Everything posted by Jham
-
Article: Twins Lose, Fans Boo, So Hope Remains
How I imagine the managerial discussion went: TR: Who do you think should start at shortstop? Gardy: I like Escobar at Short and Santana in Center. TR: You're fired. Mientkiewicz: Whoever gives us the best chance of winning. TR: We'll let you know. Molitor: Whoever you think is best, sir. TR: You're hired! We're starting Santana at shortstop even though it leaves a gaping hole in center, Escobar is better and still young, scouts say his infield D is mediocre, and we're really just looking for a stop-gap to Polanco. I am positive TR orchestrated this, but Molitor is still the manager and ultimately responsible for line ups.
-
Unwritten Rules are Not Smart
But in the end, wasn't Swisher technically doing us a favor by trying to get Nishioka out of the league on opening day?
-
Game Thread, Twins @ Tigers, 4/9 @ 12:08pm CT
Correct me if I'm wrong, but i think we actually outscored them over the last 2.5 innings. Tigers are lucky the series ended when it did.
-
Nolasco to have MRI
Nolasco quotes postgame: "I put in a lot of hard work and all that, but one start isn't going to kill you as far as mental-wise, so I just have to go back to work and do what I have to do for the next one." "I got myself into a bad situation," Nolasco said. "I couldn't make a pitch. A couple balls fell for them. I didn't give us a chance to win. The game got out of control early. There's not much you can do." Nowhere did he say anything about an elbow. It sounds like he was generally unconcerned with the start and was ready to go out again and do better. Then the next day his elbow hurt? I don't buy it. Nolasco's velocity didn't dip by much after facing Avila, as he remained in the game to throw six more pitches, including three sliders and three fastballs registered at 88, 88 and 87 mph.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Tigers, 4/8 @ 12:08pm CT
We're getting to the point where our first high draft picks may not even be around by the time our latest high draft picks make it up.
-
Through the Fence: 4/5/15 Miguel Sano workouts
Awesome account of some behind the scenes action. About time we lit a fire under these kids. We need them to get better quickly. Here's hoping that hard-work and hard-coaching pay off.
-
The Twins 2015 Opening Day Roster is Practically Set; No surprises but 40-man work.
Has everyone pretty much changed their minds on Milone for Fuld? It seems like the response last summer was 95% positive with Ryan being praised from all angles. Now, it appears Fuld would be our starting center fielder. Just think, we could have had Fuld AND Trevor May to start the season. Oh boy! I actually saw a lot I liked toward the end of last season. And it's not like we don't have suitable options for many of our glaring holes, or lack of trade bait for that matter. If CF is a, well, the other CF, then we could in a pinch go back to Santana, or call up Hicks or Rosario. If corner D is a problem, we can DH Hunter or Arcia and call upon a Rosario or throw Escobar out there since we'll be chucking him out there anyway... If Pelfrey's terrible or Boyer comes down to earth, or Stauffer retires to sell pot pies, Meyer, May, or Hamburger seem plenty capable to work their way into the league from the pen.
-
Article: Twins Make Cuts, Name Starters
Some were very critical of Gardy for playing favorites, but he was at least dogged in asking the FO for more talent. He voiced on numerous occasions his desire to have Gibson, Meyer, and May called up. He publicly disagreed with the FO on the Santana displacing Escobar debate. Molitors first few moves as manager: Santana to short, and Meyer/May back to AAA. I can't say I'm offended by anything that happened regarding the cuts provided they are short term. Hey, if Theo Epstein says he's never had a rookie break with the team, then I'm ok with our studs taking a month to get into a grove before coming up, hopefully with some confidence. If Kris Bryant isn't coming north, should Eddie Rosario? I would guess Rosario will be the first call up, as soon as he's ready. Molitor's hinted at as much. Hamburger will be added back as soon as Boyer fails or Pelfrey is traded. May will be up if he can show he's ready and Milone stumbles. It's still a competition, but eventually the season starts and you have to choose a guy. Meyer is the perfect candidate to get some experience in the pen before preparing to start next year. If we get to mid-June and most of this has taken place, I think most of those complaining will be satisfied, and I believe that is the teams ultimate hope.
-
Hicks cut
I'm not crediting Ryan with a good or bad trade. I'm crediting him for trying. For many many seasons we've been drafting and acquiring low risk low reward guys and found them riskier than anticipated with predictably poor results. I'll give the organization credit for switching it up and going after power arms. You can blame Ryan for the fact that May and Meyer are in the organization, but not for their individual failures to leap the near ground level hurtles required to make the team.
