Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Jham

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Jham

  1. Is Pat Light developing a knuckle ball or something? Or does he not qualify because his 98 was actually 93.
  2. I think you may have blended my posts with others. I've never suggested we sign a single free agent. I've suggested we hold on to Ervin Santana rather than trade him for a lesser return. I've suggested we low-ball Plouffe if it means we can put Sano in a better position (literally) to succeed. I've suggested trading Dozier for a top young arm. BUT I also suggested that we probably tried that at the deadline and didn't find interest. I said the same thing you said. Trades are about value, and if the rest of the league doesn't see Dozier as worthy of losing an ace or potential ace, we're getting great production at a great price. We're not like the Yankees where we can just unload a couple expensive relievers and instantly rebuild the farm system. We have to be creative. If the pitching isn't available for Dozier, how else can we acquire it? I don't see us signing a World Series caliber staff in the 2018 off season. Even if we're building to 2019, we're probably going to have to start adding arms now. As Chief has said, there's no guarantee the market is any good when we're buyers, and we might not have a chip like Sano or Buxton or Kepler or Dozier to deal at that point. You hit the nail on the head. Our biggest philosophical difference is patience with prospects which for the record, is the opposite of a nuanced approach. I'm all for being patient with prospects when warranted, but then you shouldn't be relying on them or building around them. Work them in, surround them with talent so that the team's success and failure isn't hinged on them. We were super patient with Alexi Casilla, Pedro Florimon, and Danny Santana. A lot of good that did us. You have to be patient with the right prospect. How do you know if you're being patient with a late bloomer or wasting years chasing a 4-year-old prospect ranking? Short answer, you don't. So either acquire more talent and rely on those prospects less, or try to acquire truly elite prospects who require less patience.
  3. I mean, I think we basically agree. It sounds like we're both looking at a wait and see type of year. It's a matter of whether we try to get creative to find capable arms and hope the kids are as good as projected, or do we wait to make those additions after they prove worthy of receiving conditions. Your previous posts made it sound like you thought we should bank on this core being outstanding three years from now, and that adding youth should trump adding talent. I don't mind your conservative approach to adding talent. But sometimes I think you're too liberal with your projections for prospect development. I take a measured approach to prospect development, and liberal approach to adding talent. I think consistently looking for upgrades is a better way to achieve steady success than trying to peak, make a push, then rebuild. Both routes have had success. Both have failed. Personal preference. So from that regard, I can't say you're wrong "per se" so I'll take back the insanity comment, but nor do I think that I've in anyway softened my stance.
  4. So that's the definition of cherry picking. I said IF they're good enough to win in 2019, they're good enough now. I'm willing to see another card. You're saying the team is historic garbage, but you want to build around that garbage for two or three more seasons? Insanity. Either they're garbage and we should fire sale while our core still has value OR we can see if this young squad can make a large jump as young clubs often do. You're calling Sano, Buxton, Kepler, Berrios, Rosario, Vargas, Chargois, et al 8 2 offsuit. I'm not the biggest believer in this core, but I think they're a lot better than that. Again, if we're that stinkin awful, how on earth can you justify building around this squad for 3 more years? Make some calculated moves, see if we can improve, and if we can't, I'd rather know that next year than 3 years from now.
