Everything posted by Dman
-
10 Breakout Twins Prospect Candidates: 1-5
Yeah I will admit I am biased when it comes to Sabato and it comes from watching him become an almost 2 outcome player as he walked or K'd in most of his at bats early in the season. It seemed like his bat had a hole in it as he massively struggled to make contact in general. He did start to pick up stream late in the second half and he was impressive at High A. Maybe unfairly but I discounted High A to some degree because of the small sample size and because with so many pitchers falling off late in the season his hit mistakes prone approach seemed likely to be more effective. Still the numbers are the numbers and he did well at high A. Jullian and his bloated BABIP probably wasn't a great comparison but they both started in A ball and Jullien had his own contact struggles but when I watched him he at least he was making contact. His K rate was pretty high as well I think higher than Sabato's but he was actually hitting the ball as well. Should all of those hits have fallen in probably not but it certainly gave those watching the impression he could make good contact bat to ball. So yeah good point on your part as I didn't look at BABIP just used my impression of watching Jullien getting hits and a near 300 average at A ball. A 451 BABIP is no where near sustainable so you could say his batting average was easily 100 points artificially high at A ball. Although his patient approach probably did get him better pitches to hit. Predictably his Average fell to around 250 at High A but his slugging was actually slightly better there as well. At any rate your factual point stands that Sabato was better than Jullien by a good margin at high A. While Rodriguez didn't hit that well my main point is that he is only 18 years old and his OPS was higher than Sabato who is 22 facing pitchers that are even more erratic than Sabato. He has 4 more years to be as bad as Sabato we will have to wait and see. Maybe Rodriquez does stay K prone and can't take a walk hard to say haven't been able to watch him so I don't know anything for sure but the numbers seem to indicate that if he can do that at 18 he likely can get much better by age 22. It was more a point about pitching and if someone 4 years younger can do just as well if not better than Sabato then how good is he? At any rate you did prove your point well. I am biased and I can see that for sure now. I do hope I am wrong and Sabato becomes the next Harmon Killebrew but he will need to show me a lot more next year to convince me.
-
10 Breakout Twins Prospect Candidates: 1-5
While I haven't completely lost faith in Sabato and SSS's cannot be relied upon I think if you watched him swing in A ball it would cause concern. I saw a guy swinging out of his shoe's with the barrel not even close to the ball. Especially on breaking stuff. I get that it takes time to recognize those pitches and lay off but his ability to make contact appears limited to me. He is not an Eddie Rosario I can hit almost anything kind of bat. He is more a I think I can guess what is coming and swing out of my shoes type of bat. I am sorry but I don't buy into the hitting better with pitchers with more control. What does that say about Eduoard Jullien who was in the same league had the same walk rate or better and he hit better than Sabato. Or how about Emmanual Rodriguez who is younger and in and even lower league dealing with pitcher's with even greater lack of control and his OPS is much higher? I think it comes down to ability to put the barrel on the ball and I am concerned Sabato might not have the same level of ability some others do. Does two SSS in an inaugural season tell us much? Probably not. I kind of look at Sabato as maybe like a Nick Pratto type player. Hopefully he can adjust and get better and find that breakout season. His High A numbers give some hope but he has a ways to go to convince me he even gets a shot at MLB ball after what I saw last year.
-
10 Breakout Twins Prospect Candidates: 1-5
That is a decent top 10. I would quibble with whether a few of those qualify as breakout candidates but all the names are intriguing. SWR was really good to start the season and like a lot of pitchers last year ran out of gas half way through the season. He was very young for AA and proved he belonged there at least to start the season. He has as good a chance as any of the Twins top pitchers to get the call next year. Soularie does look like a good pick to bounce back. He didn't show much power last year but with the broken foot probably understandable. The question about him in the draft seemed to be if he would have enough power in his bat to make it as he didn't really have a strong position to play other than left field. I know the Twins were thinking 2nd base as well but they have a glut of talent at 2nd right now he has a better path to left field if he can find a power stroke. After watching Sabato struggle last year I really question his ability to make it. I think if you just don't throw him any fastballs he will always have a high K rate. He looks like Rooker part 2 to me but it is early. He does have better plate discipline than Rooker so maybe just maybe he can get better outcomes at the plate. He had one of the more brutal starts for a college first round pick that I can remember. He is a long shot IMO but I hope he figures it out and becomes a force at the plate. Like everyone I love Durans potential but he hasn't pitched much and there are always questions about arms that throw 100MPH because they get stressed and seem prone to injury issues. Right now he feels more like a tease than a sure thing. He has nowhere to go but up after the last two years so should be a good breakout candidate. My guess is he gets injured again and likely needs surgery but we'll see. Agree with your number one Rodriguez. The FCL was a tougher league last year and he excelled as a young player. With more experience that K rate should get better. He looks like he could be special but it is early.