-
Hicks cut
That's certainly one view, and I'm sure there is some truth to it for some pitchers. Some pitchers need to get thrown to the flames for them to figure out what works and doesn't against big league guys, get jitters out, or otherwise develop. For each player there will be a "too soon" line. In many cases, it probably doesn't even matter, either they're good enough or not. I just don't think the difference in having rookies break with the team vs. come up in May or June is significant in player development or even team performance. Maybe there was a Rick Anderson effect, but it seems like we may have given up on guys like Breslow, Neshek, Worley, Liriano too soon and not received good or any value for those guys because they weren't seen as part of the future. I think this has hurt us way more than failing to get guys to the majors sooner. I don't think I've ever thought, "If ONLY we'd have gotten so and so up sooner, we could have traded Player X, or we would have won so many more games." Last time I thought that was Liriano as a rookie, and Johan not starting in the playoffs. In my opinion, Gibson and May could have probably used more seasoning prior to their call ups, but I don't blame the FO for bringing them up and getting them some action during lost seasons or in Gibson's case, to try to energize the team and fan base. Similarly, I can't say that those who think the struggles will help our young guys are categorically wrong. But if you use the excuse that it's better to let guys struggle in the majors, then calling up a young player will ALWAYS be the right move whether they are met with success or failure.
-
Hicks cut
Developing prospects isn't a science. Not every move is going to pay off, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try. If Meyer is never an ace, he was at least, at one time, a potential ace. Aces are pretty rare, getting even a potential ace for a player like Span was a pretty decent deal. I suspect both Meyer and May will be up soon enough. I want to see them play and play well, but don't blame Terry Ryan for the fact that Meyer still doesn't have a repeatable delivery and May choked in his big audition. Meyer and May just have to pitch better. They were given their chances, even last year. That's on them.
-
Hicks cut
http://www.startribune.com/sports/twins/209752351.html Sounds like Terry Ryan, who actually watched Gibson pitch and develop pretty much called his early struggles.
-
Hicks cut
A strong contingent of scouts that actually watched Gibson pitch in the minor leagues said that he wasn't ready to pitch in the bigs. I think the term TR used was "when we call him up, we want him up for good." Gibson was close to abysmal his first year. He worked on some things, he got better. Posters said that May had nothing to prove in AAA. He didn't look Major League ready to me. I'm not sure struggling through 2-4 inning outings makes a pitcher better than pitching your full pitch count against line ups that allow you to work on weaknesses and not just having to rely on your strengths just to get through the line up one time. It certainly seemed that when Gibson and May were called up, it was because of fan pressure and not sound evaluation. The Twins have shown the willingness to fast track guys who can actually perform at the big league level. All I'm saying is that I think there is a strong argument that players develop better in a farm system with lots of individual coaching than trying to learn on the Major League level with pressure and expectation. Certainly there are arguments the other way as well.
-
Hicks cut
I would think there'd be a strong argument that we actually brought Gibson and May up too soon, not too late.
-
Pelfry open to trade
In reality, he wasn't really lights out when he was healthy half a decade ago.
-
Hicks cut
If we're looking long term, why are we so concerned about May getting some extra work in before his absolutely inevitable call up in a month or two?
-
Reusse on Arcia
Arcia is my favorite player on the team. He has the potential to be an All-Star. I think he actually has the athleticism to be an adequate defensive outfielder. He is a fiery, passionate player. He plays extremely hard and seems to want to win and get his teammates fired up. Perhaps his struggles at the plate is that he tries TOO hard. He gets antsy in big spots (his 3-0 count record is infamous). But if our biggest criticism is that he plays too hard, tries too hard, and swings too hard, I can live with that. He'll calm himself and his swing down as he gains more experience. Reminds me a bit of Carlos Gomez as far as his mental approach to the game. He has an enthusiasm for the game that seems to be contagious. He just needs to harness it all in. It took Go-Go years to do. Arcia can be a better hitter than Gomez.
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
I guess we just disagree on how important it is to get the Tonkin's of the world major league innings over keeping roster guys like Stauffer and maybe Pelfrey. I'm not sure one is better than the other. Given the fact that I don't have a ton of confidence in one over the other, I'd go with the option that still allows me to change over and go with option B if option A fails. The other options couldn't beat out Caleb Thielbar or Lester Oliveras for a call-up last year. So I lean a little more toward option A. If we get to June and our rotation is Hughes, Santana, Nolasco, Gibson, and May and our pen features Graham, Stauffer, Milone, Pelfrey and Alex Meyer and we've fielded calls or traded Duensing will you be mad?