  5. It's ok to sign some stop gaps and try to win a few games before your magical 2019 run where all the prospects somehow peak at the same time. I'll agree that it's unwise to put all of our eggs in the 2017 basket. I would argue that it's more unwise to put all of our eggs in the 2019 basket. If we get to 2019 and Sano and Buxton are winning MVP's and have some sort of fun nickname, and the pitchers look like they're top 10 rotation, maybe shove all in. (Again, if they're MVP's then, they should be pretty darn good now). I'd say right now we have Q J of hearts, a really nice starting hand. But the flop came out A A 10 and now we got a crappy hand. Chief is suggesting a small bet at the board hoping we can either steal the pot or hit a King on the turn, and probably doing the same thing on the river. This way, we reserve some chips so that we can push all in if we hit that King of hearts. If things don't work, out, it's not that hard to fold. It seems like you're suggesting we fold, then fold again, until we're dealt a pair. Then just shove all in, then just watch the flop, turn, and river while having all your chips already in the middle hoping you have a pair of Kings and not a pair of fours. Personally, I'm not confident enough in our starting hand to push all in and watch the board play out through 2019. I'm suggesting we try to win now. I surround this team with some talent and give them 1 year to show they're worth continuing to build around. Then I don't need to take such a large leap the next two years. And if they can't show they're ready to compete, I fold. I try to figure out which of our "stars" still have the most trade value and I try another hand. Good players peak early and sustain success. If this core is good enough in 2019, they're good enough now. And they'll need battle testing. If not, better we find that sooner than later and move on before they Plouffe or Delmon out on us.
  6. First off, if we trade Dozier for a pitcher slightly worse than divan but maybe better than Santiago,i may quit following the team. If we trade him for a pucker better than Santana, then we're not really just sitting are we?
  7. I agree 100%. That is the question I was raising. If Dozier can't bring back a franchise changing pitching package, what are our options? Here's how I see them: 1. Take the best package we can get even if it's not a perfect exchange of value. 2. Accept a package that includes riskier prospects that are further away (not likely to help in the next 2 years) 3. Stand pat and hope the market for pitching and trading improves by next season. 4. Try to acquire pitching through trades of prospects or current players more coveted than Dozier. I think we cheer for Cubs and hope the Dodgers end up a right handed bat short of the Series. But I don't want to give away Dozier the way we gave away Span (even though that was probably a necessary risk). If we trade Dozier, I'd prefer there not be much risk involved.
  8. I wouldn't be surprised if Dozier was shopped at the deadline without much interest. He's cheap, he's really really good, and he's worthy of a trade package involving an MLB ready blue chip pitching prospect. If that's not being offered, then what's the point in trading him. Keep in mind, the idea is that we're trying to make our team better not just younger. Also, Buxton, Sano, Kepler, Rosario and Berrios are already up. Arcia is gone, DanSan is practically gone. Gibson is a non-tender candidate. Exactly what stage of the rebuild are we in? Are we at the end of a failed rebuild, the beginning of a new rebuild, or the middle of a new new rebuild? I mean, if Buxton, Sano, Kepler, Berrios et al are our core, exactly how many seasons do we expect to be able to keep them all? Are we willing to waste half of them chasing some future alignment of planets? Try to win with these kids once or twice, then rebuild. And if this isn't a good enough core anyway, Sano would bring back better pitching than Dozier.
  9. Also, the problem with waiting for your team to all develop at the same time, say 2019 is that those magical teams only happen every 20 years or so in baseball. Smart and continuous acquisition of talent is a far faster and more sustainable model. If you try to bring up a core and 3 of your 7 big prospects turn out to be really good, and the other 4 are decent role guys (probably best case scenario) you still might not be good enough to win. Then you wasted 3 years developing players, probably trading the 4 average players you have for nothing since by that time they're blocking your next wave, likely trading the few good players you have since your rebuild is now put out another 3-5 years. That model can work BUT you have to be absolutely sure that your core is going to be successful. What have we seen in the last year that leads you to believe the current young core is good enough to warrant punting 2 more seasons in order to let them develop? Conversely, if our kids are so good that they warrant that level of patience, how are they not talented enough to compete now? Good enough to give up on 2 seasons to develop, but not talented enough to compete now... That's a very small window. My thought is that if they're not good enough to compete entering their primes, they won't be able to compete when they hit their primes. If the talent's there, supplement it and try to win. If not, and that's a hard truth to consider, our young guys are our most trade-able assets. If you don't know, and I'm going to suggest that none of us know, then simply trying to acquire as much talent as you can for as much value as you can probably covers both bases better than guessing.
