Everything posted by Jham
-
Bovada places Twins over-under at 74 1/2 wins...
Usually when a line looks inviting, Vegas knows something. 74 seems to invite a bet on the under. Logically, they know something. Someone must be taking the over. And the overs must be betting more than the unders, since there seems to be so many more unders.... Which scares me from the under... Cuz what do the over-betters know that make them quieter and more confident? That said, I don't think Buxton is fixed. He still strikes out like crazy. I don't think Sano is fixed and I doubt he fields well. If Kepler has a sophomore slump... I mean, he ended the season on pedestrian run. I don't know where the pitching will come from. And I don't think Molitor was ever the right guy for the job. Feels like the first year of Epstein in Chicago when they just attempted to evaluate talent and get rid of everyone. UNDER.
-
Game Thread: Twins vs. Marlins ST G4 2/27/17 12:00 PM CT
It's like they're saying to big erv, "let's see how good toy really are..."
-
Reusse makes case for Danny Santana at shortstop
He was a top 10 organizational prospect. A dropoff may have been blatant. Lots of his skill set was not. Imo, he changed his approach to put the ball on the ground and strike out less. Not a horrible idea for a guy with a high babip. But it totally cut off his aggression and his ability to drive the ball. He k'd more instead of less. Molitor already suggested he told Buxton to put the ball on the ground and let the ball get deeper. I believe a similar discussion occurred with dansan. My support, if you can even call it that, is based on his original scouting, his relative youth, and change in approach which i believe stunned hid growth.
-
Reusse makes case for Danny Santana at shortstop
Mod's notes aside, I don't take offense to your post. I called a progression a longshot, you called impossible. Shrug. To me, regression didn't explain the total loss of power. And that's a skill he had flashed from time to time in the minors. By some measures he has been the worst player in baseball the past two seasons. He's also played well in some stretches. Most players who put up numbers like Santana don't play. Which is I think why fans are so exasperated. Most players putting up his numbers don't have his tools or flashed glimpses the way Dan San has shown as recently as last season. It is not at all unusual for young players to take their offensive struggles into the field. It's a lot of pressure to perform. Granted, handling that pressure is his job. The only reason I say he was jerked around is because the position switches and I believe an instruction to change his hitting approach. Molitor already admitted he screwed up Buxton initially. It wasn't til Buxton ignored his coach that he won his respect. That's healthy... Anyway, I would not be surprised if Santana improves with better instruction or a new organization and has a nice career. He's still only 26.
-
Reusse makes case for Danny Santana at shortstop
People need to stop being so closed-minded. Is it a long shot at this point? Sure. But it's far from impossible that Santana could turn it around and have a good career. Jason Bartlett debuted at 25 and had some up and down action before becoming solid enough in the field and at the plate. Guys cry about May and Sano being "jerked around" but are quick to pile on Dan San. No one was jerked around more than Santana. Everyone was so excited to proclaim that they called his regression based on his BABIP. Everyone was so happy to be right. Don't even try to argue that there weren't a fair amount of posters who were smugly satisfied if not downright happy to see him fail. He hit 7 HR in 430 PA his rookie year. He hit 2 in the next 2 years. He hit 27 doubles in 2014. 20 the next 2 years. That's not BABIP. BABIP regresses to the mean. 7HR to 0 and 2. That's not luck. That's an utter loss of ability to drive the ball. Did the league adjust, or did the organization try to turn him into a slap hitter? I think it's the latter. Unfortunately, I think the guy who told him to slap the ball and run is still the manager. I think that may be why he has an odd willingness to stick with Santana. Guilt or stubborness. Regardless, I don't see Santana as less talented than Bartlett in the field or at the plate. And I would not be shocked if a more aggressive swing and approach at the plate could lead to more success, less pressure, and better defensive play as well. At least, I don't think anyone should be ridiculed for believing that player and tools that splashed in 2014 might still be there.
-
Wetmore: Mauer on playing part-time
It's like Mauer is getting career advice from Adrian Peterson... Wake up, Joe. I actually would make him my everyday DH and see if that can prolong his vintage Aprils late into the season. I personally think Vargas plays a surprisingly good 1B. Not Mauer, but it's 1B and if we can get a better Mauer at the plate it's worth it. Mauer is not an everyday first baseman anymore.... For the last 3 years. FTFM.
-
Berardino: Sano working to take on 3B
Shouldn't be at 23. Peak metabolism. Plus he's a pro athlete. Has trainers dieticians and games in sleeves and 100 degree heat. He should shed excess weight during the season. The fact that he gained weight during the season may be as troubling as anything. That said, he's a kid. He quit drinking. This all speaks to rededication. Hopefully there will be more concentration in the field, in the batters box, and of the field. In other words, more maturity.
