Everything posted by Dman
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
I guess my assumption was poor. Sorry to put words in your mouth. I personally don't think anyone knew what was going to happen but this team answered the challenge.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
Not trying to call anyone out. Just trying to make a point that I felt a lot of people gave up hope when Kintzler was traded. I guess I could have just written down the number 15. I just wanted to point out how a lot of people felt about it.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
And I concede that the people that wanted to stay in the race were correct for believing in this team. I sure didn't think they would make it. All I am saying is that they did make the Playoffs even without Kintzler. Maybe the FO did give up on the team or maybe they felt Kintzer wasn't going to be the difference I don't know their thinking I just don't think they deserve much criticism for the decision. If the Twins beat New York and lose some close games in the bullpen in the next series I will eat my words and concede I wish the FO would have done more. To me this team does not match up well with Houston or Cleveland and certainly doesn't have those teams depth. This has been awesome year of Twins BB. I am shocked at where they are. We just agree to disagree on how the FO handled things.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
This was the post from John Bonnes after the Kintzler trade. ""This likely won't be a very popular opinion, but the Twins gave up on this year for maybe five guys who: a. probably don't rank in the top 15 in their organization and b. probably don't rank in the top 300 in the minors and c. likely will make little to no difference in their future? That's what Littell, Enns, & Watson are, right? And given the reliever market (which we just saw for Kintzler), they certainly wouldn't have needed to give up much to add a couple of competent relievers. I know it's been a tough week, but this was a mistake. I don't get why they wouldn't ride it and chance the 9% chance they hat making the playoffs. It feels like panic. What did we gain exactly for giving up?" This article was liked by the following members: hybridbear peterb18 bighat Dave The Dastardly Raven J DaveW whydidnt Hosken Bombo Disco Jerr Highabove shimrod Vanimal46 ChiTownTwinsFan USAFChief pbrezeasap gunnarthor Mike Sixel. I assume all those posters felt that after the Kintzler trade there was no way the Twins were going to make the post season. At least that is how I read it. No one thought the Twins had a chance after the trade and also felt that the Twins needed to add to have a chance. In the end everyone except the FO was wrong because they made the post season without Kintzler. So I guess I fail to see the angst for that trade. Would it be good to have a better bullpen right now sure but was that going to be enough to move the needle enough in the post season matchups? I don't think so, but I am sure you could make a case. Also you would have probably had to give up someone like Hildy or Bussy or more to get a couple of two month rentals. I think the FO did ok on this one.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
I guess fangraphs and all the supposed experts are schmucks then because they sure didn't see "it" coming.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
Well he is better than getting nothing at all for Kintzler and we made the postseason without Kintzler plus they threw in $500,000 in international bonus money. While Watson is not on any top 100 prospect lists he has been an All-Star twice in the minors as he has moved up. He is young for the levels he has been in. Granted he is not a hard thrower but since he is only 20 there is projection there. I believe he has a good curveball which is all the rage these days. Personally I question if he has enough stamina and pitches to be a starter but he could end up a very good reliever if he can't make it as a starter. He is in our top 20. If you don't like guys in that range or don't think they can make it then you probably don't like the trade. Personally I like the gamble given that we only had two months left of Brandon and too many pitching holes to truly compete with the big boys this year. I'd rather have Watson and $500,000 than Brandon and the same wildcard result. More good prospects = more chances to get someone who makes it.
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
Yeah but given the way the young bats were slumping or at least very inconsistent along with only two viable starting pitching options those odds appeared pretty long in July. I really think you have a bit too much 20\20 here. It felt a lot more probable that things would go in the tank than even out IMO. I know a lot of people on this board felt the FO gave up on the season when they traded Kintzler. Even the players seemed to feel the same way if I remember correctly. Knowing what I know now would I rather have Kintzler? Probably, but even if we still had him i doubt it would make much difference in the end. I would, however, have liked to give this team the best chance possible to pull out a wildcard win and if the game is close he is a big asset. I really think this comes down to whether you want to play the long or short game. I get that we have been playing the long game forever and some success was needed but for me I still like what the FO did. I like Watson's potential and the potential we can buy with $500,000 in international money. In the end things worked out and the team made the post season and will have a measure of success. To me it looks like a win, win.
- Article: What The Hell Just Happened?
- 82-74
-
Article: The Falvey And Levine Machine
For the most part I like what the FO has done this year. I like that they took time to see what they had and made changes where they saw needs. I liked what they did at the trade deadline. Granted the returns weren't incredible but it was better than getting nothing for those guys. At the time it seemed pretty unrealistic to me based on the numbers and past history that this team would make the playoffs. I was for the long term view the FO had all the way. I know there were several people on this board that did not feel that way (I am thinking of Mr Bonnes in particular) and kuddos to them for being right that this team had what it takes to get to the playoffs. They were the "true" believers. I was not one of them. Bottom line is through the "process" luck or whatever, they still got returns at the deadline and the team made the playoffs so in my mind that is true genius or at least good fortune. Having said all that the FO knows what they have now so next year they need to find a way to improve the rotation and solidify the pen. They have a good group of core players. The window is often short. I hope they are up to the task.
-
82-74
Dave since I am always willing to call you out on your bluster I have to give you props on your prediction. Took some balls to go against the grain and the numbers buy it looks like you were more right than anyone else.