  10. Well is the inverse true then? You'd trade maybe any pitcher for a good up-the-middle-prospect? If not, we just need to find a GM that thinks like you. Offer Gordon, receive Bob Gibson. I think all trades are about value. No absolutes.
  11. We're in kind of an awful spot regarding 3rd base. Sano probably can't play there. Escobar's bat probably doesn't play there, and Polanco seems to be the new shortstop. But it's tough justify spending more on Plouffe. I'd still consider doing a 2 year $12 or $13mil extension. But I'm leaning toward starting Sano and rolling with Esco if Sano can't stick or gets hurt. Mauer's lack of position flexibility is killing us. Just seems like we're putting a dangerous amount of stock in a 25 HR .230 hitter with questionable defensive value. Escobar is a solid role player who can hit a bit, but doesn't run well. If we retained Plouffe, I'd let Esco go, if not, I'd try to extend Escobar who we'll certainly find use for in one way or another over the next few seasons. Gibson gets a tender. So Santiago was pretty good when he did his own thing, picking and walking. He got lit up while trying to limit his walks. You wonder if Milone would have had a similar improvement if they didn't insist on him throwing his hittable pitches down the middle. I'd non-tender both Santiago and Milone at this point. Kintzler has closing experience and was pretty effective when not overused. I'd tender. Ditto Pressley. I've sort of seen enough of Tonkin. O'Rourke was great against lefties again. Tender.
  12. Ok, he could just be relaying information from his sources. Might not be anything "personal" about it. You called the guy an "a-hole" and a "random column writer"... Why does Ruesse deserve ripping for doing his job, while Sano should be shielded from criticism for not doing his job... Seems backwards. Again, I think we just see the article very differently. I don't see it is anything other than relaying doubts about the kid's work ethic. Evidently you see it as an attempt to tear the kid down. Sano gets all the accolades for the team's successes, taking blame for its failures is part of being a leader. It appears he's going to start doing that. Good news for all involved.
  13. I mean, Ruesse is a sportswriter, so perhaps it kind of is his job... such that perhaps he should be somewhat shielded from personal attacks for publishing sourced information that his readers probably want to know.... Irony aside, I'll continue to maintain that Ruesse's article was not a personal attack, at least not to me. It's cool if you read it another way. We clearly see personal attacks for work-related tasks very very differently...
  14. These aren't personal attacks. No one's called him a liar, a jerk, or an idiot. Nothing being said is an attack or even an insult with the exception of the word "diva" which may or may not be warranted. IF Sano doesn't like the criticism, he can always prove his doubters wrong by performing on the field, or working harder off the field. Attacks are like saying Collin Kapernick is faking his donation of a $1 million to charity because he doesn't like the troops. Or saying John Rocker is a moron for calling out ethnic minorities on NYC subway cars. Or saying Torii Hunter is an A-hole bigot and homophobe for supporting his church's stance (basically all catholic's) on gay marriage. These criticisms are different because they don't effect performance. Weight, focus, and practice habits DO effect performance. See the difference?
  15. I can't believe how badly we mis-cast Randy Johnson. He should have been pitching. I suppose, as the Alex Meyer threads all point out, he was a late bloomer, so maybe we shouldn't really be too harsh.
  16. Wait, wait, wait.... First, is "criticizing" the same thing as "attacking?" Second, Sano has been a professional baseball player, voluntarily I believe, for seven years. Third, his chosen profession involves a great deal of scrutiny both on and off the field. I'd say he's compensated fairly even if the criticism is unwarranted. I'd be somewhat more inclined to agree with you if we were discussing a college kid who was representing his University for free-ish. (somewhat more inclined). But aside from the fact that I would not consider criticizing work habits and maturity a particularly scathing indictment, I actually think criticizing a young man's character is MUCH fairer than criticizing their performance since character is something one can control, while overall talent is not. If you said criticism of a guy like Nick Punto was unfair because he maxed out all his tools and was only average, I'd say, sure, that does seem rash. But the guy who leaves winter ball early, goes to the DR with friends when he could have been working in Florida, and comes in heavy and ill-prepared to play right OR 3rd OR hit the way he's capable of is off limits? Nah, if you ask me, he's been coddled too much... I mean, his failure in right didn't lose TR his job, but Ryan was criticized for it. You act like Ruesse and others want Sano to fail. We all want to see him put in the work and be the player we all think he can be!
