past 1 1/2 seasons probably marks him as the 5th SP for 2017. Also still a big believer in Berrios. Being a quality ML SP is HARD. There is almost always a learning curve. Part of his problem, IMO, is maybe trying too hard and not relaxing. You just have to believe and hope a Dozier trade happens and we get another quality young arm to plug in. Haley? Don't know enough about him to really say much. But Gibson, Santiago and maybe Hughes all help finish out the rotation for now. (Does Wheeler ever get or deserve a shot if he pitches again as well as he did last year?) And Mejia and Gonsalves develop at Rochester while 4 other young arms begin 2017 and AA with some nice upside. Nothing is proven or guaranteed! But I don't feel things are all doom and gloom either. I'm actually kind of excited over the rotation options the next year or two.
  9. Nelson Molina, Travis Blakenhorn, Trey Cabbage, possibly TJ White and Niko Goodrum, (the latter may be best as a versatile utility guy), and maybe even Gordon if another SS comes to light. There are also a couple SS in the low minors who might convert. The problem here is almost everyone is at A ball or lower. But this also gives Sano time to actually play 3B on a daily basis for a year or two. The numbers, despite some bad plays here and there, indicate he's about average defensively. And this is despite being young, not allowed to play daily, only about 750 ML AB of experience, and the entire RF experiment last season. He's a good athlete for a larger man with a gun for an arm. He charges the ball well. I have seen very few 3B in all my years who come up and are real assets with the glove immediately, and this includes the Twins history as well. Can't we just let the kid play some before we decide he can't play? Back to Dozier....
  10. Question to you all: Putting aside for a moment who exactly is on or off the table for sure, (which the Dodgers could change at any moment based on a desire to finish the deal, OR, the Twins taking salary back, etc), which is truly the best overall fit for the Twins as the 3rd piece in this puzzle? Is it someone like Stewart who may be close? Or are we better off with someone else like a Sheffield or one of the other younger and further away youngsters with more potential but more questions? JDL joins Berrios, May, Mejia, Gonsalves, and a number of SP candidates that will all probably begin next season at AA. I'm not so sure a younger, less proven lottery type isn't more fitting for the Twins at this point.
  11. I admit I sort of forgot that list from 2005. At the risk if dating myself, I was honestly thinking all the way back to around 1983-85 or so with Banks, Sontag, Pittman, Newman, Gasser, Nivens and Bumgarner.
  12. I am much higher on May than you are, considering he seemed to show better and better consistency in 2014 and flashed potential before being placed in the pen. The problem isn't even that that took place, it's that the Twins virtually lost a full season of potential and development from him in 2016. I believe we also still have Wheeler, do we not?
  13. Just to expand a bit on your point, Rosario and Sano lead with something like a whopping 770 and 750 ML AB.
  14. Numbers don't lie, at least not completely. As a result, I'm not going to formally disagree with you. But I will offer a rebuttal. Our OF defense has the ability to be very good defensively. In fact, with ranger and overall athletic, the only negative I can begin to find is Kepler maybe having an aveerge arm. Do they have to grow offensively? Yes. But Rosario, Buxton and Kepler are all 3 quite young and still growing, learning on the job as it were, and have real talent. I think Kepler may end up being the most complete hitter of the three and may just be our next 3 hitter. Buxton has made skills and was finally coming alive late in the season. Rosario is a bit of enigma, but we saw what he is capable of in 2015, and saw glimpses last season after his demotion. I feel Polanco has all the ability in the world to be a valuable hitter and quality defensive 2B, with some pop and speed. Vargas and Park I'm less sold on, but given health and opportunity, they are a couple of bats that have potential and need to play to see what they can actually do over a sustained period. Both have power, Vargas can switch hit, (at different times he's hit better from each side), and he shows some OB ability. Park isn't ancient, has good power, and had an early season stretch where he flashed. Sano only needs to be average at 3B to be a huge asset. Part of the problems we had defensively in 2016 was guys playing that shouldn't have been playing, and guys playing out of position. SS is a question still, but a healthy Escobar playing and performing more like 2014-15 could/should be solid. More than anything for this upcoming season, I'm looking for a mostly set lineup where guys that should be playing, and need to play actually...you know...get to play.
