Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

DocBauer

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by DocBauer

  1. Sorry for the late response TNT, was just really busy. Absolutely agree with your question and your sentiment. 1] Do Bumgarner or Pineda win a game or two in the playoffs next season? Why not? It's all speculation, of course, both in regard to next season AND th3js season. Game 3 was embarrassing to me. And maybe nothing would have turned out differently in the long run. But I sure would have liked Pineda for one of those starts now. Maybe we win one in N.Y., no matter the rotation order. I see no reason Pineda can't do in 2020 what he did this season. I am not 100% sold on Bumgarner. And he was a little down this season. But he has say and experience. The velocity seems to be there. And while I remain a bit leery of a NL pitcher making the move to the AL, I am INTRIGUED by Bumgarner getting a new challenge, on a new and good team, working with Johnson. One of the things that worried me about this past series was lack of experience on the big stage. At times, I think we saw that. The Yankees had it. The Twins didn't. That could change next season. 2] The team I listed just got swept in the playoffs? Yep. Reference my above comment about experience. But let's also remember that except for Cruz, Castro, Marwin and late addition Romo, this is still a largely young team just coming in to it's own. Pineda, a healthy Gibson, Kepler, Marwin and Cron not rusty and "limping" in to the series could make this a whole different story.
  2. Sorry, but I almost feel like a copy and paste since I've pretty much said these things in other threads, but my thoughts haven't changed, so here I go again. Couple quick points/thoughts: 1] The $60-$70M budget to work with is easy, and what I've been working with. That pretty much keeps the 2020 payroll static. That DOES NOT mean the payroll won't increase, it was larger in 2018. The FO is on record...with no set $ amount of course...as stating they would add when the window was open and it seemed right to do so. The mean for 2020, speculating, should be around $150M in MLB. I don't necessarily expect that as the FO undoubtedly is looking at additional extensions. 2] I absolutely believe the FO is willing to trade a handful of top 10-30 prospects in the right deal. And as deep as the system is, it would be able to handle a mkve like that easily. But they also want sustainability, and there is no way 2 major trades are made to gut the system. All that being said: A] Odorizzi will be targeted, initial QO or not. I see no reason why he wouldn't want to return. I also see no reason why a 3yr deal, possibly 4yr or an option year, at around $14-15M per wouldn't work. B] While his suspension hurt the end of this season and will impact the start of the next, I believe Pineda will be brought back. And I like that idea. It makes sense, I'm uncertain of length but $12M sounds about right all things considered. C] I think Castro is back, no big offer forthcoming from anyone else, for about $4-5M. Cron is also back for about $5Mm unless someone can show me a better alternative for the same $. And, I also bring back Romo on a 1yr for about $3-4M, small bump from this season and very fair. Anyway you slice it, gives you approximately $30M to find another rotation arm you really need. D] Does Cole really $30M or more? I'd like to see him in a Twins uniform, but 1/5th of total payroll for 1 SP and for 5-6yrs? I just don't know. Logic would tell me contact like that would only come from N.Y., L.A., Boston, etc. If offered something close, would he choose the Twins and Rocco and Johnson and Target Field and a strong team who's window just opened? I'm saying it won't happen, even if the Twins really put themselves out there, due to many factors from bright lights to being from California, etc. So I move down a peg. I like Wheeler. But Bumgarner is my next target. It's time for the Giants to rebuild, and time for MadBum to look elsewhere for $, a change of scenery, and a chance to win. I'm nervous about the number of IP and being 32yo in 2020. He is not what he once was. But everything I've read seems the velocity is still good, and peripherals are solid, despite a somewhat mediocre 2019. Is he nearing the end? Or was it just a down season and a new challenge, environment and pitching coach just what he needs? 2 or 3yrs or however options play in to it, he'd come in around $16-18M for career production mixed in with speculation. Personally, I think it's about 50/50 the Twins sign someone vs making a trade. E] Whether FA or smaller trade, I'd make a move for a 2nd LH for the pen. All said and done, Cole and my LHRP meets or slightly bumps the 2020 payroll. Extensions bump it a little more, and we still don't hit the MLB mean. That allows even more flexibility for additions, etc. If it's a Bumgarner, Wheeler, Trade addition, even with said LHRP, the payroll stays about the same, even with extensions. And that's not necessarily bad! **Notes: Not convinced Perez is back regardless, but could be in the Bumarner/Trade scenario. Unfortunately, Gibson is gone unless it's a small incentive laden deal. Dyson could be retained on a split 2yr deal for $750K-1M 1st year rehab and something like $4-5M 2nd year deal, but not figuring him in here for obvious reasons. 2020 STAFF, allowing for 26 man roster and POTENTIAL 13 man staff: Rotation; 1 & 2] Berrios, Bumgarner/Trade (leaving Cole out) 3] Odorizzi 4] Pineda (after time served) 5] Dobnak, Smeltzer, Thorpe, Graterol (Perez, Gibson, Fljer) Bullpen: 1] Rogers 2] Duffey 3] May 4] Romo 5] LH FA/Trade 6] Littell 7] Smeltzer 8] Romero, Poppen, Flier, and about anyone and everyone else
  3. I've been very busy lately so haven't commented a lot over the final 3 games or since. That may change now, lol. I am as disappointed a d frustrated as any of us for things ended. Can't say for sure if I would feel better had we won a game, or two. Losing is still losing. Not winning the ultimate prize is still, again, losing. But in all my years watching my beloved Twins, Huskers and Vikings, (shudder on the Vikings), I have witnessed 5 championships. And each one was GLORIOUS! But I love and follow my teams each and every season for the entertainment and joy each one gives me. Even in the not so great years. We're I to base my entertainment and joy value strictly on winning it all, I'd be pretty damn disappointed and miserable. While the series with the Yankees was painful and frustrating, I had an absolute BLAST in 2019 from day one! I had a BLAST on my own, sharing the season with my father, and here on Twins Daily with everyone involved. And nothing, including the way it ended, will rob me of that joy.