-
Mid-Offseason Reflection and Grade
We see things pretty much the same. Unless the FO blows me away with some major trades for starting pitching I see things playing out pretty much as you described. If things go their way they could be a 500 club maybe slightly better but given what it takes to be a playoff team these days it doesn't look like we have what we need. I would have given them a C to C- for the offseason so far and like you it is because of the structure of the Buxton contract. They got a potential super star player signed to a deal that covers for injury. When does that ever happen in baseball? I think that was a pretty major accomplishment and picks up their grade from D range. The rest of their moves mainly non moves are nothing to write home about. They took a flyer on a pitcher and snuck another pitcher they wanted through to the minor's. There are still moves to be made but I think this lockout will last until close to spring training so will interesting to see how things ultimately shake out.
-
If the Twins want to trade Josh Donaldson, where does he go?
I agree I don't see a deal getting done in the offseason. The way things look right now the Twins kind of need his bat in the lineup. Granted if they don't do anything to help the rotation then it is likely a moot point anyway. Given what happened to Larnach and Kirilloff last year I don't know that I want to completely trust Miranda there to start the season but if they are going with a youth movement then one more isn't going to hurt. Still if Donaldson has a good start to the season he could be a good trade chip at the deadline and if the Twins are in it then I am sure they would love to keep his bat in the lineup. I just don't see a deal where the Twins feel it makes sense to unload him at this time. By midseason there will be less money left on his deal and a team that needs him would be more willing to overpay. At least that is the way I see it.
-
Would you sign Andrelton Simmons to a one-year, $5m contract?
I agree with most of this. They have an MO now that they are not going to be in on the big fish and they are going to wait the market out for bargains. The one thing I do want to add to this though is they aren't acting any different than any of the other teams that receive revenue sharing money. What bottom ten team in revenue has gone out and signed any of the big names? I can't think of any. I think they are operating or trying to operate like a Tampa or Oakland to get where they want to go. Those teams try to make something out of nothing as well. So Honestly I am not too surprised that this is the way FA went for the Twins. I think this is more operating by design than being surprised by the early run on top players.
-
Would you sign Andrelton Simmons to a one-year, $5m contract?
I get that the options are slim and if he bounces back some with the bat he could be the best left out there but I have to say I hated his black hole, near automatic out of a bat last year. He was a rally killer pitcher type bat. I just don't know if I want to put myself through that again this year. The defense he provided was good but he had his share of bonehead plays as well IMO. He isn't pristine in the field but yeah one of the better defenders out there. Given the current construction of this team though maybe it doesn't matter whether they sign him or not because it doesn't look like a playoff caliber team at this point anyway. Personally I might hate myself later but given the basic three outcome game I think the Twins should look for more offense out of the position versus defense. I think Simmons bat is bad enough that I would pass on him. Just one guys opinion.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
I can agree with this for the most part. The owners are not showing their books and not negotiating in good faith. I think there needs to be a solid floor and I believe the owners proposed something along those lines. I am fine with a floor but what is the players association doing about creating fairer competition for Free Agents? I want my team to be able to compete in Free Agency and they currently can't. If they want me on their side they need to work on things like that as well. Until they do I am sorry but I am with the evil owners who at least afford my team some measure of fairness. Even if it is small it is better than anything the players association is offering.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
I agree that if we don't want the players association to go just with the big teams the floor has to be higher. The money has to be spent on the players not just pocketed by the owners. I do think teams like Tampa, Oakland, and maybe Pittsburgh and Miami need to be moved to cities that can support them or contracted so that the floor can be at least 100M. I want to be behind the players believe me but proposing to make half the league less competitive is a non starter for me. As a fan I really do like caps as it creates a fair playing field. Everyone has the same things to work with they just need to make better decisions than the other clubs. I get why the players don't want a cap as they have no idea what the owners are making and it seems likely that it is a lot. I hate this whole thing but as a fan my greatest concern is fairer competition among teams. I don't see either side as having a proposal I am in complete agreement on but so far the players side with less revenue sharing is where they have lost me completely.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