  15. We have tons of information and speculation, and yet, we also don't have a lot of concrete information. Is it possible...I'm asking...that it's the Twins who are holding this thing up? That maybe the Dodgers are offering both JDL and Alvarez and the Twins are just asking too much for the 3rd spot? Not saying they shouldn't go for the gold here! Dozier is a high quality commodity and I couldn't and wouldn't blame the Twins for going for all they can get. But lately I've been reading he's not really worth this or worth that, etc, and the Dodgers aren't offering enough. I'm just wondering if the Twins are the ones holding up the trade here. Thoughts?
  16. I would vote no. Castro is nice, and will hit primarily from the LH side. Garver has real potential, even if he isn't 23yo. Considering his milb numbers and stint with the Yankees, just no way Murphy is as bad as he showed last season. Plus, willing to bet Turner comes back to the Twins. Now, another quality AAAA type like Hicks last season, even another Centeno, wouldn't be a bad option for depth and competition. But with the actual ML roster in mind? Nawww
  17. Nailed it!! Absolutely no reason financially, and nobody being blocked, for this team to add an infielder, a quality 4th OF, and a bounce back (possibly flip-able) closer option to help secure what games we have a chance to win while auditioning various young RP like Chargois. Even then, I could still see a bench spot for Grossman as a 5th OF, solid PH/DH bat unless we keep 3 1B/DH options, which is possible.
  18. You know, I could almost go for this. And it almost makes tons of sense. But my problem is I'm not really sure what you are getting in Profar at this point. I get it, trading Santana for a couple quality prospects doesn't guarantee you anything either! But doesn't it feel like Profar might be more of a lottery ticket at this point???
  19. No closer would give us that many wins, obviously. But there is such a thing as learning to win, IMO. And a stronger bullpen can help out a poor to mediocre rotation, just as a poor pen can lose games and overshadow a quality rotation. I'm not saying don't pitch the prospects, I'm saying hold on to leads and potential wins for this young team that is rebuilding. Let guys like Chargois and Pressly set up and slide in to the role. Make the bullpen as strong as you can, maybe flip said closer. If it's someone still relatively young ands Neftali is, perhaps you even consider re-signing him. 20 wins won't happen by a veteran, quality closer, but it's a cumulative affect that can lead to more wins.
  20. Yes, as of right now, this is pretty much the roster as I'd see it now. Of course, it's almost 100% sure to change with another FA or two and a probable trade or two forthcoming. I'd say DanSan has the weakest hold on a roster spot despite his athleticism. I so badly want him to develop in to a solid, useful and even exciting and sometimes dangerous role player. I just don't think it's going to happen any longer. Not sure Hughes will be ready to open the season. I'd really have a hard time holding Berrios out of the rotation, even with some ups and downs, just because of talent, potential, and the need to pitch.
  21. Seth, I'm curious as to his solid college season and his size...not to mention his performance at Elizabethtown...and wonder why he lasted until the 15th round? He would seem to be "projectable". Despite his size, is he just not a very hard thrower?
  22. Feliz. He's only 28, our new GM is already familiar with him as well. He could be flipped at the deadline, or, considering his age even be re-signed. You never know if a guy can thrive as a closer until he gets his shot, but someone like Feliz means you don't have to press Chargois or Pressly or anyone else in to the role. They can set up, audition here and there, then take over. Nothing wrong with a strong pen to hold any leads our young team will have, and said strong pen can help balance a weak rotation.
  23. Look, at the end if the day, this is ALL speculation at this point, even with informed sources and a fit for both clubs. But since we ARE talking speculation and theory here...along with quality information from various sources...then let's put it all together and say JDL and Alvarez are indeed the focal point. If the Dodgers would include Stewart or Buehler or whoever as a 3rd piece if the Twins would take McCarthy if their hands then this would be a MUST for the Twins. The payroll should be under 109M fir the next couple of seasons yes? Even with signing Castro Plouffe and Suzuki are gone. Santiago COULD be released if necessary but figures to be fine by '18. Santana could yet be moved, Perkins is off the books after this year, and Mayer after '18. There is a lot if payroll if the books and still to fall away. The rebuilding Twins could absolutely afford to eat a 20M deal to net them the prospects they want/need.
  24. De Leon and Alvarez, one more solid arm with potential, with a reported throw in, would get it done for me.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.