  4. Smart. Funny. And far more classy in the process.
  5. Yes, a huge shout out and thank you for your contributions as moderators and bloggers, helping to make Twins Daily the pre-eminent site that it is.
  6. I am torn between being depressed how the season ended vs how wonderful, fun and exciting the overall season was. Only one team, and one fan base ever ends a season truly happy I guess. I had a BLAST with this team! Maybe I'm just sad baseball is done until next spring. But...DAMN.,,2019 was FUN! GO TWINS!!
  7. Because I love the speculation game, Huskers, Vikings, Twins, and my dad and friends and I play this game all the time, I will gladly bite. I/we reflected on this already in the 2020 payroll thread. And we will do this over and again a dozen times before 2020 begins. But this stuff is fun! Going to try and abbreviate my previous comments in the other thread. I am also going to maintain the 2020 payroll example of $60M to play with for 2020, even though I think the Twins can and will exceed their $ numbers from this year. I am also basing my roster on what's on hand, what I hope is good logic, a feel for the FO and the work they have done, and even recent rumors and ties that make sense. Also, speculation for the marketplace as we've seen it play out the past few seasons. 1] We need 3 SP. That task is not as daunting as it appears. Odorizzi will sign for about $14M to an absolute max of $16M per year on a 3yr deal with a possible option. HUGE money for him, more than he bas ever made, about right IMO, and nobody is going to sign him for more. He is GOOD. Actually, quite good. But he is in no way $18M+ good! He and his agent should jump on anything close to this, with a good club, window open, and stick with Johnson and the Twins. Despite whatever happened, unless there is massive amounts of lip service taking place, all parties appear to be on board for a return of a healthy and clean, (hopefully smarter), Pineda returning in 2020. But he is not going to break the bank. I'm not certain if he gets 1yr or 2 or some 1 + 1, but he's back for about $12M. The 3rd SP is KEY! I still find myself laughing at times at how some are down on Berrios, not 26yo until May of next year, as some sort of disappointment. Different arguement for another time. But we need someone to join him. I'd LOVE Cole, but dismiss him. Just being logical as well as practical. He re-signs or gets even more $ or an extra year or 2 from LA, N.Y., Boston, etc, IMO. So the Twins look at the next best option and either make a major trade, or look at the next best FA option. Contending teams DON'T trade top SP. But the FO might have their eye on a guy or two about ready to explode with Johnson working with him. Or they could sign a veteran like Bumgarner who has life yet, and is ready for a change of scenery and a new opportunity and approach. For this scenario, I'm going with Bumgarner on a 3yr deal for $16-18M. A HUGE payday for him, and a new opportunity. Would anyone really offer mkre than this, combined with being a competitive team? 2] There is so much good right here, that I think some re-signings make a ton of sense and won't cost much. The exception would be a trade or FA signing for 1 more BP piece. 2020: Regular lineup: Rosario Buxton Kepler Cruz Sano Polanco Arraez Cron [give a better $5M option for a year or two and I could be in!] Garver Bench: Gonzalez Adrianza Cave [Wade has a shot and window, but a smart FA signing could surprise] Castro [$4M ish as a semi-regular who fits well and won't get a better offer] Astudillo [versatile, solid, productive when healthy] Rotation: Berrios Bumgarner/Trade Odorizzi Pineda Dobnak, Smeltzer, Thorpe, Graterol [possible flier] Bullpen: Rogers Duffey May Littell Romo [re-signed] Stashak LH FA/trade [really like the Smith option, and we've been tied to him] 26 man roster with the option of carrying an 8th RP and letting a position player go. Payroll is the same as 2019, or slightly elevated. This allows for extensions. And still provides opportunity for a payroll approaching $150M with an unknown addition.