-
Berardino: Vargas took hitting lessons from Manny
Could you explain? I mean upper cut swings are naturally longer, and lots of players will naturally shorten up against power arms. I'd agree that the Twins way of bunching hits is a tough way too win against great pitchers that don't leave many balls up. 1-0 looks better than 0-0 with a runner on first. Personally, i thought Vargas came back with a noticeably shorter more powerful swing. I'd like to see him keep that. He doesn't have the hand eye coordination that Manny and papi had. They could get away with a loop (mostly). Vargas isn't that talented.
-
Trevor May Over Jose Berrios In Rotation?
I think we have to start May over Berrios. He's been more successful, and apparently can't handle relieving. I am however, very skeptical that he'll be able to hold up to a starting campaign after breaking down as a reliever. Hopefully the regular rest will benefit him, but I can't imagine that he'll be able to keep himself from overthrowing when he gets in a jam the same way he did out of the pen.
- Article: TD Top Prospects: #8 Kohl Stewart
-
Ron Gardenhire Diagnosed With Prostate Cancer
Best of luck Gardy! We're all pulling for you!
- Article: What To Make Of Kennys Vargas
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
That's a little simplistic isn't it? Choice A - Shuffle, may, at least occasionally be better than Choice B- fix backlog. How bad is the backlog? How incompetent are the shufflers? There's a lot of variation in there. I mean, Plouffe could play 3rd. If Sano can't play third, did we have anyone to plug in who could play right as well as Plouffe played right and hit as well also? I mean, if we shuffled Sano to first and Mauer to DH in hopes of keeping Mauer fresher, would that be so terrible? Are Vargas and Park so good that it warrants having poor defense at third or rf? Not likely, in my mind...
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
I think we've hit the nail on the head here. Everybody's arguing different points. 1) Can Sano Play 3rd? 2) Can Sano Play Right? 3) If he can't play right, is it because of effort? 4) If he can't play either, where do we put him? 5) What's best for Sano now? 6) What's best for Sano in the long term? 7) What's best for the team? 8) Is 3B more important than right (where does he do less damage)? It seems if you provide an answer to any of the above, your answer is assumed for the other questions as well. It's no wonder there's disagreement.
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
I get that, poor wording. I was actually just saying that it's hypocritical to say that thinking Sano could play right was naiive and presumptuous while in your next stanza making a very presumptuous statement despite contrary evidence. "Quite possible" is a qualifier you took advantage of, but not a benefit you have afforded any other poster on the site. Who said Sano would even be good in right? A lot of people said he had the tools, or could be ok, or that it would help the team if... basically, that it's "quite possible" that a young athlete like Sano could adapt to a position with less risk and difficulty at this stage in his career. Aside from hind-sighting the result, you've hindsighted out all qualifiers made by other posters to win some sort of "I was right" ego contest. I appreciate your position and belief in Sano, but some of your rhetoric is a little over-the-top, no offense.
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
He's young and he received criticism and some negative feedback for probably the first time in his career. He may have resented this at first, but he's a kid who not only missed out on the college years, but also his high school years. That's the cost of being a sports prodigy. Now he has money and last year had a free off-season. Distractions were imminent. If he adjusts and dedicates himself in the way he did to get here in the first place, he should be just fine with a chance at being really great. He's got the personality to be a leader as well, which this team sorely needs.
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
You can't call your theory "quite possible" and then say it's presumptuous and naiive to think otherwise... He hit worse once moved to third... He also played 3rd at an abysmal level even at the end of the season. Which I and many others predicted, and so we were right... too... This isn't a contest, and that's not a good thing. Maybe he'll improve and be league avg. at third and hit top-spinners over fences to all fields, and I will gladly say NYTwinsfan was right and I am happy to be wrong... Right now his swing plane generates top spin to his power field, which means he'll hit fewer HR and have more lasers caught by left fielders than necessary. That's his biggest issue, in my opinion. I don't see him having a defensive position other than first base. If he's not a better fielder than Mauer, he definitely shouldn't be playing third. If he is better, then he should be at first, and Mauer should DH and stay fresh.
-
The State of Miguel Sano: Looking Good!
Oh playing right field for less than a half of a season set him waaay back... That's why his 3B was awful, pop ups hit him in the head or not at all, and uppercut every swing? I was in favor of him being in right, because there are fewer chances for him to screw up there than at 3rd (although mistakes tend to be more costly). But a healthy Plouffe compared to... 1 of the Schaefer's in the line up? I mean it's debatable, but hardly criminal. I'm interested in seeing Sano develop 1 thing: backspin. He can't be an elite power hitter with his hardest hit balls diving like a forkball. If he can do that he'll hit 50 and it won't matter much where we play him! Hope you're right about him being able to play 3rd though.