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
Also, if Tonkin had looked remotely reliable in his several opportunities with the big league club, we probably don't even sign Stauffer who, by the way, wouldn't have be the first low-risk bull pen guy to come in on a one-year deal and earn an extension if that should happen. If he's awful, trade him, release him, send him back to the NL and give someone else a shot. It's harder for me to justify a spot for Pelfrey other than that he's apparently healthy, and he's been successful during spring training, but I understand people wanting to give him a limited shot before eating his salary, and dumping him for nothing in order to promote___________ . To be honest, I'm far more worried about Perkins closing out games than I am about the net difference between losing Pelfrey and blocking Tonkin.
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
We pay scouts and managers to tell us when guys are ready and if they believe their minor league success will translate to big league success. I agree, there are points when you need to see what you've got, but as of now, we're tied for first place. If this season is another Jesse Crain-wreck, we'll have plenty of time to see prospect, fringe prospect, and AAAA all-stars alike. In recent memory, Fien and before him Burton were a couple of guys who made Twins games worth watching past the 5th inning. I'm not saying that Achter or Tonkin, etc. will never be pieces. I'm saying that I'm not going to dump a roster guy like Stauffer to make sure they get big league innings just because one of them might be the next Tony Swarzak.
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
We pay scouts and managers to tell us when guys are ready and if they believe their minor league success will translate to big league success. I agree, there are points when you need to see what you've got, but as of now, we're tied for first place. If this season is another Jesse Crain-wreck, we'll have plenty of time to see prospect, fringe prospect, and AAAA all-stars alike. In recent memory, Fien and before him Burton were a couple of guys who made Twins games worth watching past the 5th inning. I'm not saying that Achter or Tonkin, etc. will never be pieces. I'm saying that I'm not going to dump a roster guy like Stauffer to make sure they get big league innings just because one of them might be the next Tony Swarzak.
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
Maybe I should have put "prospects" in quotes, as the names I'm seeing thrown around as potential bull pen arms, other than Reed and Burdi, are maybe not so prospecty. These guys almost always fail in the big leagues, but are occasionally used to fill in trade gaps. But it's easier to a sell a not so prospecty guy as a prospect if you can tell your trade partner that "He'd be good in the Bigs, but we don't have room", as opposed to "We've proven conclusively that he has no big league future, because we tried him."
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
Still disagree. I think the worse worst thing that can happen is that we formulate roster decisions that impact the future/present roster based on whoever gets hot during spring training. Look at the guys hitting during the 6th through 9th innings when most of these relievers are getting action and tell me that you would feel comfortable projecting season-long success based on those results. We have been down this road before. "We don't need Span or Revere or Alex Pressley because Hicks is having a great spring!" I remember when people were saying that Slama was going to be a future set-up man. Imagine if we would have rolled with him instead of signing say Casey Fien. When we signed Neshek and Breslow, it turned few heads, and even fewer when they walked. Maybe we paid a bit for giving up on them too early and assuming we had better options on the farm. Can we please play one regular season game before we turn this season into yet another rolling audition of failed prospects eliminating whatever trade value they might have and start giving away rostered players for nothing?
-
Article: Bullpen Calculus
I think it's a bit early to give up on Stauffer. He's a somewhat proven commodity, he actually has a bit of upside, and oh yeah, we haven't played a single game yet. I'm guessing we'll have to use a number of guys this year as arms become tired, go through slumps, get hot, etc. Having guys in AAA with options isn't a bad thing.
-
Article: Fixing The Twins, Part III: Attitude
To be honest, I thought we maybe performed over our heads last year. I think that easily could have been a 100 loss season without guys like Santana, Arcia, and Vargas giving our whole team a spark and carrying us for several weeks. Obviously Dozier had a career year, as did Hughes. Some of these guys are due to regress big time. However, I think E. Santana, and Gibson are as competitive as they come, and I could see those 2 carrying the staff this year. Perk and Fien have some fire in the pen, and I think Pelfrey could has that in him if he could only get some guys out... We had a few guys playing hard for spots and for pride last year. We had a few playing to collect checks. I'm looking forward to a year where hopefully, finally, the guys playing hard will be our most prominent players. Those few weeks where Arcia carried the team last year and raised everyone else's play made more excited about the future of the team than almost anything I'd seen the previous 5 seasons. Of course, he promptly broke his ankle when our "leader" Plouffe whiffed on a bunt and left Arcia in a pickle... Vargas and Sano can't stand losing batting practice. Santana runs hard every ball. It seems like the culture is changing. Gardenhire seemed to recognize that. Moli's inherited some decent young players. Hopefully he feeds that fire rather than squelching it. If we can win a few games, the vets will reengage. Crucial season, imo. Could go either way.