Everything posted by Jham
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
Well 2 years $12 mil is mind boggling, What do you think he ends up getting open market? Last year David Freese got 1 year for $3 million. Juan Uribe got 1 year $4 million. Apparently there was no trade value anywhere either. Freese has OPS .811 this season, btw. Freese has a better track record, was better this season, and is only 3 years older than Plouffe. Look at last year's FA market, look at the trade market for 3B, look at next year's FA crop at 3rd. Exactly how much do you think Plouffe is realistically expected to make?
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Obviously, it HAS to be the organization. Otherwise these publications, prospect lists, and experts would be wrong in their player evaluations and projections which is a virtual impossibility as we all know.
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
Are there automatic raises for service years in arbitration? Twins agreed to 7 mil last year right? Presumably we offered something significantly less. I'm less than sure that he sees his FA year as a big pay day. The season he's had, doesn't give him a lot of leverage in front of a arbitrator if the Twins go low on him... so maybe that's an important question. What is plouffe's value in arb and on the open market. Perhaps i assumed his value is lower than it is.
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
I guess I don't see Plouffe as overly expensive. I would not go a $1 over $12 mil for 2 years. So money aside, perhaps a big aside, Plouffe offers much more defensive value and probably as much offensive value. I mean, we'll have places to save money. We're only going to keep 1 or none of Santiago and Milone. Would I rather have Plouffe than either of them.... Hard to say. Milone and Plouffe or Santiago? Right now I'd say Santiago... maybe... I guess I'm envious of your confidence.
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
You're exaggerating a bit. But you're right. He may not be missed. To me, it's a tough call. I would let Dozier be the catalyst. If you can move him for pitching, do it. If not, non-tender Plouffe unless he gives himself his service. I've said, I can't see keeping both. Plouffe is the easier and more obvious move. But I'd explore alternatives in order to improve the staff or even the farm system. But we may already have Dozier with no luck. Non-tendering Plouffe is certainly the more likely outcome, and would not be a move I'd disagree with. Dozier is a fine player too, after all.
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
For the record, I'm fine with your route, I'm just skeptical about turning cost savings on one player into a better player on the other end, especially with year's FA class of pitchers. And I really like Vargas AND Park, but I just think if Plouffe doesn't fit the team, they fit the team even less...Hopefully Sano's about to prove he can stick at 3rd and it won't matter much what we do for DH.
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
Short answer... maybe... if I think he can provide insurance and OPS greater than 100 for a couple years, like he has the last couple years while healthy...
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
- Game Thread: Astros @ Twins, 8/9 @ 7:10 CT
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
So aren't you saying give away Plouffe for nothing so that we can play Sano there all day every day? Plouffe improved pretty dramatically the last couple seasons. We invested a ton in the kid to get him to this point. I think we mainly disagree as to how he easily he could be replaced by any of the guys you mentioned. To me, Sano and Plouffe aren't mutually exclusive. To me, it makes sense to have both since ABW3, Varg, Park, Mauer, and Palka are all incapable of playing 3rd. I could envision a scenario next season or the season after in which we could use Plouffe and wish we had him for cheap after watching him hit 30 bombs a year in Yankee stadium or Fenway. Why force him out when you don't have to? Especially when we have players that are more movable and are even more easily replaceable. Dozier can bring back a legit pitcher. Vargas et al may or may not have more trade value than Plouffe, but offer no defensive value to our team. If Polanco is only as good as Plouffe, and could bring a return, we should at least consider trading him for a haul and keeping Plouffe for cheap. The Plouffe money invested in FA pitching will get us Pelfrey back. If you're asking whether I'd rather have Plouffe or Pelfrey...
-
What if Sano's 3B defense doesn't improve
So if I'm reading many of these posts right, we're supposed to let Plouffe go for nothing just so that the Twins aren't tempted to play Plouffe at 3rd every time Sano screws up. If this is the case, we shouldn't move Plouffe, we should move the management that can handle developing a young player. If Plouffe is let go for nothing, his spot in the lineup will almost certainly be replaced by a worse hitter. Why sacrifice a decent hitter (and capable fielder) to plug someone in who is a worse hitter (with worse defensive ability)? This is even assuming Sano can actually play 3rd. Unless we really believe Park/Palka/ABW3/Vargas are BETTER hitters by a wide enough margin to make up for the lack of defensive value, then I have to say, letting Plouffe walk for nothing makes no sense to me. Plouffe will not cost an arm and a leg, we can even go 1 year with him if we want. Letting him walk just so Sano feels more comfortable seems like a fairly delusional way to support the notion that Sano can still be a good/great/average/adequate option at 5.
-
Article: Painted Into A Corner (Infield Crunch)
Sano or Kepler for the right ace might make sense, but unlikely to happen. Getting rid of Plouffe to get Sano in makes sense. Getting rid of Plouffe just to keep say Vargas or Palka makes no sense. I'd rather spend the little bit extra for the better player and insurance in case Sano can't field.
- Article: Painted Into A Corner (Infield Crunch)
-
Why has Polanco seen no time at Short?
It's not like esco doesn't have limited range. Polanco was my pick for short last season, but Esco deserved to keep his spot. Polanco has a very quick release and barely enough am strength. I think between him and esco, we're ok at short.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
I think Polanco's extreme arm angle makes his arm strength look weaker than it is. I'd like to see him keep that elbow a little higher, but other than plays in the hole, his quick release likely makes up for arm strength on most plays.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
I was thinking grizzly bear slips on a banana peel and slides down the mountain head first... then gets picked off 2nd.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
Come on TD! I need some analogies for what we just saw! Never mind.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
I dunno... are you still considered on the roster if your bag is packed and waiting for you on the stairs of the dugout?
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
I remember Gardy saying Delmon wasn't that bad a fielder, that he just looked awkward. He was half right!
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
Santana cementing his position as 25.5th man...