-
Article: Falvey's First Stand
Yeah, I'm not saying it's not possible. I just really think that would be poor negotiation on their part if they actually wanted Dozier. If a lawyer negotiates a settlement, not showing all your cards can make sense because you can always use litigation to force or leverage opponents. In this case, there is no forcing, so not giving your best offer and saying straight up, "this is my best offer, take it or leave it," makes no sense. If it would embolden the Twins to ask for a 3rd prospect, the end result is the exact same: no Dozier. To not take your best shot at your number 1 guy because you were afraid how team C would view the offer, if they ever even heard and confirmed what that offer was, then you shouldn't get in the trade game at all. Even if the trade were strictly viewed from a prospect ranking perspective, our scouts and FO may have had different grades. I mean, the last thing we want is a DSpan - Meyer trade again, even though most of us would take that risk again even though it looks like the Nats knew exactly what they had. It did not seem that the Twins were nearly as high on De Leon as many of our posters and that they were already settling by making him the centerpiece. We've got a whole year to year and a half of prime trade time left. I doubt the return at the break or next off season will be so dramatically different that it would't fall within the highly variable margin of error for prospect projection to begin with. IMO.
-
Article: Falvey's First Stand
This would make the Dodgers front office horribly incompetent. If Dozier was their guy, and Forsythe was always an available second option, why would they withhold their best offer? That makes zero sense. And literally, that's the definition of low-balling which would imply the Twins did right to walk away, and the Dodgers got what they deserved. There is no possible advantage to withholding your best offer regardless of whether you think it will be fruitful or not.
-
Article: Forecasting Mauer's Remaining Years
To me, this all boils down to reduced bat speed with perhaps some lingering concussion issue. Mauer's approach has always been to let the ball get deep then use his exceptional hands and compact swing to make perfect contact. Seeing the ball longer allowed better pitch selectivity. As his bat speed has declined, he's had to start his swing earlier to catch up, and he's not able to be as selective. He's beaten by fastballs and off speed pitches. He's guessed more and more. There are a lot of good hitters who guess a lot, start their swings early, and strike out. Mauer has only barely adjusted his approach and swing. It may make sense for him to experiment with a leg kick and a power stroke since he has to start his swing earlier anyway. Might as well start it much earlier. But yeah, my prediction is continued decline.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Except right now, the Twins still have the Twins pitching staff...
-
Article: How The Twins Drafts Stack Up
I mean, they did what they set out to do back then. That's not luck. i was just pointing out the irony of the fact that they were unwittingly playing moneyball while they were (rightly) critical of the early metrics. The reason I said it was lucky, is because the team never changed its philosophy even as the metrics improved (in some cases vindicating the front office's initial skepticism). As the metrics improved, the guys that slipped through to the Twins started getting paid more and by better teams. The Twins then seemingly desperately tried to switch horses and go to power arms and bats with disastrous results. The idea of stocking up on huge major league ready bullpen arms was actually super-savvy and ended up being the model that won a WS for the Royals, almost won it for the Indians, and attempted by the Yankees. The problem is those big college arms weren't as big league ready as we thought. The evolution of metrics is fascinating to follow. The Twins seemingly beat the metrics by focusing on the areas where metrics initially missed (defense and ground balls), but there are fewer and fewer gaps between the stats now. As such, I wonder how relevant Moneyball is in today's game. The metrics are now commonly available to fans, let alone analytics staffs. Are there traits that are still currently undervalued in the market? Enough to make a difference in roster construction? The gap in analytics might be foreign markets where stats aren't available, and player development which still seems totally unpredictable. The Twins have been hit and miss in the first, and pretty poor in the latter.
-
Article: How The Twins Drafts Stack Up
I haven't seen many people say the Twins did a bad job drafting. I've seen some criticism of maximizing and developing talent, of holding on to and supplementing talent, and hitting on impact players. Hard to dispute a ton of that. Regarding the draft, the Twins were vocal with their organizational strategy of taking safe college arms and toolsy high school athletes early. Basically, they took safe (and cheaper) approaches than riskier high-upside arms or more expensive position players with more highly advanced skills. This strategy did not seem to change regardless of the available talent pool, or how drafting and scouting changed with analytics. The strategy worked better when analytics were limited. As teams pushed all in on Moneyball strategies that emphasized OBP and HR, the Twins continued to emphasize limiting walks and playing defense. The metrics scoffed at this approach and the Twins kept winning. The metrics caught up, and pitching and defense became coveted across the league. The Twins had actually taken advantage of a market weakness, the infancy of defensive and pitching metrics, by shear luck. Guys we used to be able to add and use are now pricing us out. Basically, like many of our prospects, we failed to develop. Let's also keep in mind, the available path to the League should be a lot easier on this team. We should have more picks making the show, at least for an audition. With that in mind, it's no wonder it seems we've got loads of fringe 40 man players being protected or cut with little relevance outside of TD forum fodder.
-
DaveW: Dodgers trade for Dozier to be completed within the next 24 hours
First post since this fall when work monitored my internet usage and blocked the forum section of the site. And I'm using it to let you know I plan on stealing your phrase and using it as often as possible from now on.