I don't think it makes negotiations tougher lets be honest the owners hold all the cards here. They can hold out forever and move to use MiLB players. The players are not going to risk losing all that money over a strike. It won't work and the owners will come out ahead one way or another. Players will start to cave one by one. There is too much at stake especially for the highest paid players. Personally I am pissed at the players union and hope their lawyer has to choke on his proposal. He doesn't have the best interests of baseball in mind. If I was a revenue sharing team I would propose major league baseball buy me out for market value and take 1 billion in salary off the books for all of baseball and see what kind of win the players get. Let them lose hundreds of jobs and lose millions of fans because his proposal does half of the teams no good. They might as well not exist and if he thinks less competition for players is a good thing then he has to be one of the biggest fools alive. If he wanted to make the players look bad he has done an excellent job. No one in their right mind could come to the conclusion that what the players are proposing is good for the teams or the players. This guy is dumber than a rock. If the players association lawyer was trying to find a way to make the game more competitive for all that is something I could get behind as a fan but personally I hope he chokes on this proposal. He has me on the side of the owners right now and I hope most baseball fans see him for the clown he is.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
I don't love the owners either and I agree with you that this is about money for both sides. To me it looks like the players union is cozying up to the richer more powerful teams owners as this proposal benefits them as it weakens their competition and strengthens their pocket book. The owners of the top 10 to 15 revenue generating teams have nothing to fear in this proposal absolutely nothing. The bottom 10 teams have much more to lose. As a fan of actually one the better lower end teams it stinks that we can't compete in the FA market. How many revenue sharing teams came out with the winning bid for one of the big FA signings this year? Any? I can't think of one. Things are skewed enough as it is and they expect us as fans to hang onto hope every year? The players association wants to make my team even less competitive? Yeah they will never have me on their side with proposals like this, never.
-
Rob Manfred's Public Arguments Framing the MLBPA's Desires As Harmful to Fans Make Little Sense
In my mind Manfred isn't completely wrong. If that is what the Players union truly wants I would counter propose contracting all teams that currently need revenue sharing to be competitive. That would allow the other 20 teams to be closer in revenue and then compete at a closer revenue level which would allow for what the Players union wants in terms of player movement and flexibility. All teams would have close to the same amount of money to compete for FA's so there wouldn't be as large a disparity. Granted the players would lose around 300 jobs but they can gain the flexibility they require. Otherwise the players union needs to understand there needs to be a cap of some kind and greater revenue sharing to allow teams to compete in the FA market fairly. So for me yeah what the players union is proposing is likely the death of my team maybe not right away but most likely eventually. It would strengthen the larger revenue teams and those fans would be happy. It would also cost the players lots of jobs but increased pay for the ones who remain. With less revenue sharing and a shorter path to free agency teams like Tampa, Oakland, Pittsburgh, and Miami really shouldn't be included in MLB anymore. It would take a miner miracle for them to compete. They are able to now only because they control players just long enough to make a run and or can sometimes trade their way back to relevancy. What the Players union is proposing is their certain death. So to me yeah I think Manfred is right their proposal will help the rich teams get richer and the poor teams get poorer. Eventually teams won't be able to draw fans when all their good players move on after 3 or 4 years to teams that can pay them more in free agency. I just don't see how this works without more revenue sharing and a cap or contraction to keep spending at a fairer level. IMO I don't think it will be good for baseball but who knows maybe getting rid of the weaker teams will make the sport stronger?