  8. Is it game 165 or last game of the year? Come on Twins! Come on baseball gods! Twins have been down before and done it! Let's add to the magic of this season! (*Note: Call me stressed or sudden superstitious, I almost feel like not watching thinking they will win if I'm NOT looking in.)
  9. Not going to call out anyone in particular, but I also had the sense at times some guys were tight and seemed to be trying too hard for the big hit or big moment. I'd like to think a game under their belt will help them relax today. I won't go so far to say the Yankees over used their bullpen...heck, they won right?...but it sure seemed like they had quick hooks and ran through almost everyone. Does that help the Twins today?
  10. I count 26. Am I wrong about roster size for the 2019 Post season? Or was there an "or" left out somewhere in the pitcher selection? I believe Astudillo makes it, first round at least, due to Adrianza's injury and not being ready. I'd remove Thorpe off the pitching list to make it 12 instead of 13. Again, am I somehow wrong about roster size? I am torn about Perez vs Gibson. I just don't know what Gibby has in the tank vs Perez as a LOOGY or single IP option. STILL not convinced Graterol is on the roster but could be traveling along as a potential replacement player. Then again, perhaps lightening in a bottle that they will uncork and hope for the best.
  11. Just want one!
  12. Ahhhhh! [shudder] I guess memory fades sometimes for good reason. Lol
  13. So, buckle up, because HERE WE GO! Going to try bullet points so I don't ramble TOO much! 1] Any Yankee curse is just B.S., no matter what happens. The past is the past. Players, coaches, and even managers are different. The Yankees are a good team. But guess what, so are our Twins! Who did we expect to play, some also-ran club? 2] These teams are so evenly matched it's almost eerie. The ONE THING that worries me is NOT that these are the Yankees. Reflecting on this season, and all the Twins have done, and the character of this team, do you really think anyone is frightened or intimidated to play them? No. The ONE THING that worries me is just more experience on the big post season stage. I think that is an X factor to be considered. 3] While things have clearly changed for both teams since they played early in the season, the truth is virtually every game was close and swung on a few plays here and there. 4] Driving home tonight on the radio, I was listening to a major pundit...cant recall now who...was talking about all the playoff possibilities. He stated bluntly that people are ignoring the Twins, their offense and season, especially their pitching...in fact stating the Twins may be deeper and better in the pitching area right now...and handing the Yankees anything was a mistake. He stated outright he felt the Twins could win this opening series. FWIW, he also stated that he felt Tampa was a legitimate threat to Houston and shouldn't be taken lightly either. 5] Post season heroes always come in unexpected forms, it seems. But the thing that has me troubled is Kepler and Marwin, followed by Arreaz. Despite all the talent the Twins have, these 3 guys could all prove to be difference makers. How ready are they? 6] Screw the networks and their ratings...to be blunt...I wanted Twins and Brewers for the WS. I'd settle now for the Twins and whoever, lol.
  14. Gut tells me Berrios starts game 1. I don't know what the Twins braintrust and analytics tell them. If my crystal ball was working, and it told me a "sharp" Berrios would be on the mound for game 1, I'd definitely go with him. One game this season in Yankee stadium, vs career numbers, tells my Odorizzi and that short RF porch aren't a great match. I think Brock is right about game 2. I HATE to do this, but let us assume the "sharp" Berrios, pen and hitters win game 1. It would seem natural to put your next best SP out there for game 2. But again, history, I think I agree on Dobnak, more of a groundball pitcher, for game 2 and a potential bullpen game. That puts Oddo in charge of game 3 at home, with a day of rest for guys used in the pen to be ready to go.
  15. I HATE being "that guy", but I'm just lost as to the original context behind this thread.
  16. EXTREMELY surprised MLB is putting the game somewhere other than ESPN or one of the networks. But I happen to work in the industry, and the MLB is usually part of a cable "package" that would include other channels such as the NFL network, NBA, etc. The cost for adding said package is usually pretty cheap. And while I can't speak for other companies, you can usually add said packages and then remove them almost immediately. You would pay pennies for adding the channel for a day or a couple of days. At worst, you'd pay $10+ dollars for 1 month if the series continues on the MLB network.
  17. Shout out to Kelly for such an intelligent response. (I chose not to copy it). My response would be to appreciate and generally agree with him that Sanchez has been the standard in recent years. BUT, that doesn't mean Garver isn't better NOW, at least for 2019.