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
I tend to agree with you. If the "math" supports that they are the best team because of season record then they should have no problem dispensing a wild card team. Teams change and grow through a season. A young team might be bad to start the season and be better at the end of the season. A team might face injuries and get players back and just make the wild card. There are lot's of reasons a team's season record might not be that great but the team is better at the end of season. Granted the playoff format creates a different set of strengths and weaknesses for teams, but since all teams do not play each other an equal number of times it seems the playoffs are the best way to settle the answer of who is the best in a given year.
-
It's Never Too Early for Magic Number
A single win in the Cleveland series would make me feel a lot better but given the state of the Tigers you have to like our chances right now. A couple of tough loses for the other teams is all it takes for them to be eliminated. I like our chances but like a lot of Minnesotans I never take anything for granted and the baseball gods can be cruel. I am rooting for them and am excited that they have a very good chance to make the playoffs. There have been some really tough years would be nice to see this team in the post season.
-
Article: Twins 2017 Minor League Hitter Of The Year
I felt that Rodriguez was the real difference maker for Chattanooga. He seemed to come up with big hits when they needed them. He made that lineup very tough at the top with Gordon and Wade as table setters his bat was very important to their success. Happy to see him get some recognition.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (9/7): ): E-Town Dominates, Kernels Sweep, and Lookouts Lose Late
Still have a chance at 3 championships. Let's get them all.
- Article: Brian Dozier Is Taking The Lead
-
Post Hoc, Ergo Propter Hoc
Fun read! I have been watching the box scores for those guys all year. A lot of slumps after the break but I agree the bats seem to be back. Let's hope the pitching holds and they should be dangerous in the playoffs.
-
SS in the system, a quick look in
I like all of those guys even Vielma who is having a down year with the stick. Unfortunately I don't know if I have enough confidence in any of them to feel comfortable trading away Gordon. Palacios is back but just one year removed from a terrible year at the plate. Lewis is not a lock to stick at short and I like him better as a center fielder myself. If he continues to do well at short my opinion could change. Wander seems solid but he is pretty far away as well. With the exception of Vielma all of those guys look like they could have well rounded offensive upside, but they all seem to have questions when it comes to defense. If the Twins could get a decent return for Escobar or Dozier or both that would allow for us to have the years of control for Gordon or Palacios instead of trading that away. Thing is the Twins are on the cusp of having a good team next year so I see them keeping both of those guys. If they lose Dozier after 2018 then they have Gordon to slide in and he should definitely be ready by 2019 so I think they will keep Gordon. Not sure how they plan to upgrade pitching but I don't see them trading Gordon to get it.
-
Travis Harrison - 2017
He looked good in A ball but never had another season that looked that good. The Twins gave him plenty of time to prove he belonged but there are just too many guys that are more athletic and hit better than he does. It was time to let him go. Hate to see a dream die but he made it further than a lot of guys do.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/24): Kernels and GCL Twins Provide Bright Spot On Sad Thursday Night
So with the Cedar Rapids win does that mean all the affiliates will have winning records this year? Is there a chance that all the affiliates will qualify for the playoffs? Pretty fun year to follow all the teams. Typically the talent pools up in two maybe three leagues but not all. I wonder if there has ever been a year like this one for the Twins affiliates?
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/22): Terrible Tuesday
MIranda and Bechtold were really hot to start the season and have cooled some recently. Wander has really come on with the bat lately as well. Some really talented young hitters are gonna end up in Cedar Rapids next year.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/17): Relievers Starting, Royce Rolling, And An Incredible Comeback For The Lookouts
I can't believe the Lookouts came back and won. After the Rosario debacle I totally had them losing that game. It has been a magical season for that group this year. They just need to win the championship to finish this off right.
-
Lewis Thorpe Promoted to AA
I am very surprised. I figured they would leave in A+ the rest of the year and start him in AA next year. HIs number are good but he seemed to have control issue's so I thought they would leave him especially since AA has a solid rotation as it is. I wonder if they moved him to make room for other promotions to come?
-
Affiliate Success: Fun With Numbers
It is exciting to see all the affiliates doing so well. I am not sure what correlation or causation can be gleaned from the win loss record though. As we all know the affiliates are more about player development than winning records and prospects are more about potential (future results) than current results. I think an argument can be made that the Twins have fantastic roster balance among their affiliates but according to most evaluators’ average talent in their system. Most affiliates have 3 to 4 really good hitters a really good pitcher or two and all of them seem to have a pretty dominant bullpen. The exception being Chattanooga who has had really good pitching 1-5 most of the year and it shows. If we are winning it seems obvious that we have good players but if the losing teams have just a couple of super star players at each level and lose a lot they are still better off than we are. I’m not trying to diminish what the affiliates have accomplished this year. Frankly I have been amazed at how well they’ve all done. I just don’t know how to quantify what that gives us other than likely a lot of good players that can’t make the jump to MLB. Winning feels a lot better than losing and I am hopeful that a lot of these players make there way to MLB. I like having a balanced system. I just hope we produce some super star players as well.
-
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/12): Royce Rolls Into Cedar Rapids
Don't forget Bechtold. He has cooled recently but I think he is only 20 years old as well. Seems to have a good eye makes contact. Add Kirolof to your grouping and you have a darn tough lineup.