  17. Minnesota-nice way of getting himselft out of managing the team next year without having to quit.
  18. I'ma pick righhht now. Grossman with 2 bad errors on 1 play to put the Twins down 8-0. Now if that doesn't sum up the season...
  19. My only take from these discussions is that the debates highlight the need for obtaining more pitching. Kohl Stewart appears to be a slightly worse Kyle Gibson. Jay has some upside. Gonsalves looks like a spitting image of Andrew Miller. The remaining possibilities including May are likely rotational filler. Improvement of this year seems unlikely, save Berrios, but that would probably be offset by a return to norm for Erv. Duffey and May both learned on the job. Hadn't really helped either of them. I think it can make guys gun shy, and fail to refine auxillary pitches.
  20. http://www.startribune.com/twins-kennys-vargas-puts-it-this-way-i-need-to-hit-home-runs/394220591/# “I’m sure he’d like to be more consistent in terms of elevating the ball and getting it over the fence, but it can be a double-edged sword,” Molitor said. “You [can] start to develop an undercut and have trouble catching the higher velocity and you pop up more than you hit home runs. There’s a lot of times when a line drive works better than elevating the ball.” Seriously Molly? GTFO.
  21. And Zuke's throwing! And the Twins' recent issues with relievers holding runners...
  22. I don't necessarily disagree. I think the biggest situational difference there is that an out ends the game. In almost every other situation, I suspect the right play is to limit advancement. Rosario sometimes makes selfish throws. Maybe he was actively taking a chance to win the game, or maybe he was just letting fly. I just didn't think it sent the right message as it would dissuade every attempt at the out in that situation. To me, it's similar to defensive indifference. If a team is down 2 with 1 on and 2 out, why give the free base of you've got a catcher who can throw? If the run really doesn't matter, take the shot at the out to end the game. Who cares? I don't even care if 1b is playing off. Like you said, make them earn it. I think not conceding a run and taking affable of over-aggressive baserunning is making them earn it. Imo.
  23. Yeah, there are limitations. The results are the average for the exact situation as documented since like 1955 or something according to the projector I used. The sample size should take a lot of the variance out of the equation, so it should be a true average. However, even though it is a projection, it only takes into account the things that have already happened. There is absolutely no taking into account the players involved. So whether it's Tommy Milone facing Mike Trout or Andrew Miller facing Logan Schaefer, the odds of winning are the same. At least that's my understanding. Perhaps there's some projectors that aren't simply historically based... We're finding new ways to measure variables all the time. So... I think the Twins should be the first to hire a computer for a manager. I'd pay to see the motivational speeches.
  24. Managers do have an impact. I won't get into the "Rosario throw home benching" scenario again, but basically, throwing home was a freebee in that situation, while playing it "the right way" would basically just give the opponent extra chances to beat you. The difference was +- 2-5%. These percentages accumulate. Let's say a manager has a similar situation once every 10 games. Let's say one manager bunts only when the odds encourage it, and the other bunts against the odds (Molitor). If a good manager makes 1 call that increases his team's odds of winning by 2.5% every 20 games, while another manager makes the wrong moves and hurts his team by 2.5% every 20 games, that's a 5% difference between the best and worst. That's a win difference a month. By the end of the year, that's a 7.5 game difference. That's a team going to the playoffs vs a team struggling to .500. I wonder if the the % gap between the best and worst might be even greater than 5%. If no one already does this, I think win projectors could be used to evaluate each move made by a manager. This would show which managers are consistently giving their teams the best chance. Additionally, you could view wins vs. win expectancy to see how often the manager's hunch or use of information not factored into win projection (playing against the odds) worked out. mWAR maybe? Do they already have mWAR?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.