-
A Letter to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred
While I agree in principal I am not so certain reality wouldn't be different. I remember the NFL strike and the replacement players. People still watched and some cities came out ahead because instead of having a bad team suddenly they were competitive. Fans root for their home team. If the product is all MiLB players for every team then that is the pool. Would some fans leave and never come back sure but I am not certain enough of them to make a large enough difference and over time I think it would even out. Might take a while like the last strike but MLB will still be there the machine is just too big. Comparing MLB tickets\games to MiLB is disingenuous. Most MiLB sites are in smaller cities, the players don't stay there long as they move up levels, they don't have a TV presence\advertising or the marketing the MLB clubs enjoy. MiLB serves a completely different purpose as that talent bubbles up to MLB which is promoted as the best of the best so that is the league that becomes the most important to fans. If the MLB players were locked out indefinitely then the best MiLB players would now be the best of the best that fans would watch. I don't see that the players have a ton of leverage here. I think they should focus on service time issues as I think that is something fans can get behind. I agree that players should get at least 50% of the pie revenue speaking and I don't like that we don't get to see the teams books because to me that means they are hiding things. Things that would most likely show them in a bad light. I am not for either side really but probably on the players side more given what I know. The issue is there is only so much they can do if the owners don't open the books. If they could get that then maybe public outrage would be enough to change things but until then what MLB is offering is likely the best they are going to get.
-
Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
I am a prospect lover but after watching pitcher after pitcher go down last year it is harder to keep faith in those up and coming pitching prospects. I tend to agree with you Duran and Canterino seem in danger of arm issues and I personally don't count on either one staying a starter. They both threw limited innings last year so their ability to help the team this year seems unlikely. Sands had his own stops and starts last year but his stats are as good as Winders and Balazovic wasn't exactly dominant last year. Winder looked pretty good until he got hit with a baseball but still only 72 innings last year. Strotman threw the most innings (101) but his WHIP is currently so high he won't make it as a starter. I know they all were coming off a year layoff and injuries seemed up league wide but really we only have 3 legit guys that might be ready this year as starters and even then unlikely to make it the entire season. So yeah I agree with you that if they truly are depending entirely on the young arms we are sunk. Still I hope we get and arm or two to work out and I hope Duran and Canterino can prove more durable in 2022. The tough thing is the offense could be pretty good this coming year so if we have the pitching we probably could compete. Still with all the best FA pitchers off the board they will have to get lucky with the leftovers to help the pitching staff. I think we are in for another tough year.
-
Poll: Lockout and potential viewing habit changes
Yeah I hear you on the manipulating money to show what you want part.
-
Poll: Lockout and potential viewing habit changes
That is an interesting viewpoint for me having no real life experience on this issue. I guess I never thought about the fact that owners don't have to start the sport up again. You are right they are billionaires and will be fine no matter what. So that is quite a bit of power they hold. I think the hard part about this for me is how much are the owners really making? We have Oakland and Tampa with very low payrolls and no owner wants to supplement another owner so there have to be limits to what the owners are making. Whether that is too much or too little is hard to say since we don't get to see the books. However, all indications are they all are doing well as all teams are in tact and there is no contraction talk. There is no sport with exception of maybe Soccer where players make more money so baseball players do quite well. I certainly think the players deserve their fair share and should have more power to market their skills at a younger age but it is hard to know what that should look like.
-
Poll: Lockout and potential viewing habit changes
I guess I am misunderstanding. Sorry. I guess I thought a lockout only lasted so long but it really is a matter of who goes first. Players or Owners. So yes what I had to say is confusing. I mainly meant that any stoppage over a full season would make it tough to come back that was the gist of my rant.
-
A Letter to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred
While lot's of owners did complain ours did go the extra mile during the pandemic. Mr. Pohlad also was willing to spend coming out of the pandemic a year where revenue was down or in the red the year before. So when player like Nelson Cruz say Minnesota is a top notch organization I think we have proof to back that up. A strike could cost owners revenue moving forward as fans get frustrated and move on to different pastimes.
- Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
-
Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
I think Winder has a chance depending on what they do in free agency other than him for pitchers pretty much no one. I think it will be last year all over again pretty much. Enough vets to cover the start of the season and as they get injured or fail then fill in from there. I expect it will fail just as it did last year and then the younger players will get their chance. If the guys they get perform well then great we should have decent team but I am not banking on that. They are already counting on two young (rookie) pitchers (Ober and Ryan) Jax has a shot to make the pen. Winder could end up in the mix with a good spring and or AAA dominance. Moran might have a shot at pen spot or injury replacement. Same with Sands. They might not start the season with those guys but they are likely an injury away from being called up. So the rotation likely looks young already. They have Strotman, Balazovich and maybe SWR in the wings as well if they start off well in AAA they could be callups. Duran, Vallimont, Canterino, Moran could all be pen options if needed. There are a lot of young (rookie) guys they could funnel through IMO depending on how they perform this year. Given how the FA pitching market shook out I don't see what the Twins can do to meaningfully improve their pitching other than depend on some younger talent or work out a trade. That is just my opinion though.
-
Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
I am really high on Canterino but am guessing that with so few innings last year and not on the 40 man that he likely doesn't make a difference this year. If he dominates like he has been they could bring him up and use him out of the pen but seems like a long shot. Duran is scary isn't he? It feels like maybe that arm won't hold up to a starters load. Also he has been more hittable than I would like to see. This is another big year for him and they could try and work him out of the MLB pen if he looks good but unlikely given so few innings last year and likely protecting his arm. I have Strotman all over the place from starter to reliever to not making it all. I just really like what I saw on the screen and hope he develops.
-
Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
Totally agree on Vallimont and Jax. Jax did well the first time through lineups has a good pitch mix and decent control. He has a chance to succeed in the pen. Vallimont doesn't have enough control to be a starter and at this point appears to be who he is. Again the pen makes the most sense as he has a great K rate and his stuff should play up in the pen. If he gains control he could be an elite pen arm. I just don't see him as a starter. I like Strotman as a potential starter better than you at least at this time. He has a solid mix and I don't know if you caught him on MiLB at all but a smooth delivery. Not sure why he gives up so much contact and doesn't miss enough bats but he feels like a tweek away from being ready to me. But to your point yes he wouldn't be a bad pen arm either and likely a good one if he can find a way to miss more bats.
-
Twins Sign RHP Dylan Bundy
Yeah it seems like the way it is stacking up that they expect the young talent to carry this team and or at least gain valuable experience. As far as Bundy is concerned I think Winder is a better choice with his 94 to 95 MPH fastball and his Plus slider. I think Strotman likely has more potential than Bundy so I guess they signed him as an experienced depth piece waiting for the younger guys to supplant him? The Twins have a lot of somewhat wasted 40 man space if they can't get those young pitchers to contribute. They would have Duran, Balazovich, Winder, Sands, Strotman, Enlow, Vallimont, Cotton, and technically Jax as guys not able to help the big club unless they improve or are given the chance. Way, way too many young guys they can't rely on to help next year that are protected. So to your point yeah it does seem like this is the year they try to Cleveland their way to a young pitching staff. Given all the young talent weighing down the 40 man they almost have no choice. Some of those guys need to step up this year and contribute or it is going to be very hard to keep them. If I am Cotton, Jax or Vallimont and likely Strotman as well I would want to have a good year or likely not going to make the cut next year. The rest might have a little more leeway. So yeah I think they will be leaning on their young talent this year as well. That being said I expect them to grab another starter or two and find a shortstop. I just don't expect them to grab a high end piece unless they can work out a trade.
-
Non tenders Minaya and Coloumbe and Megill
I never had much hope for Coloumbe or Megill but I did kind of like what Minaya showed last year. Not that he was elite or anything but he looked like someone who could work. I am sure they can find better arms out there than all three and the lack of options for Coloumbe and Minaya make it tough to roster them. I guess they are hoping that as teams trim that Megill will get lost in the wash and they can get him through and work with him at AAA. Would be nice if that worked out but I guess we will have to wait and see what happens to these guys. Well for the moment that is three more open spots. Roster management is a tough business but most all of these players will have a chance to prove themselves again next year just most likely in the minors instead of the majors.
-
Twins Claim Trevor Megill, Outright Jake Cave
I just take issue with you calling it "clever" lol when no brainer is what it has been for months now and they proved that by doing it over a guy who likely won't even make the the 40 man. Not sure how I can be bashing the FO when they did the expected. Sure I felt they could have done it sooner but what they have done so far has been fine. Although I would say clever is overselling it the opposite direction.