  18. Honestly, I think rotation and pen are no worse than a push either way, regardless of how you tilt the table in comparison. It does feel the Yankees have more of the "been there" and that can absolutely be a factor. While we can't be sure how Berrios is going to perform, we know what he can do, has done before, and he has absolutely looked much better as of late. I'm with Brock that my biggest concern is the offense limping in to this series. Even if close to 100%, how rusty are Kepler and Marwin? And is the ankle good enough for Arraez to be himself?
  19. Great article, Seth. Thanks! Big fan of Garver and believer. Even when there were questions about his defense last season, I saw enough to like. Time and hard work have really paid off for him.
  20. To be clear, W-L record for a reliever is different than for a starter. I think we can at least agree on that. And a W-L record for a SP can be skewed, absolutely, by playing for a winning team vs a losing team. Prolific offense, poor offense, good defense bad defense good pen, bad pen, all of these factors can lead to final results of a W-L record, yes? And these same factors can also change ERA, and various other stats, or affect them. Yes?? But regardless of situation, pitching well enough to win has always meant something to me. Just seen enough games when a SP maybe didn't deserve to win the game, but did, while losing a tight game where he probably deserved to win but didn't, that I've always felt it kind of evened out. Just my opinion. Agree to disagree?
  21. 100% Unless he suddenly gets a "grip" on some sort of change in winter ball and ST...pun intended...Graterol is absolutely targeted for Rochester. In fact, if he is working on something specifically, he could begin again at AA with a potentially quick promotion. Why is everyone so eager to take an ELECTRIC 21yo arm and promote him to the majors? Hope, I get it. I'd rather have sustained success than urgency. 2020 WAY TOO EARLY SPECULATION: 1] Berrios 2] Trade or FA 3] Re-signed Odorizzi (POSSIBLE QO) 4] Pineda (Early speculation by comments but makes sense) 5] Dobnak (Clearly the early candidate but has to still earn it) DEPTH AND COMPETITION (With Pineda out early) IN NO PARTICULAR ORDER: 1] Smeltzer 2] Graterol 3] Thorpe 4] Ober 5] Poppen (possible pen option) 6] Gonsalves 7] Jax 2020 WAY TOO EARLY BULLPEN: 1] Rogers 2] Duffey 3] May 4] Romo 5] Littell 6] Stashak (has to continue to earn it) 7] LH TBD (in house, FA or trade) DEPTH: Romero and every SP option plus a few more milb prospects working their way up. Plus, there is always a waiver FA who is interesting.
  22. And like you, I kinda agree and disagree. Seems we have a lot of that going on today, lol. A few years ago, King Felix had an AMAZING season for Seattle and won the Cy Young with a 13-12 record for a poor team. Kind of an abnormality at the time. And I agree W-L is not a conclusive indicator, neither is ERA. (Ignoring the current Cron debate and RBI, LOL). And while W-L is Not a final debate for a pitcher, reliever or starter, I do find merit in it for a SP. It's kind of easy to say a SP should have won a game because his team scored a bunch of runs, not necessarily meaning Gibson, but how many games did that pitcher lose, or get a no decision, because his offense, or defense, let him down? I feel it generally evens out. At least most seasons.
  23. But not only does it take a team to have a season like this, the offensive explosion was partly due to depth. He hit around 5 sometimes, especially against LHP. But if memory serves, he usually hit 6th or 7th. 25 bombas and 78 RBI with an injury plagued September. Healthy, arbitrary I know, but another 2 or 3 HR and over 80 RBI? I completely understand your point. But the stubborn German/Norwegian part of me would also argue his numbers are even more impressive CONSIDERING he was hitting behind Kepler, Polanco, Cruz, Rosario...sigh. what a lineup! I would be A-OK replacing him with an even better option. And said option may only be a half season to full season away. But unless the Twins can find and sign a Hrbek or Morneau this off season to replace him...with pitching considerations being primary...who else would you find better? LOL, I know we are splitting some fine hairs right now, but we need something to discuss at the moment in anticipation. If we knew ahead of time Cron would play a fine 1B, and would produce 25HR and 78 RBI in the bottom third of a record pacing offense in 5/6 of a season, I think we'd all be pretty happy. Just fun to talk about this stuff. I love it! We only marginally disagree, which is Great! I still think my plan and your payroll idea kicks ass! LOL
  24. Not only is Gibson a great person, but I have championed again, and again, and recently again in a post that was ignored by most concerning his career. Do so few take the time to just look up facts? Or are the "haters" simply disillusioned by the fact he never fulfilled the dream of being a late 1st round steal who would be a staff stud? I've given up trying to get "some" to look at his first 2 full seasons, and what he did the last half of 2017 and for 2018, and MOST of 2019 before sucuming to illness. They only want to concentrate on a year and a half of poor ball vs his career. In this wonderful, magical season, despite starting slow due to illness, and finishing poorly due to illness, with inflated late numbers, he is 13-7 in 2019. Where would we be without him?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.